Chaihine and Kamal and Ors (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CHAIHINE & KAMAL AND ORS (NO. 2) [2020] FamCA 728
FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Where interim financial orders made as between husband and wife – Where application by eighth Respondent for stay of certain of those orders pending appeal – Where consideration of applicable principles – Where application for stay refused – Where costs reserved
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 94AA
Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) r 22.11
Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685
Chaihine & Kamal and Ors [2020] FamCA 513
Fauna Holding Pty Ltd & Ors & Mitchell [2000] FamCA 548; (2000) FLC 93-024
Jackson & Balen [2009] FamCAFC 131
Medlow & Medlow [2016] FamCAFC 34; (2016) FLC 93-692
Re Middle Harbour Investments Ltd (in Liq) (unreported, Court of Appeal (NSW), 15 December 1976)
APPLICANT: Mr Chaihine
FIRST RESPONDENT: Ms Kamal
SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr B
THIRD RESPONDENT: Mr C Chaihine
FOURTH RESPONDENT: Mr D
FIFTH RESPONDENT: E Pty Ltd
SIXTH RESPONDENT: Mr A Chaihine
SEVENTH RESPONDENT: Mr M Chaihine
EIGHTH RESPONDENT: Mr F
NINTH RESPONDENT: G Pty Ltd
FILE NUMBER: PAC 2393 of 2018
DATE DELIVERED: 3 September 2020
PLACE DELIVERED: Parramatta
PLACE HEARD: Parramatta
JUDGMENT OF: Foster J
HEARING DATE: 24 July 2020 and by way of written submissions last received 13 August 2020

REPRESENTATION

SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Penhall & Co Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Mr O’Brien
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Sanford Legal
SOLICITOR FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Penhall & Co Lawyers
SOLICITOR FOR THE THIRD RESPONDENT: Penhall & Co Lawyers
SOLICITOR FOR THE FOURTH RESPONDENT: No appearance by Edmond Khoury Solicitors
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIFTH RESPONDENT: No appearance by Edmond Khoury Solicitors
SOLICITOR FOR THE SIXTH RESPONDENT: Penhall & Co Lawyers
SOLICITOR FOR THE SEVENTH RESPONDENT: Penhall & Co Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE EIGHTH RESPONDENT: Mr Lawrence
SOLICITOR FOR THE EIGHTH RESPONDENT: Keypoint Law
NINTH RESPONDENT – SELF-REPRESENTED LITIGANT: No appearance

Orders

  1. That the application by the eighth respondent for stay of orders made 26 June 2020 is dismissed.

  2. That the question of costs of the application for stay be reserved.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment by this Court under the pseudonym Chaihine & Kamal has been approved by the Chief Justice pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for Judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.02A(b) of the Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.02 Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth).

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT PARRAMATTA

FILE NUMBER: PAC 2393 of 2018

Mr Chaihine

Applicant

And

Ms Kamal

First Respondent

And

Mr B

Second Respondent

And

Mr C Chaihine

Third Respondent

And

Mr D

Fourth Respondent

And

E Pty Ltd

Fifth Respondent

And

Mr A Chaihine
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chaihine and Kamal and Ors (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FamCA 728
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Chaihine & Kamal and Ors (No. 2)*, the Family Court of Australia considered an application by the eighth respondent for a stay of interim financial orders made on 26 June 2020, pending an appeal to the Full Court. The dispute arose from financial proceedings between the husband and wife, where the eighth respondent, Mr F, claimed an interest in the proceeds of sale of a property at H Street, Suburb J, New South Wales. Interim orders had directed the distribution of these proceeds, and Mr F sought to prevent the operation of these orders pending his appeal.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether to grant a stay of the interim financial orders. This required the Court to consider the principles governing applications for stays pending appeal, particularly in the context of family law proceedings. The Court also had to determine whether the eighth respondent had established a sufficient basis to warrant such an intervention, especially given his prior conduct in the proceedings, including a failure to file a formal response or points of claim asserting his alleged equitable or common law interests.

The Court reasoned that a stay is an exceptional remedy and is not granted as a matter of course. It noted that the eighth respondent had failed to comply with previous court orders requiring him to file a response and particulars of his claim. Despite being joined to the proceedings and consenting to the sale of the Suburb J property, he had not formally articulated his claim. The Court found that the evidence suggested an arrangement by way of loan between the husband and the eighth respondent, rather than a clear equitable interest in the property itself. Given the eighth respondent's non-compliance with procedural requirements and the nature of his asserted claim as a prospective creditor, the Court concluded that the threshold for granting a stay had not been met.

Consequently, the Court dismissed the eighth respondent's application for a stay of the interim financial orders made on 26 June 2020. The question of the costs associated with this application was reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 26 June 2020, the Family Court of Australia made certain interim financial orders in a family law matter involving Mr Chaihine (the husband) and Ms Kamal (the wife). The orders related to the proceeds of sale of a property located at H Street, Suburb J, New South Wales. The Court ordered that the proceeds of sale be paid in accordance with earlier orders made on 30 October 2019, with some modifications. Specifically, the balance of the proceeds after payment of legal fees was to be paid into a trust account, used to pay off any outstanding arrears on a mortgage secured over another property at K Street, Suburb L, and a sum of $50,000 was to be paid to the wife. The remaining balance was to be used to make future mortgage payments, insurances, and rates for the Suburb L property.

The eighth respondent, Mr F, had been joined in the proceedings by the husband, although he had not filed a response or points of claim asserting any equitable or common law relief in relation to the matrimonial assets. Mr F had provided substantial finance for the Suburb J property and had attended a hearing on 30 October 2019 when consent orders for the sale of the property were made. However, he had not engaged in the proceedings since then, and his solicitors only filed a Notice of Address for Service on 9 July 2020.

On 13 July 2020, Mr F filed an application seeking a stay of the operation of the orders made on 26 June 2020 pending the determination of his appeal against those orders. He also sought leave to file a response to the wife's initiating application within 28 days. Mr F asserted that he had an interest in the Suburb J property and that the husband owed him money for funds provided in relation to the property. He claimed that he had provided approximately $377,351 in relation to the Suburb J property and other funds to the husband. Mr F asserted that he had a joint venture agreement with the husband relating to the property and that he would assert that the husband was indebted to him for a sum certain as a consequence of the sale of the property.

In considering the application for a stay, the Court noted that a stay would not be granted lightly or as a matter of course. The Court would consider factors such as the balance of convenience, the competing rights of the parties, and the risk that an appeal may be rendered nugatory if a stay is not granted. The Court would also make a preliminary assessment of whether the appellant has an arguable case.

In this case, the Court found that there was significant doubt as to whether Mr F would get leave to proceed with his appeal against the interlocutory order. The Court also found that if the stay was not granted, the appeal would not be rendered nugatory, as Mr F's claim for an accounting under the joint venture agreement would be determined at the final trial. The balance of convenience favoured the wife, as the present orders prevented the sale of the home occupied by her and the children due to significant mortgage arrears. The Court therefore dismissed the application for a stay.

The matter came before the Family Court of Australia as an interlocutory application by the eighth respondent for a stay of certain interim financial orders made on 26 June 2020. The eighth respondent, Mr F, sought to stay the orders pending the determination of his appeal against those orders. The application arose out of complex financial proceedings between the husband, Ms Kamal, and various other respondents relating to the disposition of matrimonial assets, including the sale of a property at H Street, Suburb J, New South Wales. The eighth respondent, who was purportedly joined to the proceedings by the husband, sought to assert an interest in the proceeds of sale of the Suburb J property based on a claimed loan arrangement with the husband. The application for a stay was heard and determined by Foster J, who dismissed the application and reserved the question of costs. In reaching his decision, the Judge considered the principles applicable to stay applications, the merits of the eighth respondent’s appeal, and the balance of convenience between the parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the eighth respondent have a valid basis to seek a stay of the interim financial orders made between the husband and wife?
2. Has the eighth respondent demonstrated an appropriate case for the stay of the interim financial orders?
3. Does the balance of convenience favour the grant of a stay to the eighth respondent?
4. Is there a significant risk that the appeal by the eighth respondent will be rendered nugatory if a stay is not granted?
5. Does the eighth respondent have an arguable case on appeal based on the grounds outlined in his Notice of Appeal?
6. Should the court consider the merits of the eighth respondent's appeal in determining whether to grant a stay?
7. Are the orders made on 26 June 2020 fair and just, taking into account the eighth respondent's asserted interest in the proceeds of sale of the Suburb J property?

Held
1. Does the eighth respondent have a valid basis to seek a stay of the interim financial orders made between the husband and wife?
The court concluded that the application for a stay was not made lightly and the applicant must demonstrate an appropriate case. The result was that the application for a stay was dismissed.

2. Has the eighth respondent demonstrated an appropriate case for the stay of the interim financial orders?
The court concluded that the eighth respondent had not demonstrated an appropriate case for the stay of the interim financial orders. The result was that the application for a stay was dismissed.

3. Does the balance of convenience favour the grant of a stay to the eighth respondent?
The court concluded that the balance of convenience favoured the wife, and not the eighth respondent. The result was that the application for a stay was dismissed.

4. Is there a significant risk that the appeal by the eighth respondent will be rendered nugatory if a stay is not granted?
The court concluded that there was no significant risk that the appeal by the eighth respondent will be rendered nugatory if a stay is not granted. The result was that the application for a stay was dismissed.

5. Does the eighth respondent have an arguable case on appeal based on the grounds outlined in his Notice of Appeal?
The court concluded that there was significant doubt as to whether the eighth respondent would get leave to proceed with his appeal against the interlocutory order. The result was that the application for a stay was dismissed.

6. Should the court consider the merits of the eighth respondent's appeal in determining whether to grant a stay?
The court concluded that the merits of the eighth respondent's appeal should not be considered in determining whether to grant a stay. The result was that the application for a stay was dismissed.

7. Are the orders made on 26 June 2020 fair and just, taking into account the eighth respondent's asserted interest in the proceeds of sale of the Suburb J property?
The court concluded that the orders made on 26 June 2020 were fair and just, taking into account the eighth respondent's asserted interest in the proceeds of sale of the Suburb J property. The result was that the application for a stay was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the eighth respondent's application for a stay of the interim financial orders, the court applied the well-established principles governing such applications. The court held that a stay will not be granted lightly, and the onus is on the applicant to demonstrate a proper basis for a stay that will be fair to all parties. The court also noted that the mere filing of an appeal is insufficient to grant a stay, and the application must be bona fide. The court further considered whether there was an appropriate case for the stay, the balance of convenience, and the risk that the appeal would be rendered nugatory if a stay was not granted. Additionally, the court assessed whether the eighth respondent had an arguable case on appeal and whether the merits of the appeal should be considered in determining whether to grant a stay.

The court found that the eighth respondent had not demonstrated an appropriate case for a stay of the interim financial orders. The court held that the eighth respondent had failed to engage in the proceedings and had not filed a Response or Points of Claim asserting any equitable or common law claim in relation to the matrimonial asset pool. Furthermore, the court found that the orders made on 26 June 2020 were fair and just, taking into account the eighth respondent's asserted interest in the proceeds of sale of the Suburb J property. The court noted that there was sufficient equity in the remaining matrimonial assets to meet any claim by the eighth respondent.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a party seeking a stay of interim financial orders must demonstrate an appropriate case for the stay, considering factors such as the balance of convenience, the risk that the appeal will be rendered nugatory if a stay is not granted, and whether the applicant has an arguable case on appeal. In this case, the court found that the eighth respondent had not demonstrated an appropriate case for a stay, and the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the orders to the wife. The court also found that the orders made on 26 June 2020 were fair and just, taking into account the eighth respondent's asserted interest in the proceeds of sale of the Suburb J property.