CITATION: | Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council (No 2) [2017] QCAT 455 |
PARTIES: | Tammy Bradshaw |
| v | |
| Moreton Bay Regional Council (Respondent) | |
APPLICATION NUMBER: | GAR136-17 |
MATTER TYPE: | General administrative review matters |
HEARING DATE: | 21 December 2017 |
HEARD AT: | Brisbane |
DECISION OF: | Member Cranwell |
DELIVERED ON: | 22 December 2017 |
DELIVERED AT: | Brisbane |
ORDERS MADE: | 1. The decision of the Moreton Bay Regional Council to make a destruction order in respect of Hank is confirmed. 2. Publication of photographs or copies of photographs of a child entered into evidence in this matter, showing an injury to her face, is prohibited. |
CATCHWORDS: | ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – destruction order in respect of dangerous dog – where further risk of non-compliance identified |
APPEARANCES: | |
APPLICANT: | Ms B McMillan of Counsel |
RESPONDENT: | Ms D Whitehouse of Council |
REASONS FOR DECISION
Ms Bradshaw is the owner of Hank.
This is an application for review of a decision made by Moreton Bay Regional Council (the Council) to make a destruction order in respect of Hank pursuant to the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld) (the Animal Management Act).
The application for review was determined by a differently constituted Tribunal on 15 August 2017. That decision was set aside on appeal on
11 December 2017. The application for review has been returned to me for reconsideration. It is trite to state that, in reconsidering the matter, I am required to make my own findings of fact and am not bound by the findings made by the previous Tribunal.
The incident
The destruction order arose out of an incident on 21 October 2016. The details of the incident, as recorded by the Council, were as follows:
Customer advised that she was at a neighbours property with other members of the street. Customer advised that her daughter was patting the dog with the owner present. Customer advised that she was approx. 2 meters from her daughter and initially thought the dog had initially ‘nudged’ the child. The dog has however bitten her daughter on the face, with grazing above and below eye socket (no injury sustained to eye) and a chunk missing from cheek. An ambulance was called and took child to Lady Cilento Childrens hospital where she received plastic surgery on the 22/10/2016, Customer advised there was no indication that the dog was going to attack, no bark, growls etc. Customer believed the dog was taken straight back to its property after the attack took place. Customer advised that the neighbourhood is hurting regarding the incident and wants the investigating officer to bear in mind that dogs owner is also struggling regarding the incident.
The hospital medical report noted that the child presented “distressed and in pain” with “blood periorally – large bite over right check – irregular border – opening communicating with oral cavity and vermillion border of lip”. The child was admitted to hospital and the wound was treated with plastic/constructive surgery.
The description of the incident set out…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] QCAT 455
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case revolved around whether Ms Bradshaw, the owner of Hank, had complied with the statutory requirements for the management of a declared dangerous dog. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether Ms Bradshaw had failed to desex Hank within the required timeframe as stipulated in the Animal Management Act and the information notice issued by the council. Additionally, the court had to consider whether Ms Bradshaw's reliance on an oral statement from a council officer to delay desexing was reasonable, given the clear and unambiguous written instructions provided.
In its decision, the Tribunal found that Ms Bradshaw had not acted reasonably in relying on an oral statement from a council officer to delay desexing Hank. The Tribunal emphasised that the information notice provided to Ms Bradshaw was clear and unambiguous, requiring Hank to be desexed within three months of the dangerous dog declaration. Despite Ms Bradshaw's efforts to justify her delay, the Tribunal held that she had not complied with the statutory requirements. Furthermore, the Tribunal confirmed the council's decision to make a destruction order in respect of Hank. The Tribunal also made an order prohibiting the publication of photographs of a child who was injured by Hank, to protect the child's privacy.
The final orders of the Tribunal confirmed the council's decision to make a destruction order for Hank and prohibited the publication of photographs of the injured child.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The decision of the Moreton Bay Regional Council to make a destruction order in respect of Hank is confirmed.
2. Publication of photographs or copies of photographs of a child entered into evidence in this matter, showing an injury to her face, is prohibited.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The information notice also extracted a number of provisions of the Animal Management Act. These provisions included s 184, which relevantly provides:Stay of operation of original decision(1) A designated review application or general review application does not stay the original decision the subject of the application.(2) However the applicant may, immediately after being given the information notice for the original decision, apply, as provided under the QCAT Act, to QCAT for a stay of the original decision.(3) QCAT may stay the original decision to secure the effectiveness of the internal review and a later application to QCAT for external review.(4) A stay may be granted on conditions QCAT considers appropriate.(5) However, if the original decision relates to a regulated dog declaration a condition must be imposed that each owner of, and responsible person for, the dog must, until the internal review and any external review and appeal are decided, ensure the requirements under schedule 1, section 3 , are complied with for the dog the subject of the declaration …[Underlining added] It is not in dispute that Hank has not been desexed. Ms Bradshaw gave evidence that a former council officer, Jamie Fry, told her on 28 February 2017 that it was not necessary to do so until “all proceedings have been finished”. The statement was made in response to Ms Bradshaw advising Mr Fry that she would be applying to the Tribunal for a review of the decision. I note that by this stage 82 days had elapsed since the date of the dangerous dog declaration. Ms Bradshaw indicated that the reason Hank had not been desexed in the period immediately following the declaration was that she was low on funds. Mr Fry’s evidence was that he gave Ms Bradshaw a further three months to have Hank desexed. A further 74 days then elapsed until Hank was seized on 23 May 2017. I have no reason to doubt Ms Bradshaw’s account of her conversation with the Council officer. However, I do not accept that it was reasonable for her to rely on Mr Fry’s oral advice after having previously received a written information notice which set out in unqualified and unambiguous terms the requirement that Hank be desexed within three months. The information notice also attached an extract from s 184 of the Animal Management Act, which sets out in equally unqualified and unambiguous terms that a review application does not stay the original decision. I do not accept the submission made on behalf of Ms Bradshaw that s 184(5) might appear to qualify s 184(1), as a clear reading of subsection (5) indicates that it relates to the conditions which the Tribunal must impose on the grant of any stay. No stay was sought by Ms Bradshaw. I note that Ms Bradshaw has made efforts to have Hank desexed following the seizure of Hank and the making of the destruction order, which I will come to below. Other requirements which Ms Bradshaw was required to comply with include that Hank be kept in an enclosure that is childproof and which stops the dog from leaving the enclosure: see Schedule 1 of the Animal Management Act. This was also set out in the information notice provided to Ms Bradshaw.