Betty Millar v ABC Merchandising and Sales

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

CITATION:              Betty Millar v ABC Merchandising and Sales [2011] NTMC 047

PARTIES:   Betty Millar

v

ABC Merchandising and Sales Pty Ltd

TITLE OF COURT:   Work Health Court     

JURISDICTION:   Work Health

FILE NO(s):   21004782

DELIVERED ON:   2 November 2011

DELIVERED AT:   Darwin

HEARING DATE(s):   2nd – 4th August 2011, 23rd August 2011

JUDGMENT OF:   Ms Fong Lim

CATCHWORDS:

Work Health – injury -causation –vulnerable knee – multiple causes- incapacity – economic loss – section 5, 65, and 73 Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act

Work Health – Deed of settlement – interpretation – effect on later claim – double compensation – burden of proof –section 54 Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act – section 17 Interpretation Act (NT)

Practice and Procedure – pleadings- failure to plead statutory provisions – Rule 8.01 Work Health Rules.

George Starr v NT of Australia unreported decision [23rd October 1998] - Applied

Australian Eagle Insurance Company Ltd v Federation Insurance [1976] 15 SASR 282 - Applied

Hopkins v Collins/Angus & Robertson [1997] 21st May 1997 unreported decision Supreme Court – considered

Normandy v Simpson [2002] NTSC 43 – considered

McIntyre v Tumminello Holdings No 1 [2004] NTMC 97 –considered - applied

Ju Ju Nominees v Carmichael [1999] 9 NTLR 1- considered - applied

Napper & anor v Bultitude [2009] 261 LSJS 62 – considered

Workcover/Royal & Sun Alliance (York Civil Pty Ltd) v Tarbotton [2003] SAWCT 40 - considered

Workcover/Royal & Sun Alliance (York Civil Pty Ltd) V Tarbotton [2005] SAWCT 34 – considered

Mansfield Pty Ltd v Mastrioanni [1998] NSWSC 259 – considered

Franklins Self Serve Pty Ltd v Wyber [1999] NSWCA 390 – applied

Manser v Spry [1994]HCA 50 - applied

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Worker:   Mr Johnson

Employer:   Mr Crawley

Solicitors:

Worker:   Caroline Scicluna & Assoc

Employer:   Cridlands

Judgment category classification:           A

Judgment ID number:   [2011] NTMC

Number of paragraphs:   112

IN THE COURT OF
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21004782

BETWEEN:

Betty Millar

Worker

AND:

ABC Marketing and Sales Pty Ltd

Employer

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 2 November 2011)

Ms FONG LIM SM:

  1. Betty Millar is a 51 year old woman who suffers pain, instability and restriction of movement in her right knee particularly when she undertakes certain activities such as repetitive squatting, standing for any length of time and climbing up and down stairs. Ms Millar claimed her present knee condition has been caused by a work injury she suffered in 2005 when employed by ABC Marketing and Sales Pty Ltd.

  2. Ms Millar’s original claim for Work Health benefits from ABC was accepted and she was paid benefits for a period of time until her doctor gave her clearance to go back to work. From that time Ms Millar returned to work trying several types of employment the most significant being her work at Mining and Civil Services in 2008. While she was employed with Mining and Civil Services she suffered two work injuries one to her knee and the other to her upper body.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Betty Millar v ABC Merchandising and Sales and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NTMC 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Betty Millar versus ABC Merchandising and Sales, the dispute revolves around an injury sustained by Ms. Millar during her employment with ABC Merchandising and Sales. The case was adjudicated in the Northern Territory District Court. Ms. Millar's claim centred on injuries she sustained to her right knee in 2005, and the subsequent economic loss she experienced, including loss of earning capacity, retraining expenses, and medical costs.

The court was tasked with determining several legal issues, including the causation of Ms. Millar's injuries, the extent to which the injury contributed to her loss of earning capacity, and the interpretation of the Deed of Agreement signed in 2009. The court also had to consider whether Ms. Millar had discharged her burden of proof regarding the compensation she had already received and whether this should be set off against any further compensation awarded. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the pleadings met the requirements of Rule 8.01 Work Health Rules.

The court ruled that Ms. Millar's injury was indeed compensable and had contributed to her loss of earning capacity. However, the court also found that the payment made to Ms. Millar under the Deed of Agreement of 2009 could be considered compensation for the loss arising from the compensable injury, including legal fees, medical expenses, and weekly benefits. Ms. Millar's failure to prove that the entire payment was not compensation for her loss required the court to deduct this amount from any compensation granted to prevent double compensation. The court subsequently ordered various payments to Ms. Millar, including weekly benefits, rehabilitation expenses, and medical expenses, and set off the $80,000 payment against the compensation payable to avoid double compensation. The court also noted that it would hear the parties on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusion:1. Ms Millar suffered a compensable injury to her right knee on 28th June 2005 while in the employ of ABC Marketing and Sales2. The compensable injury materially contributed to Ms Millar’s loss of earning capacity from 1.1.2010 to the 14.1.2011 3. The compensable injury caused Ms Millar to retrain herself at a cost to herself.4. Ms Millar has incurred medical and travel expenses in relation to the compensable injury.5. The payment made to Ms Millar under the Deed of Agreement of the 24th of September 2009 could be a payment for the loss suffered by Ms Millar arising from the compensable injury.6. Ms Millar has failed to discharge her burden to prove to the court that the whole of the payment is not compensation for loss suffered by Ms Millar arising out of the compensable injury including legal fees, medical expenses past and future and weekly benefits. Her failure to discharge this burden requires the court to deduct that amount from any compensation granted in these proceedings to avoid double compensation to Ms Millar. Orders: Based on the above findings I order:1.I declare Ms Millar remains entitled to receive compensation as a result of the injury sustained on 28 June 2005. 2.ABC Marketing and Sales pay weekly benefits to Ms Millar for the following periods:a.1.1.2010 to 25.4.2010 $9476.00b.30.4.2010 to 31.12.2010 $1995.89 c.1.1.2011 to 14.1.2011 $122.943.ABC Marketing and sales pay rehabilitation expenses to Ms Millar of $1415.00.4.ABC Marketing and Sales pay medical expenses to Ms Millar of $140 for attendances on Dr Moore and $248.00 for attendances on Mr Paterson.5.ABC Marketing and Sales pay travel expenses to Ms Millar for travel to the MRI in 2009, to appointments with Mr Paterson and Dr Moore, to Western Pathology and Nakara Medical Clinic, and Aviation Course a total of $526.75.6.Total compensation payable to Ms Millar is $13924.587.The payment of $80000 made under the Deed of Agreement of the 24th September 2009 is to be set off against the compensation payable to Ms Millar to avoid Ms Millar receiving double compensation for her loss arising out of the compensable injury.8.I will hear the parties on costs. Dated this 2nd day of November 2011 _________________________Tanya Fong Lim

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.