CEO of Customs v AMI Toyota Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Chief Executive Officer of Customs v AMI Toyota Ltd [2000] FCA 1343

CUSTOMS – customs value of goods imported into Australia – one of the components of the purchase price payable by the purchaser to the vendor was an amount paid for the right of the purchaser to be reimbursed by the vendor for the cost of the work carried out in Australia pursuant to warranties given by the purchaser to customers in respect of the vehicles. – whether the component is a payment made in relation to the goods – whether the component was a value unrelated matter as defined in s 154(1) - whether the component was a cost, charge or expense in relation to activities undertaken by the purchaser on the purchaser’s own account relating to warranties in relation to the goods – whether the alleged failure of AAT to address a central question raised by the material involved a question of law

Customs Act 1901 (Cth) s 154(1), 159, 161(1) and 161(2)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 44

LNC (Wholesale) Pty Ltd v Collector of Customs (1988) 17 FCR 154 - applied
Hayes v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1956) CLR 47 - cited
Hatfield v Health Insurance Commission (1987) 15 FCR 487 - considered
Burswood Management Ltd v Attorney-General (Cth) (1990) 23 FCR 144 - cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Singh [2000] FCA 845 - cited
Commonwealth Quarries (Footscray) Proprietary Limited v The Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1938) 59 CLR 111 - cited
E.M.I. (Australia) Limited v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth (1971) 45 ALJR 349 - cited
Bushell v Repatriation Commission (1992) 175 CLR 408 - cited
Noble v Repatriation Commission (Beaumont, Branson and Merkel J, unreported, 3 November 1997) - cited
Ex parte Hebburn; Re Kearsley Shire Council (1947) 47 SR (NSW) 416 - cited
Sinclar v Mining Warden at Maryborough (1975) 132 CLR 473 - cited
Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163 - cited

CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF CUSTOMS v AMI TOYOTA LTD AND ORS
V 138 of 2000

JUDGE:        HILL, NORTH AND MERKEL JJ
PLACE:        MELBOURNE
DATE:          19 SEPTEMBER 2000


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 138 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF CUSTOMS
APPELLANT

AND:

AMI TOYOTA LTD
(ACN 004 300 912)
FIRST RESPONDENT

TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION AUSTRALIA LTD
(ACN 004 384 338)
SECOND RESPONDENT

TOYOTA MOTOR SALES AUSTRALIA LTD
(ACN 009 686 097)
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

HILL, NORTH AND MERKEL JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

19 SEPTEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.   Save that the order of Heerey J that:

“The case be remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal with directions that the decisions of the respondent under review be set aside and that the customs value of the vehicles in question be recalculated by the respondent on the basis that the average warranty cost in relation to each vehicle be not included.”

be set aside and in lieu…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CEO of Customs v AMI Toyota Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1343
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case between the CEO of Customs and AMI Toyota Ltd, AMI Toyota Ltd appealed against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which had ruled that the average warranty cost included in the customs value of imported Toyota vehicles should not be excluded from the calculation of that value. The CEO of Customs had argued that the warranty costs should not form part of the price of the vehicles for customs purposes. The primary judge allowed the appeal and set aside the AAT's decision, directing that the average warranty cost be excluded from the customs value calculation. The CEO of Customs appealed to the Full Court against the primary judge's decision. The Full Court was required to determine whether the primary judge had erred in allowing AMI Toyota Ltd's appeal. The central legal issues were whether the average warranty cost, which was part of the price of the vehicles, constituted a payment "in relation to" the goods for the purposes of the definition of "price" in the Customs Act, and whether it should be excluded from the customs value calculation on the ground that it was a value unrelated matter. The Full Court found that the average warranty cost was indeed a payment "in relation to" the goods, as it was part of the contractual arrangement between Toyota Australia and Toyota Japan. The Court held that the warranty cost was not a value unrelated matter because it was integral to the sales transaction and not a cost incurred by the purchaser on their own account. The Full Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the primary judge's decision and directing that the case be remitted to the AAT for reconsideration in light of these findings. The Full Court also dismissed the appeal against the costs order made by the primary judge.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Save that the order of Heerey J that:

“The case be remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal with directions that the decisions of the respondent under review be set aside and that the customs value of the vehicles in question be recalculated by the respondent on the basis that the average warranty cost in relation to each vehicle be not included.”

be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that the case be remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to be determined in accordance with law and with these reasons for judgment, the appeal otherwise be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondents’ taxed costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal was allowed, the decisions under review were set aside and the case was remitted to the AAT. Directions were given that the decisions of the appellant under review be set aside, and the customs value of the vehicles in question be recalculated by the appellant on the basis that the average warranty cost in relation to each vehicle not be included. The appellant has appealed to a Full Court against the decision of the primary judge, claiming that his Honour erred in law in allowing the appeal.The facts Toyota Australia purchases, and then imports, Toyota vehicles from Toyota Japan. The terms of the individual contracts of sale for the vehicles are established in accordance with the provisions of importer agreements entered into between Toyota Australia and Toyota Japan. Although the terms of those agreements have varied from time to time, it was common ground that the variations are not relevant for the purposes of determining the issues arising on the present appeal. Under the agreements, Toyota Japan conferred on Toyota Australia the exclusive right to import Toyota vehicles into the Australian market. Each sales contract becomes effective upon Toyota Japan notifying Toyota Australia of the acceptance of orders placed by Toyota Australia for the purchase of vehicles. The price of the vehicles under each sales contract is to be set by Toyota Japan in accordance with its then current price notification and is first set out in the invoice of Toyota Japan for the vehicle. Ownership and possession of the vehicles the subject of each individual sales contract vests in Toyota Australia upon Toyota Japan delivering a bill of lading for the vehicles. After importation of the goods, Toyota Australia sells the vehicles through distributors or dealers to consumers. Under the importer agreements, each consumer is to be given a warranty by Toyota Japan and Toyota Australia in respect of the vehicle purchased. The warranty covers the cost of warranty repairs, as defined in the relevant Toyota Warranty and Procedures Manual (“the Toyota Warranty policy”). Although under the Toyota Warranty policy Toyota Japan and Toyota Australia appear to be jointly and severally liable to consumers for warranty repairs, ultimately, Toyota Japan is to bear the cost of the repairs. This is because under the contractual arrangements Toyota Australia is reimbursed by Toyota Japan for the cost of work done pursuant to such warranties. In practice, owners of Toyota vehicles bring their vehicles in for warranty repairs to Toyota dealers in Australia. The dealers repair the vehicles and seek reimbursement for their costs in performing the repairs from Toyota Australia. Toyota Australia then seeks reimbursement from Toyota Japan. The reimbursement only relates to warranty repairs, as defined in the Toyota Warranty policy. It was common ground between the parties that one of the components of the purchase price determined and set by Toyota Japan in respect of the vehicles sold to Toyota Australia was the average warranty cost, and the matter has been contested by them on that basis. The AAT explained the manner in which the average warranty cost component was calculated as follows:“In practice the warranty costs are represented by the average cost to Toyota Japan per vehicle type, calculated against the actual warranty costs incurred in a preceding six month period for that vehicle type…”

Decision

Reasons for decision

The specific questions arising on the appeal are whether:· the average warranty cost, forming part of the price of the Toyota vehicles, is a payment “in relation to such goods” for the purposes of sub-para (a) of the definition in s 154(1) of “price”;· in the event that the average warranty cost constitutes a payment “in relation to” the Toyota vehicles, is that cost required to be excluded from the price for the purposes of the Act on the ground that it falls within sub-para (b) of the definition in s 154(1) of “value unrelated matter” as being a cost, charge or expense in relation to activities undertaken by the purchaser on the purchaser’s own account in relation to a warranty or guarantee in relation to the vehicle sold;· the appeal involves a question or questions of law.The AAT decision The AAT’s reasons as summarised by the primary judge are as follows. The AAT found that the “import sales transaction” included the individual sales contracts, the importer agreements and the Toyota Warranty policy. It stated that the identification in the invoice of an amount attributable to warranty costs was “simply the identification of one of the elements constituted in the price arrived at between Toyota Australia and Toyota Japan”. It then continued:“17. Finally, the words ‘in relation to’ as used in the definition of ‘price’ in s. 154(1) are words of broad ambit which take their meaning from the surrounding context in which they appear (Workers’ Compensation Board of Queensland v Technical Products Pty Ltd (1988) 165 CLR 642 at 653 per Deane, Dawson and Toohey JJ, Australian Securities Commission v Bank Leumi Le-Israel (Switzerland) (1996) 69 FCR 531 at 547 per Lehane J with whom Lockhart and Foster JJ agreed). The context of the opening words of the definition of ‘price’ connects the goods to the subject of the individual sales contract. The individual sales contract which, through the terms incorporated by the importer agreements, addresses the issue of warranty cover, but does so as part of the overall contractual arrangements. Where the phrase ‘in relation to’ is used in paragraph (a) of the definition, it is to ‘all payments … made directly or indirectly’ (emphasis added), further indicating the breadth of what is to be comprehended when considering price. Accordingly, an allocation made for warranty costs, whether in an unitemised or an itemised invoice, cannot be characterised as being a separate allocation of cost, and must be regarded as being part of the direct payment made ‘in relation to’ the goods.18. The applicants sought to rely on the following passage from the Toyota Motor Sales’ case to justify its [sic] submission that warranty payments should not be regarded as part of the price. In that case the Full Court of the Federal Court said:‘… we do not think that in the ordinary parlance of commercial life the reimbursements can fairly be said to be rebates of, or decreases in, the prices of the relevant vehicles accruing to Toyota Australia by reason of faults or defects in those vehicles. They were payments made to Toyota Australia under arrangements essentially collateral to the purchase of the motor vehicles pursuant to which Toyota Australia was entitled to claim reimbursement in respect of at least some of the expense incurred in meeting its warranty obligations to owners of Toyota vehicles. The contractual arrangements made between the two companies pursuant to which reimbursements were made were plainly independent of the contractual arrangements pursuant to which the motor vehicles were imported.’ (pp.29-30)The Court in its reasons for decision referred to an importer agreement between Toyota Japan and Toyota Australia, but did not refer to the concept of individual sales contracts which has arisen in the instant case. Also it is apparent that the Article 22 referred to by the Court dealing with price, while its equivalent is to be found in Article 18 of B1 (and Article 16 of B2), is differently numbered, and, consequently, it is not apparent that the same importer agreements as were being considered in the Toyota Sales’ case are relevant in the instant case. Those differences leave the Tribunal unable to apply the conclusions reached in the Toyota Sales’ case to the facts as found in this case, i.e. the Tribunal is unable on the facts of this case to say that arrangements with respect to warranty payments are ‘essentially collateral’ to the purchase of the motor vehicles and therefore should not be included in their price.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the definition of "price" in s 154(1) of the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) and considered whether the average warranty cost, which is part of the price of the Toyota vehicles, falls within the definition. The court found that the phrase "in relation to" is broad and encompasses all payments made directly or indirectly in relation to the goods. The court distinguished the current case from Toyota Motor Sales (Aust) Pty Ltd v CEO of Customs (1997) 75 FCR 23 (Toyota Motor Sales’ case) as the facts and importer agreements were different. The court held that the average warranty cost is part of the direct payment made "in relation to" the goods and thus is included in the price.

Next, the court considered whether the average warranty cost should be excluded from the price as a "value unrelated matter" under sub-para (b) of the definition in s 154(1). The court noted that the warranty costs are calculated based on the actual warranty costs incurred by Toyota Japan in a preceding six month period for that vehicle type. The court held that the warranty costs are not a charge or expense in relation to activities undertaken by the purchaser on the purchaser’s own account in relation to a warranty or guarantee in relation to the vehicle sold, but rather are part of the overall contractual arrangements between Toyota Japan and Toyota Australia.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether the appeal involves a question or questions of law. The court concluded that the appeal did involve a question of law as it concerned the interpretation of the definition of "price" in the Customs Act 1901 (Cth) and the application of that definition to the facts of the case. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that the average warranty cost, which is part of the price of the Toyota vehicles, is a payment "in relation to such goods" for the purposes of sub-para (a) of the definition in s 154(1) of "price" and is not required to be excluded from the price under sub-para (b) of the definition in s 154(1) of "value unrelated matter".