Button v Director of Mental Health

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Button v Director of Mental Health & Anor [2005] QCA 67

PARTIES:

JOSEPH GARRETT BUTTON
(plaintiff/appellant)
v
DIRECTOR OF MENTAL HEALTH
(first defendant/first respondent)
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
(second defendant/second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 9202 of 2004
SC No 0018 of 2003

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Appeal from the Mental Health Court

ORIGINATING COURT:

Mental Health Court

DELIVERED ON:

18 March 2005

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

9 March 2005

JUDGES:

Williams JA, White and Douglas JJ
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the order made

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – NATURE OF RIGHT – APPEALS IN THE STRICT SENSE AND APPEALS BY WAY OF REHEARING – APPEALS BY WAY OF REHEARING – where appellant charged with two counts of rape and 2 counts of murder – where the Mental Health Court found that at the time of the alleged offences the appellant was not suffering from unsoundness of mind nor diminished responsibility – whether the Court erred in placing undue emphasis on the lack of self-reporting – whether the Court erred in placing undue emphasis on the lack of independent evidence of the appellant’s actions in the actual commission of the crime – whether the decision of the Court was against the weight of evidence and unreasonable having regard to the weight of evidence

Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld) s 27 and s 304A
Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) r 745 and r 765

Attorney General of Queensland v Kamali (1999) 106 A Crim R 269, applied
Builders Licensing Board v Sperway Constructions (Syd) Pty Ltd (1976) 136 CLR 616, considered
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118, considered
Logan v Woongarra Shire Council [1983] 2 Qd R 689, cited
Victorian Stevedoring and General Contracting Co Pty v Meakes (Dignan informant) (1931) 46 CLR 73, cited

COUNSEL:

P Richards for the appellant
No appearance for the first respondent
L J Clare for the second respondent

SOLICITORS:

Queensland Aboriginal and Islander Legal Service Secretariat for the appellant
No appearance for the first respondent
Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) for the second respondent

  1. WILLIAMS JA:  After a hearing which extended over six days the Mental Health Court on 23 September 2004 found that the appellant, Joseph Garrett Button, was not of unsound mind within the meaning of the Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld) (“the Act”), that as at 15 October 2001 when the offences with which he was charged were committed he was not deprived of any of the capacities referred to in s 27 of the Criminal Code Act 1899 (Qld) (“the Code”), and he was not then suffering from diminished responsibility as provided for in s 304A of the Code. From that decision he has appealed to this Court, seeking an order that he was “at the time of the commission of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Button v Director of Mental Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QCA 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Button v Director of Mental Health involved the appellant, who had been charged with two counts of rape and two counts of murder. The Mental Health Court found that at the time of the alleged offences, the appellant was not suffering from unsoundness of mind nor diminished responsibility. The appellant contested the decision, arguing that the court had erred in placing undue emphasis on the lack of self-reporting and the lack of independent evidence of the appellant's actions during the commission of the crime. The appellant also argued that the decision was against the weight of evidence and unreasonable.

The court considered whether the Mental Health Court erred in its assessment of the appellant's mental state at the time of the offences. Specifically, the court examined whether the emphasis on the absence of self-reporting and independent evidence was misplaced. The court also assessed whether the decision was unreasonable given the weight of the evidence presented. In evaluating these issues, the court applied principles of appeal and new trial, focusing on whether the appeal was in the strict sense or by way of rehearing.

The court found that the Mental Health Court had correctly applied the law and the evidence. The court concluded that the emphasis on the lack of self-reporting and independent evidence was not misplaced, and the decision was not against the weight of evidence. The court held that the appellant's arguments did not establish that the decision was unreasonable. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the original decision of the Mental Health Court was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant, Button, was charged with two counts of rape and two counts of murder. Button was evaluated by the Mental Health Court to determine his mental state at the time of the alleged offences. The Court found that Button was not suffering from unsoundness of mind nor diminished responsibility at the time of the alleged offences. The appellant argued that the Mental Health Court erred in its findings. He claimed that the Court placed undue emphasis on the lack of self-reporting of his actions and the absence of independent evidence regarding his involvement in the commission of the crimes. The appellant submitted that the Court's decision was against the weight of evidence and unreasonable.

This case came before the court on appeal from a decision of the Mental Health Court. The appellant was initially found not guilty by reason of unsoundness of mind but was subsequently found not guilty by reason of unsoundness of mind nor diminished responsibility. The appellant appealed the decision of the Mental Health Court, arguing that the Court erred in its findings and that the decision was against the weight of evidence and unreasonable. The appeal was heard and determined by the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Mental Health Court erred in placing undue emphasis on the lack of self-reporting by the appellant.
2. Whether the Mental Health Court erred in placing undue emphasis on the lack of independent evidence of the appellant's actions in the actual commission of the crime.
3. Whether the decision of the Mental Health Court was against the weight of evidence and unreasonable having regard to the weight of evidence.

Held
1. The court held that the Mental Health Court did not err in placing undue emphasis on the lack of self-reporting by the appellant.
2. The court held that the Mental Health Court did not err in placing undue emphasis on the lack of independent evidence of the appellant's actions in the actual commission of the crime.
3. The court held that the decision of the Mental Health Court was not against the weight of evidence and was not unreasonable having regard to the weight of evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the grounds for appeal, specifically whether the Mental Health Court erred in placing undue emphasis on the lack of self-reporting by the appellant and the lack of independent evidence. The court noted that the appellant did not self-report and there was no independent evidence of the acts he was alleged to have committed. The court found that these factors were properly considered by the Mental Health Court in assessing the appellant's mental state at the time of the alleged offences.

In relation to the third issue, the court examined whether the Mental Health Court's decision was against the weight of evidence and unreasonable. The court found that the evidence before the Mental Health Court was sufficient to support its findings. The court held that the decision of the Mental Health Court was not unreasonable and was not against the weight of evidence.

The court applied the principle that an appellate court should not interfere with the findings of fact made by the trial court unless those findings are plainly wrong or not supported by the evidence. The court found that the Mental Health Court's findings were supported by the evidence and that there was no basis to interfere with those findings. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an appellate court should not lightly interfere with the findings of fact made by the trial court where those findings are supported by the evidence.