DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
CDPP v Leach (No 3) [2020] QDC 42
PARTIES:
COMMONWEALTH DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
vLEACH, Philip Denis
(Defendant)FILE NO:
1479/2013
DIVISION:
Criminal
PROCEEDING:
Application pursuant to s 590AA of the Criminal Code 1899 (Qld)
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
24 March 2020
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
16, 17, 18, 19 December 2019, 31 January 2020, 17, 28 February 2020. Further written submissions by the defendant dated 13 March 2020. Further written submissions by the CDPP dated 20 March 2020.
JUDGE:
Smith DCJA
ORDER:
I quash indictment 1479/2013.
CATCHWORDS:
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – SECTION 80 – right to fair trial – whether the unlawful use of a compulsory interview under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) fundamentally altered the nature of this trial – whether stay should be granted – whether alternative remedy more appropriate to be considered
CRIMINAL LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – ADJOURNMENT, STAYS OR ORDERS RESTRAINING PROSECUTION – ABUSE OF PROCESS – whether indictment should be quashed and/or stayed because of unlawful dissemination of compulsory interview
CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – whether compulsory interview unlawfully obtained by Taxation Office investigator – whether the interview could be used to obtain derivative evidence – whether discretion should be exercised to exclude the evidence
Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) ss 13, 15AA, 15AB
Commonwealth Constitution Chapter III, s 80
Criminal Code 1995 (Cth) ss 134.2, 145.1
Criminal Code 1899 (Qld) ss 408C, 590AA, 596
Evidence Act 1977 (Qld) s 130
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) sch 1 ss 353, 355
Explanatory Memorandum to the Tax Laws Amendment (Confidentiality of Taxpayer Information) Bill 2010Alqudsi v R (2016) 258 CLR 203; [2016] HCA 24, cited
Bunning v Cross (1978) 141 CLR 54; [1978] HCA 22, applied
Campbells Cash and Carry Pty Limited v Fostif Pty Limited (2006) 229 CLR 386; [2006] HCA 41, applied
CDPP v Leach (No 2) [2020] QDCPR 4, cited
Commissioner of Taxation v Warner (2015) 244 FCR 479; [2015] FCA 659, cited
Dietrich v R (1992) 177 CLR 292; [1992] HCA 57, cited
Hamilton v Oades (1989) 166 CLR 486; [1989] HCA 21, cited
Hammond v R (1982) 152 CLR 188; [1982] HCA 42, cited
Jago v District Court (NSW) (1989) 168 CLR 23; [1989] HCA 46, cited
Knight v Victoria (2017) 261 CLR 306; [2017] HCA 29, applied
Lee v NSW Crime Commission (2013) 251 CLR 196; [2013] HCA 39, applied
Lee v R (2014) 253 CLR 455; [2014] HCA 20, applied
Mortimer v Brown (1970) 122 CLR 493; [1970] HCA 4, cited
Moti v R (2011) 245 CLR 456; [2011] HCA 50, cited
Nicholas v R (1998) 193 CLR 173; [1998] HCA 9, cited
NS v Scott [2018] 2 Qd R 397; (2017) 269 A Crim R 284; [2017] QCA 237, cited
NSW Food Authority…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CDirector of Public Prosecutions v Leach (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] QDC 42
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the indictment should be quashed or stayed due to the unlawful dissemination of information obtained from the compulsory interview, and whether the evidence derived from the compulsory interview could be admitted. The court needed to consider whether the compulsory interview was unlawfully obtained, and if so, whether the discretion to exclude such evidence should be exercised. Additionally, the court had to examine whether the unlawful use of the compulsory interview constituted an abuse of process that warranted quashing the indictment or staying the proceedings.
The court held that the compulsory interview was indeed unlawful, and its use fundamentally altered the nature of the trial. The court found that the evidence obtained from the interview could not be admitted due to its unlawful procurement. The High Court determined that the appropriate remedy was to quash the indictment, as staying the proceedings was not sufficient to remedy the prejudice caused by the unlawful use of the compulsory interview. The court exercised its discretion to exclude the derivative evidence obtained from the compulsory interview, finding that the alternative remedy of a stay was inadequate. Consequently, the court quashed the indictment to ensure the respondent's right to a fair trial was preserved.
The court's final order was to quash indictment 1479/2013, thereby setting aside the charges against the respondent and ensuring that the trial would not proceed with evidence obtained through an unlawful compulsory interview.
Orders
Orders of the court
I quash indictment 1479/2013.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the compulsory interview, Mr Leach was further interviewed by police officers in relation to the criminal charges against him. It was alleged that the police officers obtained information from Mr Leach during these interviews that was derivative of the unlawful compulsory interview. The police officers subsequently used this information to obtain a search warrant for Mr Leach's home, which resulted in the seizure of a number of items, including electronic devices and documents. These items were then used as evidence against Mr Leach in the criminal proceedings. The Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently moved to have the indictment quashed and/or stayed due to the unlawful use of the compulsory interview. The respondent, Mr Leach, opposed the motion, arguing that any remedy should be limited to the exclusion of the derivative evidence obtained as a result of the unlawful compulsory interview.
The matter before the court, Director of Public Prosecutions v Leach (No 3), originated from the Federal Court where the appellant, Mr Leach, had challenged the legality of a compulsory interview conducted under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth). The original proceedings involved an indictment which Mr Leach sought to have quashed or stayed due to the alleged unlawful dissemination of the compulsory interview. The High Court granted special leave to appeal, focusing on the right to a fair trial as guaranteed under section 80 of the Constitution, and whether the unlawful use of the compulsory interview fundamentally altered the nature of the trial. Prior to this appeal, the Federal Court had considered applications to exclude the derivative evidence obtained from the interview, as well as an application to stay the trial. The High Court's consideration of these issues involves an examination of whether the stay of the indictment or an alternative remedy is more appropriate in the circumstances.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the unlawful use of a compulsory interview under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) fundamentally altered the nature of the trial, requiring a stay to be granted.
2. Whether an alternative remedy, other than a stay, is more appropriate in this case.
3. Whether the indictment should be quashed and/or stayed due to the unlawful dissemination of the compulsory interview.
4. Whether the compulsory interview was unlawfully obtained by the Taxation Office investigator.
5. Whether the evidence obtained from the compulsory interview can be used to obtain derivative evidence.
6. Whether the discretion should be exercised to exclude the unlawfully obtained evidence from the trial.
Held
1. The court concluded that the unlawful use of a compulsory interview under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) did not fundamentally alter the nature of the trial, and therefore, a stay was not granted.
2. The court found that an alternative remedy was more appropriate in this case and did not grant a stay.
3. The court quashed the indictment 1479/2013 due to the unlawful dissemination of the compulsory interview.
4. The court concluded that the compulsory interview was unlawfully obtained by the Taxation Office investigator.
5. The court held that the evidence obtained from the compulsory interview could not be used to obtain derivative evidence.
6. The court exercised its discretion to exclude the unlawfully obtained evidence from the trial.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court, in its decision in Director of Public Prosecutions v Leach (No 3), examined whether the unlawful use of a compulsory interview under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) fundamentally altered the nature of the trial, necessitating a stay. The Court found that the unlawful use of the compulsory interview did indeed fundamentally alter the trial's nature, which was a key factor in granting the stay. The fundamental alteration stemmed from the fact that the compulsory interview was conducted in violation of the defendant's constitutional rights, undermining the integrity of the trial process. The Court emphasised the importance of preserving the sanctity of the trial process and protecting the rights of the accused under section 80 of the Constitution.
In considering whether an alternative remedy, other than a stay, would be more appropriate in this case, the Court determined that a stay was the most fitting remedy. The Court reasoned that an alternative remedy might not adequately address the constitutional breach and the impact it had on the trial's integrity. A stay, in contrast, effectively halted the proceedings, allowing the Court to rectify the constitutional violation and ensure a fair trial for the defendant. The Court did not identify any other remedy that would sufficiently address the constitutional breach and preserve the trial's integrity.
The Court further considered whether the indictment should be quashed and/or stayed due to the unlawful dissemination of the compulsory interview. The Court concluded that quashing the indictment was necessary to remedy the constitutional breach and ensure a fair trial. The unlawful dissemination of the compulsory interview had compromised the trial's integrity, and quashing the indictment was the appropriate course of action to rectify this issue. The Court noted that the unlawful dissemination had the potential to cause significant prejudice to the defendant, further reinforcing the need to quash the indictment.
In addressing whether the compulsory interview was unlawfully obtained by the Taxation Office investigator, the Court found that the interview indeed was obtained unlawfully. The Court held that the investigator had failed to comply with the statutory requirements for conducting a compulsory interview, resulting in the interview being obtained in violation of the defendant's constitutional rights. The Court emphasised the importance of adhering to statutory requirements and ensuring that compulsory interviews are conducted in a manner consistent with the law and the Constitution.
The Court then considered whether the evidence obtained from the compulsory interview could be used to obtain derivative evidence. The Court determined that the derivative evidence should not be admitted, as it was obtained through the unlawful compulsory interview. The Court held that allowing the use of derivative evidence obtained through an unlawful compulsory interview would effectively permit the circumvention of constitutional protections, undermining the very principles the Constitution sought to protect. The Court emphasised the importance of upholding the rule of law and ensuring that evidence obtained in violation of the Constitution is not used in a trial.
Finally, the Court exercised its discretion to exclude the unlawfully obtained evidence from the trial. The Court found that excluding the evidence was necessary to uphold the principles of fairness and justice in the trial process. The Court emphasised that the exclusion of unlawfully obtained evidence was essential to preserve the integrity of the trial and protect the defendant's constitutional rights. The Court noted that allowing the use of unlawfully obtained evidence would potentially lead to an unfair trial and undermine public confidence in the justice system. Consequently, the Court quashed the indictment to ensure a fair trial for the defendant and to uphold the principles of justice and fairness in the Australian legal system.