Caseldan Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Caseldan Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council  [2014] QLC 53
PARTIES: Caseldan Pty Ltd
(applicant)
v
Moreton Bay Regional Council
(respondent)
FILE NO: AQL809-12
DIVISION: General Division
PROCEEDING: Application to determine compensation under the Acquisition of Land Act 1967
DELIVERED ON: 9 December 2014
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD ON: 19, 20, 21, 22, 23 May 2014
30, 31 July 2014
27 August 2014
Submissions finalised and decision reserved 27 August 2014
HEARD AT: Brisbane
MEMBER: WA Isdale
ORDER:

1.    The value of the land is assessed in the amount of One Million Eight Hundred Thousand Dollars ($1,800,000).

2.    The parties will be heard on the matter of costs attributable to stamp duty for replacement land.

3.    The parties will be heard on the matter of interest.

4.    Any application for costs is to be filed and served and any reply is to be filed and served as directed.

CATCHWORDS:

Resumption – Pointe Gourde principle – valuation – offers – conditional offers – unconditional cash contract

Acquisition of Land Act 1967, ss 20, 21
Sustainable Planning Act 2009, ss 326, 329

AMP Capital Investors Ltd & Anor v Transport Infrastructure Development Corporation [2008] NSWCA 325, 163 LGERA 245
Auxil Pty Ltd & Anor v Terranova & Ors (2009) 260 ALR 164
Bowers & Anor v Pine Rivers Shire Council [2007] 28 QLCR 196
Brisbane City Council v Mio Art Pty Ltd & Anor [2011] QCA 234
Comiskey Group (a firm) v Moreton Bay Regional Council & Ors [2011] QPEC 132
Commissioner for Railways v Buckler (1996) 1 Qd R 18
Commissioner of Succession Duties (SA) v Executor Trustee and Agency Company of SA (1947) 74 CLR 358
The Crown v Murphy [1990] 64 ALJR 593
De Ieso v Commissioner of Highways (1981) 27 SASR 248; (1981) 47 LGRA 412
Department of Transport and Main Roads v Mahoney [2014] QLAC 1
Gold Coast City Council v Dobson [2014] QLAC 6
Grosser & Anor v Council of the City of Gold Coast (2001) 117 LGERA 153
Haig v Minister (1994) 85 LGERA 143
Handley v Brisbane City Council and Pike Mirls McNoulty Pty Ltd [2004] QPEC 39
Heavey Lex No. 64 Pty Ltd v Chief Executive, Department of Transport (2001) 22 QLCR 177
Housing Commission of New South Wales v San Sebastian Pty Ltd (1978) 140 CLR 196; 37 LGRA 214
Ipswich City Council v Wilson (2011) 32 QLCR 357
Kenny & Good Pty Ltd v MGICA (1992) Ltd (1999) 199 CLR 413
Mahoney & Ors v Chief Executive, Department of Transport and Main Roads (No. 3) [2013] QLC 11
McDonald v Deputy Federal Commissioner of Land Tax for New South Wales (1915) 20 CLR 231
Melwood Units Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Main Roads (1978) 52 ALJR 593, 37 LGRA 387
Minister for Public Works v Thistlethwayte [1954] AC 475
Mio Art Pty Ltd & Ors v Brisbane City Council [2009] QLC 177
Mio Art Pty Ltd v Brisbane City…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caseldan Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] QLC 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Caseldan Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council, the primary dispute centered around the valuation of land that had been resumed by the Moreton Bay Regional Council for public purposes. The case was heard in the Queensland Land Court. The legal issues that the court needed to resolve involved determining whether certain factors, including the zoning of the land as open space, should be considered in assessing the land's value at the time of resumption. This assessment was crucial to determining the compensation payable to Caseldan Pty Ltd for the land that had been taken.

The court's reasoning focused on the principle of whether the steps taken by the planning authority, such as zoning the land as open space, were part of the process that led to the resumption or if they were independent factors that affected the land's value. The court referred to previous cases such as Housing Commission of New South Wales v San Sebastian Pty Ltd and Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission to establish the framework for its decision. It was determined that if the planning authority's actions were taken with the intention of facilitating the resumption or if they were steps in the process of creating the planning scheme, then they could be considered in the valuation. However, if the actions were unconnected to the resumption or were merely coincidental, they would not affect the compensation.

The court concluded that the value of the land at the time of resumption should be assessed without considering the zoning as open space, as it was not a step attributable to the planning scheme that led to the resumption. The valuation was set at One Million Eight Hundred Thousand Dollars ($1,800,000). The court also directed that the parties would be heard on matters related to costs attributable to stamp duty for replacement land, interest, and any application for costs, with specific filing and serving directions provided.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The value of the land is assessed in the amount of One Million Eight Hundred Thousand Dollars ($1,800,000).

2. The parties will be heard on the matter of costs attributable to stamp duty for replacement land.

3. The parties will be heard on the matter of interest.

4. Any application for costs is to be filed and served and any reply is to be filed and served as directed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission[46] the Court of Appeal of Western Australia noted that whether the effect on value is attributable to ‘the Scheme’ can be a difficult question to answer.[47] The Court referred to an example given by Jacobs J, with whom the other Justices agreed in the High Court’s decision in Housing Commission of New South Wales v San Sebastian Pty Ltd.[48] Jacobs J said:“Assume an area of land on the outskirts of existing settlement, and assume a planning authority concerned to designate land uses in a planning scheme. The land is designated open space. Thereafter it is resumed for the purpose of a public reserve. The fact that the land was zoned as open space may have depreciated its value. Does the resuming authority pay compensation at the depreciated value of open space or at some other value? The question cannot be correctly answered without knowing whether there was any connexion between the zoning as open space and the subsequent resumption. If the zoning was done with the intent or in anticipation that the land should be resumed for a purpose such as a public reserve or if the zoning was proposed or dictated by the resuming authority then s 124 requires that the zoning be ignored. It is only a step in the process of subsequent resumption. But in other circumstances the resumption may be unconnected with the act of zoning. It may be that the resuming authority selects the land for resumption as a public reserve because it is zoned open space; if it does so it is doing no more than ensuring that it, as well as others, conforms to the planning scheme. In those circumstances there is no relevant relationship between the zoning and the public purpose. No public purpose, existing or anticipated, intended, or urged by the zoning authority, leads to the zoning; rather, the zoning leads to the public purpose and consequent resumption.”The Court of Appeal then said:[49] “The question of what is a ‘step in the process’ in this kind of context has since been discussed in a number of cases. Relatively recently, in Sydney Harbour Foreshore Authority v Walker Corporation Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 251; (2005) 63 NSWLR 407 [85] (Walker No 1) Basten JA (with whom Beazley JA and Stein AJA agreed), said that the ‘lesson of … San Sebastian … is that no narrow view should be taken of steps which may affect the value of land’. However, he added that ‘it is necessary to distinguish between conduct which constitutes a proper exercise of planning powers irrespective of the ultimate resumption and a use of planning powers in pursuit of a proposed resumption’.” The legislative structure in Western Australia is different to that in Queensland so the decision of the Western Australian Court of Appeal must be understood in view of the situation in that State, where the resuming and the planning authority will be the same entity[50] and the scheme was by definition the town planning scheme.[51] The Court of Appeal said: “29 It is true that a Scheme is ‘a progressive thing’. However, as we have said, the step or occurrence affecting value must be ‘attributable’ to the Scheme itself and not (as we understand s 36(2b)) to some different, or as yet unformed, notion that ultimately led to the creation of the Scheme. A step must be attributable to the Scheme, not the Scheme to a step. That is to say, the step must have been taken in order to bring about the Scheme itself, or a variant of it that is not materially different. As to this last proposition, it seems to us that a step may be attributable to a Scheme even if the form which the proposed Scheme then took differed from that which the Scheme ultimately took, so long as the difference is not such as to lead to the conclusion that the Scheme ultimately created was not substantially that which had been proposed. It also seems to us that the step must be taken with the intention of facilitating the Scheme or for the purpose of creating it, if it is to be attributable to the Scheme. So, for example, some proposed general planning consideration that may or may not lead to a Scheme of the kind ultimately implemented could not be said to be attributable to the Scheme merely because, as matters turned out, a Scheme which adopted that planning consideration was subsequently implemented (cp the approach taken in respect of the different legislation in San Sebastian).30 Also, the words ‘attributable to the Scheme’ plainly have the consequence that the effect on value of characteristics or location of the land, or other factors affecting the land (such as population pressures), which always had the capacity to enhance, or reduce, its prospects of development and hence its value are not to be disregarded merely because they led, ultimately, to the Scheme. That is so even if they are specifically identified, or otherwise referred to, by the Scheme: see in this respect the approach adopted (albeit in the context of different legislation) by Basten JA in Walker No 1. The same is true of inherent characteristics of, or other facts affecting, land that is adjacent to the subject land, so far as those characteristics or factors are capable, independently to the Scheme (and its steps), of affecting the development potential, and hence the value, of the subject land. Regard to characteristics and factors of either kind might lead a hypothetical, informed purchaser to anticipate, independently of the Scheme and its steps, an outcome similar to that which in fact happened as a result of the Scheme. In such a case the Scheme (or knowledge of steps leading to it) may have no impact on the value of the land.”[52] (References omitted.)[50][2007] WASCA 226, 4, 5, 6. [51][2007] WASCA 226, 7. [52](2007) WASCA 226, 29, 30.