[2011] QCA 302
COURT OF APPEAL
WHITE JA
Appeal No 9360 of 2011
MHC No 90 of 2010
VINCENT VICTOR BERG Applicant
and
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS Respondent
BRISBANE
DATE 26/10/2011
ORDER
WHITE JA: Mr Berg has applied for a stay of the orders made by the Mental Health Court on 27 September 2011 that he was fit to stand trial and allied orders.[1]
[1] Re Berg [2011] QMHC.
Mr Berg has been charged with 37 offences including one count of indecent treatment of a child under 16 pursuant to s 210(1)(a) of the Criminal Code which allegedly occurred between September and October 2000. He is also charged with one count of procuring a sexual act by false pretence, three counts of grievous bodily harm, two counts of assault occasioning bodily harm, one count of obtaining financial advantage by deception and 28 counts relating to offences of fraud, attempted fraud and uttering forged documents. Those offences are alleged to have occurred between June 1999 and June 2004.
The charges arise out of the allegation that Mr Berg has falsely claimed to be a Russian trained psychiatrist. They came to light as a result of investigations carried out during the Queensland Public Hospitals Commission of Inquiry in 2003. Those investigations suggested that Mr Berg's degrees had not been awarded from the institutions he claimed to have attended in Russia. He is alleged to have forged documents and deceptively claimed payment.
The charges of causing bodily harm arose from the period when Mr Berg was employed at the Townsville Hospital as a non-training psychiatry registrar. He was alleged to have treated patients with a mental illness and changed their medication causing them to suffer adverse events. The sexual offences are alleged to have occurred while he was purporting to treat patients at the hospital including a 15 year old boy. Mr Berg denies the offences.
A committal hearing was set for 11 July 2006 but was adjourned to the end of July. Mr Berg consulted psychiatrists. His then solicitor filed a reference in the Mental Health Court in November 2006 in respect of the offence of the indecent treatment of a child under the age of 16. Reports were prepared by psychiatrists during 2007. The hearing date was adjourned from time to time. That reference was struck out in June 2008. Mr Berg appealed interlocutory orders to this Court without success and unsuccessfully sought Special Leave from the High Court. On 14 May 2009 Mr Berg was charged with the balance of the offences. On 13 April 2010 Mr Berg self-referred to the Mental Health Court the 37 charges.
The reference was finally heard on 4 May 2011. As related in the reasons for judgment[2] the matter was adjourned to 31 August 2011 to allow Mr Berg's son (who had appeared on his behalf) sufficient time to consider the written submissions from the Director of Public Prosecutions dated 13 May 2011 and to formulate submissions in response on behalf of Mr Berg…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Berg v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QCA 302
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Order: Application for stay refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter originated in the Mental Health Court, where Mr Berg was assessed for his fitness to stand trial. The court concluded that Mr Berg was fit for trial, and this decision was subject to an appeal by Mr Berg. The appeal was lodged on 14 October 2011. Prior to this, Mr Berg had made several references to the Mental Health Court starting from November 2006, with various adjournments and submissions. The committal proceedings on the indecent treatment charge were scheduled for 28 October 2011. Mr Berg, citing his mental health conditions, sought a stay of the Mental Health Court's orders and applied to present his case solely in writing. His application for a stay was opposed by the Director of Public Prosecutions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court of Appeal has the inherent jurisdiction to order a stay of an order made by the Mental Health Court.
2. Whether the appeal to the Court of Appeal operates as a stay of the criminal proceedings, including the committal, pursuant to s 259 of the Mental Health Act.
3. Whether Mr Berg's mental health conditions justify a stay of the committal proceedings pending the appeal.
Held
1. The Court of Appeal does not have the inherent jurisdiction to order a stay of an order made by the Mental Health Court.
2. The appeal to the Court of Appeal does not operate as a stay of the criminal proceedings, including the committal, pursuant to s 259 of the Mental Health Act.
3. Mr Berg's mental health conditions do not justify a stay of the committal proceedings pending the appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal addressed the application for a stay of the Mental Health Court's orders, which concluded that Mr Berg was fit to stand trial. The Court first considered the inherent jurisdiction argument advanced by Mr Berg, who contended that the appeal to the Court of Appeal should operate as a stay under s 259 of the Mental Health Act. The Court noted that s 259 only applies to proceedings pending a decision by the Mental Health Court itself and does not extend to appeals to the Court of Appeal. The Court applied the relevant provisions of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, which do not automatically stay enforcement of a decision pending appeal. The Court found that Mr Berg had not demonstrated that the appeal was likely to succeed, nor had he shown that the appeal may prove abortive if not granted a stay. The Court also considered Mr Berg's mental health conditions and concluded that he could comply with the minimum standards for a fair trial as outlined in Kesavarajah v The Queen. The Court noted that Mr Berg was represented by his son, who had an enduring power of attorney, and that he had legal representation for the committal proceedings. The Court ultimately refused the application for a stay, emphasizing the importance of the administration of justice and the public interest in the expeditious resolution of the matter.
The Court of Appeal's decision was grounded in its analysis of the statutory framework provided by the Mental Health Act and the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, as well as the legal principles concerning the inherent jurisdiction of the court and the requirements for granting a stay. The ratio decidendi is that an appeal to the Court of Appeal does not operate as a stay of criminal proceedings under s 259 of the Mental Health Act, and a stay is not warranted unless the applicant demonstrates a sufficient basis to outweigh the considerations that judgments should not be treated as provisional and that courts should not be disposed to delay the enforcement of court orders. The Court also reaffirmed the importance of ensuring a fair trial by considering the accused's mental health conditions and their ability to comply with the minimum standards for a fair trial.