CAPITAL PROPERTY PROJECTS (ACT) PTY LIMITED and OTHERS v PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY and ANOR
[2007] ACTSC 54 (22 June 2007)
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Subpoena – failure to comply with orders – proceedings struck out in part.
Supreme Court Rules, r 40(54)
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act1989
Brisbane South Regional Health Authorityv Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541
Choundary v Capital Airport Group Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1755
Ex Tempore Judgment
No. SC 796 of 2006
Judge: Connolly J
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 22 June 2007
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SC 796 of 2006
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
BETWEEN:CAPITAL PROPERTY PROJECTS (ACT) PTY LIMITED
ACN 109 406 680
First Plaintiff
AND:CANBERRA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PTY LIMITED
ABN 14 080 361 548
Second Plaintiff
AND:CAPITAL PROPERTY FINANCE PTY LIMITED ABN 98 008 608 928
Third Plaintiff
AND:BRAND DEPOT PTY LIMITED
ABN 26 117 285 079
Fourth Plaintiff
AND:PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY
First Defendant
AND:DIRECT FACTORY OUTLETS CANBERRA PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 065 935
Second Defendant
ORDER
Judge: Connolly J
Date: 22 June 2007
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
Pursuant to r 1452 the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff be dismissed for failure to comply with the subpoena issued to the third plaintiff dated 10 May 2007.
The subpoenas issued to the first, second and third plaintiffs dated 7 June 2007 be withdrawn.
The subpoena issued to the fourth plaintiff dated 7 June 2007 be amended to only refer to “copies of balance sheets, profit and loss statements, trial balance and income tax returns relating to or concerning the financial position produced on or since 1 July 2006”.
The subpoena issued to the fourth plaintiff dated 7 June 2007 be returnable at the hearing on 30 July 2007 at 10 am.
The third plaintiff pay the costs of the first and second defendants thrown away by reason of the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff being dismissed.
The third plaintiff pay the first and second defendants’ costs of the application in proceedings dated 19 June 2007.
This is an application pursuant to r 40(54) of the new Rules to strike out proceedings on the basis of failure to comply with a subpoena issued on 10 May 2007. Although brought under the new Rules, it is in a similar form to procedures that were well established under the old Rules and, indeed, with the inherent power of the Court. Generally, it is true to say that when a party puts on an application to strike out by reason of failure to comply with a subpoena or a direction of the Court, it is really done as a tactical step to bring to the Court’s attention the failure by the other party. The plea is formally to strike out, but in most cases the sanction that will be granted falls well short of strike out.
It is urged in this case that no sanction short of striking out…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital Property Projects (ACT) Pty Limited v Planning & Lan... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] ACTSC 54
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with deciding whether the proceedings should be struck out as a sanction for the failure to comply with the subpoena, and if so, what form that sanction should take. The proceedings were not ordinary common law claims but rather public law claims under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1989 and prerogative relief. The court also had to consider whether the subpoenas issued to other plaintiffs should be amended or withdrawn and whether certain accounting records should be disclosed.
The court reasoned that striking out the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff was warranted due to their gross failure to comply with the subpoena. The court highlighted the importance of adhering to time limits in public law actions and the significant commercial uncertainty caused by delays. The court found that the defendants could not fairly test the basis for extending time due to the plaintiffs' inadequate response to the subpoena. The court also decided not to set aside the subpoenas issued to other plaintiffs but made necessary amendments to ensure compliance with confidentiality principles. The court ordered costs to be paid by the third plaintiff to the defendants.
In conclusion, the court dismissed the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff for failure to comply with the subpoena. It also ordered the subpoenas to be amended and withdrew certain subpoenas. The court further ruled that the subpoena to the fourth plaintiff concerning accounting records should be limited and made returnable at the hearing on July 30, 2007. The third plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of the first and second defendants thrown away due to the proceedings being dismissed and the costs of the application in proceedings dated June 19, 2007.
Background
Background to the litigation
The proceedings are public law claims seeking judicial review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1989 and prerogative relief. The plaintiffs initially sought an injunction to prevent the auction from proceeding, which was unsuccessful. They now challenge the Planning & Land Authority's decisions on various grounds, including excess of jurisdiction and a claimed state of mind of one of the plaintiffs. A key issue to be determined is whether the plaintiffs' claims are time-barred, given the short statutory time limits for public law challenges.
In response to subpoenas issued to the plaintiffs, there has been an inadequate response from the third plaintiff, Capital Property Finance Pty Limited, leading to an application to strike out part of their proceedings. Despite multiple opportunities and assurances, the third plaintiff failed to produce relevant documents and emails, including those related to their state of mind and claimed undervaluation of the lease. This failure to comply with the subpoenas has significantly prejudiced the defendants and caused substantial delay.
The court granted the application to strike out the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff for failure to comply with the subpoena, as well as dismissing their claims. The court also withdrew certain subpoenas, amended others, and ordered the third plaintiff to pay costs. The fourth plaintiff, Brand Depot, still faces a subpoena for financial records, subject to certain limitations to protect sensitive information. The court emphasised the importance of timely and complete compliance with subpoenas, especially in public law cases involving significant commercial transactions.
The matter came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as an application under rule 40(54) of the Supreme Court Rules to strike out proceedings on the basis of the third plaintiff's failure to comply with a subpoena. This application was filed by the first and second defendants, Planning & Land Authority and Direct Factory Outlets Canberra Pty Limited, respectively. The plaintiffs, Capital Property Projects (ACT) Pty Limited, Canberra International Airport Pty Limited, Capital Property Finance Pty Limited, and Brand Depot Pty Limited, had initiated proceedings challenging the decision of the Planning & Land Authority to grant a development approval and a Crown lease to the second defendant. The underlying dispute concerns the development of a block of land in Fyshwick, Canberra. Prior to this application, an injunction application to prevent the auction of the land was brought before Justice Gray, who set a preliminary point for hearing on 30 July 2007, concerning whether the challenge to the development application is a judiciable question of fact. Additionally, a question regarding the extension of time to challenge the grant of the Crown lease is also set for hearing on the same date. The court granted the application to strike out the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff for failure to comply with the subpoena and ordered various amendments to the subpoenas issued to the other plaintiffs. Costs were awarded to the first and second defendants.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff should be dismissed for failure to comply with a subpoena.
2. Whether the subpoenas issued to the first, second, and third plaintiffs should be withdrawn.
3. Whether the subpoena issued to the fourth plaintiff should be amended to only refer to certain financial documents.
4. Whether the subpoena issued to the fourth plaintiff should be returnable at the hearing on 30 July 2007 at 10 am.
5. Whether the third plaintiff should pay the costs of the first and second defendants thrown away by reason of the proceedings being dismissed.
6. Whether the third plaintiff should pay the first and second defendants’ costs of the application in proceedings dated 19 June 2007.
Held
1. The proceedings brought by the third plaintiff should be dismissed for failure to comply with a subpoena, resulting in the dismissal of the third plaintiff's case.
2. The subpoenas issued to the first, second, and third plaintiffs should be withdrawn, meaning they are no longer in effect.
3. The subpoena issued to the fourth plaintiff should be amended to only refer to certain financial documents, specifically "copies of balance sheets, profit and loss statements, trial balance and income tax returns relating to or concerning the financial position produced on or since 1 July 2006".
4. The subpoena issued to the fourth plaintiff should be returnable at the hearing on 30 July 2007 at 10 am, setting a specific time and date for compliance.
5. The third plaintiff should pay the costs of the first and second defendants thrown away by reason of the proceedings being dismissed, resulting in financial responsibility for the third plaintiff.
6. The third plaintiff should pay the first and second defendants’ costs of the application in proceedings dated 19 June 2007, adding to the financial responsibility of the third plaintiff.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning in this case revolves around the third plaintiff's failure to comply with a subpoena and the consequences of this failure. The court found that the third plaintiff's failure to comply with the subpoena was so gross that it warranted dismissing the proceedings brought by the third plaintiff. The court held that the third plaintiff had not produced any real documents in response to the subpoena, and there had been a significant delay in providing even a single-page document that was clearly insufficient. Furthermore, the third plaintiff had failed to produce emails, despite repeated assurances that they were working on it.
The court also found that the third plaintiff's failure to comply with the subpoena meant that the defendants could not fairly test the claimed basis for the extension of time. The court was concerned about the massive commercial uncertainty that would result if a Crown lease could be challenged eight and a half months after it was granted. The court was less troubled about denying the plaintiffs their day in court on this issue because the plaintiffs had bid $38 million against the $39 million bid, and the valuation advice they had suggested $15 million.
In relation to the subpoenas issued to the first, second, and third plaintiffs, the court found that they were no longer necessary given the dismissal of the third plaintiff's proceedings. However, the subpoena issued to the fourth plaintiff was amended to only refer to certain financial documents, and the court declined to set it aside. The court held that it was not inappropriate to go down a separate discovery process, but it was not at all inappropriate to do it by way of subpoena.
Finally, the court ordered that the third plaintiff pay the costs of the first and second defendants thrown away by reason of the proceedings being dismissed and the costs of the application in proceedings dated 19 June 2007. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a court may dismiss proceedings brought by a party who fails to comply with a subpoena, particularly where the failure to comply causes significant delay and commercial uncertainty. Additionally, a court may amend a subpoena to limit its scope if it is too broad, but may still enforce it if it is necessary to resolve an important issue such as standing in administrative law proceedings.