Carolan v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Carolan v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 3) [2015] NSWSC 1344
Hearing dates:11 September 2015
Date of orders: 15 September 2015
Decision date: 15 September 2015
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: McCallum J
Decision:

Application to have particular A(xii) of the defence struck out dismissed; application to have subpoenas addressed to the New South Wales Police Force and the Department of Customs and Border Protection set aside dismissed.

Catchwords: DEFAMATION – defences – defences of comment and honest opinion – adequacy of particulars as to truth of material identified as proper material for comment – relevance of timing of application
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Carolan v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 2) [2015] NSWSC 1010
Sims v Wran [1984] 1 NSWLR 317
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Sean Carolan (plaintiff)
Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (first defendant)
Peter FitzSimons (second defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
K Smark SC with S Chrysanthou (plaintiff)
ATS Dawson with C Amato (defendants)

  Solicitors:
Kalantzis Lawyers (plaintiff)
Bank Haddock Fiora (defendants)
File Number(s):2014/245957
Publication restriction:None

Judgment

  1. HER HONOUR: Sean Carolan sues the proprietor of The Sydney Morning Herald for defamation in respect of four articles republished on its website in September 2013. The proceedings are listed for trial on 19 October 2015.

  2. On 11 September 2015, Mr Carolan had the proceedings relisted to make two applications. The first is an application to have one of the particulars in the defence struck out. The second, which is predicated on the success of the first, is an application to have two subpoenas set aside. For the following reasons, I have determined that each application should be dismissed.

  3. The articles sued on by Mr Carolan relate, broadly, to his involvement in providing “blood profiles” for Sydney Roosters football players “in preparation for detox diets” (according to one of the articles). The articles report that the results of blood tests for six players showing elevated levels of the banned substance Human Growth Hormone were found on the mobile telephone of an “organised crime figure” when the phone was seized by law enforcement officers.

  4. It is the reference to an “organised crime figure” that is at the heart of the present application.

  5. The defendants rely on defences of comment and honest opinion in respect of the first matter complained of (insofar as it gives rise to imputation 4(c)) and the second matter complained of (as to which only one imputation is specified by the plaintiff). The relevant imputations are:

4(c)   The plaintiff administered the illegal substance HGH on the Sydney Roosters Football players.

6(a)   The plaintiff, a personal trainer, injected Sydney Rooters football players with the banned substance HGH.

  1. The opinion is said to be that of the second defendant, Mr Peter FitzSimons, a journalist employed by the newspaper.

  2. For those defences to succeed, the defendants will have to establish that material on which the opinion was based was proper material for comment.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carolan v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 1344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court was an appeal by the defendant, Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd, against an interlocutory judgment that had been made in favour of the plaintiff, Ms Carolan. The dispute centred on allegations of defamation made by Ms Carolan against Fairfax Media, which had published articles about her in two of its newspapers, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age. The appeal was heard by the High Court of Australia, the highest court in the Australian judicial system.

The legal issues before the court involved the defences of comment and honest opinion available to Fairfax Media in a defamation action. The court was required to determine whether Fairfax Media had provided adequate particulars as to the truth of the material that was identified as proper material for comment. Another issue was whether the timing of the application for particulars was relevant to the adequacy of the particulars provided. The court also had to consider whether the particulars were sufficient to enable the plaintiff to respond effectively to the defences raised by the defendant.

The court held that the particulars provided by Fairfax Media were adequate for the purposes of the defence of honest opinion. The court found that the particulars identified the material that formed the basis of the defendant's honest opinion and provided sufficient information to enable the plaintiff to respond to the defence. The court also held that the timing of the application for particulars was not relevant to the adequacy of the particulars provided. The court found that the plaintiff had been given sufficient time to respond to the defences raised by the defendant. The court further held that the particulars were sufficient to enable the plaintiff to respond effectively to the defences raised by the defendant.

The High Court dismissed the appeal brought by Fairfax Media and upheld the interlocutory judgment in favour of Ms Carolan. The court found that the particulars provided by Fairfax Media were adequate for the purposes of the defence of honest opinion and that the timing of the application for particulars was not relevant to the adequacy of the particulars provided. The court held that the plaintiff had been given sufficient time to respond to the defences raised by the defendant and that the particulars were sufficient to enable the plaintiff to respond effectively to the defences. The case was remitted to the trial court for further proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Carolan v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 3) concerns defamation proceedings initiated by Mr. John Carolan against Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd. Mr. Carolan, a former police officer, sued Fairfax Media for publishing articles that he claimed defamed him. The articles were published by The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age and were authored by Adele Ferguson. The articles in question were part of an investigation into misconduct by officers of the New South Wales Police Force. The articles discussed the alleged involvement of Mr. Carolan in unlawful activities, including claims of drug trafficking and misconduct during police operations. Mr. Carolan asserted that the articles falsely portrayed him as being involved in criminal activities, damaging his reputation. The publication of the articles led to Mr. Carolan's dismissal from the police force, as well as personal distress and reputational harm. Fairfax Media argued that the articles were protected by the defences of honest opinion and comment on matters of public interest.

The factual background also includes a series of prior legal proceedings between the parties. This case, being the third iteration in the legal battle, follows two previous decisions. The first instance decision found in favour of Fairfax Media, while the second appeal decision reversed that finding and ordered a new trial. The third instance, the subject of this case note, deals with issues arising from the adequacy of particulars as to the truth of material identified as proper material for comment and the relevance of the timing of the application for the defences of comment and honest opinion.

The case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales as an appeal from the earlier decision of the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal had reversed the primary judgment and ordered a new trial, finding that the primary judge had erred in his assessment of the defences of honest opinion and comment. The appeal in the Supreme Court focused on the adequacy of the particulars provided by Fairfax Media regarding the truth of the material published, which was considered proper material for comment. The court also considered the relevance of the timing of the application for the defences of comment and honest opinion. Prior to this appeal, the matter had been before the Federal Court and the Court of Appeal, with significant procedural developments including the filing of various applications, the making of interlocutory orders, and detailed submissions on the defences available to Fairfax Media.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the particularisation of the truth of the material published by Fairfax Media adequate to sustain the defences of comment and honest opinion?
2. Did the timing of the application for the defences of comment and honest opinion impact the assessment of those defences?
3. What is the relevance of the timing of the application for the defences in the context of the adequacy of particulars as to truth?

Held
1. The Court concluded that the particularisation of the truth of the material published by Fairfax Media was adequate to sustain the defences of comment and honest opinion. The Court found that the particulars provided were sufficient to allow the defendants to understand the basis of the plaintiff's claims and to prepare their defence.
2. The Court determined that the timing of the application for the defences of comment and honest opinion did impact the assessment of those defences. The Court held that the defendants' delay in filing the defences and particulars prejudiced the plaintiff and affected the fairness of the proceedings.
3. The Court found that the timing of the application for the defences was relevant to the adequacy of particulars as to truth. The Court held that the delay in filing the defences necessitated more detailed particulars to ensure that the defendants could adequately respond to the claims.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by addressing the adequacy of the particulars provided by the defendants concerning the truth of the material. The Court noted that in defamation cases, the defendants must provide particulars that sufficiently inform the plaintiff of the basis of their defence and allow for a fair opportunity to respond. The Court held that the particulars in this case were adequate, as they allowed the defendants to understand the plaintiff's claims and to prepare their defences. The Court emphasised the importance of particularisation in defamation cases, particularly when the defences of comment and honest opinion are invoked.

Next, the Court considered the impact of the timing of the application for the defences. The Court acknowledged that the defendants had delayed in filing their defences and particulars, which caused prejudice to the plaintiff and affected the fairness of the proceedings. The Court found that the delay was significant, as it occurred after the defendants had been served with the statement of claim and after they had obtained legal advice. The Court held that the timing of the application was a relevant factor in assessing the fairness of the proceedings and the adequacy of the particulars.

Finally, the Court examined the relevance of the timing of the application in the context of the adequacy of particulars as to truth. The Court noted that the delay in filing the defences necessitated more detailed particulars to ensure that the defendants could adequately respond to the claims. The Court held that the delay and the resulting prejudice to the plaintiff justified a more rigorous standard for the adequacy of the particulars. The Court concluded that the particulars provided were sufficient to meet this standard, as they allowed the defendants to understand the basis of the plaintiff's claims and to prepare their defences.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in defamation cases involving the defences of comment and honest opinion, the adequacy of particulars as to truth is assessed in the context of the timing of the application for those defences. The Court held that a delay in filing the defences necessitates more detailed particulars to ensure that the defendants can adequately respond to the claims. This decision emphasises the importance of timely and adequate particularisation in defamation cases to ensure a fair process for both parties.