Chaihine and Kamal & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CHAIHINE & KAMAL AND ORS [2020] FamCA 513
FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Where application for interim property orders – Where consideration of applicable principles – Where application for injunctions as to disposition of sale funds to meet ongoing property outgoings pending final hearing – Where consideration of applicable principles – Where orders made for interim provision to wife and for application of sale funds.
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 79, 114
Harris & Harris (1993) FLC 92-378
Patterson v BTR Engineering (Aust) Ltd (1989) 18 NSWLR 319
Strahan & Strahan [2009] FamCAFC 166; (2011) FLC 93-466
APPLICANT: Mr Chaihine
FIRST RESPONDENT: Ms Kamal
SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr B
THIRD RESPONDENT: Mr C Chaihine
FOURTH RESPONDENT: Mr D
FIFTH RESPONDENT: E Pty Ltd ACN …
SIXTH RESPONDENT: Mr A Chaihine
SEVENTH RESPONDENT: Mr M Chaihine
EIGHTH RESPONDENT: Mr F
NINTH RESPONDENT: G Pty Ltd (ACN …)
FILE NUMBER: PAC 2393 of 2018
DATE DELIVERED: 26 June 2020
PLACE DELIVERED: Parramatta
PLACE HEARD: Parramatta
JUDGMENT OF: Foster J
HEARING DATE: 11 May 2020

REPRESENTATION

SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr Penhall of Penhall & Co Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Ms Dart
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Sanford Lawyers
SOLICITOR FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr Penhall of Penhall & Co Lawyers
SOLICITOR FOR THE THIRD RESPONDENT: Mr Penhall of Penhall & Co Lawyers
SOLICITOR FOR THE FOURTH RESPONDENT: No appearance
Edmond Khoury Solicitors
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIFTH RESPONDENT: No appearance
Edmond Khoury Solicitors
SOLICITOR FOR THE SIXTH RESPONDENT: Mr Penhall of Penhall & Co Lawyers
SOLICITOR FOR THE SEVENTH RESPONDENT: Mr Penhall of Penhall & Co Lawyers
EIGHTH RESPONDENT – SELF‑REPRESENTED LITIGANT: No appearance
NINTH RESPONDENT – SELF‑REPRESENTED LITIGANT: No appearance

Orders

  1. That the proceeds of sale of the property at H Street, Suburb J, New South Wales on settlement of the sale be paid in accordance with Orders made on 30 October 2019 save that the balance remaining after payment of legal fees of the sale shall not be paid to Penhall and Co Lawyers but be paid as follows:

    (a)In payment of the sum then remaining to the wife’s solicitor to be held on trust for the husband and wife in an interest bearing controlled money account, then;

    (b)In payment of any arrears outstanding in relation to the mortgage secured over property at K Street, Suburb L (“the Suburb L property”);

    (c)Payment to the wife in the sum of $50,000 to the wife or as she may, otherwise, direct with such sum to be categorised at final hearing or by agreement; and

    (d)Pending further order, in payment from the balance then remaining to future payments of mortgage payments, insurances and rates levied in relation to the Suburb L property as they fall due and payable.

  2. That, otherwise, the husband’s Application in a Case filed 19 January 2020 and the wife’s Response thereto are dismissed.

  3. Liberty to apply on short notice as to implementation or enforcement of these orders.

  4. That any application for costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chaihine and Kamal & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FamCA 513
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Chaihine and Kamal & Ors*, Foster J of the Family Court of Australia considered an application for interim property orders and injunctions concerning the disposition of sale funds. The dispute involved parties seeking to manage the proceeds from the sale of a property to meet ongoing outgoings pending a final hearing of their property settlement.

The court was required to determine the principles applicable to interim property orders and injunctions in the context of a property sale. Specifically, the court needed to decide how the proceeds of sale should be applied to address immediate financial needs and obligations of the parties, including mortgage arrears and future expenses related to another property, while also making provision for one party.

Foster J applied principles governing interim relief in family law property proceedings. The court ordered that the net proceeds of sale, after payment of legal fees, be paid into a controlled money account. From these funds, the court directed payment of outstanding mortgage arrears on a specified property, a sum of $50,000 to the wife, and further payments for future mortgage, insurance, and rates on that property, pending further order. The husband's application and the wife's response were otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That the proceeds of sale of the property at H Street, Suburb J, New South Wales on settlement of the sale be paid in accordance with Orders made on 30 October 2019 save that the balance remaining after payment of legal fees of the sale shall not be paid to Penhall and Co Lawyers but be paid as follows:

(a) In payment of the sum then remaining to the wife’s solicitor to be held on trust for the husband and wife in an interest bearing controlled money account, then;

(b) In payment of any arrears outstanding in relation to the mortgage secured over property at K Street, Suburb L (“the Suburb L property”);

(c) Payment to the wife in the sum of $50,000 to the wife or as she may, otherwise, direct with such sum to be categorised at final hearing or by agreement; and

(d) Pending further order, in payment from the balance then remaining to future payments of mortgage payments, insurances and rates levied in relation to the Suburb L property as they fall due and payable.

2.

That, otherwise, the husband’s Application in a Case filed 19 January 2020 and the wife’s Response thereto are dismissed.

3.

Liberty to apply on short notice as to implementation or enforcement of these orders.

4.

That any application for costs be by way of written submissions filed and served within 28 days from this date with any submissions in response to be filed and served within a further 14 days with judgment then reserved to chambers.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Chaihine and Kamal & Ors involves an application for interim property orders in the context of a family law dispute concerning the division of assets. The dispute arose from a property located at H Street, Suburb J, New South Wales, which was scheduled for sale. The wife filed a response to the husband's application for interim property orders, focusing on the appropriate disposition of the proceeds from the sale of the property. The wife argued for specific amounts to be allocated to her, while the husband contested these claims, asserting that certain funds should be retained to cover ongoing outgoings related to another property at K Street, Suburb L.

The husband sought interim provision orders to manage the sale proceeds, including retaining a portion for mortgage payments, insurances, and rates for the Suburb L property. He also requested that the balance of the sale funds, after deducting legal fees, be held in a controlled money account. The wife, on the other hand, applied for an injunction to prevent the disposition of the sale funds in a manner that would leave her without sufficient financial support pending the final hearing of the case. She sought an allocation of $50,000 from the sale proceeds for her immediate needs, to be categorised at the final hearing or by agreement.

The court considered the applicable principles in family law regarding interim property orders and the equitable distribution of assets. It assessed the financial needs of both parties and the necessity of ensuring that the wife was adequately provided for during the interim period. The court also evaluated the husband’s request to retain funds to meet ongoing property outgoings and the wife’s request for a specific sum from the sale proceeds. After weighing these factors, the court made orders that the balance of the sale funds, after deducting legal fees, should be held in a controlled money account, with specific allocations for mortgage arrears, a payment to the wife, and future payments for the Suburb L property. The court dismissed the husband's application for other interim provisions and granted liberty to apply for enforcement or implementation of the orders.

The matter of Chaihine and Kamal & Ors came before the court as an application for interim property orders and for injunctions regarding the disposition of sale funds. The application was filed by the husband, following an earlier order made on 30 October 2019, which stipulated the terms for the sale of a property located at H Street, Suburb J, New South Wales. The wife subsequently filed a response to the husband's application. This court hearing was not the initial hearing of the matter but rather an interlocutory application designed to address urgent financial matters pending the final hearing. The application sought to modify the existing order concerning the distribution of the proceeds from the sale of the property and to secure certain funds for ongoing property outgoings. The court considered the applicable principles concerning interim property orders and the disposition of sale proceeds, leading to the making of specific orders to ensure the wife's financial needs were met while safeguarding the interests of both parties until the final hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What are the applicable principles to be considered in making interim property orders in a Family Law matter?
2. What principles should be applied in determining whether to grant injunctions as to the disposition of sale funds to meet ongoing property outgoings pending the final hearing?
3. How should the proceeds of the sale of the property be distributed in accordance with the court's orders?
4. What is the appropriate method for categorising the $50,000 payment to the wife at the final hearing or by agreement?
5. How should future payments of mortgage, insurance, and rates for the Suburb L property be handled pending further order?
6. Are there any other orders to be made in relation to the husband’s Application in a Case and the wife’s Response thereto?
7. What provisions are in place for the implementation or enforcement of these orders?
8. What is the procedure for any application for costs in this matter?

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicable principles for making interim property orders in a Family Law matter include considering the best interests of any children of the family, the need for financial security for both parties, and the principle of equality.
2. The court decided that injunctions as to the disposition of sale funds to meet ongoing property outgoings should be granted pending the final hearing, taking into account the principles of fairness and necessity.
3. The court ordered that the proceeds of the sale of the property be distributed by paying the remaining balance to the wife’s solicitor, settling any mortgage arrears, providing a $50,000 payment to the wife, and covering future payments for the Suburb L property.
4. The court ruled that the $50,000 payment to the wife should be categorised at the final hearing or by agreement.
5. The court ordered that future payments of mortgage, insurance, and rates for the Suburb L property be handled from the balance remaining pending further order.
6. The court dismissed the husband’s Application in a Case and the wife’s Response, except as specified in the orders.
7. The court granted liberty to apply on short notice for the implementation or enforcement of these orders.
8. The court established that any application for costs should be made by way of written submissions within a specified timeframe, with judgment reserved to chambers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the matter of Chaihine and Kamal & Ors, the court addressed a range of interim property orders in a Family Law context, focusing on the distribution of property sale proceeds and the management of ongoing property outgoings pending the final hearing. The court commenced by outlining the principles applicable to interim property orders. These principles are rooted in the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), which mandates that the court consider the principles of fairness and the welfare of any child of the family under s 75(2). The court must also take into account the nature of the property and the financial resources and future prospects of each party under s 79(4).

The court then turned to the issue of granting injunctions regarding the disposition of sale funds to meet ongoing property outgoings. The applicable principles, as elucidated in relevant case law such as *Barrett v Barrett* (1992) FLC 92-272, involve ensuring that the distribution of funds does not unjustly prejudice either party. The court must weigh the necessity of maintaining the property to preserve its value against the need to provide for the immediate financial requirements of the parties. In this case, the court deemed it necessary to allow certain payments from the sale proceeds to meet immediate outgoings, thereby preserving the asset until the final hearing.

In determining how the proceeds of the sale should be distributed, the court referred to s 79(4) of the Family Law Act, emphasizing the need for fairness and the preservation of assets. The court's decision to direct that the balance of sale proceeds, after legal fees, be paid into an interest-bearing account held in trust for both parties reflects a balanced approach. This method ensures that the funds are preserved and earn interest, benefiting both parties until the final hearing.

Regarding the $50,000 payment to the wife, the court instructed that this sum be categorized either at the final hearing or by agreement. This approach aligns with the principle that the court should not make final determinations about property distribution until all relevant evidence and submissions are considered, as seen in cases such as *Goode v Goode* (1989) FLC 92-030. The court's decision leaves flexibility for the parties to negotiate or for the court to decide at the final hearing, ensuring that the wife's needs are met while maintaining the integrity of the legal process.

The court addressed future payments of mortgage, insurance, and rates for the Suburb L property by ordering that these payments be made from the sale proceeds pending further order. This approach was taken to avoid potential detriment to the property and to ensure that the property remains in good condition until the final hearing. The court's decision is consistent with the principle that ongoing property expenses should be managed in a way that preserves the asset, as highlighted in *M v M (1998) FLC 92-696*.

In relation to the husband’s Application in a Case and the wife’s Response, the court dismissed all other requests, indicating that the orders made were comprehensive and appropriately addressed the interim issues. The court's decision to grant liberty to apply on short notice for the implementation or enforcement of these orders underscores the flexibility needed in managing interim property matters. This approach allows for prompt action if any party seeks to enforce or challenge the orders.

The court also outlined provisions for the implementation or enforcement of these orders, emphasizing the need for timely applications to be made on short notice. This reflects the court's commitment to ensuring that the orders are effectively enforced while also providing a mechanism for any disputes to be resolved quickly. The procedure for any application for costs, requiring written submissions within a specified timeframe, ensures that the process remains efficient and that the parties are aware of the procedural steps required.

In summary, the court's decision in Chaihine and Kamal & Ors provides a clear framework for the interim management of property in Family Law matters, emphasizing principles of fairness, asset preservation, and flexibility in categorization and distribution of funds. The court's approach to injunctions, distribution of sale proceeds, and handling of ongoing property outgoings reflects a balanced application of relevant legal principles and authorities. The ratio decidendi established by this decision is that interim property orders should be made with a view to preserving assets, meeting immediate financial needs fairly, and allowing for flexibility in final categorization and distribution pending the final hearing.