Cabal v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Cabal v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (No 4) [2000] FCA 1806

IMMIGRATION – refugees – protection visas – Refugee Review Tribunal – procedures – joinder of spouse to application in Tribunal – notification of hearing and opportunity to give oral evidence – notification to children of primary applicant – whether independent notification required – all applicants legally represented at all times – constitution of Tribunal – appointment of member to hear review – direction in writing – whether required of Principal Member or delegate when constituting himself or herself as Tribunal – failure to consider material issues – sufficiency of statement of reasons – approach to determining whether well-founded fear of persecution – whether error of law

Extradition Act 1998  (Cth) s 12
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)s 457, s 460 s 470 s 412 s 421 s 422 s 424 s 425 s 430
Migration Regulations1994 reg 2.08A

Chan Yee Kin v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379 referred to
Peniche v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 709 referred to
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Singh (2000) 98 FCR 469 cited

TERESA PASINI CABAL, CARLOS CABAL PASINI, SOFIA CABAL PASINI, ANAMARIA CABAL PASINI, TERESA CABAL PASINI and CARLOS CABAL PENICHE v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
V339 OF 1999
MARCO PASINI BERTRAN and MONSERRAT GONZALEZ KARRAS v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
V340 of 1999

FRENCH J
11 DECEMBER 2000
PERTH (Heard in Melbourne)

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V339 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

TERESA PASINI CABAL
FIRST APPLICANT

CARLOS CABAL PASINI
SECOND APPLICANT

SOFIA CABAL PASINI
THIRD APPLICANT

ANAMARIA CABAL PASINI
FOURTH APPLICANT

TERESA CABAL PASINI
FIFTH APPLICANT

CARLOS CABAL PENICHE
SIXTH APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH

DATE OF ORDER:

11 DECEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

PERTH (Heard in Melbourne)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application is dismissed.

2.        The First and Sixth Applicants are to pay the Respondent’s costs of the application.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

V340 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

MARCO PASINI BERTRAN
FIRST APPLICANT

MONSERRAT GONZALEZ KARRAS
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH

DATE OF ORDER:

11 DECEMBER 2000

WHERE MADE:

PERTH (Heard in Melbourne)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The application is dismissed.

2.        The Applicants are to pay the Respondent’s costs of the application.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V339 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

TERESA PASINI CABAL
FIRST APPLICANT

CARLOS CABAL PASINI
SECOND APPLICANT

SOFIA CABAL PASINI
THIRD APPLICANT

ANAMARIA CABAL PASINI
FOURTH APPLICANT

TERESA CABAL PASINI
FIFTH APPLICANT

CARLOS CABAL PENICHE
SIXTH APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
RESPONDENT

V340 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

MARCO PASINI BERTRAN
FIRST APPLICANT

MONSERRAT GONZALEZ KARRAS
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cabal v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1806
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cabal v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (No 4), the applicants, Mrs Cabal and her family, along with Mr Pasini and his wife, have applied for protection visas in Australia, claiming they are refugees under the Refugees Convention. Their applications were rejected by the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, and this decision was affirmed by the Refugee Review Tribunal. The applicants are now seeking review of the Tribunal's decisions in the Federal Court. The court was tasked with determining whether the Tribunal's decisions to deny the applicants protection visas were legally sound.

The central legal issues involved whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to hear the matter, whether it had properly considered the applicants' claims, and whether the Tribunal's decisions were reasonable and in accordance with the applicable laws. Specifically, the applicants argued that the Tribunal had failed to consider certain evidence and had not properly constituted itself according to the statutory requirements.

The court found that the Tribunal had the necessary authority to hear the case and that it had considered the relevant evidence. It held that the language of the relevant statute did not require a written direction from the Principal Member of the Tribunal for the Tribunal to be properly constituted. The court also found that the Tribunal had not erred in its consideration of the evidence, and that the refusal of protection visas was reasonable given the circumstances. Consequently, the court dismissed the applicants' applications and ordered them to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The First and Sixth Applicants are to pay the Respondent’s costs of the application.

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The Applicants are to pay the Respondent’s costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Cabal’s wife and children and Mr Pasini and his wife have applied in this country for protection visas. They claim that Australia owes them protection obligations under the Refugees Convention. They have been refused visas by the Minister’s delegate and the delegate’s decision has been affirmed by the Refugee Review Tribunal. They now seek an order of review in this Court against the decisions of the Refugee Review Tribunal.Factual Background Teresa Cabal Pasini (Mrs Cabal) and her husband, Carlos Cabal Peniche, their four children, Carlos, Sofia, Anamaria and Teresa, Mrs Cabal’s brother, Marco Pasini Bertran (Pasini) and his wife, Monserrat Gonzalez Karras, are all Mexican citizens. The Cabal family arrived in Australia on 1 October 1996 using false names under passports purportedly issued by the Dominican Republic. Mr Pasini and his wife arrived in Australia in April 1997, also using false names and passports apparently issued by the Dominican Republic. In November 1998 Mr Cabal and Mr Pasini were arrested on provisional warrants pursuant to s 12 of the Extradition Act 1998 (Cth). The arrests were made pursuant to requests from the United States of Mexico which seeks to extradite the two men on charges of offences against Mexican banking, tax and money laundering laws. These requests led to the issue of notices by the Attorney-General under s 16 of the Extradition Act followed by a hearing before a magistrate to determine the eligibility of Cabal and Pasini for surrender under s 19 of the Act. That hearing took sixty nine days. The Magistrate’s decision was given on 17 December 1999 determining both men to be eligible for surrender to Mexico. Cabal and Pasini applied to the Federal Court for review of the decision under s 21 of the Act. However the magistrate’s decision was confirmed on 29 August 2000. An appeal against that decision has been heard by the Full Court in the last sittings in Melbourne and judgment is presently reserved. On 13 November 1998 Mrs Cabal applied for a protection visa under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) on behalf of herself and her children. Mr Pasini did the same for himself and his wife. The protection visas were sought on the basis that all were refugees within the meaning of the Refugees Convention and that by reason of that Convention, Australia was under protection obligations towards them. On 8 December 1998 a delegate of the minister refused the grant of protection visas to both the Cabal and Pasini applicants. On 14 December 1998 the Cabals and Pasinis lodged applications for review of the delegate’s decisions with the Refugee Review Tribunal. On 31 May 1999 the Tribunal, constituted by Kerry Boland, affirmed the decisions not to grant protection visas. Separate reasons were published in respect of the Cabals and the Pasinis. Applications for orders of review of these decisions of the Tribunal were filed in this Court on 23 June 1999. One application was filed for the Cabals (339/1999) and a separate application for the Pasinis (340/1999). The applications did not come on for hearing until 4 September 2000.History of Proceedings before the Tribunal

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This ground fails for the same reasons as ground 1(v). The children concerned were aged 7, 9, 13 and 14 at the time of the Tribunal hearing. Cabal Ground 1(vii) – Failure to have regard to the Applicants desire to obtain oral evidence from Mr Cabal Snr There was no identifiable part of the written submissions relating to this ground. The solicitor’s letter of 12 January 1999 expressed a desire that evidence be taken from Mr Cabal Snr among others. In the event the Tribunal received a 182 page statement from him. It was plain from the restrictive tenor of Mrs Cabal’s answers to Tribunal’s questions in evidence that there was no prospect of her husband subjecting himself to questioning in oral examination. There is, in any event, no evidence for the contention that the Tribunal failed to have regard to the applicant’s request in their solicitor’s letter. Cabal Ground 1(viii) – Failure to comply with section 426(3) Under this ground it is said that the Tribunal failed to comply with s 426(3) by refusing unreasonably or without good cause to obtain oral evidence from Carlos Cabal Peniche. For the reasons expressed in respect of ground 1(vii) this ground also fails. Cabal Ground 2 – Want of jurisdiction Under this ground it is said that the Tribunal was not properly constituted for the purpose of the review because no direction had been given as required by subs 421(2) by the Principal Member. Counsel for the Minister however, tendered to the Court an Instrument of Delegation (Exhibit 3) under which the Principal Member of the Refugee Review Tribunal delegated to Ms Boland various of his powers under the Act including the power to “…constitute cases to Melbourne Members”. The applicants relied upon the fact that the only document produced by the Tribunal evidencing Ms Boland’s appointment as the member to conduct the review was a document entitled “RRT Case Load Report” which listed the Cabal and Pasini applications under Ms Boland’s name. This document was signed by Ms Boland. I am prepared to assume that it may not itself have constituted a written direction of the kind contemplated in s 421, but was rather in the nature of a case management report. Nevertheless it plainly evidenced her appointment as the Tribunal member for the purpose of conducting the Cabal and Pasini reviews. Having regard to that material, I am not prepared to infer that the Tribunal was not properly constituted for the purpose of undertaking these reviews. In this case Ms Boland had the power of the Principal Member to constitute the Tribunal for particular cases. In my opinion s 421 should not be construed as requiring the Principal Member or the delegate to give a written direction to himself or herself as the case may be, as a condition of that member constituting the Tribunal. There is no sensible policy reason to support such a construction. The language of s 421(2) is facultative. On the face of it and according to its construction in accordance with the ordinary meaning of its words, it does not require the Principal Member to give a written direction in every case. In this respect the language of s 421(2) stands in contrast with the mandatory language of s 422(1) where, if the constituted member stops being a member or is otherwise unavailable the Principal Member “must direct” another member to constitute the Tribunal for the purpose of finishing the review. The difficulty with s 421 however is that s 421(1) appears to define the constitution of the Tribunal for the purpose of a particular review as its constitution “in accordance with a direction under subs (2)”. In my opinion, however, what s 421 makes clear is that the Tribunal is to be constituted by a single member in each case and that single member is to be designated by the Principal Member. There is a procedural requirement for a written direction but if the Principal Member were to give a direction other than in writing it would not, in my opinion, invalidate the authority of the Tribunal to proceed with the review. A fortori where it is the Principal Member who constitutes himself or herself as the member, the absence of a written direction will not deprive him or her of authority to proceed with the review. The same of course applies to a delegate exercising the powers of the Principal Member to constitute the Tribunal. In my opinion, there is no merit in this ground of review. Cabal Ground 3(i), (ii) and (iii) – Want of authorisation for decisions

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
Injunctive relief was sought by the applicants in the Federal Court on 25 May to prevent the Tribunal from proceeding but the application was dismissed by Weinberg J on 27 May 1999. On 28 May 1999 the applicants’ advisers provided further documents and video tapes and submitted by letter of that date a further complaint about what they called the “undue haste of the Tribunal” and asked for additional time to arrange for translation of documents previously submitted to the Tribunal. The Tribunal’s written reasons in each case were published on 31 May 1999. The Tribunal’s Reasons for Decision In its published reasons for decision in the Cabals’ case the Tribunal described their claims as set out in written submissions and oral evidence given on 22 and 23 February 1999. It also referred to post-hearing submissions comprising statements provided by Mrs Cabal, her husband and brothers, Marco Pasini Bertran and Pedro Pasini Bertran, Marco’s wife Monserrat Gonzalez Karras, Petrona Lopez who had been employed as a nanny with the Cabal family, their Mexican legal adviser, Mr Zinser, and a former business associate, Scott Perry. An affidavit of 24 February 1999 from George Defteros advised that he was counsel acting on behalf of Cabal and Pasini in relation to the extradition matters. His affidavit set out evidence which it was anticipated would be led at the extradition proceedings through an affidavit of a Mexican official, Rodolfo de la Guardia Garcia. The text of la Guardia’s affidavit was reproduced in full in the Tribunal’s reasons. It referred to the issue of warrants of arrests against Cabal, his history of flight, proceedings known as amparo proceedings taken in Mexico to effect stays of the warrants and the outcomes of those proceedings. The Tribunal also referred to a report by a consultant forensic psychiatrist outlining the personal and background history of Mrs Cabal and her four children. The substance of the claim made by Mrs Cabal was that she feared that if returned to Mexico, she and her family would be subject to harassment by authorities in various ways, including the possible placement of her children in custodial institutions. She refused at the hearing to answer a number of questions on the grounds of legal advice, apparently on the basis that to do so would somehow prejudice the position of her husband and Pasini in the extradition proceedings. One of the questions she refused to answer was why she believed her husband was a refugee. The Tribunal referred to the post-hearing statements which were received from Mrs Cabal and her husband and from Pasini and his brother, Pedro. Other statements referred to were from Pasini’s wife, the Cabal children’s nanny, Zinser, and Defteros. The affidavit of la Guardia, exhibited to that of Defteros, set out in some detail the history of the warrants for the arrest of Mr Cabal Snr, his flight from Mexico and other matters including “amparo” applications for stays of the warrants in Mexico. The Tribunal referred to a report by a consultant forensic psychiatrist, Dr David Sime, relating to the mental state of Mrs Cabal and her children. The above statements included some received as late as 21 May 1999.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

The court began by addressing the argument that the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) failed to consider relevant submissions and evidence. The court found that the RRT did consider the submissions and evidence provided, including statements from various individuals and an affidavit from a Mexican official. The court rejected the argument that the RRT failed to have regard to the applicants' desire for oral evidence from Mr. Cabal Snr, noting that the RRT received a 182-page statement from him and that there was no prospect of him being questioned orally due to Mrs. Cabal’s refusal to answer questions. Therefore, the court held that the RRT did not fail to consider relevant submissions and evidence.

Next, the court considered the argument that the RRT failed to comply with section 426(3) of the Act by unreasonably refusing to obtain oral evidence from Carlos Cabal Peniche. The court found that this ground also failed, as the reasons given for the previous finding applied equally to this argument. The court noted that the RRT had considered all relevant submissions and evidence, and thus there was no unreasonable refusal to obtain oral evidence.

The court then addressed the argument that the RRT was not properly constituted for the purpose of the review. The applicants argued that the RRT was not properly constituted because no written direction had been given by the Principal Member as required by section 421(2) of the Act. The court examined the Instrument of Delegation which showed that the Principal Member had delegated powers to Ms. Boland, including the power to constitute cases. The court concluded that the RRT was properly constituted for the purpose of the review, as the Instrument of Delegation provided sufficient authority for Ms. Boland to constitute the Tribunal.

Concerning the argument that the RRT lacked the necessary authorisation to make the decisions, the court found that the RRT had the required authorisation. The applicants argued that the RRT did not have the necessary authorisation because no written direction had been given, but the court found this argument unconvincing, as the delegation of powers provided the necessary authorisation for Ms. Boland to constitute the Tribunal.

Finally, the court examined the argument that the RRT acted with undue haste in reaching its decision. The applicants claimed that the RRT did not allow sufficient time for translation of documents and other preparations. The court noted that the RRT had considered all relevant submissions and evidence, including those received as late as 21 May 1999. The court concluded that the RRT did not act with undue haste and that there was no basis to interfere with the RRT's decision.

In summary, the court held that the RRT did not fail to consider relevant submissions and evidence, did not unreasonably refuse to obtain oral evidence, was properly constituted, had the necessary authorisation, and did not act with undue haste. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that the RRT's process and authority to conduct reviews and make decisions are robust, provided there is evidence of proper delegation and consideration of all relevant submissions and evidence.