Budarick and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Budarick and Comcare (Compensation) [2019] AATA 116 (8 February 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/5818

Re:Steven Budarick

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:                  Member Mark Hyman

Date:8 February 2019

Place:Canberra

The application for dismissal is denied.

........................................................................

Member Mark Hyman

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – compensation - application to dismiss – where review application is alleged to be misconceived or to have no reasonable prospects of success – relevant principles – medical evidence – existence of two case theories, each of which has evidentiary support – applicant’s case is not fanciful – application to dismiss denied

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 37, 42A, 42B
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, s 31A
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 16, 19, 20, 21, 21A, 22, 71

Social Security Act 1994, s 94

Cases

Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners (1949) 78 CLR 62
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways(NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125
Jefferson Ford Pty Ltd v Ford Motor Company of Australia Ltd [2008] FCAFC 60
Oliver and Comcare [2018] AATA 1964

Spencer v Commonwealth of Australia [2010] HCA 28

Secondary Materials

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member Mark Hyman

8 February 2019

  1. This decision is about whether the application for review made by the applicant, Mr Steven Budarick, should be dismissed. Mr Budarick made a claim for workers’ compensation on 29 October 1997 in respect of a back condition which he said was brought about by events occurring on 1 October 1997. Comcare denied liability for “acute thoracic back strain” under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) and affirmed that decision in a reconsideration determination dated 22 June 1998. Mr Budarick applied to this tribunal for review of that determination; in a decision dated 8 August 2000 the tribunal set aside the reviewable decision and substituted a decision that Comcare was liable to pay compensation in respect of a chronic pain disorder.

  2. Comcare decided in 2004 that it was not presently liable for medical treatment of Mr Budarick under section 16 of the SRC Act and affirmed that decision in a reconsideration determination dated 26 April 2005. Mr Budarick again applied for review, and by a consent decision dated 24 November 2005 Comcare accepted liability for incapacity and medical treatment (under sections 19 and 16 of the SRC Act) in respect of a chronic pain disorder occasioned by events occurring on 1 October 1997.

  3. Comcare by a determination dated 4 August 2017 decided that it had no present liability under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act, and affirmed that decision in a reconsideration determination dated 16 August 2017. Mr Budarick has applied to the tribunal for review of that decision; Comcare now proposes that the application should be dismissed, which would bring Mr Budarick’s review to an end before it was heard.

  4. The tribunal held a dismissal hearing on 1 February 2019. Mr Budarick appeared in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Budarick and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Comcare to dismiss Mr Budarick's review application, either on the grounds that it was misconceived or had no reasonable prospects of success, pursuant to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). The dispute arose from a long and complex medical history related to an injury sustained in 1997, with Comcare having accepted liability for a "chronic pain disorder" which was later recharacterised by medical professionals and Comcare itself through various diagnostic terms. Despite ongoing treatment, Comcare had determined in 2017 that it had no present liability for section 16 medical expenses and section 19 incapacity payments.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Comcare's application to dismiss Mr Budarick's review application should be granted. This required the Tribunal to consider Comcare's submissions that it had no liability for any injury occurring in 1991, that recent medical opinions attributed Mr Budarick's current complaints to events in 1991 rather than the accepted 1997 injury, and that even if the 1997 injury arose from earlier events, it was not significantly contributed to by the workplace, any current incapacity did not derive from the injury, and further medical treatment was either unnecessary or unreasonable.

The Tribunal reasoned that while Comcare was correct in asserting that any claims relating to the 1991 injury were finalised and outside the scope of the current review, this did not automatically warrant dismissal of the present application. The Tribunal observed that the medical evidence presented two distinct case theories. One theory, supported by several specialists, suggested that Mr Budarick had no physical ailment, that past injuries were short-lived, and that his current pain was psychological and not employment-related. The existence of these competing case theories, each with evidentiary support, meant that Mr Budarick's case was not fanciful, and therefore, the application to dismiss was denied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Comcare has put forward as grounds for dismissal either that the application has no reasonable prospect of success (paragraph 42B(1)(b) of the AAT Act) or that it is misconceived (paragraph 42B(1)(a)).BACKGROUND There is a long and complex medical history relating to the 1997 injury. The initial claim was for an “acute thoracic back strain” (or possibly “sprain” - T11, folio 16), but the tribunal decision assigning liability to Comcare was in respect of a “chronic pain disorder” (T40, folio 140). Despite that change in diagnosis, Comcare continued to refer to the accepted condition as “thoracic sprain” (see for example T52, T60, T92, T104). Eventually the doctor with whom Mr Budarick appears to have the closest connection, Dr Robert Reid, a sport and exercise medicine specialist, suggested to Comcare that the accepted condition be recharacterised as “chronic lumbar and spinal pain syndrome” (T190). Comcare acknowledged the sense of this but wished to find terms that aligned with their diagnostic code (T197) and settled on “pain in the thoracic spine” and, as a secondary condition, “myalgia and myositis, unspecified” (T198, T199). Mr Budarick made a number of other claims, for example for a special bed, and for a long-armed tool for collecting rubbish from the ground; these were denied (T114, T116, T119, T129, T136, T137, T138). Mr Budarick continued to receive various forms of treatment, including massage, acupuncture and medication. Comcare continued to pay for medical treatment up to the determination of 4 August 2017 that Comcare had no present liability for section 16 medical expenses and section 19 incapacity payments (T263). Over the two decades between the injury and the reviewable decision of 2017 a significant number of medical reports were obtained from specialists in different sub-disciplines.APPLICABLE LAW The legislation governing this matter is the SRC Act, which provides for compensation to be paid in respect of injuries occasioned by employment, and the AAT Act, which governs the operations of the tribunal and the exercise of its powers. Section 5A of the SRC Act defines an injury for the purposes of the Act. An injury is either a disease or an injury other than a disease, or an aggravation of such an injury, arising out of or in the course of employment. Section 5B, which applies to diseases, then reads (so far as is relevant for present purposes) as follows:(1) In this Act:disease means: (a) an ailment suffered by an employee; or (b) an aggravation of such an ailment;that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee’s employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee.…(3) In this Act:significant degree means a degree that is substantially more than material. Section 4 defines “ailment” to mean “any physical or mental ailment, disorder, defect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development)”. Section 14 of the SRC Act is the gateway provision for compensation. It provides that liability to pay compensation arises in respect of an injury suffered by an employee if it results in death, incapacity for work or impairment (subject to exclusions not presently relevant). Section 16 of the SRC Act provides for compensation to be paid for medical treatment. and incapacity. Subsection 16(1) provides as follows:Where an employee suffers an injury, Comcare is liable to pay, in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury (being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances), compensation of such amount as Comcare determines is appropriate to that medical treatment.The word “injury” in sections 14 and 16 is used to mean an injury for which the necessary connection with employment has been demonstrated under sections 5A and 5B; that is, “injury” means an injury of the kind that makes it compensable under the SRC Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The essence of Comcare’s submissions is that:(a)Comcare has no liability for any injury occurring in 1991, any liability having come to an end in 1994, and the tribunal has no jurisdiction in respect of any injury other than the accepted injury, which dates from 1997;(b)Mr Budarick’s treating doctors, in recent medical certificates and other documentation, attribute his injury to events in 1991;(c)such opinions cannot be a basis for Comcare’s continuing liability for incapacity and medical expenses arising from the 1997 injury;(d)even if the 1997 injury is understood as arising from the 1991 events the application must fail because:(i)the evidence is that it was not significantly contributed to by the workplace or alternatively that any workplace contribution has now been overtaken by other factors;(ii)in any case any current incapacity does not derive from the injury; and(iii)Mr Budarick does not need medical treatment, or alternatively is untreatable, or alternatively it is not reasonable for him to obtain the treatment.CONSIDERATION Comcare is correct in asserting that the injury that Mr Budarick sustained in 1991 is not before me, in the sense that any claims against that injury have already been resolved and finalised, and cannot be agitated in the present matter, which relates to an acceptance of liability dating from 1997. The facts of that earlier claim are apparent from papers that Comcare provided in the tender bundle at the dismissal hearing (Exhibit R1). As noted above, Mr Budarick made a claim in 1991; Comcare accepted liability but on 16 July 1993 determined that liability had ceased. That decision was affirmed in a reconsideration determination dated 28 October 1993. Mr Budarick sought review by this tribunal, which affirmed the reconsideration determination on 14 February 1994. (That history is apparent from the tribunal’s decision, Budarick and Comcare [1994] AATA 85.) Subsequently, in 1995, Comcare made an own motion reconsideration of the determination of 16 July 1993, as documented in a record tendered by Comcare at the hearing (Exhibit R2), prompted by further claims made by Mr Budarick for injuries that he said he sustained on 2 and 25 August 1994. The delegate affirmed the 1993 decision. These events establish clearly that Comcare has no current liability in respect of the 1991 injury and no claim in relation to that injury is within the scope of the current review. In the extensive papers prepared for the substantive hearing of the matter it is abundantly evident that there are two case theories implicit in the medical reports. The case theory that is apparent, explicitly or implicitly, in the reports of Mr F Keiller, a surgeon, (T33), Dr W Glaser, a psychiatrist (T35, T39), Dr P Stevenson, a consultant physician (T140), Dr N McGill, a rheumatologist (T166, T167, T169) and Dr T Kostos, a rheumatologist (T256 and Exhibit R3, from among pre-hearing documents) can be summarised as follows:·Mr Budarick has nothing physically wrong with him; ·any and every injury in the past was a short-lived soft tissue injury that would have resolved quickly; ·any pain he now experiences is essentially psychological; ·his condition is a manifestation of illness behaviour; and·his condition is not caused by or derived from his employment.