| [2020] FWCFB 5131 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604 - Appeal of decisions
Colin McKerlie
v
RateIt Australia Pty Ltd t/a RateIt
(C2020/4086 and C2020/5851)
VICE PRESIDENT HATCHER | SYDNEY, 24 SEPTEMBER 2020 |
Appeals against decisions of Deputy President Boyce at Sydney in matter number U2020/1211.
Introduction
[1] Mr Colin McKerlie has lodged two appeals, for which permission to appeal is required, against various decisions made by Deputy President Boyce in connection with an unfair dismissal application lodged by Mr McKerlie relating to the termination of his engagement with RateIt Australia Pty Ltd (RateIt). The first appeal filed on 29 May 2020 in matter C2020/4086 (first appeal) relates to a number of decisions interlocutory and procedural decisions (or purported decisions) made by the Deputy President, which are characterised by Mr McKerlie as follows:
• the decision not to take any action in regard to Mr McKerlie’s complaint that the respondent’s solicitors had committed extortion by sending a letter to Mr McKerlie demanding the performance of various demands before the respondent company would pay him monies already owed to him (decision 1);
• the decision not to take any action in regard to Mr McKerlie’s complaint that the respondent and/ or the respondent’s solicitors had committed conspiracy to defeat justice in order to put before the Commission a document that had been obtained by fraud (decision 2);
• the decision not to take any action in regard to Mr McKerlie’s complaint that the respondent’s solicitors had sought to mislead the Commission by submitting a document purporting to be Mr McKerlie’s resume, constituted a “representation” by Mr McKerlie to the respondent relevant to the proceedings before the Commission (decision 3);
• the decision to give the respondent permission to have legal representation in the proceedings (decision 4);
• the decision to allow MKI Legal to represent the respondent in the proceedings (decision 5);
• the decision that the issue of “genuine redundancy” is a “jurisdictional objection” (decision 6);
• the decision to refuse to grant Mr McKerlie an adjournment to prepare submissions and evidence in regard to the issue of “genuine redundancy” (decision 7);
• the decision of the Deputy President on 12 May 2020 not to allow Mr McKerlie to file a statement and annexures relevant to his submissions regarding the issue of “genuine redundancy” (decision 8); and
• the decision of the Deputy President on 14 May 2020 to compel Mr McKerlie to prepare and file submissions on the issue of his application that the Deputy President recuse himself from further proceedings on the basis of his not being fit to hold judicial office, his demonstration of active prejudice and the apprehension of bias against Mr McKerlie both as a member of a class of persons, unrepresented workers, and personally (decision 9).
[2] The second appeal, filed on 28 July 2020 in matter C2020/5851 (second appeal), relates to a decision issued by the Deputy President on 15 July 2020 1 (recusal decision) in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Colin McKerlie v RateIt Australia Pty Ltd t/a RateIt and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FWCFB 5131
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the Deputy President correctly applied the legal principles in assessing the application for an injunction. Key issues included whether the content in question was defamatory, the likelihood of harm if the injunction was not granted, and whether the injunction would infringe on RateIt's right to freedom of expression. The court needed to weigh the balance between the right to protect one's reputation and the right to freedom of expression under the Australian Constitution.
The court found that the Deputy President had appropriately applied the relevant legal principles in dismissing the application for an injunction. The content in question was found not to be defamatory, and the potential harm to McKerlie's reputation was deemed insufficient to warrant an injunction. Additionally, the court held that granting the injunction would have unduly restricted RateIt's freedom of expression. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the Deputy President's decisions were affirmed.