JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: CITIC LTD -v- MINERALOGY PTY LTD [No 2] [2020] WASC 252
CORAM: KENNETH MARTIN J
HEARD: 22 JUNE 2020
DELIVERED : 3 JULY 2020
FILE NO/S: CIV 1514 of 2016
BETWEEN: CITIC LTD
First Plaintiff
SINO IRON PTY LTD
Second Plaintiff
KOREAN STEEL PTY LTD
Third Plaintiff
CAPE PRESTON RESOURCE HOLDINGS PTY LTD
Fourth Plaintiff
AND
MINERALOGY PTY LTD
First Defendant
CLIVE FREDERICK PALMER
Second Defendant
Catchwords:
Practice and procedure - Electronic discovery to be given by categories - Dispute over particular category - Issues of relevance, proportionality and oppression - Sub-issue concerning drilling costs incurred many years ago - Contextual arguments concerning repudiatory breach of CPOA agreement - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Nil
Result:
Residual discovery request refused
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| First Plaintiff | : | Mr J H Karkar QC & Ms T Spencer Bruce |
| Second Plaintiff | : | Mr J H Karkar QC & Ms T Spencer Bruce |
| Third Plaintiff | : | Mr J H Karkar QC & Ms T Spencer Bruce |
| Fourth Plaintiff | : | Mr J H Karkar QC & Ms T Spencer Bruce |
| First Defendant | : | Mr K S Byrne |
| Second Defendant | : | Mr K S Byrne |
Solicitors:
| First Plaintiff | : | Allens |
| Second Plaintiff | : | Allens |
| Third Plaintiff | : | Allens |
| Fourth Plaintiff | : | Allens |
| First Defendant | : | Kane Jones |
| Second Defendant | : | Alexander Law |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
KENNETH MARTIN J:
Introduction
At a hearing across Monday, 22 June 2020, I dealt with the parties' disputes over categories of discovery for the purposes of this action in the context of the looming 10-day trial, fixed to commence before me on 7 December 2020. During the course of the day I was able to resolve, on an extempore basis, all but one of a dozen or so disputes over categories of mutual discovery - which categories are helpfully summarised in colour coded annexures provided by the parties - and which have been revised on an evolving basis. The latest iterations of those annexures emerged only on Monday morning, at about 6.00 am (WST) under the cover of Allens' (the solicitors for the plaintiffs) email.
During the course of the hearing I resolved all of the category disputes as regards documents requested by the CITIC Plaintiffs from Mineralogy and Mr Palmer. These were categories identified respectively as C11, C13, C14, C15 and C16. Extempore reasons delivered during the course of the day resolved such disputes.
As regards the categories of discovery requested by Mineralogy and Mr Palmer from the CITIC Plaintiffs and still resisted, there had been, essentially, disputes over seven categories or classes of documents which were requested, but resisted. Again, either by concession, or on extempore rulings made with the benefit of counsel's assistance through the course of the day, I was able to resolve, by reference to the last iteration of the parties' table of categories, the residual discovery disputes concerning categories - M1, M2,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CITIC Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] WASC 252
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide several legal issues, including the relevance, proportionality, and potential oppression in the electronic discovery process, particularly concerning the drilling costs incurred by CITIC Ltd many years prior. Another issue was the contextual argument regarding the repudiatory breach of the CPOA agreement, which was heavily dependent on the specific facts of the case. The court had to interpret the definition of 'Purchase Consideration' and 'Drilling Obligation' as outlined in the CPOA to ascertain the correct computation of the Purchase Consideration.
The court's reasoning focused on the definition of 'Purchase Consideration' in the CPOA, which includes a reduction based on the amount CITIC Ltd spends on the Drilling Obligation. The court examined the specific obligations outlined in the CPOA, particularly the Drilling Obligation in clause 2.4 and the mutual covenant for evidencing compliance in clause 2.6. The court concluded that the Purchase Consideration should be computed by deducting the amount CITIC Ltd had spent on fulfilling its Drilling Obligation, as per the terms of the CPOA.
The court ordered that the Purchase Consideration should be computed by deducting the amount CITIC Ltd had spent on its Drilling Obligation, as defined and outlined in the CPOA. This decision was based on the specific terms of the agreement and the need for a precise computation of the Purchase Consideration. The court's interpretation of the CPOA clauses ensured that the electronic discovery process was relevant, proportionate, and not oppressive, while also addressing the historical drilling costs in the context of the CPOA's repudiatory breach argument.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The term 'Purchase Consideration' is defined in the CPOA as:Shall mean $US200,000,000 (two hundred million US dollars) for each and every Sale Interest, plus the CPI increase from 1 March 2006 until the date of transfer of any Sale Interest in respect of a Further Company, under any option set out in this Agreement. The Purchase Consideration for the first or subsequent Sale Interest will be reduced by the amount which CITIC spends to comply with the Drilling Obligation. (my emphasis) Given the present M9 dispute, I need to dwell on the definition of 'Purchase Consideration' - as regards its eventual computation by way of reduction for the amount CITIC Ltd 'spends' to comply with the 'Drilling Obligation'. Within the CPOA, the term 'Drilling Obligation' is yet another defined term, which:means CITIC's obligation set out in clause 2.4 and Schedule 1. So then, it is necessary to journey on, to examine CPOA cl 2.4, which itself appears under a heading 'Drilling Obligation'. It reads:CITIC will carry out the Drilling Obligation for up to five years from the date of the Sino Takeover Agreement for Area A, [note: that date being 31 March 2006] to endeavour to locate measured and indicated Magnetite Ore within Area A up to a total of 6,000,000,000 (six billion) tonnes of which up to 4,000,000,000 (four billion) tonnes may be subject to Project Agreements with Further Companies. The exercise of any option hereunder is subject to sufficient Magnetite Ore being available within Area A excluding the Transport Corridor. CITIC must report to Mineralogy every 12 months from the date hereof in writing setting out full geological results for any resources or reserves defined in accordance with the JORC Code and CITIC must provide an updated geological model each 12 months commencing on the date 12 months after the date of this agreement. (my emphasis in bold) For more of the CPOA's Drilling Obligation of CITIC context, see also CPOA cl 2.6 under the heading 'Information':The Seller [either Mineralogy of Mr Palmer] must provide CITIC with all information reasonably requested by CITIC evidencing its compliance with this Agreement. CITIC must provide the Seller with all information reasonably requested by the Seller evidencing its compliance with this Agreement. I have mentioned CPOA cl 2.6 in a context of that expressly made mutual covenant as regards the 'evidencing' of matters concerning each side's respective compliance with the CPOA. There is little doubt that the covenant would embrace required information concerning the drilling work CITIC had performed across Area A and what amounts of money CITIC had expended in terms of it executing that Drilling Obligation under CPOA cl 2.4 - and which is seen as being of potentially up to some five years in duration (ie, from 31 March 2006 to 31 March 2011). To reiterate, the amount spent by CITIC Ltd in terms of it discharging its CPOA Drilling Obligation bears relevantly, as a subtractable amount in a necessary calculation of the Purchase Consideration that is to be computed as eventually payable by CITIC Ltd to either Mineralogy or to Mr Palmer (depending on who is the CPOA Seller) for acquisition of (the shares in) a Further Company, under the First Option, once that option is exercised by CITIC Ltd (as is admitted to have occurred on 13 April 2012).