Budarick and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Budarick and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2019] AATA 643 (4 April 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/5818

Re:Steven Budarick

APPLICANT

Australian Capital TerritoryAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member Mark Hyman

Date:04 April 2019

Place:Canberra

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................................................................

Member Mark Hyman

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – thoracic back strain – chronic pain disorder – cease effects - whether injuries continue to show required connection with employment – liability for medical expenses and incapacity - medical evidence – decision affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, ss 37, 42B

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 4, 14, 16, 19, 64, 71

Cases

Bailey v Broadsword Marine Contractors [2017] FCAFC 219

Budarick and Comcare [1994] AATA 85

Budarick and Comcare [2000] AATA 673

Budarick and Comcare [2019] AATA 116

Commonwealth v Borg (1991) FCA

Comcare v Nichols [1999] FCA 209

Kennedy Cleaning Services Pty Ltd v Petkoska (2000) 200 CLR 286

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May (2016) 257 CLR 468

Prain v Comcare [2017] FCAFC 143

Zickar v MGH Plastic Industries Pty Ltd (1996) 187 CLR 310

Secondary Materials

Black’s Medical Dictionary, Forty-Third Edition, Bloomsbury, 2017
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text Revision, American Psychiatric Association, 2009
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, American Psychiatric Association, 2013

Gould’s Medical Dictionary, Third Edition, McGraw Hill 1972.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member Mark Hyman

04 April 2019

  1. This decision is about whether Mr Steven Budarick, the applicant, can continue to receive compensation from the Australian Capital Territory, the respondent. Mr Budarick received compensation payments from Comcare (the respondent in this matter until the Australian Capital Territory became a licensee) over a number of years in respect of an injury sustained in 1997. On 4 August 2017 Comcare decided that there was no present liability for medical expenses under section 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) and no present liability for incapacity under section 19 of that Act. That decision was affirmed in a reconsideration determination dated 16 August 2017. The reconsideration determination is a decision for which application for review may be made to this tribunal under section 64 the SRC Act. On 29 September 2017 Mr Budarick applied to the tribunal for review of Comcare’s decision.

  2. The tribunal held a hearing on 14 February 2019. Mr Budarick appeared in person, representing himself, and gave evidence. Ms Kristy Katavic of Counsel appeared for Comcare, instructed by Ms Elizabeth West of Comcare. Dr Tony Kostos, a consultant rheumatologist, appeared by telephone as an expert witness. The tribunal had available the documents (the “T-documents”) provided by Comcare under section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act); documents provided by Comcare under section 71 of the SRC Act; and a number of documents tendered before or at the hearing. The last includes material provided in the context of an earlier application by Comcare to dismiss this matter as having no reasonable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Budarick and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 643
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Budarick against a decision by the Australian Capital Territory (Comcare) to deny liability for medical expenses and incapacity payments. The dispute centred on whether Mr Budarick's chronic pain disorder continued to have the required connection with his former employment.

The court was required to determine the diagnosis of Mr Budarick's condition and whether his employment had made a material contribution to it, particularly in light of medical evidence suggesting a significant psychological element and the potential for non-organic sources of pain. The court also had to consider the temporal scope of its review, specifically whether it had jurisdiction to make findings about liability prior to 4 August 2017.

The court noted that Mr Budarick had a consistent history of back problems following several incidents, including one in 1997. While medical evidence, including that of Dr Reid, indicated a chronic pain syndrome with a significant psychological component and a lack of identifiable physical pathology, the court considered an alternative case theory. This theory posited that Mr Budarick's pain syndrome was initially caused by work-related back injuries, and that even if psychosocial factors now contributed, his employment remained a material starting point for his condition. The court clarified that its review was limited to the period from 4 August 2017, and it would refrain from making findings about liability before that date.

The court affirmed the decision under review, which denied liability under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act from 4 August 2017.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The first medical attention Mr Budarick received following the 1997 incident was from Dr R Wolska. Medical certificates dated 2 October 1997and 7 October 1997 certify Mr Budarick for leave from his employment for two weeks; a brief report dated 19 March 1998 diagnosed “acute thoracolumbar back strain”, attributed it to activities during his employment and suggested that the incident represented a recurrence of symptoms from previous injuries.Evidence of Dr Robert Reid As noted above, Mr Budarick was seeing Dr Reid before the 1997 injury, and he continued to see him afterwards and up to the present. A series of letters and reports record Mr Budarick’s progress over about twenty years and Dr Reid’s opinion on his condition and its causes. Dr Reid’s first report provided as part of the documentary record after the 1997 incident[24] is dated 13 February 1998. He reported that Mr Budarick told him of the injury; that he had flashes of pain down his right arm, lasting for a second but occurring quite frequently; and that he had other pains in his back, especially around the thoracic area and to the upper lumbar area. Dr Reid diagnosed strain of the thoraco-lumbar muscles, more on the right than the left. [24] T 20, folios 34-5. Over the years that followed Dr Reid maintained considerable interest in Mr Budarick’s progress, and supported the provision of various forms of therapy or other support, including general rehabilitation,[25] acupuncture,[26] massage,[27] psychology consultations;[28] and also other aids, such as an improved bed,[29] and a long-handled reacher for picking up rubbish.[30] [25] T45, folio 149; T48, folio 154.[26] T58, folio 166.[27] T96, folio 214; T102, folio 234; T111, folio 252; T121, folio 265; T143, folios 316-7.[28] T62, folio 170; TT96, folio 214; T102, folio 234; T111, folio 252; T121, folio 265.[29] T114, folio 256; T117, folios 260-1.[30] T116, folio 259; T133, folio 286. Two themes that are apparent in Dr Reid’s various letters are that first, there is a significant psychological element in Mr Budarick’s condition;[31] and in his medical certificates he begins to refer to Mr Budarick having depression or depressive symptoms.[32] He also suggests that Mr Budarick does not have a “mechanical” problem in his back, or any form of physical pathology.[33][31] See e.g. T62, T96, T102, T143, T154.[32] See e.g. T103[33] T117, T151, T154, T 159.5 (dated 25 February 2005). In a report dated 27 November 2007[34] Dr Reid stated that his diagnosis of Mr Budarick was of “chronic lumbar and spinal pain syndrome”; that this condition was unchanged in 10 years; and that the condition was highly resistant to numerous therapies that had been trialled over the years. In 2011 Dr Reid sought and obtained approval[35] for Mr Budarick to have his back imaged with a SPECT/CT bone scan. The result was that the image was largely unremarkable, but that there was mild facet joint arthritis at L4/5 on the right and degenerative arthritis at the left lower sacroiliac joint. In a report dated 19 December 2012[36] Dr Reid identified Mr Budarick’s condition as arising initially from an incident in the workplace in 1991. That incident involved “lifting a towball from a trailer”. There is reference further to two further “reinjuries” in August 1994. Dr Reid describes the condition as not degenerative and states that the condition has not been superseded by a different condition.[34] T190, folios 442-3.[35] T210, folio 476; T212, folio 478; T213, folio 479.[36] T223, folios 503-4.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Under questioning, Dr Kostos explained that an English doctor named Waddell had written a book drawing attention to patterns of symptoms regarding back pain that exhibited inconsistencies and did not align with actual physical injuries. These signs indicated back pain of non-organic source, usually driven by psychosocial factors, personality traits, previous life experiences, attitudes and beliefs and a lack of adaptability to cope with anxiety and stress. Dr Kostos said that it is still contentious whether physical injuries can be the triggering stressor for the development of a chronic pain response of this kind. Typically in these cases one would find a long history of symptoms over many years, preceding the occurrence of a stressor with which the patient is unable to cope, in turn setting off the chronic pain syndrome.CONSIDERATION The case made for Comcare is that there is no present liability for medical expenses and incapacity under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act as of 4 August 2017. That case is based on medical evidence that Mr Budarick’s chronic pain syndrome is not a condition to which his former employment made a material, or indeed any, contribution. I could not say that Mr Budarick, in response, presented a case to me. He did not appear to have a satisfactory grasp of the case made by Comcare and did not outline a basis for why I should make findings at odds with those advocated by Comcare. But, as I noted in denying Comcare’s earlier application to dismiss the matter as having no reasonable prospects of success, there is an alternative case theory implicit in some of the succession of medical reports, namely those of Dr Danta, Mr White, Dr Lucas, Mr Brown, Dr Knox, and Dr Reid. On this implicit case theory Mr Budarick’s pain syndrome was initially caused by back injuries at work, and although he now has no identifiable physical ailment, and his present condition may be contributed to by psychosocial factors, it remains that Mr Budarick’s employment made a material contribution to his condition by having been its starting point. It will be apparent that Comcare’s argument – especially if Dr Kostos’s evidence is accepted - implies that at no time did employment ever make a contribution to Mr Budarick’s condition, and that the conclusion could therefore be drawn that liability could be denied from an earlier date than 4 August 2017. But liability before that date is not within my jurisdiction: the decision under review denies liability under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act from the date of the initial determination, namely 4 August 2017, and that determines the scope of my review. I will therefore refrain from making any findings about liability before that date.What is the diagnosis of Mr Budarick’s condition? A great deal about Mr Budarick is uncontroversial. He has given a consistent history to many different doctors (or, where he has been able to give a history, it has been a consistent history) over a long period. It seems plain that he was a healthy and active person up to 1991; that he suffered a minor back injury in 1988 or 1989, an injury that appears to have resolved quickly with no lasting consequences; that he injured his back once again in 1991 which seems to have resolved after a period of about three years; that his back gave him further problems after injuries in August 1994; that he suffered a further back incident in 1997; and that during much of the 1990s and in the years since he has had a problem with pain.