TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Chanel Limited to registration of trade mark application 1655658 (3, 4, 29) - NOIX DE COCO and device - in the name of Emily Greco
| Delegate: | Adrian Richards |
| Representation: | Opponent: Sean McManis of Shelston IP Applicant: Written submissions by Emily Greco |
| Decision: | 2017 ATMO 69 Opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – sections 44 and 60 pressed – ground of opposition under section 44 established – registration refused |
Background
Ms Emily Greco (‘the Applicant’) filed an application for registration under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘the Act’) in respect of the following trade mark:
Application number: 1655658
Trade mark:
(‘the Trade Mark’)
Specification of goods: Class 3: Aftershave moisturising cream; Anti-ageing creams; Beauty creams; Cleansing creams; Massage creams, not medicated; Nail treatment creams (cosmetics); Non-medicated creams; Non-medicated creams for moisturising the skin; Non-medicated creams for personal care; Non-medicated creams for softening the skin; Non-medicated creams for soothing the skin; Non-medicated creams for the feet; Non-medicated creams for the lips
Class 4: Candles; Fragranced candles; Perfumed candles; Scented candles
Class 29: Coconut oil
Filing date: 4 November 2014 (‘the Relevant Date’)
The Trade Mark was advertised on 26 March 2015 as having been accepted for possible registration. On 26 May 2015, Chanel Limited (‘the Opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose registration of the Trade Mark. In accordance with the procedure prescribed in Part 5 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘the Regulations’), all other documents required to establish the opposition process were duly filed by the parties, followed by their evidence.
After the parties’ evidence had all been submitted, the Opponent asked to be heard in person. A hearing was set down for 7 February 2017, which I held as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. Both parties filed written submissions beforehand, but the Applicant elected not to attend. The Opponent was represented at the hearing by Sean McManis of Shelston IP.
Evidence
The evidence filed by the parties consists of the following declarations:
Evidence in Support
Declaration of David Blakeley, Managing Director of Chanel (Australia) Pty Ltd, made 29 October 2015 with annexures DB-1 to DB-29, including confidential annexures DB-8 to DB-11 (‘Blakeley 1’).
Declaration of Sean Francis McManis, solicitor and principal at Shelston IP, made 29 October 2015 with Annexures A to C (‘McManis 1’).
Evidence in Answer
Declaration of Emily Greco, made 3 February 2016 (‘Greco’).
Evidence in Reply
Declaration of David Blakeley, Managing Director of Chanel (Australia) Pty Ltd, made 15 April 2016 with annexures DB-30 to DB-32 (‘Blakeley 2’).
Declaration of Sean Francis McManis, solicitor and principal at Shelston IP, made 14 April 2016 with Annexures SFM-1 to SFM-4 (‘McManis 2’).
Grounds and onus
The Opponent had nominated grounds of opposition under ss 42(b), 44 and 60 of the Act in its Statement of Grounds and Particulars; however s 42(b) was not pressed at the hearing. The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Chanel Limited v Emily Greco and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] ATMO 69
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the goods for which the Applicant sought registration (candles) were the same as, or of the same description as, the goods covered by the Opponent's registered trade marks, namely perfumes, soaps, and cosmetics. Secondly, if the goods were not the same, whether the Applicant's trade mark was deceptively similar to the Opponent's registered trade marks under section 44 of the relevant Act.
The court found that the goods claimed in Class 3 for the Applicant's trade mark, such as creams for corporeal use, were the same as the goods claimed in Class 3 for the Opponent's registered trade marks, which included toilet preparations and cosmetics. For goods in Class 4, specifically scented candles, the court considered whether they were of the same description as the Opponent's registered goods of perfumes, essential oils, and soaps. Applying a practical judgment based on the nature of the goods, their uses, and trade channels, the court considered evidence demonstrating that traders often applied their trade marks to both fragrances and candles, that well-established fragrances were used in scented candles, and that retailers commonly stocked both product lines. The court also noted evidence showing that candle making processes were similar to soap making and that fragrances or essential oils were often incorporated into scented candles, with candles sometimes used as a heat source for diffusing essential oils.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Opponent has put forward three of its own registered trade marks (together, ‘the Opponent’s Trade Marks’), the relevant details of which are set out below:Registration number: 210430Trade mark: COCOSpecification of goods: Class 3: Perfumed soap, perfumes, non-medicated toilet preparations, cosmetics and dentifrices, excluding all hair preparations, being goods included in Class 3Filing date: 22 May 1967 All three of the Opponent’s Trade Marks have a priority date earlier than the Relevant Date. Section 14(1) of the Act defines goods as being similar to other goods if they are the same as those other goods or if they are of the same description as those other goods. For each of the Opponent’s Trade Marks the goods are cast in broad terms such as ‘toilet preparations’ and ‘cosmetics’. The goods claimed in class 3 for the Trade Mark relate to various creams for corporeal use, a subset of ‘toilet preparations’ or ‘cosmetics’. I therefore find that each of the Opponent’s Trade Marks’ claimed goods in class 3 are the same as the claimed goods of the Trade Mark in class 3. For the Trade Mark’s claims to goods in class 4, the Opponent relies on its registrations’ coverage of perfumes (and other descriptions for fragrances), essential oils and soaps, such goods being ‘similar’ in terms of s 44 in light of the evidence in Blakely 1. The Trade Mark’s claim in class 4 is essentially for candles, with specific mention of scented candles. These are not the same goods as fragrances, essential oils and soaps, so it is necessary to consider whether they are of the same description. The test to be applied here is a practical judgement formed by looking at a number of factors, falling within the categories of the nature of the goods, their respective uses and the trade channels through which they are commonly sold, with no single factor being determinative.[3][3] Re Jellinek’s Application (1946) 63 RPC 59, 70. Mr Blakely has held a number of senior positions in the cosmetics and fashion industries over several decades. That said his awareness in relation to candles appears not to have been directly informed by this professional experience but by his own research and observations. The results of his research have however been annexed to the declaration, as have some materials which support his observations, so rather than relying on his experience or expertise, his evidence on this subject is largely corroborated. This evidence shows that a significant number of traders who attach their house trade mark to fragrances, essential oils and soaps also do so to candles. Notably, several well-established fragrances (and some rather overtly named imitations of them) were being used in scented candles at the Relevant Date. The evidence also shows that product lines of fragrances, essential oils, soaps and candles from the same trade source are also carried by the same retailers. Blakely 1 annexes several websites that concern candle making, providing instructions and the ability to order materials. These show that scented candles will often incorporate fragrances or essential oils, and that the processes that go into making candles are similar to making soap. Most of these websites also include instructions on soap making. Several of the websites also illustrate the practice of diffusing essential oils by use of heat, often with a candle used as the heat source.