Bucher Municipal Pty Ltd v Lustrissimi

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

S ECI 2023 02480

BUCHER MUNICIPAL PTY LTD Plaintiff
v
ADAM LUSTRISSIMI First Defendant
- and -
DR MATTHEW CAMPBELL Second Defendant

---

JUDGE:

O’Meara J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

22 November 2024

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

29 November 2024

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Bucher Municipal Pty Ltd v Lustrissimi

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2024] VSC 735

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Judicial review – Medical panel opinion – Plaintiff claimed in respect of industrial deafness and tinnitus – Accepted injury in respect of industrial deafness; tinnitus rejected – Medical questions referred to a medical panel – Medical panel calculated whole person impairment of 11% taking into account allowance of 2% for tinnitus – Whether opinion legally unreasonable, illogical, irrational or not open – Whether failure to take account of relevant matters – Whether constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction owing to factual error – Whether denial of procedural fairness – Whether reasons of medical panel legally inadequate – Barrett Burston Malting Co Pty Ltd v Kotzman [2013] VSC 248, Wingfoot Australia Partners Pty Ltd v Kocak (2013) 252 CLR 480, Chang v Neill (2020) 62 VR 174, Sidiqi v Kotsios [2021] VSCA 187, Scardamaglia v Amcor Pty Ltd [2023] VSC 114 and Amcor PLC v Scardamaglia [2023] VSCA 290, considered – Proceeding dismissed.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff MF Fleming KC with
E Golshtein
Hall & Wilcox
For the First Defendant B McManamey IDA Legal
For the Second Defendant No appearance

HIS HONOUR:

A        Introduction

  1. The first defendant was born on 12 October 1977 and is presently 47 years of age.

  1. For about 20 years, he was employed in metal fabrication and spray painting at Bucher Municipal Pty Ltd (‘plaintiff’).  He was exposed to noise in that employment and, from about 2013, noticed decreased hearing acuity.[1]

    [1]Joint court book (‘JCB’) 48.  See also JCB 81, 88.

  1. On 14 July 2022, the first defendant claimed an impairment benefit in respect of ‘Ears Hearing / Tinnitus‘.[2]

    [2]JCB 59.

  1. The claims agent (‘agent’) referred the first defendant for assessment by Mr Robin Hooper, otorhinolaryngologist and honorary emeritus consultant.

  1. On 14 November 2022, Mr Hooper reported that –

(a)   he had been asked to determine, inter alia, the degree of impairment of the whole person resulting from any diminution of hearing;

(b)  the first defendant gave a history including ‘difficulty hearing speech in background noise’ and ‘constant ringing in the ears’;

(c)   ‘pure tone audiometry showed a bilateral moderate high frequency hearing loss’ and the first defendant had ‘100% speech discrimination in the right ear and 97% speech discrimination in the left ear at appropriate levels of amplification’;

(d)  ‘the total hearing disability … [was] 11.8% binaurally’; and

(e)   the first defendant’s ‘compensable hearing loss … [represented] a whole person impairment of 10%’.[3]

[3]JCB 90.

  1. Mr Hooper’s assessment sheet identified no additional…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bucher Municipal Pty Ltd v Lustrissimi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] VSC 735
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bucher Municipal Pty Ltd sought judicial review of a decision made by a medical panel regarding an industrial claim by Lustrissimi. Lustrissimi claimed for industrial deafness and tinnitus, but the panel accepted the injury related to industrial deafness and rejected the claim for tinnitus. The panel calculated a whole person impairment of 11%, taking into account a 2% allowance for tinnitus. Bucher Municipal argued that the panel's opinion was legally unreasonable, illogical, irrational, or not open, and that there was a failure to take account of relevant matters, a constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction due to a factual error, and a denial of procedural fairness. Additionally, Bucher Municipal contended that the reasons provided by the medical panel were legally inadequate.

The court examined whether the medical panel's opinion was legally unreasonable, illogical, irrational, or not open to the evidence presented. The court found that the panel had considered the relevant evidence and had provided a reasoned basis for its decision. The court also considered whether there was a failure to take account of relevant matters, a constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction, and a denial of procedural fairness. The court concluded that the panel had adequately considered the evidence and had not acted in a manner that denied procedural fairness. Finally, the court assessed whether the reasons of the medical panel were legally inadequate. The court found that the reasons were sufficient to justify the decision made by the panel.

In light of the above, the court dismissed the proceeding, finding that the medical panel's opinion was legally sound, and that there was no failure to take account of relevant matters, constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction, or denial of procedural fairness. The reasons provided by the medical panel were deemed adequate. Consequently, Bucher Municipal's application for judicial review was dismissed, and the decision of the medical panel was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.