Carbone v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2017 0028

RON CARBONE Applicant
V
TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION AUSTRALIA LIMITED  Respondent

---

JUDGES: OSBORN, PRIEST & KAYE JJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 30 August 2017
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 12 September 2017
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2017] VSCA 249
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2017] VCC 73 (Judge Bourke)

---

ACCIDENT COMPENSATION – Workers compensation – Serious injury – Impairment to the right and left shoulder – Whether substantial organic basis – Disentanglement – Pain and suffering – Loss of earning capacity – Whether trial judge failed to provide adequate reasons – Finding as to credibility of Applicant – Whether denial of procedural fairness – Application for leave to appeal refused – Accident Compensation Act 1985 s 134AB – Mutual Cleaning & Maintenance Pty Ltd v Stamboulakis (2007) 15 VR 649 – Hunter v Transport Accident Commission [2005] VSCA 1 – Ucar v Nylex Industrial Products Pty Ltd (2007) 17 VR 492.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors

For the Applicant

For the Respondent

Mr J Mighell QC with
Mr R Ajzensztat

Mr S A O’Meara QC with
Mr R Kumar

Nowicki Carbone Lawyers

Minter Ellison Lawyers

OSBORN JA
KAYE JA:

  1. The applicant issued a proceeding in the County Court by which he sought leave, pursuant to s 134AB of the Accident Compensation Act1985 (‘the Act’), to commence proceedings at common law against the respondent for damages for pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity in respect of injuries to his shoulders in the course of his employment with the respondent.  After a hearing, in which the applicant was cross-examined, the judge, by a reserved decision, dismissed the application.[1]  The applicant seeks leave to appeal from that decision.

The circumstances

  1. The applicant was born in 1973, and, at the time at which he made the application, was 43 years of age.  Having completed Year 10, he undertook one year of a carpentry apprenticeship.  He then commenced employment, in May 1994, with the respondent on a full-time basis, working about 38 hours per week, together with about 10 hours overtime.  His duties included fitting car doors and bonnets from production lines;  work which involved repetitive and heavy lifting of component parts of motor vehicles. 

  1. On 8 June 2010, the applicant suffered injury to his right shoulder in the course of his employment when lifting a heavy car door from the production line.  The weight of the car door put excessive strain on his shoulder, and he felt immediate pain in that area radiating down his right arm and fingers.  At the time of his injury the applicant’s role at work was as a ‘team leader’ in which he worked full time hours.  Following that injury, he did not return to unrestricted work with the respondent. 

  1. On 4 August 2010 an MRI, performed on the applicant’s right shoulder, disclosed signs of supraspinatus tendinosis and partial thickness in substance tearing at its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carbone v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] VSCA 249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the County Court of Victoria, Carbone initiated proceedings against Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd, seeking compensation for a serious injury sustained in a work-related accident. The primary dispute centred around the substantial organic basis of the injury, the disentanglement of psychological from physical injuries, and the resultant pain and suffering as well as loss of earning capacity. The court was tasked with determining whether the trial judge had provided adequate reasons for his findings, particularly in relation to the credibility of the applicant, and whether there had been a denial of procedural fairness.

The legal issues before the court encompassed the interpretation and application of the Accident Compensation Act 1985, specifically in relation to the determination of serious injury and the criteria for awarding compensation. The court needed to examine whether the trial judge's reasoning was sufficient to justify his conclusions on the organic basis of the injury, the disentanglement of pain and suffering, and the loss of earning capacity. Additionally, the court had to consider if the trial judge's findings on the applicant's credibility were supported by the evidence and whether there had been any procedural unfairness.

The County Court held that the trial judge had provided adequate reasons for his findings, thereby dismissing the appeal. The court found that the judge had properly disentangled the psychological and physical aspects of the injury and had not erred in assessing the credibility of the applicant. It was determined that the trial judge's findings were supported by the evidence and that there was no procedural unfairness. The application for leave to appeal was therefore refused, affirming the decision of the trial judge.

No specific orders were made in the County Court's decision as the appeal was dismissed. However, the refusal of leave to appeal effectively upheld the original judgment, which would include the determination of the compensation to be awarded to Carbone.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established