Clear Interiors Pty Ltd v Sinergia Construction Project Management Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Civil)

CLEAR INTERIORS PTY LTD v SINERGIA CONSTRUCTION PROJECT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

[2017] SASC 79

Judgment of Judge Roder a Master of the Supreme Court

2 June 2017

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - BUILDERS - LICENCES AND REGISTRATION - OTHER MATTERS

Application for winding up. Defendant allowed to oppose the application for winding up.

Corporations Act 2001  ; Building Work Contractors Act 1995  ; Builders Licensing Act 1986  , referred to.
Sinergia Construction Project Management Pty Ltd v Clear Interiors Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1256; Accordent v RMBL Investments (2009) 105 SASR 62; Aussie Vic Plant Hire Ltd v Esanda Finance Corp Ltd (2008) 232 CLR 314; Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties v Paliflex Pty Ltd (1999) 149 FLR 179; Braams Group Pty Ltd v Miric (2002) 44 ACSR 124; Nunkuwarrin Yunti of SA Inc v A L Seeley Constructions Pty Ltd (1998) 72 SASR 21; Leslie v Howship Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 15 ACLC 459; Byrne & Frew v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410; Lepresto v Sam [2000] SASC 31; Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd v The Satellite Group (Harold Park) Pty Ltd [2000] NSWSC 1235; Arrow Asset Management Pty Ltd v Sportsworld Group Plc [1999] NSWSC 1207; Expile Pty Ltd v Jabb’s Excavations Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 96; Commonwealth Broadcasting Corp Pty Ltd v Pacific Mobile Phones Pty Ltd (2008) 219 FLR 422; Ewen Stuart & Associates Pty Ltd v Blue Mountains Virtual Air Helitours Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWSC 113; Effem Foods Ltd v Nicholls [2004] NSWCA 332; Guest v The Nominal Defendant [2006] NSWCA 77; Perpetual Nominees Ltd v Masri Apartments Pty Ltd (2004) 49 ACSR 719, considered.

CLEAR INTERIORS PTY LTD v SINERGIA CONSTRUCTION PROJECT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
[2017] SASC 79

Background

  1. The plaintiff has issued proceedings for the winding up of the defendant.

  2. The plaintiff relies on a statutory demand issued under s 459E(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (“the Act”).

  3. For a summary of the background to the matter, I borrow from the judgment of Charlesworth J in Sinergia Construction Project Management Pty Ltd v Clear Interiors Pty Ltd[1]. The plaintiff operated a joinery business. In March 2016 it completed works for the fit-out of a store in The Colonnades Shopping Centre. The plaintiff issued an invoice in the amount of $37,779.50 addressed to the defendant. On 27 May 2016 the plaintiff issued the statutory demand, relying on the debt allegedly established by the invoice.

  4. The defendant made an application in the Federal Court to set aside the statutory demand. The basis was that the alleged debt was not owed by the defendant, but by the store. The defendant denied any contractual relationship with the plaintiff.

  5. The defendant was represented in that application by its sole director – Mr Struck – who had been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clear Interiors Pty Ltd v Sinergia Construction Project Mana... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Clear Interiors Pty Ltd v Sinergia Construction Project Management Pty Ltd, the dispute revolves around the interpretation of a statutory demand and its impact on the winding-up process of a company. The matter was heard by the Australian court, where the primary issue was whether the statutory demand was validly issued and if it correctly identified a debt owed by the defendant to the plaintiff. The defendant contested the validity of the demand, arguing that the plaintiff was not entitled to claim the amount specified in the demand.

The court was tasked with determining whether the statutory demand was valid and if the plaintiff had a genuine arguable dispute regarding the defendant's liability to pay the debt. The central legal issue was whether the demand constituted a valid debt under the relevant legislation, specifically the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court also considered whether the statutory demand correctly identified a debt due under a contract or if it included a quantum meruit claim, which would not qualify as a debt for the purposes of the winding-up provisions.

The court found that there was a genuine arguable dispute regarding the defendant's liability to pay the debt. The reasoning of the court was that the demand could be reasonably characterised as a debt due under the contract, and the defendant had a complete defence under section 6 of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) if that characterisation was correct. The court also noted that if the plaintiff's claim was based on a quantum meruit, it might not qualify as a debt for the purposes of the statutory demand. Therefore, the court concluded that the statutory demand was valid, and the plaintiff had standing to apply for the winding up of the defendant.

The court ultimately allowed the plaintiff's application for leave to amend the statement of claim to include the statutory demand as a basis for the winding-up application. The defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The evidence does not make out the third such basis for dispute. I would not allow leave to amend on that ground. The other bases appear to me to be matters of law. I have indicated to the parties that I will not make orders based on the other two grounds without hearing from the plaintiff.Conclusion In my opinion for the following reasons there is, at the very least, a genuinely arguable dispute as to the defendant’s liability to pay the debt. I further consider that that dispute is raised fairly by the Notice of Appearance. Genuine dispute and adequacy of Notice of Appearance I agree with Mr McCabe’s first proposition - it is “hard to think of a more cogent ground of dispute” than that the plaintiff is prohibited by statute from recovering the sum in question. It is clear from the Notice of Appearance that the defendant seeks to oppose winding up on that ground. Mr Heinrich says that the plaintiff is entitled to claim, has not restricted itself from claiming – and in fact has claimed - the “debt” on a different basis and so s 6 of the BWCA, which is relied on by the defendant, is irrelevant. I do not have to decide that. I have to decide whether there is a real dispute. It is clear to me that there is such a dispute – and that it is raised by grounds 1-5 of the Notice of Appearance. I consider that there is a real dispute because:·The parties have argued about the characterisation of the demand. The defendant says that the demand is for a debt due under the contract. I think that the defendant’s characterisation is clearly arguable. The language of contract appears throughout the documents relating to the demand[8]. If the defendant’s characterisation is correct, s 6 of the BWCA appears to provide a complete defence. ·The question of the existence of a contract was the subject of the dispute before Charlesworth J. Her Honour concluded that:“It is enough that the defendant [in this case the plaintiff] has established that it has a present right in contract to sue the plaintiff [in this case the defendant] personally for the sum specified in the statutory demand and that there is no genuine dispute as to the existence and enforceability of that contractual right of against the plaintiff.”[8] For example, “debt”, “creditor”, “indebted”, “invoices”, “sum due”, “tax invoice”, “C.O.D.”, “terms of payment”, “variations”. That may not – as Mr Heinrich submitted - be a finding that the plaintiff’s only rights against the defendant are in contract, but it may add some colour to the defendant’s characterisation. The plaintiff argued before me that the demand should be understood as being (or at least including) a demand for a debt that was not due under the contract – that is, a debt for work done (being liable to paid by reason of a quantum meruit). The plaintiff may be right. However, the defendant pointed to what appears to me to be a powerful reason why that argument may not be right. The argument is that such an entitlement is not a “debt” for the purposes of Part 5.4 of the Act. It is, correctly, said that there is no definition of “debt” in the Act. The generally understood definition of debt is a certain amount[9] currently due.[10] It appears that there may be some circumstances in which an unliquidated claim could be a “debt”[11] but this does not appear to be one. The fact that there was a contract price for the work does not necessarily mean that that amount is the amount “due” on a quantum meruit – at most, it would be a “starting point”.[12] In my opinion it would be only in very unusual circumstances that a sum claimed on a quantum meruit could support a statutory demand.[13] The reasoning of Windeyer J in Consolidated Constructions Pty Ltd v The Satellite Group (Harold Park) Pty Ltd[14] appears to me to be powerful. The argument proceeds that the statutory demand in question should not be construed as claiming something that is not a “debt”. I further note that if the plaintiff is a “contingent” or “prospective” creditor, it has no standing to apply for the winding up of the defendant, not yet having obtained the leave of the Court.[15] [9] Byrne & Frew v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410 at [15].[10] See the qualifying words “due and payable” in s 495E(1).[11] Assaf, Statutory Demands and Winding Up in Insolvency, 2nd Ed, [2.29].[12] Lepresto v Sam [2000] SASC 31.[13] Arrow Asset Management Pty Ltd v Sportsworld Group Plc [1999] NSWSC 1207.[14] [2000] NSWSC 1235.[15] Section 459P(2)(a).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.