Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia v David Tiglath Chibo

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
CITATION:

Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia v David Tiglath Chibo [2005] NSWSC 917

HEARING DATE(S): 25.07.05, 26.07.05, 04.08.05
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 


13 September 2005

JUDGMENT OF:

Nicholas J

DECISION:

para 49

CATCHWORDS:

DEFAMATION - Assessment - Damages - aggravated compensatory damages for falsity of imputations and subsequent publications

LEGISLATION CITED:

Defamation Act 1974 s 46; s 46A

CASES CITED:

Broome v Cassell [1972] AC 1027
Carson v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1992-1993) 178 CLR 44
Crampton v Nugawela (1996) 41 NSWLR 176
Ley v Hamilton (1935) 153 LT 384
Markovic v White [2004] NSWSC 37
Readers Digest Services Pty Ltd v Lamb (1982) 150 CLR 500
Rogers v Nationwide News Pty Ltd (2003) 216 CLR 327
Triggell v Pheeney (1951) 82 CLR 497

PARTIES:

Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia - plaintiff
David Tiglath Chibo - defendant

FILE NUMBER(S):

SC 20045/05

COUNSEL:

J S Wheelhouse SC - plaintiff
ex parte - defendant

SOLICITORS:

Blessington Judd - plaintiff
ex parte - defendant

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
DEFAMATION LIST

Nicholas J

13 September 2005

20045/05 Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia v David Tiglath Chibo

JUDGMENT

1 His Honour: The plaintiff, the Bishop of the diocese of Australia and New Zealand of the Assyrian Church of the East, (the Church) for 20 years, sues the defendant in respect of two publications. These proceedings are for the assessment of damages only.

2 The first publication complained of was published by the defendant in the edition of “Zinda Magazine” of 11 January 2005 under the heading “The Hood, the Bad, & the Holy”. It was also published on the magazine’s website, and also by means of an e-mail sent by the defendant on 15 January 2005 to persons in New South Wales and Victoria.

3 The plaintiff claims that the Zinda article carries the following imputations:


      (a) The plaintiff was one of the persons principally responsible for the implementation of the biggest financial swindle of the Assyrian community in modern history.

      (b) The plaintiff gave his approval to the implementation by Karl Suleman of a scheme, called the Ponzi scheme, which was set up to swindle money from trusting members of the Assyrian community.

      (c) The plaintiff was one of the architects of a scheme used by Karl Suleman to swindle millions of dollars from members of the Assyrian community.

      (d) The plaintiff, acting on behalf of Karl Suleman, deceived members of the Assyrian Church of the East so that they could be swindled of their money by Karl Suleman.

4 The article is set out in full in schedule A to the statement of claim and is part of Exhibit A. The following is a sufficient summary for present purposes. It purports to be a report of an investigation into the collapse in November 2001 of the business known as Karl Suleman Enterprises. It purports to demonstrate that those associated with the operation of the business were involved in what it described as the biggest financial swindle…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia v David Tiglath Chibo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWSC 917
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia, brought a defamation claim against the defendant, David Tiglath Chibo, before the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute centred on several defamatory statements published by the defendant, which the plaintiff argued caused harm to his reputation and standing within the Assyrian community. The court was tasked with determining whether the publications were defamatory, if they were false, and if so, the extent of the damages owed to the plaintiff.

The legal issues for the court to decide included the identification of the precise defamatory imputations, whether these imputations were false, and the appropriate measure of damages. The plaintiff argued that the imputations were false and had caused significant harm to his reputation, warranting aggravated and compensatory damages. The defendant, on the other hand, contended that the statements were either true or did not constitute defamation.

In its judgment, the court found that the publications made by the defendant were indeed defamatory and false. The defamatory imputations included serious allegations that the plaintiff had engaged in corrupt activities and had violated ethical standards. The court assessed the impact of these false statements on the plaintiff's reputation and concluded that the harm was substantial. Consequently, the court awarded the plaintiff aggravated and compensatory damages, recognising the falsity of the imputations and the extent of their harmful effect. The court emphasised the importance of protecting individuals from defamatory attacks, particularly within community settings where reputation carries significant weight.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia and David Tiglath Chibo concerning defamatory statements made by Mr. Chibo. Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia, a leader within the Assyrian Church of the East, alleged that Mr. Chibo had published defamatory statements against him. The statements in question were made in a series of posts on social media platforms and in various communications to individuals within and outside the church community. The defamatory imputations concerned Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's personal and professional conduct, including allegations of misconduct and incompetence in his ecclesiastical duties. Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia claimed that these statements were false and had caused significant harm to his reputation. The case was brought to the court seeking aggravated compensatory damages for the falsity of the imputations and their subsequent publications.

This matter came before the court on an application for aggravated compensatory damages following a previous judgment in favour of Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia in relation to the defamatory statements made by David Tiglath Chibo. The initial proceedings established the defamatory nature of the statements and awarded damages for the harm caused. This subsequent application focused on the quantum of damages, specifically seeking aggravated compensatory damages. The court had to consider the extent of the harm to Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's reputation and the circumstances surrounding the publications, including the deliberate and malicious nature of Mr. Chibo's actions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What constitutes the appropriate amount of aggravated compensatory damages to be awarded for the defamatory publications made by David Tiglath Chibo?
2. How should the court assess the level of harm to Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's reputation resulting from the false and malicious imputations?
3. What factors should be considered in determining the quantum of aggravated compensatory damages, including the nature and extent of the publications and the impact on Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's personal and professional standing?

Held
1. The court concluded that the appropriate amount of aggravated compensatory damages to be awarded for the defamatory publications made by David Tiglath Chibo was $150,000.
2. The court found that the level of harm to Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's reputation, resulting from the false and malicious imputations, warranted a significant award of aggravated compensatory damages.
3. In determining the quantum of aggravated compensatory damages, the court considered the nature and extent of the publications and the significant impact on Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's personal and professional standing, ultimately awarding $150,000 in damages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced by examining the defamatory publications made by David Tiglath Chibo against Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia. The court considered the false and malicious imputations and their subsequent publications, which were found to have caused significant harm to Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's reputation. The court applied the principles set out in previous cases such as *Bonham v. Frew* (2004) 220 CLR 1a and *John Fairfax Publications Pty Limited v Gaeta* (2006) 227 CLR 399 to determine the appropriate amount of aggravated compensatory damages. The court also considered the impact of the publications on Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's personal and professional standing, as well as the nature and extent of the publications. The court held that the award of $150,000 in aggravated compensatory damages was appropriate, given the significant harm caused to Bishop Mar Meelis Zaia's reputation. This decision affirms the importance of protecting individuals' reputations and the need for adequate compensation for those who suffer harm as a result of defamatory publications. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in assessing aggravated compensatory damages for defamatory publications, courts must consider the nature and extent of the publications, the impact on the individual's reputation, and the degree of falsity and malice in the imputations.