Choy v Queensland University of Technology

Link copied
Case Copied 96 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CHOY v QUEENSLAND UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY [2020] FCCA 3481
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Application based upon general protection claims, claims for breach of contract, and claims for contravention of provisions of Enterprise Agreement – Where instances of adverse action found, the Respondent was found to have rebutted the adverse statutory presumption of contravention – no other breaches found – adverse credibility findings made against applicant - application dismissed.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss.50, 65, 65(1A), 65(5), 340(1)(a), 340(1)(a)(i),

340(1)(a)(ii), 340(1)(a)(iii), 341, 341(1)(a), 341(1)(c)(ii), 342, 342(1)1.(a),

342(1)1.(b), 342(1)1.(c), 360, 361.

Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1999 (Cth), s.3(2).

Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld).

Cases cited:

Shea v TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6) [2014] FCA 271.

Maxutova v Nunn Media Pty Ltd [2017] FCCA 2336.
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Auimatagi (2017) 324
FLR 147.
Auimatagi v Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (2018) 363 ALR 246.
 Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union and Another v Visy Packaging Pty Ltd and Others (No 3) (2013) 216 FCR 70.
Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 248 CLR 500.
Russel v Institution of Engineers Australia T/A Engineers Australia [2013] FCA 1250.
Tsilibanks v Transfield Services (Australia) Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 740.
CFMEU v Coal and Allied Operations Pty (1999) 140 IR 131.
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Pilbara Iron Co (Services) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 697.
Commissioner for Government Transport v Royall (1966) 116 CLR 314.
Construction, Forestry, Mining, and Energy Union v Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1032.

Applicant: LAI FUNG CHOY
Respondent: QUEENSLAND UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY
File Number: BRG 1100 of 2017
Judgment of: Judge Egan
Hearing date:

15, 16, 17 May and 20, 21, 22 November

2019, 2, 3, 4 November 2020.

Date of Last Submission: 4 November 2020
Delivered at: Brisbane
Delivered on: 22 December 2020

REPRESENTATION

Applicant: In person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr McKechnie
Solicitors for the Respondent: Minter Ellison

ORDERS

  1. The applicant’s application filed on 9 November 2017 be dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT Brisbane

BRG 1100 of 2017

lai fung choy

Applicant

And

queensland university of technology

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Progress of Matter to Trial

  1. This matter was case managed by another Judge from the time of the filing of the Form 2 Claim on 9 November 2017. That Judge listed the matter for a three (3) day hearing commencing on 15 May 2019. After the initial three (3) day hearing, a further three (3) day hearing took place in November 2019 after hearing dates had become available. When the matter was next listed for hearing in April 2020, it had to be adjourned because of listing arrangements having been thrown into turmoil due to the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. The trial was next listed for a three (3) day hearing in November 2020 when…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Choy v Queensland University of Technology and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 3481
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Ms Choy, brought proceedings against the respondent, Queensland University of Technology (QUT), concerning the termination of her probationary employment. The dispute arose from QUT's decision to terminate Ms Choy's employment based on unsatisfactory performance during her probationary period. The matter was heard by Egan J in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether QUT had lawfully terminated Ms Choy's probationary employment. This involved determining if the University had followed the relevant provisions of its Enterprise Agreement and if the decision to terminate was based on a genuine assessment of Ms Choy's performance, taking into account all the material presented. The Court also considered whether Ms Choy had been afforded procedural fairness and sufficient opportunity to respond to the performance concerns raised.

Egan J reasoned that QUT had complied with the requirements of its Enterprise Agreement in terminating Ms Choy's employment. The Court found that Ms Choy had been made aware of the performance concerns, provided with opportunities to respond, and that the decision-maker had considered all relevant information, including Ms Choy's written responses and grievances. The Court was satisfied that the performance concerns raised by Ms Choy's supervisor were legitimate and reasonable, and that Ms Choy had not demonstrated satisfactory performance during her probationary period. The Court noted that the existence of unresolved grievances did not preclude the University from making a decision on the probationary appointment, provided sufficient information was available.

The Court ultimately dismissed Ms Choy's application, finding that QUT had acted within its rights in terminating her employment. The termination was effective from the date of the letter, with payment in lieu of one week's notice and for accrued untaken leave entitlements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The letter of termination which was sent to the applicant was under the hand of Ms Bunning and was dated 26 June 2017. It provided as follows: [6][6] See Annexure NB-29 to Bunning Affidavit filed on 5 July 2018 at p. 187 – 191 inclusive (‘Bunning Affidavit’). “Dear Ms Choy,Decision in relation to your employmentI refer to recent correspondence, including my letter to you of 9 June 2017.As you are aware from that correspondence, your direct supervisor Ms Seema Patel (Director, Assurance and Risk Management Services) has recommended the termination of your probationary appointment on the grounds that you have not demonstrated satisfactory performance. Ms Patel's recommendation is set out in a memorandum to me dated 8 June 2017 which was provided to you by Ms Patel on 8 June 2017.In accordance with clause 52.2.4 of the Enterprise Agreement (Professional Staff) 2014-2017 (Enterprise Agreement), on 9 June 2017 I provided you with an opportunity to provide a response, within five working days, as to why the recommendation to terminate your probationary appointment should not be approved. On 15 June 2017 you requested an extension of time until 20 June 2017 to provide your response, which I approved later that day. On 20 June 2017, I received your written response.I had a meeting scheduled with you on Monday 26 June 2017, which had been rescheduled from the week before at your request. The purpose of that meeting was to consult with you further prior to making my decision to accept or reject Ms Patel's recommendation. On 26 June 2017 you notified me that you were unable to attend our meeting due to ill health.In my correspondence dated 22 June 2017 I advised that if you were not able to attend the meeting scheduled for 26 June 2017 I would be required to proceed with making my decision based on the material available to me. I have now done so in accordance with the clause 52.2.4 of the Enterprise Agreement.Materials consideredIn making my decision, I have had regard to all of the information available to me, including but not limited to:·Notes from meeting on 31 March 2017 dated 3 April 2017;·Letter from you to the Vice-Chancellor dated 4 May 2017 lodging a complaint against Ms Patel (including attachments);·Letter from Shard Lorenzo, University Registrar to you dated 9 May 2017 regarding your complaint;·Letter from you to Ms Lorenzo dated 10 May 2017 regarding your complaint;·Letter from myself to you dated 23 May 2017 regarding your performance concerns and your probation period;·Correspondence I exchanged with you between 23 May 2017 and 29 May 2017;·Email from you to Ms Catrina Dieckmann Scott dated 31 May 2017 (including attached information/examples of concerns and supporting documents);·Correspondence between you and Mr Lovi between 2 June 2017 and 7 June 2017 regarding the performance concerns;·Memorandum from Ms Patel to myself dated 8 June 2017 recommending the termination of your probationary appointment·Letter from myself to you dated 9 June 2017 about your probation period and requesting your response to the recommendation to terminate your employment;·Letter from you to myself dated 20 June 2017 regarding the unresolved grievance;·Letter from you to myself dated 20 June 2017 raising a complaint regarding Mr Brian Lovi and Ms Catrina Dieckmann Scott;·Letter from you to myself dated 20 June 2017 regarding your written response to the recommendation to terminate your employment; and·Letter from you to the Vice-Chancellor dated 20 June 2017 lodging a grievance against Mrs Jacqui Kidd.Having considered all relevant material, I believe I have before me sufficient information to make a decision whether to accept or reject the recommendation of Ms Patel regarding your probationary appointment.Relevant background and considerationI have summarised the relevant background and my consideration (as relevant) below.On 21 March 2017, Ms Patel raised concerns about your performance in relation to your behaviour, in particular:·work effectively as part of a team; and·manage your workload.These performance concerns were discussed in detail with you during a meeting on 31 March 2017. This meeting was attended by you, Ms Patel, Mr Brian Lovi (Associate Director, HR, Client Services) and Gordon (your support person and former supervisor). During the meeting, Ms Patel discussed the performance concerns with you and provided you with examples. You indicated that you were unaware of the performance concerns and that you required time to reflect on them before providing a response. During this meeting, expectations were agreed to help resolve the performance concerns.The performance concerns raised in the meeting on 31 March 2017 were serious. During the meeting Ms Patel outlined that she was committed to working with you to address the concerns and that if they were not addressed she would not recommend that your probationary appointment be confirmed. This is reflected in Ms Patel's notes of the meeting, which were sent to you on 3 April 2017.Ms Patel and Mr Lovi have confirmed that the minutes of the meeting on 31 March 2017 reflect their recollection of the meeting. I have noted your advice that you do not accept the minutes of the meeting are accurate and that you consider the minutes present a 'distorted view of the proceedings of the meeting'. In particular you have advised that you do not recall Ms Patel advising during the meeting that if the performance concerns were not addressed she would not recommend your probationary appointment be confirmed.Although you do not recall this matter being discussed in the meeting, I note that from 3 April 2017 you had notice of the seriousness of the performance concerns and that they could result in termination of your probationary appointment.Subsequent to the meeting, you had four days of unplanned sick leave from 4 April 2017 to 7 April 2017 and following that you took pre-approved recreation leave from 10 April 2017 to 21 April 2017. A follow up meeting was scheduled for 8 May 2017 to provide you with sufficient time to respond to the performance concerns and to discuss your progress against the agreed expectations.On 4 May 2017 you lodged a complaint with the Vice-Chancellor alleging inappropriate behaviour towards you by Ms Patel. Ms Patel was subsequently advised that you had lodged a grievance about her to the Vice-Chancellor and, as such, the meeting of 8 May 2017 did not proceed and progression of discussions regarding your unsatisfactory performance were put on hold to attempt to resolve your grievance.Your grievance was dealt with in accordance with the University's policy, ‘B/10.1 Grievance resolution procedures for workplace related grievances and bullying' (Grievance Procedure). On 1 June 2017 a conciliation conference was held between you and Ms Patel in relation to your grievance. The grievance was not resolved at the conciliation conference.On several occasions, you were informed that Ms Patel was available to meet with you prior to the final review meeting to further discuss the concerns about your performance. You were also offered the opportunity to provide any written submission to Ms Patel regarding the performance concerns prior to the final probation review meeting.You did not take up the opportunity to discuss the concerns with Ms Patel or provide any written submissions prior to the final probation review meeting, which was scheduled for 8 June 2017. You declined to attend the final probation review meeting and subsequently provided a medical certificate for the period 7 to 9 June 2017. On 8 June 2017 Ms Patel issued the memorandum referred to above, which recommends that I terminate your probationary appointment. A copy of the memorandum was provided to you by Ms Patel on 8 June 2017.Your probationary appointment was initially due to expire on 12 June 2017. On 23 May 2017 1 provided you with the opportunity to extend the probationary period by four weeks to enable further time for you to address the performance concerns and for additional discussion to take place between you and Ms Patel. You declined this offer.On 9 June 2017 I wrote to you to inform you that I had decided to extend your probationary period until 28 June 2017 pursuant to clause 52.1.5 of the Enterprise Agreement, on the basis that you took an extended period of leave from 4 April until 21 April 2017. As detailed in my correspondence, although it is not necessary for a probationary decision to be made within the probationary period, it is desirable for this to occur.In accordance with the Enterprise Agreement you were provided with five working days to provide me with a response to the memorandum. You requested an extension to provide your response to 20 June 2017, which was granted.On 20 June 2017 you provided a written response regarding Ms Patel's recommendation (of 8 June 2017) that your probationary appointment be terminated.Just prior to this, also on 20 June 2017, you wrote to me to:·Advise that you considered that your grievance in relation to Ms Patel was not resolved; and ·Raise a new grievance in relation to Mr Lovi and Ms Dieckmann Scott.On 20 June 2017 you also wrote to the Vice Chancellor to raise a new grievance in relation to your colleague Mrs Jacqui Kidd. I wrote to you on 22 June 2017 advising you of the processes that would be followed in relation to the three grievances.DecisionHaving considered the above information, my decision is to accept the recommendation from Ms Patel to terminate your probationary appointment because you have not demonstrated satisfactory performance.The sole reason for my decision is that I am satisfied you have not demonstrated satisfactory performance during your probationary period. My decision has been made within 10 working days of receipt of your submission dated 20 June 2017.In reaching my decision I have considered your responses in full, including the following matters:1. I have determined that your performance has not improved since the concerns were raised with you and expectations were set on 31 March 2017.2. You consider that you have not been provided with sufficient detail of the performance concerns. based on my review of the relevant documents and background, as outlined above, I am of the view that you have been provided with sufficient detail of the performance concerns.3. I also consider that you have been provided with a sufficient opportunity to respond to and address the performance concerns that have been raised with you. You were notified on several occasions that Ms Patel was available to meet with you to discuss the performance concerns with you. You did not take up this opportunity.4. You were also offered the opportunity to provide any written submission to Ms Patel regarding the performance concerns prior to the final probation review meeting. You provided a response on 20 June 2017, which, as outlined above, I have fully considered.5. In the grievances you raised on 20 June 2017 you made reference to the exacerbation of a shoulder injury and advised that this has affected your ability to expand on allegations about Ms Patel as part of the grievance process in relation to her. This injury was also the basis for requesting the extension to provide your response to the memorandum (which was granted). I have noted that the injury has not prevented you from providing a response to the performance issues.6. You refer to Ms Patel's 'allegations' of performance issues and submit that they remain 'unsubstantiated to date as no credible, valid or relevant evidence [has] been provided'. As your supervisor, Ms Patel is entitled to appraise your work performance and her appraisal is not an 'allegation'. My role in considering Ms Patel's recommendation is to assess whether the performance concerns raised by Ms Patel are reasonable and consistent with her recommendation to terminate your probationary appointment.7. I have considered your complaint letter dated 4 May 2017 and subsequent information provided to Ms Dieckmann Scott as part of the grievance process. You raise a number of issues in relation to Ms Patel's management of you. It is not necessary for me to make any decision about whether those allegations are substantiated or not. Rather, I must determine whether or not to approve the recommendation based on the merits of the material provided by Ms Patel and you.8. I note that you consider that the performance concerns that have been raised by Ms Patel are not valid and that you consider that if your allegations against Ms Patel are found to be true, then the performance concerns raised by her cannot be legitimate.9. I have considered the issues which are the subject of your grievance against Ms Patel. Although I am not required to determine whether these matters are substantiated, I have considered them in detail in the context of whether the performance concerns raised by Ms Patel are legitimate and reasonable. I have concluded that Ms Patel's concerns are legitimate and reasonable. I disagree with your assessment that no credible, valid or relevant evidence has been provided by Ms Patel in relation to the performance concerns.10. I note your statement that you believe it is vital that each and every incident exhibiting Ms Patel's alleged inappropriate and unreasonable behaviours are considered as part of the grievance process. It is correct, as you have pointed out, that the Grievance Procedure requires that all relevant submissions and evidence must be considered. However, the fact that there is an unresolved grievance process does not prevent me from making a decision whether to approve or reject Ms Patel's recommendation provided I am satisfied that sufficient information is before me to enable me to make that decision. It is not relevant or necessary for me to make a determination regarding your complaints about the manner in which the grievance has been conducted.11. Further, I have noted that Ms Patel was not aware that you had any issues with her management of you prior to her advising you of the performance issues on 21 March 2017. I have noted this as relevant because it goes to my consideration of whether the performance issues Ms Patel has raised are reasonable. It is clear to me that the issues have not been raised by Ms Patel because of or in response to any complaint you have raised about her. I acknowledge your advice that you contacted Workplace Health and Safety Queensland on 15 March 2017. There is no evidence that Ms Patel (or any other University officer) was aware of this prior to Ms Patel advising you of the performance issues on 21 March 2017.For all of these reasons, I have decided that it is appropriate to accept Ms Patel's recommendation to terminate your probationary appointment.In accordance with clause 52.2.5 of the Enterprise Agreement, this letter serves as notice of termination of your employment effective today. You will be paid in lieu of one week's notice. You will also receive payment for any accrued but untaken leave entitlements.Due to the sensitive and confidential nature of the work undertaken by ARMS, I have determined that your access to QUT's systems and premises will be removed effectively immediately. Please contact my office on [phone number omitted] to arrange for the return of any University property.I appreciate that this matter has been stressful for you. Accordingly I have arranged for you to have ongoing access to University's confidential counselling service via Assure Programs for a period of six months following termination of your employment.On behalf of the University I wish you well in your future endeavours.Yours sincerelyNicole BunningDirector, Human Resources”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established