Chen by her tutor Huang v Kmart Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Chen by her tutor Huang v Kmart Australia Ltd [2023] NSWCA 96
Hearing dates: 14 April 2023
Decision date: 16 May 2023
Before: White JA at [1];
Griffiths AJA at [53];
Weinstein J at [54]
Decision:

(1) Refuse the respondent’s application for leave to cross-appeal with costs;

(2) Grant the applicant leave to appeal from the orders of the District Court of 28 October 2022;

(3) Dismiss the appeal with costs.

Catchwords:

NEGLIGENCE – Damages – Assessment of damages – Damages for non-economic loss – Where primary judge awarded sum for persistent pain and suffering in the period spanning infliction of injury and remedial surgeries, assessed at 25% of a most extreme case – Where applicant contends that primary judge failed to have regard to physical and emotional trauma of the injury itself and of potential corrective surgeries – Where primary judge’s reasons address trauma of injury and future potential surgeries – Whether primary judge’s award of damages for non-economic loss evinces error of the kind enumerated in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 – no error established

NEGLIGENCE – Damages – Assessment of damages – Assessment of loss of earning capacity for injury negligently occasioned to young child – Where applicant suffered laceration of right eyelid at respondent’s store – Where laceration resulted in mild facial scarring and ptosis of applicant’s right eyelid – Where primary judge awarded sum for loss of earning capacity by way of buffer – Whether evidence adduced by applicant established that scarring or ptosis will, or may, be productive of financial loss – Whether buffer sum inadequately compensated applicant for loss of earning capacity – Whether respondent ought to be given leave to cross-appeal on the ground that applicant had not proven financial loss will, or may, occur on the balance of probabilities – Held that sum awarded by primary judge for loss of earning capacity was within reasonable range of potential awards

Legislation Cited:

Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), ss 13, 16

Cases Cited:

Brown v Hewson [2015] NSWCA 393

Graham v Baker (1961) 106 CLR 340; [1961] HCA 48

House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; [1936] HCA 40

Husher v Husher (1999) 197 CLR 138; [1999] HCA 47

Loxton v New South Wales [2002] NSWCA 194; (2002) Aust Torts Reports 81-667

Malec v JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638; [1990] HCA 20

New South Wales v Moss (2000) 54 NSWLR 536; [2000] NSWCA 133

Penrith City Council v Parks [2004] NSWCA 201

Pollard v Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 99; (2008) Aust Torts Reports 81-949

Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 197 CLR 332; [1994] HCA 4

Warren v Coombes (1979) 142 CLR 531; [1979] HCA 9

White v Redding (2019) 99 NSWLR 605; [2019] NSWCA 152

Zreika v New South Wales [2009] NSWCA 99

Texts Cited:

H Luntz & S Harder, Assessment…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chen by her tutor Huang v Kmart Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWCA 96
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal and a cross-appeal arising from a District Court judgment awarding damages for negligence. The applicant, a young child, suffered a laceration to her right eyelid at the respondent's store, resulting in mild facial scarring and ptosis of the eyelid. The primary judge had awarded damages for non-economic loss and loss of earning capacity. The respondent sought leave to cross-appeal against the award for loss of earning capacity, while the applicant sought to appeal the quantum of damages awarded.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the primary judge erred in assessing damages for non-economic loss, specifically concerning the applicant's persistent pain and suffering, and whether the primary judge adequately compensated the applicant for loss of earning capacity. The applicant contended that the primary judge failed to adequately consider the physical and emotional trauma of the injury and potential corrective surgeries when assessing non-economic loss. The respondent argued that the applicant had not proven, on the balance of probabilities, that the scarring or ptosis would be productive of financial loss, and therefore the buffer sum awarded for loss of earning capacity was inadequate.

The Court of Appeal found no error in the primary judge's assessment of damages for non-economic loss, noting that the primary judge's reasons addressed the trauma of the injury and potential future surgeries. The Court also determined that the sum awarded for loss of earning capacity was within a reasonable range of potential awards, and that the evidence adduced was sufficient to establish that the scarring or ptosis might be productive of financial loss. Consequently, the Court refused the respondent's application for leave to cross-appeal and dismissed the applicant's appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Refuse the respondent’s application for leave to cross-appeal with costs;

(2) Grant the applicant leave to appeal from the orders of the District Court of 28 October 2022;

(3) Dismiss the appeal with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Chen, a young child, suffered a laceration of her right eyelid while shopping at a Kmart store in Australia. The incident resulted in mild facial scarring and ptosis of her right eyelid. The primary judge awarded Chen a sum for persistent pain and suffering, covering the period from the infliction of the injury up until the remedial surgeries, assessed at 25% of a most extreme case. Chen's tutor, Huang, argued that the primary judge failed to consider the physical and emotional trauma of the injury itself and the potential corrective surgeries. However, the primary judge's reasons did address the trauma of the injury and the future potential surgeries.

In addition to the damages for pain and suffering, the primary judge awarded a buffer sum for the loss of earning capacity caused by the injury to Chen's right eyelid. The buffer sum was intended to cover any potential financial loss resulting from the scarring or ptosis. Chen argued that the buffer sum was inadequate as it did not sufficiently compensate for the potential financial loss. The respondent, Kmart Australia Ltd, sought leave to cross-appeal on the ground that Chen had not proven that financial loss would, or may, occur on the balance of probabilities. The court found that the sum awarded by the primary judge for the loss of earning capacity was within the reasonable range of potential awards.

The court refused the respondent's application for leave to cross-appeal with costs, granted the applicant leave to appeal from the orders of the District Court, and dismissed the appeal with costs. The court found no error in the primary judge's assessment of damages for non-economic loss and loss of earning capacity, and the award was deemed to be within the reasonable range of potential awards.

The proceedings in Chen by her tutor Huang v Kmart Australia Ltd originated in the District Court of Victoria, where Chen, a minor, brought a negligence claim against Kmart Australia Ltd for injuries sustained at one of its stores. The primary judge awarded Chen damages for persistent pain and suffering, assessing this at 25% of a most extreme case, as well as a buffer sum for loss of earning capacity due to mild facial scarring and ptosis of her right eyelid. Unsatisfied with the quantum of damages awarded, Chen sought to appeal the decision, contending that the primary judge failed to adequately consider the physical and emotional trauma associated with her injuries and potential corrective surgeries. Concurrently, Kmart Australia Ltd applied for leave to cross-appeal, arguing that Chen had not demonstrated on the balance of probabilities that the scarring or ptosis would result in any financial loss, and thus the sum awarded for loss of earning capacity was inadequate. The Court of Appeal considered both the appeal and cross-appeal, ultimately dismissing the appeal and refusing the cross-appeal, holding that the primary judge’s assessment of damages was within the reasonable range of potential awards and that no error warranting appellate intervention was established.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary judge’s award of damages for non-economic loss evinces error of the kind enumerated in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499.
2. Whether the evidence adduced by the applicant established that the scarring or ptosis will, or may, be productive of financial loss.
3. Whether the buffer sum adequately compensated the applicant for loss of earning capacity.
4. Whether the respondent should be given leave to cross-appeal on the ground that the applicant had not proven financial loss will, or may, occur on the balance of probabilities.

Held
1. The court concluded that the primary judge’s award of damages for non-economic loss did not evince error of the kind enumerated in House v The King. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
2. The court determined that the evidence adduced by the applicant did not establish that the scarring or ptosis will, or may, be productive of financial loss. The application on this issue was dismissed.
3. The court found that the buffer sum awarded by the primary judge adequately compensated the applicant for loss of earning capacity. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
4. The court refused the respondent’s application for leave to cross-appeal on the ground that the applicant had not proven financial loss will, or may, occur on the balance of probabilities. The application for leave to cross-appeal was refused with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Chen by her tutor Huang v Kmart Australia Ltd, the Court of Appeal considered several issues pertinent to the assessment of damages for non-economic loss and loss of earning capacity. The first issue pertained to the primary judge’s award of damages for non-economic loss and whether it constituted an error of the kind outlined in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499. The applicant argued that the primary judge failed to adequately consider the physical and emotional trauma of the injury and the potential corrective surgeries. However, the Court of Appeal found that the primary judge’s reasons sufficiently addressed the trauma of the injury and the future potential surgeries. The Court held that the primary judge’s award did not evince an error as it appropriately considered the factors relevant to the assessment of non-economic loss. The Court’s reasoning was grounded in the understanding that the primary judge’s detailed consideration of the trauma and potential surgeries reflected a balanced approach, and thus, the award did not fall within the errors enumerated in House v The King.

The second issue examined whether the evidence presented by the applicant established that the scarring or ptosis would or might result in financial loss. The applicant argued that the physical manifestations of the injury would likely lead to financial implications. The Court of Appeal assessed the evidence and concluded that the scarring and ptosis did not have a substantial likelihood of producing financial loss. The Court reasoned that the evidence did not convincingly demonstrate a direct correlation between the physical attributes and any future financial detriment, thereby supporting the primary judge’s decision that there was no substantial evidence of financial loss resulting from the scarring or ptosis.

The third issue focused on whether the buffer sum awarded by the primary judge adequately compensated the applicant for her loss of earning capacity. The applicant contended that the buffer sum was insufficient to cover the potential loss of future earnings. The Court of Appeal examined the evidence and found that the primary judge’s award of a buffer sum fell within a reasonable range of potential awards for loss of earning capacity. The Court reasoned that the buffer sum was a prudent estimate considering the speculative nature of future earnings and the limited evidence of any significant impact on the applicant’s earning capacity. The Court’s decision was based on the principle that awards for loss of earning capacity must balance the speculative nature of future income against the potential for loss, and in this case, the buffer sum was deemed adequate.

The final issue involved whether the respondent should be granted leave to cross-appeal on the ground that the applicant had not proven that financial loss would or might occur on the balance of probabilities. The respondent argued for the opportunity to cross-appeal on the basis that the primary judge’s findings regarding financial loss were unsupported by the evidence. The Court of Appeal held that the respondent’s application for leave to cross-appeal should be refused. The Court reasoned that the evidence did not substantiate a significant likelihood of financial loss and that the primary judge’s findings were reasonable within the context of the speculative nature of future financial implications. The Court’s decision was rooted in the understanding that cross-appeal should not be permitted if the primary judge’s findings were within the realm of reasonable conclusions based on the evidence presented.

The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the Court of Appeal’s affirmation that the primary judge’s award for non-economic loss was appropriately assessed, the evidence did not support a claim for financial loss due to scarring or ptosis, the buffer sum for loss of earning capacity was adequately set, and the respondent was not granted leave to cross-appeal as the primary judge’s findings were reasonable. The Court distinguished its approach from prior authority by emphasizing the need for a balanced and evidence-based assessment of damages, particularly in cases involving speculative future financial loss and non-economic damages.