Bpesam Iv M Limited v DRA Global Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BPESAM IV M Limited v DRA Global Limited [2020] FCA 738

File number: WAD 103 of 2020
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 29 May 2020
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – selective share buy-back scheme – procedures in Div 2 of Pt 2J.1 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – general duty to make full and fair disclosure to shareholders – duty under s 257D(2) to disclose all information material to the decision how to vote on the resolution – special resolution passed approving share buy-back scheme – whether resolution invalid on the basis of incorrect financial information provided to shareholders – where valid shareholder approval was a condition precedent of the share buy-back agreements – whether s 259F of the Corporations Act cures any defect in the resolution – Knauf Plasterboard Pty Ltd v Plasterboard West Pty Ltd (in liq) (2017) 254 FCR 559 considered

CORPORATIONS – misleading or deceptive conduct – s 1041H of the Corporations Act and s 12DA of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act) – materiality – financial statements issued and then re-issued due to discovery of substantial errors – whether initial financial statements were materially misleading in relation to shareholder approval of a share buy-back scheme – where company represented that the erroneous financial statements were a true and fair view of the company’s position – where errors were not known and could not have been ascertained at the time of approval – consideration of subjective knowledge test under s 257D(2) and the objective test under s 1041H of the Corporations Act – principle in Fraser v NRMA Holdings Ltd (1995) 555 FCR 452 applied

CONTRACTS – construction – condition precedent for execution of share buy-back agreement – waiver clause – whether authority to waive is absolute or confined to certain circumstances – where the terms require consideration only of likelihood and timing of the condition precedent being satisfied – whether ambiguity in the terms is required for regard to be had to the commercial context – where both the terms and the commercial context indicate authority to waive is confined to specific circumstances only

REMEDIES – injunctions and declarations – sources of power to grant orders sought derived from s 23 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 1324 of the Corporations Act and s 12GD of the ASIC Act – whether a sufficient nexus exists between the injunction sought and the conduct that constitutes the contravention – whether policy considerations underlying s 259F(1) provide a discretionary reason not to grant an injunction – whether the applicants lack standing to pursue injunctive relief

REMEDIES – injunctions and declarations – relief sought in relation to share buy-back agreements – where applicant is not a party to the agreements – where the relevant counterparties to the agreements have not been joined – whether counterparties must be joined in order for the relief to be granted – consideration of the effect of the relief on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bpesam Iv M Limited v DRA Global Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 738
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bpesam Iv M Limited brought an action against DRA Global Limited, seeking various declarations and injunctive relief in relation to a share buy-back scheme. The case raised several legal issues concerning the validity of the share buy-back scheme, misleading financial statements, and the enforceability of the share buy-back agreements. The court had to determine whether the share buy-back scheme was validly approved by shareholders, whether the financial statements provided to shareholders were misleading, and whether the share buy-back agreements could be enforced despite the absence of certain counterparties.

The court found that the share buy-back scheme was validly approved by shareholders, despite the incorrect financial information provided to them. The court held that the shareholders had made a valid decision to approve the scheme, and that the duty to disclose all material information under the Corporations Act did not invalidate the resolution. The court also found that the initial financial statements were materially misleading, but that the misleading nature of the statements did not invalidate the shareholder approval of the share buy-back scheme. The court held that the company’s representation that the erroneous financial statements were a true and fair view of its position was misleading, but that the misleading nature of the statements did not invalidate the shareholder approval of the share buy-back scheme. The court further found that the authority to waive the condition precedent for the execution of the share buy-back agreements was confined to specific circumstances only.

The court granted the relief sought by the applicants, including declarations and injunctive relief in relation to the share buy-back agreements. The court held that the applicants were entitled to the relief that they sought, and that the relief should be granted. The court found that a sufficient nexus existed between the injunction sought and the conduct that constituted the contravention, and that policy considerations underlying the Corporations Act did not provide a discretionary reason not to grant an injunction. The court also held that the applicants had standing to pursue injunctive relief, despite not being a party to the share buy-back agreements and the absence of the relevant counterparties.

The court ordered that declarations be made to the effect that the share buy-back scheme was validly approved by shareholders, that the initial financial statements were materially misleading, and that the authority to waive the condition precedent for the execution of the share buy-back agreements was confined to specific circumstances only. The court also granted injunctive relief to prevent DRA from proceeding with the share buy-back scheme until certain conditions were met, including the provision of accurate financial information to shareholders and the waiver of the condition precedent for the execution of the share buy-back agreements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Having canvassed that explanation as to the manner in which I have treated the affidavit evidence, I move to consider the background and the key arguments. BACKGROUND DRA is a diversified global engineering, project delivery and operations management group. It is an unlisted Australian public company, headquartered in Perth, Western Australia. Mr Naude explains that over the years DRA has had high levels of management ownership. This has been a contributing factor, he says, to DRA’s success. Mr Naude joined DRA Group Holdings (Pty) Ltd (DRAGH) in April 2013. DRAGH is a company incorporated in South Africa, which was acquired by Minnovo Global Limited, now known as DRA Global Limited, in July 2018. Although DRAGH and DRA Global are occasionally referred in these reasons separately, they have been described for most purposes together as DRA. From 2016 to mid-2019, Mr Naude served as DRA’s chief financial officer and strategy director. As such, he was accountable for DRA’s group financial and commercial activities, including mergers and acquisitions, strategic investments and group-corporate service functions. As the Chief Executive and Managing Director of DRA now, he is accountable for the management of DRA’s group business activities. Until 2016, all of DRA’s shares were held by employees or former employees of the DRA Group. From time to time, prior to 2018, when DRA became a public company, the DRA Group Holding Share Purchase Trust facilitated the purchase of shares by management personnel and employees of DRAGH by way of funded Share Schemes. This was done as a means of promoting share ownership amongst the senior management team so as to align the interests of DRAGH’s management with its shareholders. The shares acquired under the Share Schemes ranked pari passu with other DRAGH shares. This arrangement is entirely conventional. The Share Schemes entail the Trust offering funding to management personnel and employees (Share Scheme participants), which was used to acquire shares from those shareholders who had left DRAGH and wished to sell their shares on a willing-buyer, willing-seller basis. This arrangement gave rise to a series of loans (Shareholder Loans) from the Trust and other DRAGH group companies to the Share Scheme participants. Typically, the Share Scheme participants were required to pay a portion of the acquisition price in cash. The terms of the Shareholder Loans were such that any benefit (by way of dividend or otherwise) received by the holder in respect of the underlying DRAGH shares would first be applied in full to service the loan, firstly, to settle current and accrued interest and then to repay the principal. The only repayment requirements were that, as long as the loan was outstanding, any dividends declared on the shares would need to service the loan and, if the holder sold their shares, they would have to first apply the sale proceeds in discharge of the loan. DRAGH had no other recourse to the loan holders. According to Mr Naude, a total of 11 such Share Schemes have been implemented to date.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The nature and extent of the relief sought is commensurate with the protections to which the applicants are entitled. CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, in my view, the applicants are entitled to the relief that they seek and the relief should be granted. No party has suggested that costs should not follow the event but if there are contentions to the contrary then they can be addressed on the papers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Consistent with this, the NOM also included the following statements on pages 24 and 27, as part of the ‘Explanatory Notes’ in respect of Item of Business number 13:ITEM 13, RESOLUTION 12 APPROVAL OF SHARE SCHEME BUY-BACK…The buy-back of Shares under Tranche 2 is also conditional on [DRA] or its nominee receiving valid irrevocable acceptances for at least [AUD]$100 million by way of an primary capital raise [sic] or sell down of existing Shares under an initial public offering or reverse takeover on the ASX and a secondary listing on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange. This condition may be waived by the Independent Non-executive Directors of [DRA] only with consideration to be given by Independent Non-executive Directors only to the likelihood and the timing of the Condition being satisfied and subject to the [Act].…The Board considers it to be in the interests of all Shareholders that the Share Scheme Buy Back is completed and that the proposed structure largely mitigates most of the risks posed to other Shareholders as most of the Share Scheme Buy Back Shares will only be bought back under Tranche 2 when there is certainty that the Listing will occur and other Shareholders will have an opportunity to realise value.Extensive safeguards which prescribe the level of disclosure required are contained in Division 2 of Part 2J.1 of the [Act] which are designed to ensure that Shareholders are adequately informed and not disadvantaged by buy-backs.(Emphasis added.) Around July 2019, Mr Salomon who was then one of two DRA directors nominated by the applicants because of their shareholding, was informed for the first time, by DRA’s management personnel, that the financial position and performance of DRA in the fiscal year ended 31 December 2018 was not as represented in the Initial 2018 Financial Statements, including by reason of DRA’s performance in respect of projects it was undertaking, known as the Elikhulu Project in South Africa, the Nokeng Project in South Africa, the Dargues Reef Project in New South Wales, the Limpopo Iron Ore magnetite Project and other matters. There was a meeting of directors in approximately August 2019 attended by representatives from BDO – DRA’s auditors – where these matters were discussed. In those discussions, BDO’s representatives made it clear that the Initial 2018 Financial Statements did not present a true and fair view of DRA’s financial performance in the 2018 fiscal year, and that the Initial 2018 Financial Statements would need to be restated. Also around August 2019, DRA’s accountants commenced preparation of a corrected version of the financial statements for the fiscal year ended 31 December 2018. On 17 December 2019, DRA lodged with ASIC ‘Reissued and Restated’ audited financial statements in respect of the year ended 31 December 2018 (Corrected 2018 Financial Statements). Among other things, the Corrected 2018 Financial Statements reported an operating loss of approximately AUD$52,711,138 in respect of DRA’s fiscal year ended 31 December 2018, rather than the operating profit of AUD$25,451,479 that had been recorded in the Initial 2018 Financial Statements. Shareholders received a communication from Mr Mansell, sent on behalf of DRA by email on 17 December 2019 notifying them that the Corrected 2018 Financial Statements had been lodged with ASIC, providing a brief summary as to matters that the DRA said led to the restatement, and informing shareholders that a copies of the Corrected 2018 Financial Statements were available upon request from DRA. The reasons for, and effect of, the corrections to DRA’s reported financial performance in the 2018 fiscal year are recorded in detail in the notes in the Corrected 2018 Financial Statements and are produced by Mr Salomon in Exhibit 1 to his first affidavit.