Carmelita Paolucci v Makedyn Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Carmelita Paolucci v Makedyn Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1871
Hearing dates: 23, 24 and 25 November 2020
Date of orders: 17 December 2020
Decision date: 17 December 2020
Jurisdiction: Equity - Real Property List
Before: Rein J
Decision:

[86]-[87]

Catchwords:

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION — Contract – the Plaintiff (a landowner) and the Defendant (a developer) entered into a contractual arrangement by which the Plaintiff would sell her property to the Defendant for $3.5M of which $2.5M was payable in cash and which included an agreement that the Defendant would on completion of the development reconvey to the Plaintiff two lots (which later became three lots) with completed dwellings (a “House” and a “Duplex”) constructed on the lots (“the Reconveyance Contract”) – a “Sunset Clause” provided that the contract could be rescinded by either party “at any time” after 24 May 2017; registration of the relevant subdivision plans was achieved by May 2018. The parties then fell into a dispute concerning the dimensions of the residences required by the Reconveyance Contract to be constructed – issues which arose were: (1) whether the Defendant was in breach of the Reconveyance Contract in failing to complete the construction and reconveyance; (2) whether specific performance or an order for partial specific performance was available; (3) whether the Defendant had a contractual right of rescission pursuant to the Sunset Clause (cl 32.1.4 of the Reconveyance Contract); (4) whether the limitation on damages in cl 32 of the Reconveyance Contract was limited to rescission; (5) whether the reference in cl 30.1 of the Reconveyance Contract to 241.54m2 was a reference to the size of the Duplex or to the two residences forming part of the Duplex –Held: (1) the dimensions of 241.54m2 is a reference to the total area of the Duplex rather than a reference to each residence; (2) the Defendant was in breach of the requirement to provide a layout plan for the House and the Duplex but this breach was rectified in late 2018; (3) the Defendant was not otherwise in breach of the Reconveyance Contract. The long delay in registration of the relevant plans of subdivision was not the fault of the Defendant. The Defendant had not wilfully and deliberately failed to achieve completion of the contract and non-completion was a consequence of the dispute about dimensions; (4) the limitation on damages was not limited to rescission; (5) specific performance or partial specific performance not available because the Defendant by failing to complete was not in breach of the contract and is willing and able to complete the Reconveyance Contract.

LAND LAW — Conveyancing — Contract for sale — Rescission – The Defendant cross claimed seeking permission pursuant to s 66ZS(6) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) (“the Conveyancing Act”) to rescind the Reconveyance Contract and later amended its cross claim to rely on s 66ZS which is the successor to s 66ZL (see…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carmelita Paolucci v Makedyn Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NSWSC 1871
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carmelita Paolucci and Makedyn Pty Ltd were involved in a dispute before the court concerning a contractual agreement for the sale of property. Paolucci agreed to sell her property to Makedyn for $3.5 million, with $2.5 million payable in cash. The agreement included a requirement for Makedyn to construct two lots with completed dwellings on the property and reconvey them to Paolucci upon completion ("the Reconveyance Contract"). The contract contained a "Sunset Clause" allowing either party to rescind the agreement after 24 May 2017 if certain conditions were not met. The primary issues before the court were whether Makedyn was in breach of the Reconveyance Contract, whether specific performance or partial specific performance was available, whether Makedyn had a contractual right of rescission, the extent of the limitation on damages in the contract, and the interpretation of a clause relating to the dimensions of the residences to be constructed.

The court found that the dimensions of 241.54m2 referred to the total area of the Duplex rather than each individual residence. Makedyn was in breach of the contract for failing to provide a layout plan for the House and the Duplex, but this breach was rectified in late 2018. The court held that Makedyn was not otherwise in breach of the Reconveyance Contract, and the long delay in registration of the relevant plans of subdivision was not the fault of Makedyn. The court also determined that the limitation on damages was not limited to rescission. As for the availability of specific performance or partial specific performance, the court concluded that these remedies were not available because Makedyn was not in breach of the contract and was willing and able to complete the Reconveyance Contract.

The court further addressed the cross-claim made by Makedyn seeking permission to rescind the Reconveyance Contract under section 66ZS(6) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW). The court dismissed the cross-claim, finding that it was not just and equitable to permit Makedyn to rescind the contract. The court also allowed without prejudice correspondence into evidence, stating that the status of the letter was doubtful but, in any event, excluding the content would create a misleading impression.

The final orders of the court included the dismissal of Makedyn's cross-claim for rescission and the allowance of without prejudice correspondence into evidence. The court found that Makedyn was not in breach of the Reconveyance Contract and that specific performance or partial specific performance was not available. The court's decision provided clarity on the interpretation of the Reconveyance Contract and the rights and obligations of the parties involved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Carmelita Paolucci, the Plaintiff, entered into a contractual arrangement with Makedyn Pty Ltd, the Defendant, a developer, for the sale of her property for $3.5 million. Of this amount, $2.5 million was to be paid in cash. The contract, referred to as the Reconveyance Contract, included an agreement that the Defendant would, upon completion of the development, reconvey to the Plaintiff two lots, later increased to three lots, with completed dwellings constructed on the lots. A "Sunset Clause" in the contract allowed either party to rescind the contract "at any time" after 24 May 2017. The relevant subdivision plans were registered by May 2018. Following this, the parties fell into dispute concerning the dimensions of the residences required by the Reconveyance Contract to be constructed.

The issues in the dispute included whether the Defendant was in breach of the Reconveyance Contract in failing to complete the construction and reconveyance, whether specific performance or an order for partial specific performance was available, whether the Defendant had a contractual right of rescission pursuant to the Sunset Clause, whether the limitation on damages was limited to rescission, and whether the reference to 241.54m2 was a reference to the size of the Duplex or to the two residences forming part of the Duplex. The court held that the dimensions of 241.54m2 referred to the total area of the Duplex rather than each residence. The Defendant was in breach of the requirement to provide a layout plan for the House and the Duplex but this breach was rectified in late 2018. The Defendant was not otherwise in breach of the Reconveyance Contract. The long delay in registration of the relevant plans of subdivision was not the fault of the Defendant. The Defendant had not wilfully and deliberately failed to achieve completion of the contract and non-completion was a consequence of the dispute about dimensions. The limitation on damages was not limited to rescission. Specific performance or partial specific performance was not available because the Defendant was not in breach of the contract and is willing and able to complete the Reconveyance Contract.

The matter came before the court following a dispute between the Plaintiff and the Defendant concerning the Reconveyance Contract. The Plaintiff alleged that the Defendant was in breach of the contract, while the Defendant cross-claimed seeking permission to rescind the contract pursuant to section 66ZS(6) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW). The Defendant later amended its cross-claim to rely on section 66ZS, which is the successor to section 66ZL. The case involved issues concerning the interpretation of the Reconveyance Contract, the availability of specific performance, and the application of the Sunset Clause. The court heard evidence and submissions from both parties before making its determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the dimensions of 241.54m2 is a reference to the total area of the Duplex rather than a reference to each residence.
2. Whether the Defendant was in breach of the requirement to provide a layout plan for the House and the Duplex.
3. Whether the Defendant was otherwise in breach of the Reconveyance Contract.
4. Whether the limitation on damages in cl 32 of the Reconveyance Contract was limited to rescission.
5. Whether the reference in cl 30.1 of the Reconveyance Contract to 241.54m2 was a reference to the size of the Duplex or to the two residences forming part of the Duplex.
6. Whether rescission by the Defendant should be permitted pursuant to s 66ZS of the Conveyancing Act.
7. Whether specific performance or partial specific performance was available because the Defendant was not in breach of the contract and is willing and able to complete the Reconveyance Contract.
8. Whether without prejudice correspondence should be admitted into evidence.

Held
1. The dimensions of 241.54m2 is a reference to the total area of the Duplex rather than a reference to each residence.
2. The Defendant was in breach of the requirement to provide a layout plan for the House and the Duplex but this breach was rectified in late 2018.
3. The Defendant was not otherwise in breach of the Reconveyance Contract.
4. The limitation on damages was not limited to rescission.
5. Specific performance or partial specific performance not available because the Defendant by failing to complete was not in breach of the contract and is willing and able to complete the Reconveyance Contract.
6. Rescission by the Defendant should not be permitted pursuant to s 66ZS of the Conveyancing Act because it was not just and equitable to permit the Defendant to rescind.
7. Specific performance or partial specific performance not available because the Defendant was not in breach of the contract and is willing and able to complete the Reconveyance Contract.
8. Correspondence allowed into evidence – the status of the letter was doubtful but, in any event, if privileged a misleading impression would be created if that content was excluded.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court examined the contractual agreement between the Plaintiff and the Defendant, focusing on the obligations and the dimensions specified within the contract. The Court clarified that the dimensions of 241.54m2 referred to the total area of the Duplex and not each individual residence. This was based on the plain meaning of the contract terms and the context in which the dimensions were mentioned.

Regarding the layout plan, the Court found that the Defendant was initially in breach for not providing the required layout plan, but this breach was subsequently rectified. The Court held that the Defendant was not otherwise in breach of the Reconveyance Contract, as the delays in registration were not attributable to the Defendant and the non-completion was a consequence of the dispute over dimensions.

On the issue of damages, the Court determined that the limitation on damages in clause 32 of the Reconveyance Contract was not limited to rescission. The Court found that the Defendant had not wilfully and deliberately failed to achieve completion, and therefore, specific performance or partial specific performance was not available. The Defendant was willing and able to complete the Reconveyance Contract.

The Court dismissed the Defendant's cross claim for rescission under section 66ZS of the Conveyancing Act. The Court held that it was not just and equitable to permit the Defendant to rescind the contract, considering the circumstances and the Defendant's willingness to complete the contract.

In relation to the without prejudice correspondence, the Court allowed the correspondence into evidence. Although the status of the correspondence was doubtful, the Court held that excluding the content, even if privileged, would create a misleading impression.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a contract's dimensions refer to the total area of the specified property rather than individual units, and rescission under section 66ZS of the Conveyancing Act is not permitted if it is not just and equitable to do so. Additionally, specific performance or partial specific performance is not available if the party seeking it is willing and able to complete the contract, even if there has been a breach that has been rectified.