Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2)

Citation:

[2021] ACTSC 296

Hearing Date:

30 August 2021

DecisionDate:

19 November 2021

Before:

Mossop J

Decision:

See [117]

Catchwords:

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION – SECURITY OF PAYMENT – Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) – challenge to adjudicator’s decision – application for prerogative relief – application of the doctrine of issue estoppel – where the adjudicator erred in the scope and effect of s 24(4) of the Act

ESTOPPEL – ISSUE ESTOPPEL – Application of issue estoppel to adjudication decisions is limited – issue estoppel is not generally applicable between adjudications

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JURISDICTIONAL ERROR – Where application of issue estoppel gives rise to a jurisdictional error – error of law on the face of the record established – jurisdictional error a material one

Legislation Cited:

Australian Capital Territory (Self-Government) Act 1988 (Cth), ss 28, 48A

Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT), ss 8(1)(b)(iii), 10, 15, 24, 25, 27, 28, 38, 43(1)
Commercial Arbitration Act 1986 (ACT) (repealed)
Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT), r 3558

Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 69

Cases Cited:

AE & E Australia Pty Ltd v Stowe Australia Pty Ltd [2010] QSC 135

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd [2021] ACTSC 166
Blair v Curran (1939) 62 CLR 464
Caltex Refineries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Allstate Access (Australia) Pty Ltd [2014] QSC 223
DualcorpPty Ltd v Remo Constructions Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 69; 74 NSWLR 190
Empire Global Pty Ltd v SA Expert Designs Pty Ltd [2019] ACTSC 244
Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd v Brady Marine & Civil Pty Ltd [2015] ACTSC 384; 11 ACTLR 111
Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; 264 CLR 123
J Hutchinson Pty Ltd v Galform Pty Ltd & Ors [2008] QSC 205
Kirk v Industrial Court (NSW) [2010] HCA 1; 239 CLR 531
Kuligowski v Metrobus [2004] HCA 34; 220 CLR 363
LaingO’Rourke Australia Construction Pty Ltd v Monford Group Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 491
Maxcon Constructions Pty Ltd v Vadasz [2018] HCA 5; 264 CLR 46
Modscape Pty Ltd v Francis [2017] TASSC 55; 29 Tas R 288
Pines Living Pty Ltd v John O’Brien & Walton Construction Pty Ltd [2013] ACTSC 156
Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd [2018] HCA 4; 264 CLR 1
Salini-Impregilo S.P.A. v Francis [2020] WASC 72

Watpac Constructions v Austin Corp [2010] NSWSC 168

Parties:

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd t/as Benex Pipelines ( Plaintiff)

Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd atf Harlech Family Trust (First Defendant)

Jonathan H Sive (Second Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

J Moffett ( Plaintiff)

A Greinke (First Defendant)

Solicitors

BAL Lawyers ( Plaintiff)

Mills Oakley (First Defendant)

File Number:

SC 206 of 2021

MOSSOP J:

Introduction

  1. This is an application for prerogative relief directed to a decision of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACTSC 296
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This is an application for prerogative relief directed to a decision of an adjudicator under the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) (SOP Act). The plaintiff, Beno Excavations Pty Ltd, challenged the adjudicator's decision to pay $598,813.17 to the defendant, Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd. The dispute involved claims for payments under a long-term arrangement between the parties. The adjudicator determined that the claims were payable, relying on the doctrine of issue estoppel and an expanded interpretation of s 24(4) of the SOP Act.

The court found that the adjudicator's interpretation of s 24(4) of the SOP Act was incorrect. The court held that s 24(4) only required consistency in the valuation of the same work or goods and services in subsequent adjudications, not the application of issue estoppel to a broader range of issues. The court also found that the doctrine of issue estoppel did not generally apply between adjudications under the SOP Act. The court concluded that the adjudicator's errors constituted a jurisdictional error, as they substantially altered the nature of the adjudicator's function and resulted in addressing the wrong issues.

The court ordered that the parties provide agreed or competing orders to give effect to the decision, including orders relating to costs, and listed the matter for final orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (Beno) is a civil contracting company. Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (Harlech) was engaged by Beno as a general manager and consultant. Following the end of this arrangement, Harlech made a payment claim under the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) (SOP Act) for $60,153.23. Beno responded that it would pay nothing and this was subject to adjudication. The adjudicator determined that the full amount claimed by Harlech was payable. After this adjudication, Harlech made two further payment claims for substantially larger amounts relating to work in 2017 and 2018. Beno again responded that it would pay nothing. The two payment claims were subject to a second adjudication before the same adjudicator. The second adjudication decision determined that almost the total amount claimed by Harlech was payable by Beno. Beno sought prerogative relief in relation to the second adjudication decision, challenging the adjudicator’s interpretation of the operation of s 24(4) of the SOP Act and the application of the doctrine of issue estoppel.

This case is an application for prerogative relief brought against a decision of an adjudicator under the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) (SOP Act). The plaintiff, Beno Excavations Pty Ltd, challenged the adjudicator's decision in relation to a payment claim made by the first defendant, Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd. The matter came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as an interlocutory application seeking prerogative relief in relation to the adjudicator's decision. The Court had earlier considered a similar challenge to the adjudicator's decision in Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd [2021] ACTSC 166 (Beno Excavations (No 1)). In that case, the Court granted an extension of time to bring the proceedings on the condition that the grounds of challenge were limited to the adjudicator's interpretation of the operation of s 24(4) of the SOP Act and issue estoppel. The adjudicator filed a submitting appearance in the form of a document entitled "Memorandum of Consent [to] Jurisdiction of the Court". The plaintiff requested that the Court not consider the terms of that document, and the Court did not do so. The Court found that the adjudicator had erred in his application of issue estoppel and the scope and effect of s 24(4) of the SOP Act. The error was characterised as a jurisdictional error because it substantially altered the relationship between s 24(4) and s 24(2) of the SOP Act and the adjudicator misconceived the nature of his function. The Court determined that the error was material because it could not be concluded that compliance with the provisions of the SOP Act "could have made no difference to the decision that was made in the circumstances in which that decision was made". The Court ordered the parties to formulate orders to give effect to the decision and listed the matter for the making of final orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the adjudicator correctly interpret the scope and effect of section 24(4) of the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT)?
2. Was the adjudicator correct in applying the doctrine of issue estoppel to preclude the plaintiff from advancing arguments in the second adjudication?
3. Is the error in the adjudicator's interpretation of section 24(4) of the Act a material one that warrants a grant of prerogative relief?
4. Does the application of issue estoppel between adjudications give rise to a jurisdictional error?
5. If the error is a jurisdictional one, should prerogative relief be granted in this case, considering the interim nature of the security of payment scheme and the need for speedy determinations?

Held
1. The court concluded that the adjudicator did not correctly interpret the scope and effect of section 24(4) of the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT). The adjudicator's interpretation was broader than intended, leading to the error in the decision.
2. The court found that the adjudicator was incorrect in applying the doctrine of issue estoppel to preclude the plaintiff from advancing arguments in the second adjudication. The court determined that issue estoppel does not generally apply between adjudications under the Act.
3. The court determined that the error in the adjudicator's interpretation of section 24(4) of the Act is material. The error warranted a grant of prerogative relief as it affected the decision-making process significantly.
4. The court concluded that the application of issue estoppel between adjudications gave rise to a jurisdictional error. This was because the adjudicator's misunderstanding of the Act's provisions substantially altered the required decision-making process.
5. Given that the error was jurisdictional, the court considered the need for speedy determinations and the interim nature of the security of payment scheme. However, the court emphasized the importance of ensuring decisions are lawful and free from jurisdictional error, ultimately deciding to grant the prerogative relief sought by the plaintiff.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that the adjudicator's interpretation of the scope and effect of section 24(4) of the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) was incorrect. The adjudicator had expanded the scope of the provision to include the methodology applied in a previous adjudication, which was not permitted by the Act. The court noted that section 24(4) of the Act requires the same value to be attributed to the same work or goods and services unless there has been a change in circumstances since the previous valuation. The adjudicator's error in this respect was material, as it substantially altered the relationship between section 24(4) and section 24(2) of the Act, resulting in the adjudicator misconceiving the nature of his function and addressing the wrong issues.

The court further held that the doctrine of issue estoppel does not generally apply between adjudications under the Act. The court found that issue estoppel should not be extended to preclude the re-agitation of questions of fact or law determined in one adjudication in a subsequent adjudication relating to different claimed amounts. The statutory scheme of the Act does not compel the conclusion that antecedent issues of fact or law remain binding from one adjudication to the next. The court concluded that the adjudicator's error in applying issue estoppel to preclude the plaintiff from advancing arguments in the second adjudication gave rise to a jurisdictional error.

Given that the error was jurisdictional, the court considered whether prerogative relief should be granted. The court noted that the interim nature of the security of payment scheme and the need for speedy determinations do not detract from the imperative that decisions be lawful and free of jurisdictional error. The court found that the error was material, as it was not possible to conclude that compliance with the provisions of the Act could have made no difference to the decision in the circumstances in which it was made.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the adjudicator's misinterpretation of the scope and effect of section 24(4) of the Act, which resulted in a jurisdictional error, warrants the grant of prerogative relief. Furthermore, the doctrine of issue estoppel does not generally apply between adjudications under the Act, and its misapplication can also give rise to a jurisdictional error.