BPVS and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

BPVS and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) [2019] AATA 4470 (4 November 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/5089

Re:BPVS

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President B W Rayment OAM QC

Date:4 November 2019

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal decides that:

1.The reviewable decision, being the decision of the respondent dated 31 August 2018, to refuse the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa, is to be set aside.

2.The matter will be remitted to the respondent with a direction that the discretion in s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) is to be exercised in favour of the applicant.

...............................[sgd]….........................

Deputy President B W Rayment OAM QC

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – refusal to grant Protection (Class XA) visa – where applicant owed protection obligations – offences due to drugs – where applicant convicted of offence once – risk of re-offending if abstinent from drug use – where applicant does not pass character test – whether discretion should be exercised – Direction No. 79 – primary considerations and other considerations – nature and offence of past criminal conduct – whether there is a risk to the Australian community – where applicant is owed non-foulement obligations – where legal consequence of non-refoulement obligations result in possible prolonged detention – contrary to dictates of good government – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 36, 197C, 501

CASES

BBFD and Minister for Home Affairs [2019] AATA 3907

BHKM and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 3
DMH16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 448; 253 FCR 576
FTYC and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 20
FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185
NBMZ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCAFC 38; (2014) 220 FCR 1
SYLN and Minister for Home Affairs [2018] AATA 4408; (2018) 163 ALD 186

Tanielu v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCA 673; (2014) 225 FCR 224

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Direction No. 79 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President B W Rayment OAM QC

4 November 2019

  1. In this case, the Federal Court quashed an earlier decision of this Tribunal and remitted the proceedings to the Tribunal to determine the applicant’s application for review according to law. These are my reasons for decision of the remitted application for review.

  2. The applicant applied for a review of a decision of the Minister’s delegate that refused to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa.

  3. It is agreed between the parties that, within the meaning of s 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’), the applicant is a person in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied that protection obligations are owed, because, if he were returned to India, there is a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm as a necessary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BPVS and Minister for Home Affairs (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4470
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of BPVS and the Minister for Home Affairs concerned an application for a Protection (Class XA) visa. The applicant, who had arrived in Australia in 2006, had a history of drug use and criminal convictions, including common assault and drug offences, between 2015 and 2017. Despite these convictions, the applicant had not been sentenced to imprisonment, and various courts had imposed rehabilitation and counselling orders. The applicant had also been diagnosed with a psychiatric condition and contracted HIV. The delegate had found that Australia owed non-refoulement obligations to the applicant. The matter came before Deputy B W Rayment Oam Qc P of the Federal Court.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the applicant passed the character test, and if not, whether the discretion to grant the visa should be exercised in his favour, particularly in light of Direction No. 79. This involved assessing the nature of the applicant's past criminal conduct, the risk of re-offending, and the potential risk to the Australian community. Crucially, the court was required to consider the legal consequences of refusing the visa, specifically in relation to Australia's international non-refoulement obligations.

The court reasoned that while the applicant did not pass the character test due to his criminal conduct, and the "expectations of the Australian community" factor generally favoured refusal in such cases, these considerations were outweighed by the non-refoulement obligations owed to the applicant. The court noted that if the applicant were returned to India, Australia would breach its international treaty obligations. The legal consequence of refusing the visa, in this context, was that the applicant would likely face prolonged detention, as removal to India would contravene these obligations, and no alternative resettlement or visa arrangements had been made. The court considered that such a situation, where detention might continue indefinitely due to the inability to comply with international obligations, was contrary to the dictates of good government.

Consequently, the court set aside the decision under review. The court found that the legal consequences stemming from the non-refoulement obligations owed to the applicant were paramount and outweighed other mandatory considerations, including the protection of the Australian community and community expectations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The same relevant facts were examined by the delegate who found that non-refoulement obligations were owed by Australia in respect of the applicant under its international treaties.BACKGROUND The applicant came to Australia in 2006 and studied business, tourism and commercial cooking at a Sydney college. He was in a same-sex relationship until 2013, and committed no offence. In 2008, he returned to India and went through a marriage ceremony, which was organised by his family who were Sikhs and did not approve of homosexuality. He returned to Australia about a month after the marriage without his wife. The applicant met another person in 2013 and established a relationship with him. Their relationship was turbulent. The new partner introduced him to drugs, and the applicant contracted HIV. The applicant said that his partner hit him, and the police were called, but the applicant decided not to press charges. The relationship was troubled, and was described by the applicant as on and off, until it was terminated in 2015. The applicant was charged with a number of criminal offences. The events covered by the first six charges extended from March 2015 until March 2016. He was first convicted in May 2017. He was never sentenced to a term of imprisonment. A table of the relevant charges and the outcome of each charge is as follows: In 2016, he was admitted to a hospital for treatment for a psychiatric condition. He was hallucinating and splashed urine on the nurses working there, for which charges of common assault were brought against him. Those were the charges dealt with in the NSW District Court in August 2016. The applicant said that he was then clean for a year. In 2017, the applicant met someone else who introduced him to drugs again and he relapsed. There was a dispute with his flatmates, which led to the charges of common assault dealt with in the NSW District Court in May 2017. In the applicant’s evidence, he said that his drug-taking continued after the end of the relationship which began in 2013. He said that in earlier years, he tried to rehabilitate himself, would be clean for a few weeks, and then relapse. He appears to have been successful in remaining abstinent only after his last offence, for which he was dealt with in May 2017. The applicant did not contest the various charges that he faced. The earlier offences related to clashes that he had with the person who became his partner in 2013. The courts dealt with him leniently, requiring him to have counselling, educational development and drug and alcohol rehabilitation, to attend doctors regularly and consultations at the Albion Centre. In April 2017, he was required to continue to undergo treatment and counselling with Ms Hennessy or other appropriate health professional. The absence of a custodial sentence appears to reflect a view by the various courts that he was not a danger to the community, despite what had become a substantial criminal record by 2017 if not earlier. At the time the applicant was charged in May 2017, he was working at a nursing home as a nurse. He told his boss that he had relapsed. His boss said that he had to take four weeks off and go into rehabilitation. He said that it was at this time that he decided definitively never to relapse again. He went to St Vincent’s Hospital for a stimulant treatment program. He went back to work at the nursing home and remained there until, in August 2018, he was taken into immigration detention.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Following some different views expressed at first instance in the Federal Court, the Full Federal Court decided by majority in FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185 that the “expectations of the Australian community” factor was one which in most cases would, of itself, favour the refusal or cancellation of a visa of a person who failed the character test where the non-citizen has breached, or where there is an unacceptable risk that they will breach the law. In applying the consideration, it is not for the delegate or for the Tribunal to assess for itself what community expectations are, either in general or in the particular case. However, it is one consideration among other mandatory considerations, which will be put into the balance to decide how the discretion should be exercised in the particular case. As will appear, in my opinion, the consideration stemming from the non-refoulement obligations owed in respect of the applicant outweigh any other mandatory consideration in this case, including the expectations of the Australian community.Other Considerations The first of the expressly included other considerations is international non-refoulement obligations. Those obligations arise in this matter. If the applicant were returned to India, this country would be in breach of its international obligations. The effect of existing authority in the Federal Court is that there would be a duty to return the applicant to India if the visa is refused: see s 197C of the Act and the decision of North ACJ in DMH16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 448; (2017) 253 FCR 576 (‘DMH16’). The legal consequences of the exercise of a discretion are matters to which a decision-maker under s 501 should have regard. If those consequences contravene high government policy, then the dictates of good government would make a decision-maker very slow to do so, to say the least. I invited submissions from the parties arising from the decisions of this Tribunal, in which I participated, of BHKM and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 3, FTYC and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 20 and SYLN and Minister for Home Affairs [2018] AATA 4408; (2018) 163 ALD 186. At paragraphs [4]–[13] of the Minister’s submissions, the following submissions were made:4The Tribunal is required to consider the legal consequences of a decision to refuse to grant the applicant a protection visa (NBMZ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection at [6]-[10] and [18] per Allsop CJ and Katzmann J; [164]-[167] per Buchanan J. See also Cotterill v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection at [107], [123]-[126]).5Accepting the authority of DMH16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, as the applicant has been found to engage Australia’s protection obligations, if the Tribunal exercises its discretion to refuse to grant the applicant a protection visa, the legal consequence is that the applicant would become liable to removal from Australia under s.198 of the Act as soon as reasonably practicable. However, the Minister submits that the practical consequence of a decision to refuse to grant the applicant a protection visa is not removal to India – it could be removal to a third country of course, in circumstances where refoulement would be in breach of Australia’s international treaty obligations and no decision has yet been made as to how those obligations can be complied with. 6In BHKM, FTYC and SYLN, the Tribunal was informed that government policy is that even if a protection visa is refused or cancelled and protection obligations are owed, a non-citizen will not be removed in breach of Australia’s international treaty obligations (BHKM at [52], SYLN at [70]). That remains government policy to date. 7As at the date of these further submissions, no decision has been made by the Minister on whether or not he will exercise his non-compellable powers to grant the applicant a visa under s.195A or make a residence determination under Subdiv B of Div 7 of Part 2 of the Act. Nor has any decision been made as to whether the applicant can be resettled in a third country. It is, with respect, appropriate for the Minister and his department to defer consideration of these matters until after the outcome of the review process relating to the refusal of the applicant’s visa. If the delegate’s decision is affirmed, it is open to the Minister to consider the alternative management options available to him in relation to the applicant, consistently with the policy that Australia will not breach its non-refoulement obligations.8To the extent that the applicant contends that the Minister would not exercise his non-compellable powers under ss.195A and 197AB, there is nothing in the Act that supports such a contention. Any assertion as to what the Minister might decide is no more than pure speculation. While it is true that the Minister continues to defend the delegate’s decision to refuse to grant the applicant a permanent protection visa, he is not precluded, either as a matter of law or logic, from making a subsequent decision to grant the applicant a bridging visa under s.195A or make a residence determination under s.197AB to allow the applicant to remain in Australia on such basis as the Minister sees fit. 9This position is consistent with the observations of Griffiths J in DOB18 v Minister for Home Affairs at [31] about the need to have regard to the particular stages of decision making with which the Minister is engaged, and that it was open to the Minister to leave for later decision the way in which to deal with non-refoulement. On appeal, Robertson J in DOB18 v Minister for Home Affairs at [185] noted the distinction between considering the risk of harm on the one hand, and considering whether or not, if the appellant made a protection visa application, non-refoulement obligations would then be fully considered. His Honour did not consider this distinction “to be accurately referred to as a distinction between the different stages of decision-making, if by that expression it is intended to mean that the claims of harm as found by the Minister in the present case need not be considered in making a decision under s 501BA(2)”. 10However, Griffiths J’s observations remain apt in the present case. That is, in giving consideration to the risk of harm to the applicant if returned to India and the legal consequences of a decision to refuse to grant him a protection visa, the Tribunal should have regard to the different stages of decision making. Further, it is respectfully submitted that the Tribunal should refrain from any inference as to the outcome of those subsequent stages of decision making. However, the Tribunal can and should have regard to the facts that: (a) the Minister accepts that the applicant is owed non-refoulement obligations, (b) the Government’s stated policy is that it will not remove non-citizens where to do so would breach Australia’s non-refoulement obligations, (c) there is no evidence that the Minister has removed non-citizens in breach of those obligations in the past, and (d) the Minister has available to him a number of alternative management options to give effect to the said policy in respect of the applicant.11To the extent that the possibility of future consideration of the Minister’s non-compellable powers was rejected in FRH18 v Minister for Home Affairs, that case involved a decision made by the Minister personally in circumstances where by virtue of the Minister’s findings on what was in the national interest, Rares J held that any future “consideration” of the exercise of the Minister’s personal non-compellable powers to grant another visa or make a residence determination would necessarily result in a negative decision (at [58]). 12Accordingly, contrary to the Tribunal’s findings in SYLN at [74], the practical consequence of a decision to refuse to grant the applicant a protection visa is not indefinite detention. The applicant will be detained for such time until (a) a decision is made by the Minister whether or not to exercise his non-compellable powers under ss.195A and 197AB; (b) the applicant is resettled in a third country; or (c) there is no longer a real chance of serious or significant harm such that any return to India in the future is free from such risk. It is accepted that it is probable that the applicant would remain in immigration detention until one of these possibilities eventuates. 13The Minister submits that the Tribunal must take into account these possibilities as comprising the range of potential legal and practical consequences of its decision. The Minister further submits that consideration of the possibilities that face the applicant if the visa application is refused does not outweigh the protection of the Australian community and the expectations of the Australian community. The applicant has shown himself to be a person who is willing to engage in conduct that is inconsistent with Australian community standards and who poses a threat to the safety of members of the Australian community. (citations omitted)