Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2018] QCATA 140

PARTIES:

TAMMY BRADSHAW
(applicant)

v

MORETON BAY REGIONAL COUNCIL

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

APL002-18

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO:

GAR136-17

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

24 September 2018

HEARING DATE:

31 May 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Brown, presiding

Member Jones

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal is granted.

2.   The appeal is allowed.

3.   The decision of the tribunal made on 22 December 2017 is set aside.

4.   The decision of the Moreton Bay Regional Council made on 23 May 2017 to issue a Destruction Notice in respect of the dog Hank is set aside.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL GENERAL PRINCIPLES – INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW – IN GENERAL – FAILURE TO EXERCISE DISCRETION – where questions of fact – where findings of fact against the weight of the evidence – whether appropriate to grant leave to appeal – rehearing under s 147 of the QCAT Act – where error of law – whether Tribunal below took into account relevant considerations – whether decision unreasonable or plainly unjust – whether there has been a failure to properly exercise discretion

Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld), s 70(1)(a), s 89(1), s 89(2)(a), s 89(2)(b), s 97(1), s 125, Schedule 1 s 19
Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Regulation 2009 (Qld), Part 2 Division 3
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (2009) (Qld), s 19(a), s 20(1), s 20(2), s 142(1), s 142(3)(b), s 146, s 146(b), s 147(2), s 147(3)

Cachia v Grech [2009] NSWCA 232
Chambers v Jobling (1986) 7 NSWLR 1
Ericson v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013] QCA 391
Glenwood Properties Pty Ltd v Delmoss Pty Ltd & Anor [1986] 2 Qd R 388
Harrison and Anor v Meehan [2016] QCATA 197
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499
McIver BulkLiquid Haulage Pty Ltd v Fruehauf Australia Pty Ltd [1989] 2 Qd R 577
Paterson v Paterson (1953) 89 CLR 212
Perry v Comcare [2006] FCA 33
QUYD Pty Ltd v Marvass Pty Ltd [2009] 1 Qd R 41
Thomas v Ipswich City Council [2015] QCATA 97

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

B McMillan of Counsel, instructed by Anderson Fredericks Turner

Respondent:

D Whitehouse of Counsel, instructed by Moreton Bay Regional Council

REASONS FOR DECISION

What is this appeal about?

  1. On 22 December 2017 the tribunal confirmed a destruction order made by Moreton Bay Regional Council in respect of ‘Hank’, a 4 year old male Neapolitan Mastiff dog. 

    The factual background relevant to the appeal

  2. On 21 October 2016 Ms Bradshaw was attending a social function at a neighbour’s home. Ms Bradshaw was standing in the front yard holding Hank by the collar. A 7 year old child approached Ms Bradshaw and Hank. After an interaction between the child and Hank it became apparent that the child had sustained a serious injury to her face. An ambulance was called and the child was transported to hospital.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCATA 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council concerned a dispute between Ms Bradshaw, the owner of a Neapolitan Mastiff dog named Hank, and the Moreton Bay Regional Council, which had issued a destruction order for Hank following an incident where the dog seriously injured a child. The tribunal had confirmed the Council's decision, but Ms Bradshaw appealed, contending that the tribunal's decision was against the weight of the evidence and that there were errors in the tribunal's consideration of the relevant statutory provisions. The legal issues before the court included whether the tribunal had properly exercised its discretion, whether its findings were against the weight of the evidence, and if the decision was unreasonable or plainly unjust.

The court found that the tribunal had failed to properly exercise its discretion in several respects. The tribunal did not adequately consider Ms Bradshaw's willingness to take additional steps to mitigate risks posed by Hank, such as desexing the dog and making the enclosure childproof. The court also found that the tribunal's findings regarding compliance with the conditions imposed by the Anti-Racism Act were flawed. The tribunal had concluded that Ms Bradshaw would not comply with the conditions, but the court found that this was not supported by the evidence. Furthermore, the tribunal had not considered the additional steps Ms Bradshaw was prepared to take, which were outside the scope of the statutory conditions.

The court concluded that the tribunal's decision was against the weight of the evidence and that there had been a failure to properly exercise discretion. Consequently, the court granted leave to appeal and allowed the appeal. The decision of the tribunal made on 22 December 2017 was set aside, and the destruction order issued by the Council on 23 May 2017 was also set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal is granted.

2. The appeal is allowed.

3. The decision of the tribunal made on 22 December 2017 is set aside.

4. The decision of the Moreton Bay Regional Council made on 23 May 2017 to issue a Destruction Notice in respect of the dog Hank is set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 22 December 2017 the tribunal confirmed a destruction order made by Moreton Bay Regional Council in respect of ‘Hank’, a 4 year old male Neapolitan Mastiff dog. The factual background relevant to the appeal On 21 October 2016 Ms Bradshaw was attending a social function at a neighbour’s home. Ms Bradshaw was standing in the front yard holding Hank by the collar. A 7 year old child approached Ms Bradshaw and Hank. After an interaction between the child and Hank it became apparent that the child had sustained a serious injury to her face. An ambulance was called and the child was transported to hospital. Ms Bradshaw and her partner were subsequently interviewed by an officer of the Council and on 17 November 2016, Ms Bradshaw received correspondence from the Council enclosing a Proposed Regulated Dog Declaration Notice. On 18 January 2017 the Council advised Ms Bradshaw that the Regulated Dog Declaration was upheld. On 23 May 2017 the Council issued a Destruction Order in respect of Hank and on that date Hank was seized by Council officers. Ms Bradshaw applied to the Tribunal for a review of the decision by the Council to issue the Destruction Order. The Tribunal confirmed the Council’s decision.[1] Ms Bradshaw successfully appealed that decision to the QCAT Appeal Tribunal and the application for review was remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration.[2] The Tribunal subsequently confirmed the original decision by the Council to issue the Destruction Order.[3] Ms Bradshaw appeals the Tribunal’s decision. [1]Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2017] QCAT 281.[2]Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2017] QCATA 139.[3]Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council (No 2) [2017] QCAT 455.The statutory framework - appeals A party to a proceeding may appeal to the appeal tribunal against a decision of the tribunal.[4] [4]QCAT Act, s 142(1). An appeal on a question of law is of right. An appeal on a question of fact or a question of mixed law and fact requires the leave of the appeal tribunal.[5] In deciding an appeal on a question of law only the appeal tribunal may confirm or amend the decision, set aside the decision and substitute its own decision or set aside the decision and return the matter to the same or a differently constituted tribunal for reconsideration.[6] An appeal on a question of law does not entail re-hearing the matter. The appeal tribunal may set aside the decision and substitute its own decision on a question of law only if determination of the question of law is capable of resolving the matter as a whole in the applicant’s favour.[7][5]Ibid, s 142(3)(b).[6]Ibid, s 146.[7]Ericson v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013] QCA 391. An appeal against a decision on a question of fact or mixed law must be decided by way of rehearing with or without the hearing of additional evidence as decided by the appeal tribunal.[8] The appeal tribunal may confirm or amend the decision or set aside the decision and substitute its own decision.[9][8]QCAT Act, s 147(2).[9]Ibid, s 147(3).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In response to each of the grounds of appeal, the Council says:(a)Ground 1 – the decision below was both evident and intelligible and took into account Ms Bradshaw’s willingness to have Hank desexed, the statements relating to Hank’s good nature, the absence of prior or subsequent attacks and the additional steps Ms Bradshaw was prepared to undertake in respect of Hank. The Council says that the evidence is entirely consistent with the ultimate decision to confirm the destruction order;(b)Ground 2 – the evidence before the learned member was that there were spaces between the palings of the enclosure fence through which a child could fit a hand at the time a council officer inspected the property in April 2017 and that this situation was subsequently remedied by Ms Bradshaw;(c)Ground 3 – the findings by the learned member must be viewed in the context of the strict requirements imposed by the AM Act in respect of declared dangerous dogs. The Council says that Hank was not desexed within 3 months after the dangerous dog declaration nor was the enclosure made childproof until almost 5 months after the declaration. It was, says the Council, open to the learned member to find that it was more likely than not that Ms Bradshaw would not be compliant with the conditions imposed by the Council;(d)Ground 4 – the conditions imposed by Council do not require Hank to be muzzled when at home. Further, the conditions do not require Hank to be kept in a second enclosure within the enclosure. Both of these were additional steps Ms Bradshaw said she was prepared to implement. Neither could be the subject of conditions. Ms Bradshaw’s evidence was that she permitted small children to play with Hank after the attack and before he was seized. It was open on the evidence for the learned member to find that full compliance with the conditions would not be sufficient to address the threat of a sudden and unprovoked attack on the children at the house;(e)Ground 5 – the absence of any prior incidents of aggression or injury caused by Hank was irrelevant. It was the sudden and unprovoked nature of the attack that caused the decision to be made by the learned member. (f)Ground 6 – the conditions imposed by the AM Act fail to adequately protect any small children residing at the address. In addition, Ms Bradshaw herself volunteered undertaking additional steps to minimise risk, all of which fall outside the scope of the conditions;(g)Ground 7 – Ms Bradshaw appears to accept that steps beyond those imposed by the conditions may be required to manage any future risk to the community posed by Hank. The Council says Ms Bradshaw still fails to appreciate that she did not comply with the conditions in the first instance. Consideration In exercising the Tribunal’s review jurisdiction the learned member was required to decide the review in accordance with the QCAT Act and the AM Act.[36] The purpose of the review was to produce the correct and preferable decision.[37] The learned member was required to hear and decide the review by way of a fresh hearing on the merits.[38] [36]QCAT Act, s 19(a).[37]Ibid, s 20(1).[38]Ibid, s 20(2).