Central Northern Adelaide Health Service v Atkinson
Link copied
CaseCopied
70 min read
Full text
SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court)
CENTRAL NORTHERN ADELAIDE HEALTH SERVICE v ATKINSON
[2008] SASC 371
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Justice Bleby, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Kelly)
24 December 2008
HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION
Appeal from Equal Opportunity Tribunal – appellant is a provider of health services –eligibility criteria for health services are that patient must be Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander or from a non-English speaking background or be under 25 years of age – respondent refused access to medical services provided by the appellant on basis that respondent did not meet eligibility criteria – the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA) (“EOA”) prohibits discrimination on the basis of race and age however provides exceptions under s 65 and s 85P respectively – appeal allowed.
HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION - CONSTITUTIONAL MATTERS - INCONSISTENCY OF LAWS
Whether, as beneficial and remedial legislation, a purposive approach should be adopted in the construction of the EOA – whether s 65 inconsistent with the exception to discrimination under the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) (“RDA”) s 8 – intention of the savings provision of the RDA s 6A in limiting the operation of State law unless it furthers the objects of the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Racial Discrimination and is capable of operating concurrently with the RDA – whether s 65 can be construed as a law that furthers the objects of the Convention – s 65 can be construed such that there is no inconsistency between it and the RDA s 8.
HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION - GROUNDS OF DISCRIMINATION - RACIAL DISCRIMINATION
Tribunal held that the eligibility criteria of the appellant’s scheme directly discriminated on the grounds of race and that it did not come within the s 65 exception – whether the appellant was carrying out a “scheme” for the benefit of persons of a particular race for the purposes of s 65 – whether s 65 requires the scheme to identify the particular race or races to be benefited – specific identification not required – the appellant’s scheme falls within the protection of the s 65 exception.
HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION - GROUNDS OF DISCRIMINATION - DISCRIMINATION ON BASIS OF AGE
HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION - DIRECT DISCRIMINATION
Tribunal held that the appellant’s scheme directly discriminated on the basis of age – whether the appellant was carrying out a “scheme” for the benefit of persons of a particular age or age group in order to meet a need that arises out of or is related to the ages or ages of those persons for the purposes of s 85P – whether the eligibility criteria that patients be under 25 years of age was too broad for the purposes of a s 85P scheme – no basis under structure of s 85P or of EOA to imply that a scheme must be directed at a narrow age group or that needs must be similar…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Central Northern Adelaide Health Service v Atkinson and more:
The appeal in Central Northern Adelaide Health Service v Atkinson concerns the eligibility criteria for health services provided by the appellant, which were held to unlawfully discriminate against the respondent, Mr Atkinson, on the basis of both race and age. The Equal Opportunity Tribunal had found that the eligibility criteria of the appellant's scheme, which allowed access to medical services only to Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander people, those from non-English speaking backgrounds, or those under 25 years of age, amounted to direct discrimination contrary to the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA). The Tribunal also found that the eligibility criteria did not fall within the exceptions provided under sections 65 and 85P of the Act. The appeal was brought by the appellant against the decision of the Tribunal under the provisions of section 98(1)(b) of the Act.
The legal issues before the court were whether a purposive approach should be adopted in the construction of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA) as beneficial and remedial legislation, whether section 65 of the Act is inconsistent with the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) section 8, and whether section 65 can be construed as a law that furthers the objects of the Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination. The court also considered whether the appellant's scheme was carrying out a "scheme" for the benefit of persons of a particular race for the purposes of section 65, and whether the eligibility criteria that patients be under 25 years of age was too broad for the purposes of a section 85P scheme.
The court found that the purposive approach should be adopted in the construction of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA) as beneficial and remedial legislation. The court held that section 65 can be construed such that there is no inconsistency between it and the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) section 8. The court also held that the appellant's scheme falls within the protection of the section 65 exception, and that the eligibility criteria that patients be under 25 years of age is not too broad for the purposes of a section 85P scheme.
The court allowed the appeal and quashed the decision of the Tribunal. The court found that the Tribunal erred in law in concluding that the appellant's scheme directly discriminated on the grounds of race and age and did not come within the exceptions provided under sections 65 and 85P of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA). The court held that the Tribunal should have considered the purposive approach in the construction of the Act, and that the appellant's scheme was carrying out a "scheme" for the benefit of persons of a particular race or age group for the purposes of sections 65 and 85P of the Act. The court held that the eligibility criteria that patients be under 25 years of age was not too broad for the purposes of a section 85P scheme.
The final orders of the court were that the appeal be allowed, the decision of the Tribunal be quashed, and the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration in light of the court's reasons. The court also ordered that the appellant pay the costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
The Tribunal recorded a finding that the Northern Health Service unlawfully discriminated against Brian Atkinson on the basis of both race and age contrary to the provisions of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA). The Tribunal then ordered that an apology be provided by the Northern Health Service to Mr Atkinson. This appeal is brought against the decision of the Tribunal under the provisions of section 98(1)(b) of the Act.[5] [5] Section 98(1)(b) relevantly provides:(4)An appeal under this section must be conducted as a review of the decision or order of the Tribunal.(5)The Supreme Court may, on the hearing of an appeal, exercise one or more of the following powers:(a) affirm, vary or quash the decision or order appealed against, or substitute, or make in addition, any decision or order that should have been made in the first instance;(b)remit the subject matter of the appeal to the Tribunal for further hearing or consideration or for rehearing;(c)make any order as to costs or any other matter that the justice of the case requires.Factual Background Mr Atkinson is 77 years of age. His native language is English. He emigrated to Australia from the United Kingdom in 1960. Currently he is in receipt of a full age pension and holds a health care card. He moved to a housing trust home in Mansfield Park in 2003 from the Tea Tree Gully area. Mr Atkinson has access to other non-medical services that are available at the Parks Community Health Centre and has used the physiotherapy, psychologist and dental services. The Parks Community Health Centre forms part of the Central Northern Adelaide Health Service. In 2004 Mr Atkinson sought access to medical services at the Parks Community Health Centre. A receptionist refused Mr Atkinson access and told him that he could not see a medical practitioner at the Parks Community Health Centre because there were specific criteria for persons wishing to access services there and he did not qualify. The receptionist also advised Mr Atkinson to consider consulting one of the other medical practitioners in the near vicinity. In the latter half of 2005, Mr Atkinson again sought access to medical services at the Parks Community Health Centre. Again he was told that he did not meet the eligibility criteria. He says on this occasion part of the explanation given to him was that there were limited resources and the criteria for persons wishing to access the Parks Community Health Centre was in place to assist disadvantaged groups. On 30 December 2005, Mr Atkinson lodged a complaint with the Commissioner for Equal Opportunity under the provisions of section 93 of the Act.[6] [6] (1) A complaint alleging that a person has acted in contravention of this Act may be made—(a)by any person aggrieved by the act;(b)by any person aggrieved by the act, on behalf of himself or herself and any other person aggrieved by the act;(c) where a person aggrieved by the act has an intellectual impairment—by a person who is, in the opinion of the Commissioner, a suitable representative of the interests of the aggrieved person.(1a) A person cannot make a complaint pursuant to subsection (1)(b) on behalf of some other person unless that other person has consented in writing to the making of the complaint.(1b) A person who consents to a complaint being made on his or her behalf is bound by any decision or order made on the complaint.(1c)A complaint—(a)must be in writing and set out the details of the alleged contravention; and(b)must be lodged with the Commissioner.(2)A complaint must be lodged—(a)when the alleged contravention is constituted of a series of acts—within six months of the last of those acts;(b)in any other case—within six months of the date on which the contravention is alleged to have been committed.(3) Upon a complaint being lodged under this section, the Commissioner must cause a written summary of the particulars of the complaint to be served, personally or by post, upon the respondent named in the complaint.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
On 11 April 2008, the Tribunal unanimously upheld the complaint of discrimination on the basis of age and by majority, upheld the complaint of discrimination on the basis of race. As earlier observed the Tribunal directed that there should be a written apology. No compensation was ordered.The Evidence Before The Tribunal In order to understand the submissions on appeal it is necessary to examine the evidence before the Tribunal about the operation of the Parks Community Health Centre. Evidence was placed before the Tribunal by affidavit and oral evidence including evidence from Dianne Jones, the Director of Services and Programs with the Northern Health Service. The evidence before the Tribunal demonstrates that the Parks Community Health Centre has a plan specifically designed to assist new migrants to Australia, particularly refugees from the Horn of Africa, including those from Ethiopia, Somalia, Burundi and Sierra Leone as well as the existing Indo-Chinese community in the Parks area. The evidence of Ms Jones outlines the development of a scheme in the Parks Strategic Plan which took into account a range of resources including national and state health priorities and outcomes. As part of this process, staff members, other organisations in the area and members of the local community, were consulted. As a result of this, “priority population groups” were determined as Aboriginal people; young people; children and families; and people from non‑English speaking backgrounds or culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds especially refugees. These population groups were identified as often having the greatest difficulty in accessing mainstream health services. They were also identified as often having complex and chronic health problems. The scheme of the Parks Community Health Centre was to benefit persons of a number of different races but those races are commonly linked by characteristic of disadvantage. Following the implementation of the Parks Strategic Plan and the adoption of the eligibility criteria, medical services and limited resources were then “effectively targeted to benefit the priority groups in order to assist in re-dressing the inequality they would otherwise experience”. Ms Jones’ affidavits attest to the fact that the Parks area contains five of the six most disadvantaged suburbs in the Adelaide metropolitan area and also has a relatively high proportion of people from a non-English speaking background and new migrants. Ms Jones’ affidavits also provide some insight into the specific health needs of new arrivals from linguistically diverse backgrounds. Their vulnerabilities are compounded by emotional health issues, cultural dislocation, social isolation and economic disadvantage resulting from difficulty in finding employment. New arrivals, particularly those who are not proficient in the English language, generally lack knowledge of available services, are less likely to have access to family support and need information to adapt their diet to meet their nutritional needs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
BLEBY J
In my view the submission that there is no inconsistency on a literal reading should be rejected. The purpose of the Convention and of the Racial Discrimination Act is to ban and eliminate racial discrimination. However, it is recognised that special circumstances of racial disadvantage may require discrimination to overcome those disadvantages. Such discrimination may be permitted but will be subject to strict limitations as to scope and time. Section 65 directly confronts this objective. It allows for discrimination on the basis of race in less constrained circumstances. There is no reference to scope or time in section 65. On its face, section 65 could permit and authorise racial discrimination in circumstances that would directly conflict with the Convention and the Racial Discrimination Act. The Decision Of The Equal Opportunity TribunalRace In relation to the complaint of discrimination on the ground of race, Members Shetliffe and Jasinski held that the imposition of the requirement that patients be “Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander” or, “from a non-English speaking background” by the Northern Health Service amounted to “direct discrimination” pursuant to section 51(a) and (c) of the Equal Opportunity Act.[61] The Northern Health Service accepted that it was correct to so categorise this requirement. The characteristic of being from a “non-English speaking background” or not is one which “appertains generally to persons of the other’s race, or … that is generally imputed to persons of that race”.[62][61] Atkinson v Central Northern Adelaide Health Service [2008] SAEOT 5, [87], [91], [103]; AB2, 626, 627, 629.[62] Equal Opportunity Act section 51(c). Members Shetliffe and Jasinski then held that insofar as the criterion related to “Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islanders” it was “done for the purpose of carrying out a scheme or undertaking for the benefit of persons of a particular race” and fell within the exception in section 65.[63] Members Shetliffe and Jasinski held that the requirement that patients be “from a non-English speaking background” did not fall within the section 65 exception, because it did not relate to a “particular race” or races.Counsel for the [Northern Health Service] drew our attention to definitions of the word “particular” and argued that it can be interpreted to mean a “number of” rather than just a single item. If this were so, the word “particular” would be otiose. We are of the view that the use of the word within the section of the Act suggests that Parliament intended a scheme to apply to an identifiable, specific race or races. The word “particular” has a job to do. To be able to identify whether a scheme is discriminatory or whether it comes within the exemption, there is a requirement for a precise race or races to be identified.We find that an exemption under s 65 does not apply to the scheme relating to people from a “non-English speaking background”. It may identify a feature or characteristic of race but does not identify a particular race or races. “Non-English speaking” is a characteristic of a diverse set, even mixture of races from different nationalities, countries of origin, colour or ancestry. Such a broad range traverses persons with no identifiable race or races, therefore, does not come within an exemption under s 65.[64][63] Atkinson v Central Northern Adelaide Health Service [2008] SAEOT 5, [99]; AB2, 629; the respondent apparently did not complain about the criterion that a patient be “Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander: Atkinson v Central Northern Adelaide Health Service [2008] SAEOT 5, [19]; AB2, 614.[64] Atkinson v Central Northern Adelaide Health Service [2008] SAEOT 5, [101]-[102]; AB2, 629.