Charter Pacific Corporation Ltd v Belrida Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Charter Pacific Corporation Ltd v Belrida Enterprises Pty Ltd & Ors [2002] QSC 254

PARTIES:

CHARTER PACIFIC CORPORATION LIMITED
           
(plaintiff)
v
BELRIDA ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
           
(first defendant)
THOMAS QUINN
           
(second defendant)
MICHAEL JOHN COVENTRY and LYNETTE

HELEN COVENTRY as trustees of the

MIKE AND LYN COVENTRY FAMILY TRUST
           
(third defendants)
BARRY TABE as trustee of the TABE FAMILY TRUST
           
(fourth defendant)
ANDREW COVENTRY
           
(fifth defendant)


MICHAEL JOHN COVENTRY and LYNETTE HELEN COVENTRY as trustees of the MIKE AND LYN COVENTRY FAMILY TRUST

           (first cross-claimants)
BARRY TABE and ANDREW COVENTRY as trustees of the TABE FAMILY TRUST
           (second cross-claimants)
v
CHARTER PACIFIC CORPORATION LIMITED

           (first defendant by counterclaim)
KEVIN JOHN DART
           (second defendant by cross-claim)
BRYAN GERRARD DART
           (third defendant by cross-claim)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 784 of 1994

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Claim, counterclaim and cross-claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

30 August 2002

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

24 January 2000 – 3 March 2000; 28, 29, 31 August 2000; 1 September 2000 – 6 October 2000; 11 October 2000 – 13 November 2000; 15 November 2000 – 23 November 2000; 28 November 2000 – 8 December 2000; 29 January 2001 – 16 February 2001; 26 February 2001 – 6 April 2001; 17 April 2001 – 24 April 2001; 26 April 2001 – 2 May 2001; 28 May 2001 – 1 June 2001.

JUDGE:

Fryberg J

ORDER:

Judgment for the plaintiff against the third, fourth and fifth defendants for $604,634.30 plus interest to date, calculated from 1 June 1994 at the rate which is one per cent higher than the benchmark rate of the National Australia Bank from time to time.1.   

Judgment for the first cross-claimants against the plaintiff for $397,600 plus interest to date, calculated on $360,000 from 1 June 1994 and on $37,600 from 29 July 1994, at the rate which is one per cent higher than the benchmark rate of the National Australia Bank from time to time2.   .

Judgment for the second cross-claimants against the plaintiff for $397,600 plus interest to date, calculated on $360,000 from 1 June 1994 and on $37,600 from 29 July 1994, at the rate which is one per cent higher than the benchmark rate of the National Australia Bank from time to time.3.   

4.   Action relisted for further argument as to the form of order and costs.

CATCHWORDS:

EQUITY – Fraudulent and innocent misrepresentation – Materiality, inducement and reliance upon misrepresentation – Where misrepresentation objectively likely to induce party to contract – How reliance proved

CORPORATIONS – Corporate finance – Shares – Valuation – Whether agreement induced by misrepresentations could assist in determining value – Most appropriate method of valuation

DAMAGES – General principles – Whether costs recoverable as damages

BANKRUPTCY – Administration of property – Proof of debts – What debts provable – Damages and contingent liabilities – Damages under s 1005 Corporations Law – Whether damages “by reason of a contract” – s 82(2) Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

EQUITY…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Charter Pacific Corporation Ltd v Belrida Enterprises Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] QSC 254
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Charter Pacific Corporation Ltd brought proceedings against Belrida Enterprises Pty Ltd and others, seeking damages for fraudulent and innocent misrepresentation and other relief. The Federal Court of Australia heard the case, which involved complex issues of corporate finance, equity, and damages. The central dispute was whether the plaintiff could rely on fraudulent and innocent misrepresentations to determine the value of shares and to seek damages. The court also considered the recoverability of costs as damages, the nature of provable debts in bankruptcy, and the appropriateness of interlocutory injunctions and undertakings.

The court had to decide several legal issues, including the materiality and inducement of the misrepresentations, the appropriate method of share valuation, and the recoverable costs as damages. It needed to determine whether the misrepresentations were objectively likely to induce a party to contract, and if so, how reliance upon such misrepresentations could be proven. The court also had to consider whether the damages claimed were "by reason of a contract" for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) and whether the interlocutory injunctions and undertakings were reasonable attempts to mitigate the apprehended loss.

The court found that the plaintiff could indeed rely on the misrepresentations to determine the value of the shares and to seek damages. It held that the misrepresentations were material and likely to induce reliance. The court also determined that the appropriate method of valuation was to consider the effect of the misrepresentations. Regarding costs, the court found that they were recoverable as damages. It further held that the damages claimed were "by reason of a contract" under the Bankruptcy Act, and that the interlocutory injunctions and undertakings were reasonable attempts to mitigate the apprehended loss. The court therefore enforced the undertakings.

The court made several orders, including a judgment for the plaintiff against the third, fourth and fifth defendants for $604,634.30 plus interest. It also made judgments for the first and second cross-claimants against the plaintiff for $397,600 plus interest. The action was relisted for further argument as to the form of order and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the plaintiff against the third, fourth and fifth defendants for $604,634.30 plus interest to date, calculated from 1 June 1994 at the rate which is one per cent higher than the benchmark rate of the National Australia Bank from time to time.1.

Judgment for the first cross-claimants against the plaintiff for $397,600 plus interest to date, calculated on $360,000 from 1 June 1994 and on $37,600 from 29 July 1994, at the rate which is one per cent higher than the benchmark rate of the National Australia Bank from time to time2. .

Judgment for the second cross-claimants against the plaintiff for $397,600 plus interest to date, calculated on $360,000 from 1 June 1994 and on $37,600 from 29 July 1994, at the rate which is one per cent higher than the benchmark rate of the National Australia Bank from time to time.3.

4. Action relisted for further argument as to the form of order and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established