CITIC Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [No 3]

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   CITIC LTD -v- MINERALOGY PTY LTD [No 3] [2020] WASC 398

CORAM:   KENNETH MARTIN J

HEARD:   24 SEPTEMBER & 9 OCTOBER 2020

DELIVERED          :   4 NOVEMBER 2020

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1514 of 2016

BETWEEN:   CITIC LTD

First Plaintiff

SINO IRON PTY LTD

Second Plaintiff

KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD

Third Plaintiff

CAPE PRESTON RESOURCE HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Fourth Plaintiff

AND

MINERALOGY PTY LTD

First Defendant

CLIVE FREDERICK PALMER

Second Defendant


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Application by CITIC Plaintiffs for leave to amend statement of claim and reply - Leave required under previous directions - Leave to amend opposed in certain respects - Issues concerning computation of Purchase Consideration upon exercise of First Option - Sub-issues concerning set-off from nominated Purchased Consideration of allowable Drilling Obligation costs incurred by CITIC Ltd - Further issues concerning upward adjustment of Purchase Price by reference to Consumer Price Index (CPI) - Arguments over interpretation and implied terms and set-off concerning alleged delays and breaches of contract by defendants in non-performance of CPOA - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA), O 21 r 5

Result:

Uncontroversial amendments allowed
Drilling costs amendments allowed
CPI Increase amendments refused

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Plaintiff : Mr J H Karkar QC, Mr S Parmenter QC
& Mr A Barraclough
Second Plaintiff : Mr J H Karkar QC, Mr S Parmenter QC
& Mr A Barraclough
Third Plaintiff : Mr J H Karkar QC, Mr S Parmenter QC
& Mr A Barraclough
Fourth Plaintiff : Mr J H Karkar QC, Mr S Parmenter QC
& Mr A Barraclough
First Defendant : Mr K S Byrne
Second Defendant : Mr K S Byrne

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff : Allens
Second Plaintiff : Allens
Third Plaintiff : Allens
Fourth Plaintiff : Allens
First Defendant : Alexander Law
Second Defendant : Alexander Law

Cases referred to in decision:

AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

CITIC Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 223

CITIC Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [No 2] [2020] WASC 252

Eshelby v Federated European Bank [1932] 1 KB 254

Hightime Investments Pty Ltd v Lungan [No 2] [2010] WASC 296

Mineralogy v Sino Iron & Ors [No 16] [2017] WASC 340

Secured Income Real Estate (Aust) Ltd v St Martins Investments Pty Ltd (1979) 144 CLR 597

Sino Iron Pty Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [No 16] [2014] WASC 406

KENNETH MARTIN J:

Introduction

  1. This action is currently listed for a two week trial before me commencing on 7 December 2020.  Under directions issued some time ago there were to be no further amendments to the pleadings without leave.  The action has been formally entered for the trial by the four plaintiffs (the CITIC Plaintiffs).

  2. The subject matter of the presently opposed interlocutory application is the CITIC Plaintiffs' chamber summons of 22 September 2020 seeking leave for them to significantly amend…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CITIC Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [No 3] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASC 398
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, CITIC Ltd brought an application against Mineralogy Pty Ltd and others concerning a dispute over the terms of a contract for the purchase of sale interests (CPOA). The primary issue was whether CITIC Ltd was entitled to amend its statement of claim to assert additional claims, particularly regarding the computation of the Purchase Consideration upon exercise of the First Option, the allowable Drilling Obligation costs, and the upward adjustment of the Purchase Price by reference to the Consumer Price Index (CPI). The case turned on the interpretation of the CPOA, particularly its definition of 'Purchase Consideration', the calculation of drilling costs, and the impact of CPI on the final purchase price.

The court had to decide whether CITIC Ltd was entitled to amend its statement of claim to include additional claims concerning the computation of the Purchase Consideration, the allowable Drilling Obligation costs, and the upward adjustment of the Purchase Price by reference to CPI. The court also had to determine if Mineralogy Pty Ltd's opposition to these amendments was justified. This required a detailed examination of the CPOA and the specific clauses concerning the Purchase Consideration and CPI adjustments.

The court found that the definition of 'Purchase Consideration' under the CPOA included both an upward adjustment by reference to the CPI and a downward adjustment for drilling costs incurred by CITIC Ltd. The court concluded that the amendments sought by CITIC Ltd were permissible as they were based on the terms of the CPOA and did not introduce new claims but rather clarified the existing ones. The court granted leave to amend the statement of claim, noting that the issues concerning the computation of the Purchase Consideration and the allowable Drilling Obligation costs were indeed within the scope of the original contract and thus could be addressed through the proposed amendments.

The court issued orders granting CITIC Ltd leave to amend its statement of claim in the respects specified in the application. This decision allowed CITIC Ltd to pursue its claims concerning the computation of the Purchase Consideration, the allowable Drilling Obligation costs, and the upward adjustment of the Purchase Price by reference to CPI, thereby clarifying the legal framework within which these issues would be resolved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By reference to the terms of the CPOA, I will mention at first its express cl 1.1 definition of the term 'Purchase Consideration', presenting there in the following terms:Purchase Consideration shall mean US$200,000,000 (two hundred million US dollars) for each and every Sale Interest, plus the CPI Increase from the 1 March 2006 until the date of transfer of any Sale Interest in respect of a Further Company, under any option set out in this Agreement. The Purchase Consideration for the first or subsequent Sale Interests will be reduced by the amount which CITIC spends to comply with the Drilling Obligation. My reasons, CITIC v Mineralogy explain that there are a number of key definitions used in the CPOA. Schedule A to those reasons collects some of those definitions. I incorporate them all here by reference, but do not repeat them. Fundamentally, however, cl 3.3 of the CPOA, as regards the so called First Option (defined by subclause 3.1), says:3.3The exercise price for the First Option will be the Purchase Consideration. Relevantly, therefore, to any future ascertainment upon a precise $US figure to be paid over as the Purchase Consideration are its two fundamental ingredients ‑ one upward and one downward, as to price. First, by reference to the definition of Purchase Consideration there must be found, the amount spent by CITIC Ltd to comply with its described Drilling Obligation seen set out in cl 2.4 and Schedule 1 of the CPOA, the downward factor, an essential aspect of the to be calculated Purchase Consideration end figure (and often referred to as the drilling costs). In my further and better discovery reasons, CITIC v Mineralogy [No 2], I had discussed that CITIC Ltd Drilling Obligation costs factor at some length: see [35] ‑ [37]. Secondly, the other key input factor to be ascertained in any exercise of arriving at a final Purchase Consideration amount payable under the CPOA is the CPI (Consumer Price Index) Increase, 'from 1 March 2006 until the date of transfer of any Sale Interest in respect of a Further Company …'. This is the upward adjustment factor to the Purchase Consideration. Within the definition provisions of the CPOA at cl 1.1 is to be found as well, a definition for 'CPI Increase': CPI Increase means US$200,000,000 x (CPI2 ‑ CPI1) CPI1Where CPI1 is the last published CPI figure before 1 March 2006 and CPI2 is the last published CPI figure before the date of completion of a Takeover Agreement. For general orientation purposes some key dates as discussed below need to be kept in front of mind upon the present application seeking leave to amend. The CPOA itself between CITIC Ltd, Mineralogy and Mr Palmer was entered on 22 October 2008 and subsequently varied on 30 March 2012. Relevantly, that variation had allowed some further time for the exercise by CITIC Ltd of the First Option, under CPOA cl 3. Originally, by CPOA cl 3.2, the time that was allowed for an exercise of the First Option had been until 5:00 pm on 31 March 2012. Under the agreed variation, the time allowed was extended, essentially by a further two weeks, out until 14 April 2012.