Campbell v T. L. Clacher No. 2 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Campbell & Anor v T. L. Clacher No. 2 Pty Ltd & Ors [2019] QSC 218

PARTIES:

SUZANNE CAMPBELL AND WENDY HOOK

(Applicants)

v
T. L. CLACHER NO. 2 PTY LTD ACN 010 253 979 (AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CLACHER FAMILY TRUST)

(First Respondent)

AND

FLOWON 241 PTY LTD ACN 603 200 102 (AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BLUMKE FAMILY TRUST)
(Second Respondent)

AND

THOMAS LAIDLAW CLACHER
(third respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 11662 of 2016

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

4 September 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

6 and 7 March 2018, 3, 4, 5 and 6 December 2018.

JUDGE:

Jackson J

ORDER:

The judgment of the court is that:

1.   It is declared that the resolutions made by the first respondent as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust on 14 June 2014, 9 October 2014 and 12 December 2014 were made invalidly and in breach of trust;

2.   It is declared that the transfers of the properties, shares and cash identified in the Annexure to these reasons by the first respondent as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust to the second respondent as trustee of the Blumke Family Trust were made invalidly and in breach of trust;

3.   It is ordered that the first respondent be removed as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust;

4.   It is ordered that failing appointment by the Court of an individual as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust within 21 days of this order, the Public Trustee of Queensland be appointed as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust;

5.   It is ordered that the third respondent is restrained from exercising the powers of removal or appointment of a trustee under clause 22 of the Clacher Family Trust;

6.   It is ordered that the second respondent execute such documents and do all such things as the trustee of the Clacher Family Trust reasonably requires to enable the properties, shares and cash identified in the Annexure to these reasons that it holds as trustee of the Blumke Family Trust to be transferred to the trustee of the Clacher Family Trust within 7 days of being so requested;

7.   It is ordered that within 28 days of the appointment of the new trustee of the Clacher Family Trust the second respondent deliver up to such new trustee complete copies of the books and records of the second respondent in its capacity as trustee of the Blumke Family Trust and of the Blumke Family Trust since 16 December 2014;

8.   The proceeding is otherwise adjourned to a date to be fixed in relation to the grant of further or other relief and the determination of any questions of costs;

9.   Liberty to apply;

10.  It is directed that the applicants file and serve an outline of submissions as to costs, together with any supporting affidavits, on or before 9 September 2019;

11.  It is directed that the respondents file and serve an outline…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Campbell v T. L. Clacher No. 2 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 218
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Campbell v T. L. Clacher No. 2 Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the beneficiaries of the Clacher Family Trust and the trustee, T. L. Clacher No. 2 Pty Ltd, regarding the validity of certain resolutions and transfers made by the trustee. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The primary issue before the court was whether the trustee, T. L. Clacher No. 2 Pty Ltd, made certain resolutions and transactions in breach of trust. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the resolutions made by the trustee were attended by a genuine and proper consideration of the discretionary power, especially in light of any unconscionable conduct to which the trustee may have been subjected.

The court found that the trustee, who was also the sole director of the company, was subject to unconscionable conduct by certain beneficiaries. This conduct influenced the trustee's decisions to make distributions to another trust, which was managed by one of those beneficiaries. The court concluded that the resolutions made by the trustee were not attended by a real and proper consideration of the discretionary power due to the influence of the unconscionable conduct. Consequently, the resolutions and the resulting transfers were deemed invalid and in breach of trust.

In light of these findings, the court ordered the removal of the trustee from their position. It also directed the appointment of a new trustee within 21 days, or the Public Trustee of Queensland if no other appointment was made. Furthermore, the court mandated the return of the transferred assets to the Clacher Family Trust, required the production of relevant records, and outlined the process for determining costs. This decision underscores the importance of trustees acting in the genuine interests of the beneficiaries and the court's willingness to intervene where there is evidence of improper influence or lack of proper consideration in the exercise of discretionary powers.

Orders

Orders of the court

The judgment of the court is that:

1. It is declared that the resolutions made by the first respondent as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust on 14 June 2014, 9 October 2014 and 12 December 2014 were made invalidly and in breach of trust;

2. It is declared that the transfers of the properties, shares and cash identified in the Annexure to these reasons by the first respondent as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust to the second respondent as trustee of the Blumke Family Trust were made invalidly and in breach of trust;

3. It is ordered that the first respondent be removed as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust;

4. It is ordered that failing appointment by the Court of an individual as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust within 21 days of this order, the Public Trustee of Queensland be appointed as trustee of the Clacher Family Trust;

5. It is ordered that the third respondent is restrained from exercising the powers of removal or appointment of a trustee under clause 22 of the Clacher Family Trust;

6. It is ordered that the second respondent execute such documents and do all such things as the trustee of the Clacher Family Trust reasonably requires to enable the properties, shares and cash identified in the Annexure to these reasons that it holds as trustee of the Blumke Family Trust to be transferred to the trustee of the Clacher Family Trust within 7 days of being so requested;

7. It is ordered that within 28 days of the appointment of the new trustee of the Clacher Family Trust the second respondent deliver up to such new trustee complete copies of the books and records of the second respondent in its capacity as trustee of the Blumke Family Trust and of the Blumke Family Trust since 16 December 2014;

8. The proceeding is otherwise adjourned to a date to be fixed in relation to the grant of further or other relief and the determination of any questions of costs;

9. Liberty to apply;

10. It is directed that the applicants file and serve an outline of submissions as to costs, together with any supporting affidavits, on or before 9 September 2019;

11. It is directed that the respondents file and serve an outline of submissions as to costs, together with any supporting affidavits, on or before 16 September 2019;

12. The applicants file and serve any outline of submissions in reply, on or before 18 September 2019;

13. The applicants are to deliver a bundle of all submissions to his Honour Justice Jackson’s Associate by email by 5pm on 18 September 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is appropriate to begin by setting out some uncontentious facts. Uncontentious facts The third respondent was born in 1926. He married Pauline Male in 1950 and they remained married until her death in September 2012. The first named applicant (“Wendy”), the second named applicant (“Suzanne”) and Janine Blumke (“Janine”) are daughters of third respondent and Pauline. Each of the daughters is married and has children, who are the grandchildren of third respondent and Pauline. Wendy is married to Charles (“Mac”) Hook. Suzanne is married to Jon Campbell. Janine is married to Glenn Blumke. Wendy was born on 17 June 1957. Suzanne was born on 10 July 1961. Janine was born on 27 April 1966. Throughout her teenage years, Wendy resided with her parents and sisters at 17 Melville Court, Wynnum (“the Family home”). It was built by the third respondent and Pauline. The third respondent said to Wendy on numerous occasions that he loved every aspect of that home and that he wanted to live there until his passing. The third respondent worked as an optometrist carrying on his own practice. Pauline worked as the receptionist in the practice from its establishment until around 1956. After Wendy’s birth, Pauline remained at home, although she did some book keeping for the practice. Wendy worked as a receptionist in the practice from 1973 to 1983, and from 1991 to 1994. Mac Hook was employed as an optometrist in the practice from 1975 to 1994. In 1994, Wendy and Mac Hook purchased the optometry practice from the third respondent. After that, the third respondent worked for Wendy and Mac Hook, on a part time basis, until about 1996. Wendy spoke with the third respondent every day at work at the practice. He was 69 years old when he retired. He was a private person. He would generally spend his time gardening and assisting Pauline around the Family home. He did not become involved in hobbies after his retirement. In September 1979, Wendy married Mac Hook. When they purchased a house the third respondent assisted them including, for example, with the painting. The third respondent and Pauline were frequent visitors to Wendy and Mac’s house and vice versa. In about 1996, Wendy and Mac Hook moved into a new home at 3 Glenshiel Street, Wynnum West, located close to the Family home. Wendy and Mac Hook were able to visit the third respondent and Pauline on a more regular basis. Wendy, Mac Hook and their children joined the third respondent and Pauline for holidays at Maroochydore. In addition, they played social tennis with the third respondent and Pauline every Friday night. After tennis, they would gather at the Family home for dinner. Pauline organised Clacher family gatherings, which were held regularly at Easter and Christmas holidays. The gathering was usually at Wendy’s home or the Family home. As Pauline aged, Wendy, Suzanne and Janine would host Christmas celebrations on a rotational basis. Wendy attended every Easter and Christmas celebration hosted by Pauline, Suzanne or Janine after she moved out of home on being married. The Clacher family would also regularly celebrate family birthdays, Mothers’ Day and Fathers’ Day at either the Family home or Wendy and Mac’s home. Wendy cannot recall specifically missing any birthday, Mothers’ Day or Fathers’ Day celebrations, until after the events of September 2014.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Third, the reasons consider the role of independent advice to the disponor as follows:“As Manning J put it in Re Levey; Ex parte Official Assignee, ‘the Court does not allow any person to take advantage of any known weakness of the vendor’ and the Court asks whether that party had ‘the opportunity’ of professional advice as to ‘the effect of what he [was] doing’. This denial of the opportunity to have ‘the assistance of a disinterested legal adviser’, rather than speculation as to what might have followed had it been pursued, is an element in the unconscientious conduct in respect of which equity intervenes to deny the entitlement of the disponee to retain the property in question, unless the disponee shows the disposition to have been ‘fair, just and reasonable’.[32] (footnotes omitted)[32](1998) 194 CLR 457, 485-486 [100].No real and genuine consideration Because the first respondent was trustee of the Clacher Family Trust and held the assets on trust for the beneficiaries of that trust, it was not entitled to give away the assets of the trust to a non-beneficiary. By cl 2 of the trust deed, the trustee had discretionary power to pay or apply the income of the trust fund for the benefit of the beneficiaries then living or any one or more of them exclusive of the others, in such shares and proportions as the trustee should in its absolute discretion determine prior to 30 June of the year. As well, by cl 4, the trustee had power from time to time to pay or apply such part or parts of the capital of the trust fund as the trustee, in its absolute discretion, deemed fit to or for the benefit of the beneficiaries or such one or more of them, exclusive of the others and in such shares or proportions as the trustee in its discretion determined. By the definition of the “beneficiaries” in cl 1 of the trust deed, a trustee of any other trust, the capital or income of which was or may be held in whole or in part for any one or more of persons referred to in the preceding paragraphs of the definition was a beneficiary, as defined. Paragraph (a) of the preceding paragraphs specified the third respondent was a beneficiary. Accordingly, because the third respondent was a secondary beneficiary of the Blumke Family Trust, on settlement of the Blumke Family Trust the second respondent as trustee became a beneficiary of the Clacher Family Trust, as defined. Therefore, the first respondent had the constitutional power to make distributions of income or capital of the Clacher Family Trust to the second respondent, in accordance with cl 2 and 4 of the trust deed. However, in my view, the exercises of power by the third respondent as sole director of the first respondent to make those transfers, were not attended by a real and proper consideration of the discretionary power to make the relevant distributions, because the third respondent as sole director of the first respondent was subject to unconscionable conduct by Janine and Glenn Blumke.