Bideena Pty Ltd v Growth Super Fund Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bideena Pty Ltd v Growth Super Fund Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 327

File number: NSD 425 of 2016
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 31 March 2017
Catchwords: COSTS – where the plaintiff filed interlocutory process without notifying defendants beforehand – where parties settled issues on interlocutory process – whether plaintiff’s conduct was unreasonable – whether there should be no order as to costs – whether costs should be costs in the cause – whether costs should be defendants’ costs in the cause – whether defendants’ costs should be paid on an indemnity basis – order that costs be costs in the cause
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N, 43
Cases cited:

Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Limited (1993) 46 FCR 225

Hockey v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd(No 2) (2015) 237 FCR 127

Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association (Inc.) (1986) ATPR ¶40-748

DSE (Holdings) Pty Limited v InterTAN Inc [2004] FCA 1251

ONE.TEL Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2000) 101 FCR 548

Oxford Funding Pty Ltd v Oxford Asia Pacific Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1542

Re Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs; Ex Parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622

Yperion Technology SAS v Luminex Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 38

Date of hearing: 10 February 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 63
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr A Leopold SC with Mr E Young
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: W M Lawyers Pty Ltd
Counsel for the First and Fifth Defendants: Mr G Parker SC with Ms S Tame
Solicitor for the First and Fifth Defendants: Judd Commercial Lawyers
Counsel for the Second, Third and Fourth Defendants: Mr L V Gyles SC
Solicitor for the Second, Third and Fourth Defendants: J Biady and Associates Pty Ltd

ORDERS

NSD 425 of 2016
BETWEEN:

BIDEENA PTY LTD ACN 003 711 313

Plaintiff

AND:

GROWTH SUPER FUND PTY LTD ACN 159 257 548

First Defendant

ARF INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 159 928 891

Second Defendant

AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL FINANCE PTY LTD ACN 078 025 564 (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Defendant

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 MARCH 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.As between the plaintiff and the second, third and fourth defendants the costs of the interlocutory process filed by the plaintiff on 29 March 2016 be costs in the cause.

2.As between the plaintiff and the fifth defendant the costs of the interlocutory process filed by the plaintiff on 29 March 2016 be costs in the cause.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MARKOVIC J:

  1. On 29 March 2016 Bideena Pty Ltd (Bideena), concurrently with the filing of the originating process commencing this proceeding, filed an interlocutory process in which it sought orders, among others, for interlocutory…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bideena Pty Ltd v Growth Super Fund Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 327
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bideena Pty Ltd initiated legal proceedings against Growth Super Fund Pty Ltd and others, seeking various forms of relief, including injunctive relief and disclosure orders, to prevent the defendants from dealing with certain funds and to compel the production of financial records. The defendants contested the application, and the matter was settled before the hearing of the interlocutory process. The central issue before the court was how to determine the costs associated with the interlocutory process, given that the relief sought was ultimately not pursued due to the settlement. The court considered whether the plaintiff's conduct in filing the interlocutory process without prior notice was unreasonable and whether any costs should be awarded.

The court found that while the plaintiff's conduct was not unreasonable, the costs associated with the interlocutory process should be considered in light of the fact that the relief sought was not pursued. The court held that costs are compensatory in nature rather than punitive and that any assessment of the necessity of the work and the recoverability of costs should be addressed by the taxing officer. Given that the costs related specifically to the interlocutory process, the court decided that the appropriate order was for the costs to be costs in the cause. This means that the costs of the interlocutory process would be shared between the parties involved in that specific process, rather than being awarded on an indemnity basis or paid by a single party.

The court's final orders were that the costs of the interlocutory process filed by the plaintiff on 29 March 2016 be costs in the cause between the plaintiff and the second, third, and fourth defendants, as well as between the plaintiff and the fifth defendant. The rationale behind this decision was to ensure that the costs associated with the interlocutory process were fairly distributed among the parties involved in that stage of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. As between the plaintiff and the second, third and fourth defendants the costs of the interlocutory process filed by the plaintiff on 29 March 2016 be costs in the cause.

2. As between the plaintiff and the fifth defendant the costs of the interlocutory process filed by the plaintiff on 29 March 2016 be costs in the cause.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bideena submitted that there should be no order as to costs. As an alternative, in response to a suggestion made by me during the course of argument, it further submitted that an order that costs of the interlocutory process be costs in the cause would be appropriate. Mr Patakas submitted that Bideena should pay his costs of the interlocutory process or, in the alternative, that the costs of the interlocutory process should be his costs in the cause. The ARF Parties submitted that Bideena should pay their costs of the interlocutory process on an indemnity basis. FACTS The interlocutory process sought 12 orders including, relevantly:1.An order that [ARF], [Ms Patakas] and [Mr Patakas] be restrained from transferring, gifting, paying, assigning, encumbering, charging, transferring or crediting to another account or otherwise dealing with any money which is beneficially owned by [ARF], and whether held in the controlled money account or trust account of [Mr Patakas] as the solicitor for [ARF] or in any bank accounts, including any accounts held with the Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited and the Bendigo/Adelaide Bank, which stand in, or are held in, the name of [ARF] or of which it is the beneficial owner, until further order of the Court.2.An order that [Ms Patakas] and [Mr Patakas] disclose to the Court, by affidavits sworn by each of them and filed and served within 7 days, all the particulars, including account names, account numbers, branch numbers, branch locations and names of all account signatories of all bank accounts in which any money which is beneficially owned by [ARF] is currently held or stands to the credit of [ARF], including but not limited to the payment of about $2.1m made to [Mr Patakas] as the solicitor for [ARF] by Abadee Dresdner Freeman Lawyers in about December 2014.3.An order that [Ms Patakas] and [Mr Patakas] do all things and take all steps necessary to enable or procure [Investments] and [ARF] to deliver up to the Registrar at the Sydney Registry all original registers, books, financial records and financial reports (as defined in s.9 of the Corporations Act) of each of [Investments] and [ARF], and whether held by [Investments, ARF, Ms Patakas or Mr Patakas] or their agents, and do all things and take all steps otherwise necessary to procure [Investments] and [ARF] to produce all such original registers, books, financial records and financial reports to the Registrar at the Sydney Registry within 14 days of this order.…9.An order that [Ms Patakas] and [Mr Patakas] disclose to the Court by an affidavit sworn by each of them, which shall be filed and served within 7 days, all the particulars, including the dates, amounts, account details and purposes for the making of each and every advance, withdrawal, payment and repayment of loan principal, interest on any loans or legal costs, charges, expenses, fees and legal costs paid by [ARF] to [Mr Patakas] or [Goeke] under the security agreement supporting the charge registered on 29 August 2013 under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 as charge no. 201308290049861 or under any costs agreements or bill of costs or bills of costs or tax invoices made or issued pursuant to the provisions of the Legal Profession Act 2004 or the Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW) 2015.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I put that alternative to the parties and gave them an opportunity to make submissions on it. The ARF Parties and Mr Patakas submitted that it would be unjust for Bideena to have its costs of work that was ultimately unnecessary and in respect of relief that was never pressed and that it was unreasonable for Bideena to bring the application in the manner it did. I have already addressed the question of whether Bideena’s conduct was reasonable. Relevantly, costs are compensatory in nature and not punitive. Any issue as to whether work was necessary and whether the costs of that work ought to be recovered, once a costs order is made, is a matter for the taxing officer.CONCLUSION In my opinion the appropriate order, given that the costs which I am considering relate to the interlocutory process, is that costs should be costs in the cause. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The balance of the orders sought in the interlocutory process were for:·interlocutory relief against Goeke;·leave pursuant to s 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) for Bideena to bring proceedings in the names of Investments and ARF against Growth, Ms Patakas, Mr Patakas and Goeke;·an order that Bideena have leave to serve a sealed copy of any orders made on the manager of the bank or banks disclosed in the affidavits filed pursuant to the relevant orders, if made; and ·orders that the matter proceed on pleadings and that the Court make a suitable timetable for the further conduct of the proceeding including the interlocutory process. On 29 March 2016 Bideena’s solicitors, W M Lawyers, sent letters together with sealed copies of the originating process, the interlocutory process and four supporting affidavits to each of Growth, Investments, ARF, Ms Patakas and Mr Patakas (29 March Letters). Save for the addressees those letters were substantially identical and relevantly provided:Both the originating process and initiating process are listed for directions at 9.30am on 14 April 2016 next at the Federal Court of Australia, Law Courts Building. Queen’s Square, Sydney.Subject to our receipt, prior to the return date of the interlocutory process, of unconditional written undertakings, firstly, by the sixth defendant, Goeke Investment Finance Pty Ltd (Goeke), not to take any steps to appoint a receiver to the property of the third defendant, Agricultural and Rural Finance Pty Ltd (ARF) (the Goeke undertaking), and secondly, by the fourth and fifth defendants, Anastasia Patakas and Evangelos Patakas, not to procure ARF to withdraw, transfer or otherwise pay any funds from its bank accounts or controlled money account with Mr Patakas (the Patakas undertakings) until the final determination of this proceeding, Bideena proposes that directions be made for the filing of pleadings and that a timetable be made for the filing of those pleadings and substantive and interlocutory affidavits, together with the allocation of an urgent date for the hearing of the interlocutory process, at that first directions hearing. However, in the event that no such undertakings are forthcoming, Bideena will ask the Court to hear, at the very least, the prayers in paragraphs 1, 4 and 5 of the interlocutory process, upon Bideena giving to the Court the usual undertaking as to damages, either on its return date or, if sufficiently urgent, on such earlier date as is convenient to the Docket Judge on short notice.We enclose proposed short minutes of order for the first directions hearing. Kindly advise whether they are acceptable to you by close of business this coming Monday, 4 April next. Your attitude to those proposed undertakings and orders will determine whether or not we apply to have the proceeding listed at an earlier date in order to agitate the prayers for injunctive relief in the interlocutory process (being the prayers in paragraphs 1, 4 and 5).The proposed short minutes of order enclosed with the 29 March Letters included:UPON THE COURT NOTING THE FOLLOWING UNDERTAKINGS TO THE COURT:…2.The undertaking by the fourth and fifth defendants, in their capacities as the director (or the directors) and the solicitor respectively of the third defendant, not to withdraw, transfer, assign, encumber, pay or otherwise deal in the proceeds of the bank accounts of the third defendant held at any bank or the controlled money account of the third defendant maintained by the fifth defendant as the trustee for the third defendant until the final determination of this proceeding;…THE COURT ORDERS THAT:…8.The defendants file and serve their affidavits in response to each of the originating process and the interlocutory process by [blank] April 2016.9.The plaintiff file and serve its affidavits in reply to those affidavits by [blank] May 2016.…11.The interlocutory process be listed for hearing for one day before the Docket Judge at 10.15am on [blank] 2016.