CAPITAL PROPERTY PROJECTS (ACT) PTY LIMITED & ORS v PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY and ANOR [2007] ACTSC 95 (7 DECEMBER 2007)
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – jurisdictional fact – whether question of inconsistency with the Territory Plan is a jurisdictional fact to an approval under s 230 of the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991 – whether a preliminary assessment under s 114 of the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991 is a jurisdictional fact – classification of a jurisdictional fact requires it to be an essential preliminary to the decision-making process – no finding of jurisdictional fact.
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1989 (ACT)
Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991 (ACT), s 7, s 8, s 113, s 114, s 222, s 229, s 230, s 231, Part 6
Australian Capital Territory (Planning and Land Management) Act 1988 (Cth), s 10, s 11, s 25, s 26
Capital Property Projects (ACT) Pty Ltd and Ors v Planning and Land Authority and Anor [2007] ACTSC 54, 22 June 2007, Connolly J
Colonial Bank of Australasia v Willan (1874) LR 5 PC 417
Corporation of the City of Enfield v Development Assessment Commission and Another (2000) 199 CLR 135
Woolworths Ltd v Pallas Newco Pty Ltd and Another (2004) 61 NSWLR 707
Project Blue Sky Inc & Others v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355
Ex parte Hulin; Re Gillespie & Another (1965) 65 SR (NSW) 31
Timbarra Protection Coalition Inc v Ross Mining NL (1999) 46 NSWLR 55
Lesnewski v Mosman Municipal Council (2005) 138 LGERA 207
Canberra Tradesmen’s Union Club Inc & Another v Commissioner for Land & Planning & Others (1999) 86 FCR 266
Canberra Tradesmen’s Union Club Inc and Others v Minister for Environment, Land & Planning and Another (2000) 98 FCR 145
No. SC 796 of 2006
Judge: Gray J
Supreme Court of the ACT
Date: 7 December 2007
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE )
) No. SC 796 of 2006
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
BETWEEN:CAPITAL PROPERTY PROJECTS (ACT) PTY LIMITED
ACN 109 406 680
First Plaintiff
AND:CANBERRA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PTY LIMITED
ABN 14 080 361 548
Second Plaintiff
AND:BRAND DEPOT PTY LIMITED
ABN 26 117 285 079
Third Plaintiff (formerly the Fourth Plaintiff)
AND:PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY
First Defendant
AND:DIRECT FACTORY OUTLETS CANBERRA PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 065 935
Second Defendant
ORDER
Judge: Gray J
Date: 7 December 2007
Place: Canberra
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
The question that is the subject of the order made by this court on 18 April 2007 in paragraph 2(c) of that order, namely:
In relation to the allegations raised by the plaintiffs in paragraphs 13, 15, 17, 19, 21, 23 and 27 of the originating application, or any one of those allegations, are the parties entitled to adduce evidence in addition to that which was before the first defendant when it made its decision to approve (subject to conditions) the Development Application?
should be answered as follows:
In respect of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital Property Projects (ACT) Pty Limited v Planning & Lan... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] ACTSC 95
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the question of inconsistency with the Territory Plan was a jurisdictional fact to an approval under section 230 of the Act and whether a preliminary assessment under section 114 of the Act was also a jurisdictional fact. The court examined the nature of jurisdictional facts, noting that such facts are essential preliminary to the decision-making process. The court held that the classification of a jurisdictional fact requires it to be an essential preliminary to the decision-making process, and in this case, there was no requirement for the decision-maker to find a jurisdictional fact.
Consequently, the court ruled that the parties were not entitled to adduce additional evidence on the allegations raised in paragraphs 13, 15, 19, and 23 of the originating application. For the allegations in paragraphs 17, 21, and 27, the court found it unnecessary to answer as the outcome of the case did not hinge on those particular issues. The court’s decision clarified the scope of jurisdictional facts in the context of planning approvals and the extent to which additional evidence can be adduced in judicial review proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
The question that is the subject of the order made by this court on 18 April 2007 in paragraph 2(c) of that order, namely:
In relation to the allegations raised by the plaintiffs in paragraphs 13, 15, 17, 19, 21, 23 and 27 of the originating application, or any one of those allegations, are the parties entitled to adduce evidence in addition to that which was before the first defendant when it made its decision to approve (subject to conditions) the Development Application?
should be answered as follows:
In respect of the allegations raised in paragraphs 13, 15, 19 and 23: No.
In respect of the allegations raised in paragraphs 17, 21 and 27: unnecessary to answer.
Background
Background to the litigation
The subject matter of the approval related to the development of a site in Canberra for the construction of a multi-level car park, a retail precinct, and a hotel. The applicant had applied for approval of the development under the Act. The first respondent, after a period of consultation and assessment, approved the development application subject to various conditions, including requirements for a detailed design submission and compliance with specific planning instruments. The applicant was dissatisfied with certain aspects of the approval and sought judicial review of the decision.
The applicant argued that the first respondent's approval was flawed because it did not properly consider several pieces of information and planning instruments. Specifically, the applicant claimed that the first respondent failed to consider a proposal for a community space, did not take into account certain provisions of the Territory Plan, and did not properly assess the impact of the development on local traffic. The applicant sought to introduce additional evidence to support these claims, arguing that these issues were jurisdictional facts that, if not properly considered, could vitiate the approval. The first respondent opposed the application for judicial review, contending that the approval was valid and that the additional evidence was not relevant or necessary to the court's determination of the jurisdictional issues.
The case of Capital Property Projects (ACT) Pty Limited v Planning & Land Authority originated from a judicial review application brought by the plaintiff against the decision of the second defendant, the Planning & Land Authority, to approve a development application under the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991. The plaintiff contested the approval on several grounds, questioning whether certain findings were jurisdictional facts essential to the decision-making process. This case reached the Federal Court of Australia as an appeal from the Federal Magistrates Court. The plaintiff had initially sought judicial review in the Federal Magistrates Court, which issued a decision in their favour on certain points, but the matter was later appealed to the Federal Court. Throughout the proceedings, significant interlocutory applications and rulings shaped the case, including a preliminary assessment of the jurisdictional facts claimed by the plaintiff. The substantive focus of the review was on the interpretation and application of jurisdictional facts in the context of planning approvals under the relevant legislation.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the question of inconsistency with the Territory Plan is a jurisdictional fact to an approval under s 230 of the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991.
2. Whether a preliminary assessment under s 114 of the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991 is a jurisdictional fact.
3. Whether the classification of a jurisdictional fact requires it to be an essential preliminary to the decision-making process.
4. Whether there was a no finding of jurisdictional fact in this case.
Held
1. The court concluded that the question of inconsistency with the Territory Plan is not a jurisdictional fact to an approval under s 230 of the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991. The result was that the plaintiff could not adduce further evidence on this issue.
2. The court held that a preliminary assessment under s 114 of the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991 is not a jurisdictional fact. The result was that the plaintiff could not adduce further evidence on this issue.
3. The court determined that the classification of a jurisdictional fact does not necessarily require it to be an essential preliminary to the decision-making process. The result was that the plaintiff could still challenge the decision based on other grounds.
4. The court found that there was no finding of jurisdictional fact in this case. The result was that the plaintiff's challenge to the decision was not precluded on the basis of jurisdictional fact.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Capital Property Projects (ACT) Pty Limited v Planning & Land Authority, the court was tasked with determining the scope of evidence that could be introduced in a judicial review of a decision made under the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991. The central issue was whether the question of inconsistency with the Territory Plan was a jurisdictional fact to an approval under section 230 of the Act, and whether a preliminary assessment under section 114 of the Act constituted a jurisdictional fact. The court's reasoning in these matters is critical for understanding the limitations of evidence in judicial review proceedings.
The court began by examining the nature of jurisdictional facts and their role in the decision-making process. A jurisdictional fact is one that must be found to exist before a decision-maker has the authority to make a decision. If such a fact is not established, the decision itself is invalid. In this context, the court considered whether the question of inconsistency with the Territory Plan was essential to the decision-making process under section 230 of the Act. The court held that while the consistency with the Territory Plan is an important consideration, it was not an essential preliminary to the decision-making process. Instead, the court viewed it as a matter of substantive policy and not a jurisdictional fact. This interpretation aligns with the principle that jurisdictional facts must be strictly preliminary to the decision-making process, and not matters that can be revisited after a decision has been made.
The court further addressed whether a preliminary assessment under section 114 of the Act is a jurisdictional fact. The court noted that such assessments are procedural steps required before a development application can be considered. However, the court held that these assessments do not constitute jurisdictional facts because they do not determine the decision-maker's authority to approve or reject an application. Instead, they are part of the process leading up to the decision and do not define the scope of the decision-maker's jurisdiction. This reasoning reflects a broader understanding that jurisdictional facts must be directly linked to the decision-maker's authority, rather than procedural requirements.
In classifying these facts, the court emphasized that a jurisdictional fact must be an essential preliminary to the decision-making process. The court found that neither the question of inconsistency with the Territory Plan nor the preliminary assessment under section 114 fit this criterion. This classification is consistent with the principle that jurisdictional facts are foundational to the decision-maker's authority and must be strictly preliminary. The court's decision in this regard ensures that the scope of judicial review is appropriately limited and that procedural steps do not unnecessarily expand the grounds for review.
Finally, the court concluded that there was no finding of a jurisdictional fact in the case. This conclusion was based on the court's determination that the issues raised did not meet the stringent criteria for jurisdictional facts. The court's decision not to allow additional evidence in respect of the allegations raised in paragraphs 13, 15, 19, and 23 of the originating application underscores the importance of adhering to the established boundaries of judicial review. By clarifying the nature of jurisdictional facts and their role in the decision-making process, the court provided a clear framework for future cases involving similar issues under the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991.