Atkinson v Central Northern Adelaide Health Service

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TRIBUNAL

(District Court Administrative and Disciplinary Division)

ATKINSON v CENTRAL NORTHERN ADELAIDE HEALTH SERVICE

[2008] SAEOT 5

Judgment of His Honour Judge Rice, Member Mr D Shetliffe and Member Ms H Jasinski

11 April 2008

DISCRIMINATION LAW

Alleged discrimination by the respondent on the grounds of race and age - respondent applied criteria whereby persons from a non-English speaking background or not under 25 years of age were not able to access medical services - whether exemption provisions apply on the assumption that discrimination took place - meaning of "scheme" and "undertaking".

Held (by all Members): Discrimination on the ground of age had taken place;  further, by majority (Members Shetliffe and Jasinski), that discrimination on the ground of race made out - orders accordingly - written apology to complainant but no compensation.

Equal Opportunity Act 1984 ss 5, 6(3), 7, 51, 61, 65, 85A, 85K, 85P, 93(2), referred to.
Wright v City of Brighton 162 LSJS 85; Khan v State of South Australia [2000] SADC 1 (7/1/00); Waters and Others v Public Transport Corporation (1991) 173 CLR 349, considered.

ATKINSON v CENTRAL NORTHERN ADELAIDE HEALTH SERVICE
[2008] SAEOT 5

JUDGE RICE:

Introduction

  1. In this matter the complainant, Mr Bryan Atkinson, has lodged a complaint that the Central Northern Adelaide Health Service has discriminated against him on the basis of race and age, contrary to the provisions of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (“the Act”).

  2. The essence of the complaint is that Mr Atkinson sought access to the medical services provided by the respondent Health Service, but that access was refused because he did not meet the eligibility criteria, more particularly on the basis that he was not Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander or from a non-English speaking background and was not under 25 years of age.

  3. There is no doubt that the respondent Health Service applied formalised criteria when people sought access to those medical services, but it says its actions were not (and are not) unlawful because they were done for proper purposes permitted by the Act. There is also no doubt that the criteria are quite restrictive and that they were altered both before and after these events.

  4. I note the Act is binding on the Crown (s 7). The respondent Health Service is an agency of the Government of South Australia.

    Preliminary points

  5. Two preliminary points have arisen.  The complaint was lodged with the Commissioner for Equal Opportunity on 30 December, 2005.  Attempts to conciliate the complaint were unsuccessful.

  6. As to the first, the Notice of Referral of the complaint by the Commissioner incorrectly states that the referral is made pursuant to s 98(5) of the Act. The correct legal basis for such a referral is pursuant to s 95(8), which is what was referred to in the Commissioner’s covering letter. With the concurrence of both parties, the Tribunal has applied the slip rule and views it as a proper referral pursuant to s 95(8).

  7. As to the second point, a complaint pursuant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Atkinson v Central Northern Adelaide Health Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SAEOT 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Equal Opportunity Tribunal found that the Central Northern Adelaide Health Service discriminated against Mr Atkinson on the basis of age, which was unlawful. They also found that there was discrimination on the basis of race, but it was lawful because it was part of a scheme or undertaking for the benefit of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. The Tribunal ordered the Health Service to provide Mr Atkinson with a written apology, but did not order compensation because the discrimination had only a minor impact on him. The decision turned on the interpretation of the terms "scheme" and "undertaking" in the Equal Opportunity Act, and whether the Health Service's actions fell within those exemptions.