Leaver and Minister for Urban Infrastructure and Cities [2019] AATA 5252 (5 December 2019)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number: 2019/0619
Re:Richard Leaver
APPLICANT
AndMinister for Urban Infrastructure and Cities
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle
Date:5 December 2019
Place:Perth
The Tribunal affirms the decision made by the Associate Administrator of Vehicle Standards dated 29 January 2019 to not approve an application for the importation of a 2010 Jaguar XF.
......................[sgd]..................................................
Deputy President Boyle
CATCHWORDS
motor vehicle importation – vehicle from United Kingdom – vehicle without identification plate – whether requirements of Regulation 13 met – whether discretion under Regulation 11 should be exercised – Applicant’s residency status – period of ownership – period for which applicant overseas prior to application – decision affirmed
LEGISLATION
Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 (Cth) – ss 3, 3(b), 5, 7, 18, 20(1)(b)
Motor Vehicle Standards Regulations 1989 (Cth) – regs 10, 11, 13(ac), 13(1)(a), 13(1)(b), 13(1)(aa), 13(1)(ab), 13(1)(ac), 13(1)(ad), 11,
CASES
Colley and Secretary, Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Cities and Regional Development [2019] AATA 4204
SAS Trustee Corporation v Miles [2018] HCA 55
SZTAL v Minister for Immigration (2017) 91 ALJR 936
Selway and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government [2010] AATA 595
Selway v Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development & Local Government [2011] FCA 43
Whalley and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport and Regional Development [2019] AATA 661Williamson and Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government [2009] AATA 48
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Commonwealth, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 23 May 1989 (Robert Brown, Minister) – pp 2697, 2688
Explanatory Statement, Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 (Cth); Motor Vehicle Standards Amendment Regulations 2009 (No. 1)
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Boyle
5 December 2019
THE APPLICATION
This is an application for the review of a decision made by the Associate Administrator of Vehicle Standards dated 29 January 2019 to not approve an application for the importation of a 2010 Jaguar XF (the Vehicle).
BACKGROUND
On 3 January 2019 the Applicant applied to the Minister under Regulation 10 of the Motor Vehicle Standards Regulations 1989 (Cth) (Regulations) for approval to import the Vehicle under the personal import option (T4).
It is not disputed that the Vehicle does not have an identification plate and is nonstandard for the purposes of s 5 of the Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 (Cth) (the Act).
In making the decision on 29 January 2019 not to approve the importation of the Vehicle, the decision-maker found that the requirements of Regulations 13(1)(ac),13(1)(ad) and 13(1)(a) were not satisfied. The decision-maker was also not satisfied that there were sufficient grounds to warrant the exercise of the discretion under Regulation 11 (T2, T8).
In the application to import the Vehicle (T4), the Applicant advised that:
(a)he purchased the Vehicle, which was first registered in 2010, in July 2017;
(b)since purchasing the Vehicle, he had used it for travel in the United Kingdom (UK) and through various countries in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Leaver and Minister for Urban Infrastructure and Cities and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] AATA 5252
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the specific requirements of Regulation 13 of the relevant legislation for the importation of a vehicle, and if not, whether there were sufficient grounds to exercise the general discretion under Regulation 11 to permit the importation. The applicant contended that the absence of an identification plate did not render the vehicle unsafe, citing superior European safety standards and a good ANCAP rating. He also argued that his transient lifestyle in Australia and lengthy stays overseas meant he qualified as an expatriate returning to reside permanently in Australia, having owned the vehicle for over 12 months prior to his intended return.
Deputy President Boyle P found that the applicant did not satisfy the requirements of Regulation 13. Furthermore, the Tribunal determined that there were insufficient reasons to exercise the discretion under Regulation 11. Consequently, the decision of the Associate Administrator of Vehicle Standards to refuse the application for importation was affirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Applicant’s submissions, lodged on 24 June 2019, responded to the Respondent’s submissions and are to the following effect:(a)The fact that the Vehicle does not have an identification plate does not mean that it is not safe or a pollution hazard. Australian standards are deficient and European standards are superior. The ANCAP safety rating for the Vehicle European model is as follows: 4 of 5 stars and an overall rating of 32.38 out of a possible score of 37. The Vehicle is therefore suitable to be imported.(b)Insofar as Government policy is to apply uniform safety standards, the Vehicle meets all of the safety standards so the “objectives of the legislation, and more, thus the expectations of the Australian community are being met and so is the intention of the legislation”.(c)Citing Senior Member Toohey’s statement that “there needs to be good reason for the discretion in reg 11 to be exercised” (see [18(o)(i)] above), the Applicant asks “…what more good reason can there be than the vehicle in question is as safe as secure [sic] and less polluting than Australian built vehicles and that the vehicle has a good ANCAP rating and that all the requirements of the legislation are being met and that the importation of the vehicle will in no way undermine or frustrate the policy and objectives of the Act?”(d)In relation to the Respondent’s argument relating to the policy of the legislation being that it applies to former residents returning after extended absence overseas or to new residents coming to Australia to reside permanently (see [18(g)-(l)] above), the Applicant says that:(i)His home in Perth has been leased for the last 4 years and when he returns to Perth he stays in a motor home or “house sit[s]” other people’s properties.(ii)When he is in the UK he lives in apartments often for months on end.(iii)Living a “transient lifestyle” in Perth does not constitute “residing in Australia”(iv)His time overseas in the accommodation circumstances that he describes constitute the Applicant an expatriate as that term is used in the Explanatory Statement (see [18(g)]); and(v)In relation to Regulations 13(1)(ac),(ad) and (a) the Applicant says that:·I have owned the vehicle while overseas.·I will have owned the vehicle for a continuous period of at least 12 months before arriving in Australia.·The vehicle was always available to me for my personal use.·I owned the vehicle at the time of application.·I am returning to live permanently in Australia at the end of 2019 because I do not intend continue [sic] to make lengthy trips overseas in the future.(e)The Department has not shown that the Vehicle fails to meet the Government strategy to make vehicles safe and environmentally friendly. The Applicant claims that the Vehicle fulfils that Government’s strategy.(f)The Applicant living in a house and an apartment and a Motor Launch in the UK and Europe for lengthy periods and conducting all activities of daily living therefrom, constitute him residing in the UK as much as similar circumstances constitute him residing in Australia.(g)The Regulations require that an expatriate returning from long periods overseas can be considered for bringing their vehicle with them and he qualifies in both aspects.CONSIDERATIONRegulation 13