Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

CITATION:

Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2017] QCAT 281

PARTIES:

Tammy Bradshaw
(Applicant)

v

Moreton Bay Regional Council

(Respondent)

APPLICATION NUMBER:

GAR136-17

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

HEARING DATE:

9 August 2017

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Olding

DELIVERED ON:

14 August 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

ORDERS MADE:

1.   The decision of the Moreton Bay Regional Council to make a Destruction Order in respect of the dog “Hank” is confirmed.

2.   The publication of photographs or copies of photographs of a young female child entered into evidence in this matter, showing an injury to her face, is prohibited.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – power to make destruction order not concurrently with dangerous dog declaration – where no further risk or non compliance identified – where alleged warrant issued on invalid grounds

Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld), s 125, s 126, s 127, s 127A

APPEARANCES:

APPLICANT:

Tammy Bradshaw

RESPONDENT:

Moreton Bay Regional Council

REPRESENTATIVES:

APPLICANT:

represented by Mr M Taylor of Counsel instructed by Couper Geysen

RESPONDENT:

represented by Ms D Whitehouse, instructed by Moreton Bay Regional Council

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Ms Bradshaw has applied for review of the decision of the Respondent Council to make a destruction order in respect of her dog, Hank.

  2. The order has as its genesis an incident on 21 October 2016 in which a child, then seven years of age, suffered a serious injury to her face.

  3. The Tribunal’s role is to decide the matter by way of a fresh hearing on the merits to produce the correct and preferable decision.[1]

    [1]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Queensland) (“QCAT Act”),
  4. I have decided to confirm the decision. 

The facts

  1. The following facts are either expressly accepted by both parties or based on unchallenged evidence; I accordingly find that:

    Background

    a)Hank is a large, male dog of the Neapolitan Mastiff breed.

    b)Ms Bradshaw was at all relevant times Hank’s owner and responsible for him.

    c)Hank is an entire male dog, that is, he has not been de-sexed.

    The incident on 21 October 2016

    d)On the evening of 21 October 2016, Ms Bradshaw was attending a gathering of neighbours outside the home of one of the neighbours and had Hank with her.

    e)Hank was unrestrained but when Ms Bradshaw saw the child approaching, she held Hank by the collar.

    f)An incident occurred after the child started to pat Hank. Hank moved forward towards the child. Witnesses thought that Hank had merely nudged the child, but then saw the child was crying and bleeding.

    g)Although no-one knows precisely how the injury to the child occurred, Ms Bradshaw accepts that Hank caused it.

    h)The incident came as a surprise and without warning. No signs of aggression preceded the incident. It happened too quickly for Ms Bradshaw to restrain Hank, even if she were able to do so.

    i)Neither Ms Bradshaw nor the child’s mother had any prior concerns about the child being…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QCAT 281
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bradshaw v Moreton Bay Regional Council involved Ms Bradshaw, the owner of a Neapolitan Mastiff dog named Hank, who had been declared a dangerous dog by the Moreton Bay Regional Council following an incident where Hank bit a young child. Ms Bradshaw sought review of a destruction order made in relation to Hank. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was tasked with reviewing the Council's decision.

The central legal issues before the tribunal included whether the Council had the power to make a destruction order concurrently with the dangerous dog declaration and whether the warrant issued for Hank's seizure was valid. Additionally, the tribunal needed to assess whether there was any further risk posed by Hank or non-compliance with the conditions of the dangerous dog declaration that warranted the destruction order.

The tribunal found that the Council did not have the concurrent power to make a destruction order when it declared Hank a dangerous dog. The tribunal also determined that the warrant issued for Hank's seizure was invalid as it was based on incorrect information. Furthermore, no further risk or non-compliance was identified that would justify the destruction order. Despite the child's injury and the scarring, the tribunal noted that there had been no further incidents involving Hank and that Ms Bradshaw had complied with most conditions attached to the dangerous dog declaration.

The tribunal confirmed the destruction order but prohibited the publication of photographs of the injured child. This decision underscores the importance of procedural correctness in administrative decisions affecting animal welfare and property rights.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the Moreton Bay Regional Council to make a Destruction Order in respect of the dog “Hank” is confirmed.

2. The publication of photographs or copies of photographs of a young female child entered into evidence in this matter, showing an injury to her face, is prohibited.

Background

Background to the litigation

The following facts are either expressly accepted by both parties or based on unchallenged evidence; I accordingly find that:Backgrounda)Hank is a large, male dog of the Neapolitan Mastiff breed.b)Ms Bradshaw was at all relevant times Hank’s owner and responsible for him.c)Hank is an entire male dog, that is, he has not been de-sexed.The incident on 21 October 2016d)On the evening of 21 October 2016, Ms Bradshaw was attending a gathering of neighbours outside the home of one of the neighbours and had Hank with her.e)Hank was unrestrained but when Ms Bradshaw saw the child approaching, she held Hank by the collar.f)An incident occurred after the child started to pat Hank. Hank moved forward towards the child. Witnesses thought that Hank had merely nudged the child, but then saw the child was crying and bleeding.g)Although no-one knows precisely how the injury to the child occurred, Ms Bradshaw accepts that Hank caused it.h)The incident came as a surprise and without warning. No signs of aggression preceded the incident. It happened too quickly for Ms Bradshaw to restrain Hank, even if she were able to do so.i)Neither Ms Bradshaw nor the child’s mother had any prior concerns about the child being near Hank.The nature of the injuryj)The child was taken by ambulance that evening to a hospital where she presented “distressed and in pain”, with “blood periorally – large bite over right cheek – irregular border – opening communicating with oral cavity and vermillion border of lip”.[2][2]Copy of hospital medical report.k)This description is consistent with photographs provided by the child’s mother, which also show to the lay observer abrasion above the child’s right eyebrow and two lines of abrasion leading from just below her eye to the hole beside her mouth.l)The child was admitted to hospital and the wound was treated with plastic/constructive surgery.m)By 27 October 2016, in medical terms the wound had healed well with no signs of infection or inflammation.[3][3]Copy of hospital medical report.n)However, the child’s cheek is scarred and may require further surgery as she grows. She also suffers emotionally both from a fear of dogs and self-consciousness about her scar.The actions of the Councilo)On 9 December 2016, the Council declared Hank to be a “dangerous dog”.p)The Council was empowered to also make a destruction order when it made the dangerous dog declaration, but did not do so at that time.q)As a result of the dangerous dog declaration, Ms Bradshaw was required to comply with certain conditions, including displaying a dangerous dog warning sign, having an appropriate enclosure for Hank and having him de-sexed within 90 days.r)Ms Bradshaw complied with the conditions relating to signage and the enclosure but not the requirement to have Hank de-sexed within the 90-day period. She did not do this because a then council officer told her, incorrectly, that it was not necessary to do so until review of the Council’s decision had been finalised. The requirement to have Hank de-sexed was stated in the documents accompanying the dangerous dog declaration sent to Ms Bradshaw. At the time of the Tribunal hearing on 9 August 2017, Ms Bradshaw had booked Hank in for de-sexing on 11 August 2017.s)Subsequent to the making of the dangerous dog declaration, complaints were made to the Council that Hank had been seen on the street unaccompanied on two occasions and once being walked without a muzzle. Council officers undertook inquiries in response to the complaints but the allegations were not substantiated.t)Ms Bradshaw exercised her right to seek an internal review of the decision to make the dangerous dog declaration and the Council confirmed the decision. u)Later, following a review of its procedures and complaints about its actions in respect of this particular dog, including complaints through political channels, the Council determined that it was a mistake not to issue a destruction order. v)There had not been any further attack by Hank, nor any substantiated non-compliance with the conditions of the dangerous dog declaration (other than the failure to de-sex Hank).w)The Council then sought and obtained a warrant to enable Council officers to enter Ms Bradshaw’s home and seize Hank.x)On 23 May 2017, the Council seized Hank and issued the destruction order that is the subject of this review.y)Since that time, Hank has been held at the animal refuge at Dakabin.z)Before Hank was seized, but after being declared a dangerous dog, Ms Bradshaw and her partner continued to allow his young children, and other children in Ms Bradshaw’s extended family, to play with Hank.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.