Bickfords Trading Pty Ltd v BNB Management Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by Bickfords Trading Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application numbers 1989998 (class 33) – 20 20 Distillery and 2023510 (class 33) – TWENTY TWENTY 20 20 DISTILLERY (figurative) – both in the name of BNB Management Pty Ltd

Delegate: Nicholas Barbey
Representation: Opponent: Collison & Co
Applicant: Sonia Stewart of counsel instructed by FB Rice Pty Ltd
Decision: 2022 ATMO 140
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – opposition under s 52 – ss 41, 42(b), 44 and 60 pursued – s 41 established in respect of both trade marks – evidence of use insufficient – registration of trade marks refused

Background

  1. This decision concerns oppositions brought by Bickfords Trading Pty Ltd (‘Opponent’) pursuant to s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) to registration of the following trade marks (together ‘Trade Marks’):

    Trade Mark:  20 20 Distillery (‘Word Mark’)       

    Application number:              1989998

    Applicant:  BNB Management Pty Ltd (‘Applicant’)

    Filing Date:  17 February 2019

    Specification:  Class 33: distilled alcoholic beverages; alcohol for drinking; distilled beverages; low alcohol spirits; low alcohol cocktails; liquors (alcoholic beverages); alcoholic beverages containing wine; fermented liquors; alcoholic beverages containing fruit; alcoholic beverages (except beer); fruit extracts (alcoholic); alcoholic extracts of fruits; fruit based alcoholic beverages; alcoholic cocktails

    (‘998 Goods’)

    Trade Mark:  (‘Logo Mark’)           

    Application number:              2023510

    Applicant:  BNB Management Pty Ltd

    Priority Date:  17 July 2019

    Specification:  Class 33: still spirits; malt whisky; still liqueurs; grain spirit produced from wheat; fermented spirit; low alcohol spirits; digesters (liqueurs and spirits); spirit based cocktails (spirits predominating); spirits (beverages); blended whisky; digesters (liqueurs and spirits); fermented spirit; grain spirit produced from wheat; spirit based cocktails (spirits predominating); spirits (beverages); still spirits

    (‘510 Goods’)

  2. The acceptance of each trade mark for possible registration was advertised on 27 May 2020. The Opponent filed notices of intention to oppose on 20 July 2020 followed by Statements of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGPs’) on 17 August 2020. The Applicant filed notices of intention to defend on 9 October 2020.

  3. Evidence in Support (‘EIS’) was filed by the Opponent and the Applicant filed Evidence in Answer (‘EIA’). An oral hearing was subsequently requested. Submissions were filed by the Opponent on 6 May 2022 (‘Opponent’s Submissions’) and by the Applicant on 12 May 2022 (‘Applicant’s Submissions’).

  4. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard this matter by video conference on 20 May 2022. Anthony Norris of Collison & Co presented submissions on behalf of the Opponent and Sonia Stewart of counsel presented submissions on the Applicant’s behalf.

    Grounds of opposition, onus and standard of proof

  5. The SGPs nominated grounds of opposition under ss 41, 42(b), 44 and 60 of the Act. To be successful, the Opponent bears the onus of establishing at least one of these grounds.[1]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bickfords Trading Pty Ltd v BNB Management Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ATMO 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bickfords Trading Pty Ltd opposed the registration of two trade mark applications by BNB Management Pty Ltd: application number 1989998 for "20 20 Distillery" and application number 2023510 for a figurative mark incorporating "TWENTY TWENTY 20 20 DISTILLERY". The oppositions were heard by Nicholas Barbey, Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks.

The primary legal issue before the Delegate was whether the grounds of opposition, specifically relating to section 41 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth), had been established. This section concerns the distinctiveness of a trade mark. The Delegate was required to determine if the applicant's proposed marks were capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods and services from those of other persons, considering the evidence presented by both parties regarding their respective brands and their use in the market.

The Delegate reasoned that the ordinary civil standard of proof, based on the balance of probabilities, applied to the oppositions. The relevant date for assessing rights for the word mark was 17 February 2019, and for the logo mark, it was 17 July 2019. The Opponent, Bickfords Trading Pty Ltd, presented evidence of its "Twenty Third Street Distillery" brand, launched in 2016, which uses the number 23 prominently and is associated with various spirit products distributed nationally. The Applicant, BNB Management Pty Ltd, commenced its "20 20 Distillery" business in 2018, adopting the name as a play on "20 20 vision" and using it in social media campaigns from March 2019. Despite the applicant's evidence of use, the Delegate found that the Opponent had established the section 41 ground of opposition for both trade marks.

Consequently, the Delegate refused to register both trade mark application numbers 1989998 and 2023510. The Delegate also awarded costs against the Applicant in respect of application number 1989998, and reduced costs in respect of application number 2023510.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant standard of proof is the ordinary civil standard based on the balance of probabilities.[2] In relation to the Word Mark, the date at which the rights of the parties are to be determined is 17 February 2019, being both the filing and priority date of the application. With respect to the Logo Mark, the relevant date is 17 July 2019 which is the filing and priority date of that application. [2] Telstra Corporation Limited v Phone Directories Company Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 156, [133] (Besanko, JagotEvidence The following declarations were filed in respect of both oppositions: The Tolhurst Declaration states that the ‘Twenty Third Street Distillery’ was launched on 23 September 2016. The distillery’s name is derived from its location which is ‘on the corner of 23rd Street & Renmark Avenue in Renmark, South Australia’.[3] Ms Tolhurst declares that the ‘number 23 has been synonymous to the brand’ and is used as a key date for product launches and events.[4] Reference is also made to six Australian trade mark registrations owned by the Opponent which incorporate the words ‘twenty third’ or the numerals ‘23’.[5] [3] Tolhurst Declaration, [5.1].[4] Ibid [5.2].[5] See Australian trade mark registrations 1755126 (‘TWENTY THIRD STREET DISTILLERY’), 1755127 (‘23RD STREET DISTILLERY’), 1841748 (‘23RD STREET DISTILLERY NOT YOUR NANNA'S BRANDY’), 2012951 (‘BATCH23 BY TWENTY THIRD STREET DISTILLERY’), 2036133 (‘TWENTY THIRD STREET’), 2036134 (‘23 TWENTY THIRD STREET DISTILLERY, RENMARK EST. 2016’). Ms Tolhurst explains that the ‘Twenty Third Street Distillery brand is home to 14 products ranging across brandy, gin, rum, vodka and whisky’.[6] Its products are distributed nationally and stockists include Dan Murphy’s and Vintage Cellars. The ‘Twenty Third Street Distillery’ brand is promoted at events across Australia and the Opponent operates a website as well as social media accounts which feature the words ‘Twenty Third Street Distillery’.EIA[6] Tolhurst Declaration, [5.6]. According to the Bedding Declaration, the ‘20 20 Distillery business’ started in 2018 and its distillery is located in Queensland. Mr Bedding states that the Word Mark was devised in [7] Bedding Declaration, [8].mid-2018 and the Logo Mark was created in June 2019. The expression ‘20 20 distillery’ was adopted because it is a ‘play on the term “20 20 vision” and the desire for the business to adopt a brand which reflects an ethos of being clearly focused on delivering high end spirits made from premium quality local ingredients’.[7] Mr Bedding declares that the Word Mark was ‘first used in June 2019 when the Applicant commenced a brand awareness campaign through social media accounts’[8] and the tasting room at the distillery first opened to the public on 12 December 2020. Annexed to the Bedding Declaration are various articles which refer to the Trade Marks and/or products sold by the Applicant. Mr Bedding explains that Facebook and Instagram accounts featuring the Trade Marks are also used to promote the Applicant’s products. Relevantly, the first post on the Applicant’s Facebook page is dated 8 March 2019 and announces a ‘20 20 Distillery coming soon to Noosa’.[9][8] Ibid [14].[9] Ibid [19].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act relevantly provides:Decision(1) Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or (b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established. The Opponent has established the s 41 ground of opposition in respect of both Trade Marks. As such, I refuse to register trade mark application numbers 1989998 and 2023510.Costs Both parties have sought an award of costs. Costs usually follow the event. Accordingly, in respect of trade mark application number 1989998, I award costs against the Applicant per s 221 of the Act in the amounts set out in Schedule 8 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (Cth). In respect of trade mark application number 2023510, I award reduced costs against the Applicant in the same manner as indicated in Hume Industries (Malaysia) Berhad v James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd.[41][41] [2001] ATMO 78.Nicholas BarbeyHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks18 August 2022

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.