Candetti Constructions Pty Ltd v M & I Samaras (No 1) Pty Ltd & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master)

CANDETTI CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD v M & I SAMARAS (NO 1) PTY LTD & ORS

[2011] SASC 165

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

4 October 2011

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - SUPPORTING AFFIDAVIT - REQUIREMENTS FOR

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEMAND - GENUINE DISPUTE AS TO INDEBTEDNESS - OFFSETTING AND OTHER LIKE CLAIMS - GENERALLY

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEMAND - GENUINE DISPUTE AS TO INDEBTEDNESS - ASSESSING GENUINENESS - GENERALLY

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - WINDING UP IN INSOLVENCY - STATUTORY DEMAND - APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEMAND - FOR DEFECT OR SOME OTHER REASON

Appeal against decision of a Master refusing to set aside a statutory demand - demand for amount appellant had allegedly admitted it was liable to pay - the Master found there was no admission of liability - respondent argued that the amount demanded was independent of the admission and was for an undissected portion of a debt - whether, as a matter of construction, the respondent had demanded and whether, as a matter of law, s 459E permits demand for an undissected portion of a debt - whether the demand should be set aside pursuant to s 459J - whether delay may give rise to reduction of value in quantum meruit - whether appellant had proven relevant delay - whether appellant had a genuine off-setting claim as a consequence of delay.

Held: The statutory demand did not demand an undissected portion of the debt - in any event, s 459E does not permit a demand for an undissected portion - alternatively the demand should be set aside pursuant to s 459J - delay is capable of founding a basis for reduction of value in quantum meruit - appellant had not proven any such delay - the appellant had failed to prove any genuine off-setting claim - appeal allowed.

Corporations Act 2011 (Cth) s 459E, s 459G, s 459H, s 459J; Evidence Act 1929 (SA) s 67C; Corporations Rules 2003 (SA) r 5.2, referred to.
Bentham Management Pty Ltd v Union Finance Pty Ltd (2007) 247 LSJS 103; Crown House Engineering Ltd v Amec Projects Ltd (1989) 38 BLR 32, applied.
Arcade Badge Embroidery Co Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2005) 58 ATR 456; Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57; Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618; British Steel Corporation v Cleveland Bridge and Engineering Co Ltd [1984] 1 All ER 504; Chippendale Printing Co Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1995) 55 FCR 562; Condor Asset Management Ltd v Excelsior Eastern Ltd (2005) 56 ACSR 223; Construction Services Civil Pty Ltd v J & N Allen Enterprises Pty Ltd (1985) 1 BCL 363; David Grant &…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Candetti Constructions Pty Ltd v M & I Samaras (No 1) Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASC 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Candetti Constructions Pty Ltd v M & I Samaras (No 1) Pty Ltd & Ors, the primary issue was whether a statutory demand issued by M & I Samaras against Candetti Constructions could be set aside. The dispute revolved around the validity of the statutory demand and the underlying debt claimed by Samaras. Specifically, the court had to determine if the demand was valid under the Corporations Act, whether there was a genuine dispute over the debt, and if there were any grounds for setting aside the demand as per section 459J of the Act. The court also needed to assess whether any delay by Candetti could justify a reduction in the value of the debt claimed by Samaras under quantum meruit principles.

The statutory demand in question specified an amount that Candetti allegedly admitted liability for. However, the Master had found no such admission. Samaras argued that the amount demanded was independent of any admission and pertained to an undissected portion of a debt. The court had to determine if the statutory demand correctly demanded an undissected portion of the debt and if section 459E of the Corporations Act allowed for such a demand. Additionally, the court considered whether the statutory demand should be set aside under section 459J, whether any delay by Candetti could justify a reduction in the quantum meruit value of the debt, and whether Candetti had a genuine off-setting claim due to any such delay.

The court found that the statutory demand did not demand an undissected portion of the debt and, in any case, section 459E of the Corporations Act does not permit such a demand. The court ruled that the demand should be set aside under section 459J of the Act. It was established that delay could indeed justify a reduction in the value of a debt under quantum meruit, but Candetti had failed to prove any such delay. Furthermore, the court concluded that Candetti had not proven any genuine off-setting claim. Consequently, the appeal was allowed. The court's final orders would detail the specifics of setting aside the statutory demand and any other relevant directives.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Candetti appeals against that decision.The Facts In the set aside proceedings, the parties have disclosed only the tip of the iceberg in terms of the relevant dealings between them. It is apparent that, if there were substantive proceedings between the parties, a comprehensive picture would necessarily be painted, involving facts and circumstances (and possibly issues and causes of action) which have not been disclosed on the set aside application.Marion project Candetti was engaged by an organ of the State to design and construct the State Aquatic Centre, the GP Health Care Centre and a Car Park at Marion (“the Marion project”). Candetti in turn engaged[2] Samaras to fabricate the structural steel for the Marion project. [2] By “engage”, I do not imply that there was a contract between the parties (as this is a live issue in the set aside proceedings), or that the “engagement” occurred at a specific point in time (as this is not apparent on the evidence). On a date unknown, Candetti invited Samaras in some manner to tender to fabricate the structural steel for the Marion project on terms unknown. The invitation to tender is not in evidence. On a date unknown, Samaras lodged with Candetti a tender in some form on terms unknown. The tender is not in evidence. On 18 September 2009, Samaras sent to Candetti a letter attaching a revised schedule of rates (“the September rates schedule”) in connection with the tender and responding to an email dated 18 September 2009 (which is not in evidence). On 5 January 2010, Samaras sent an email to Candetti attaching a Car Park target Guaranteed Maximum Price (“GMP”) submission. The email is in evidence, but not the submission. On 6 January 2010, Candetti sent an email to Samaras stating that various exclusions and clarifications were required to the Final GMP, and instructing Samaras to procure the steel for the Car Park in the meantime. Between some time in 2010 and late 2010 or early 2011, Samaras fabricated the structural steel for the project. Samaras lodged progress claims for the fabrication of the structural steel for a total amount of $13,291,583. The progress claims are not in evidence, nor are any details (eg date, amount, scope of work) disclosed by the evidence. Candetti has paid to Samaras a total of $11,833,648 in respect of the structural steel for the project. Samaras claims that it is owed by Candetti the difference of $1,457,935 (“the Principal Amount”). In December 2010, there was a meeting between Candetti and Samaras to attempt to negotiate a settlement of accounts relating to the project. On 11 April 2011, there was a further meeting for the same purpose. At that meeting, a number of offers for an overall settlement of accounts were put (with a denial of liability), but no resolution was achieved.Common Ground Project In addition to the Marion project, Candetti was also involved (in an unspecified way) in a project known as Common Ground at Light Square, Adelaide.Crane Hire Services

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLUE J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLUE J

Full text does not contain this section.