[2012] AATA 244
Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION File Number(s)
2011/4463
Re
William Campos
APPLICANT
And
Minister for Infrastructure and Transport
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal Senior Member J F Toohey
Date 30 April 2012 Place Sydney The decision under review is affirmed.
..............[sgd]..........................................................
Senior Member J F Toohey
CATCHWORDS
MOTOR VEHICLE STANDARDS – importation of nonstandard vehicle – mobility scooter –whether discretion to approve importation should be exercised in the applicant’s favour – whether exercise of the discretion would undermine the objectives of the Act – public safety considerations – decision under review affirmed
LEGISLATION
Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 ss 3, 5, 7, 10A, 18, 19, 20 and 21
Motor Vehicle Standards Regulations 1989 regs 7, 11, 13, 18 and 24
CASES
Haughey and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government [2008] AATA 540
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24
Selway v Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government [2011] FCA 43Zillin and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government [2011] AATA 135
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Commonwealth, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 23 May 1989, 2687, (Robert Brown) (Second reading speech).
Department of Infrastructure and Transport, Importing Vehicles to Australia, July 2010.
Department of Infrastructure and Transport, Specialist and Enthusiast Vehicle Scheme (SEVS) (2011) viewed 27 April 2012.
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member J F Toohey
BACKGROUND
Mr William Campos has a disability which will make it increasingly difficult in coming years for him to drive a standard motor vehicle or two-wheeled scooter. He lives in a hilly part of Sydney where there are no footpaths. His research into the mobility scooters available in Australia has led him to conclude that none is suitable for his use because they lack the necessary stability and braking power.
In March 2011, Mr Campos entered into a contract with a company in Canada for the purchase of a Zhejian Wanjin Pailson Motor Tricycle, to be manufactured in Canada. The vehicle has yet to be manufactured because Mr Campos believes its brakes may require modification to meet Australian standards, and that other modifications, such as to the size of the lights, may also be needed. He has no argument with the application of the standards or with modifying the vehicle as necessary in order to meet them.
In June 2011, Mr Campos sent an email to the Department of Infrastructure and Transport (the Department) asking whether he needed approval to import the vehicle. On being advised that approval would be required, he made his application.
On 25 August 2011, a delegate of the Minister for Infrastructure and Transport (the Minister) refused Mr Campos’ application on the ground that the vehicle failed to comply with the relevant Australian Design Rules (ADRs) and would need to do so in full before approval to import could be granted. The delegate further decided that the discretion by which approval might be granted should not be exercised in his case. Mr Campos seeks review of that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Campos and Minister for Infrastructure and Transport and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] AATA 244
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the exercise of the discretion to approve the importation of the nonstandard vehicle would undermine the objectives of the Act, and whether the applicant had demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant an exception to the blanket prohibition on the importation of nonstandard vehicles. The court had to consider the public safety implications of approving the importation of the vehicle and whether the applicant had provided compelling reasons to justify an exception.
The court found that while Mr Campos had suffered considerable financial hardship and would have been entitled to import the vehicle under the previous regulations, the legislation imposed a broad prohibition against the importation of nonstandard vehicles, primarily to maintain public safety. The court was not persuaded that the applicant's circumstances warranted an exception to this prohibition, as there was no evidence that the importation of the vehicle would significantly advance the safety of the public more broadly. The court also noted that Mr Campos had not demonstrated a pressing current need for the vehicle and had not provided compelling reasons why the existing models available in Australia were unsuitable for his use.
The court affirmed the decision of the Minister for Infrastructure and Transport, upholding the refusal to approve the importation of the nonstandard mobility scooter. The court's decision underscored the importance of maintaining the safety of the public on the roads and the limited circumstances in which the discretion to approve such importations should be exercised.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Those considerations included that the applicant would have been entitled to import the vehicle under the previous regulations, that he had suffered “considerable financial hardship” as a result of the refusal, that he otherwise met all the requirement of reg 13, and that the Department itself appeared to consider that, with conditions, he could be put in a substantially comparable position to other people affected by the amending Regulations. CONSIDERATION Mr Campos frankly acknowledges that his purpose in seeking approval to import the vehicle is to identify what, if any, modification it requires in order to meet Australian standards. He has no argument with the standards; if modifications are necessary, he will have them incorporated into the specifications for the vehicle’s manufacture. He accepts the possibility that, even with modifications, the vehicle might not meet the standards, in which case he proposes to give it to a charity overseas which he supports. Assuming, with modification, the vehicle would meet Australian design requirements, there is no suggestion that Mr Campos’ safety, or the safety of anyone else, might be adversely affected if approval is granted. He is willing to destroy it or donate it if it fails. However, I am not persuaded that is sufficient to exercise the discretion. The legislation imposes a prohibition against the importation of vehicles that is broad in its scope and purpose, underpinned by the compelling policy of maintaining the safety of the public on the roads. Consistent with its policy and objectives, it is, in effect, a blanket prohibition against personal importation of nonstandard vehicles except in very limited circumstances. Against that background, there needs to be good reason for the discretion in reg 11 to be exercised. That is not to say that an applicant must demonstrate something exceptional about his or her case. Nothing in the language of reg 11 fetters the discretion. It is not necessary to find “some exceptional or special or rare circumstances” for the discretion to be exercised: Selway (above) at [39]. It is relevant in this regard that the legislation recognises that the imposition of a condition, or conditions, may be appropriate, and sufficient to meet the policy objectives of the legislation. That said, Tribunal decisions have generally required “some element of unfairness or injustice to the applicant if approval were not granted”: Haughey and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government [2008] AATA 540 at [19]. Mr Campos says innovation is needed in the area of transport for people with disabilities and, with an ageing population, there is some force to that argument. However, it is difficult to see how the safety of the public more broadly would be advanced by approving the importation of a single vehicle for his personal use. The respondent contends there are three wheeled vehicles and mobility scooters readily available in Australia that would suit Mr Campos’ needs. The respondent has not provided any evidence of such vehicles. Equally, however, Mr Campos has not demonstrated why those models currently available are not suitable for his use. It is relevant that he does not claim any pressing current need for the vehicle.