Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 4)

Citation:

[2022] ACTSC 275

Hearing Date:

4 October 2022

DecisionDate:

11 October 2022

Before:

Elkaim J

Decision:

(i)     The applicant has leave to rely on the application in proceeding filed on 4 January 2022.

(ii)    The respondent (the first defendant) is to pay the applicant (the plaintiff) the sum of $196,428.79 by way of restitution.

(iii)    The respondent is to pay the applicant $11,893 by way of interest on the sum stated in the previous order.

(iv)   The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of the application in proceedings filed on 4 January 2022.

Catchwords:

CIVIL LAW – APPLICATION – Restitution – where the plaintiff seeks an order that the first defendant pay the plaintiff a sum by way of restitution

Legislation Cited:

Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) s 38

Cases Cited:

Barclays Bank Pty Ltd v W.J. Simms Son & Cooke (Southern) Ltd [1980] 1 QB 677

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] ACTSC 296
David Securities Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1992) 175 CLR 353
Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd [2022] ACTCA 42

Production Spray Painting & Panel Beating Pty Ltd v Newnham (No 2) (1992) 27 NSWLR 659

Parties:

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd t/as Benex Pipelines ( Plaintiff)

Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd atf Harlech Family Trust (First Defendant)

Jonathon H Sive (Second Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

D Robens ( Plaintiff)

Dr A Greinke (First Defendant)

Solicitors

Joseph Tallarita (Plaintiff)

Mills Oakley ( First Defendant)

File Number:

SC 206 of 2021

Elkaim J:

  1. On 4 January 2022 the plaintiff filed an application in proceeding seeking an order that the first defendant pay to the plaintiff the sum of $196,428.79 by way of restitution, together with various associated orders.

  1. The application is opposed.

  1. The application is supported by an affidavit of Ms Diana Bencic sworn on 1 September 2022. The respondent relies upon an affidavit of Mr Benjamin Moseley affirmed on 16 September 2022.

  1. Ms Bencic is the business and administration manager of the plaintiff company. Mr Moseley is a director of the first defendant company.

  1. The basis for the application is seemingly straightforward:

(a)On 17 March 2021 an adjudicator (the second defendant) made a determination under the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) (the SOP Act) directing the plaintiff to pay $598,812.17 to the first defendant.

(b)After obtaining the necessary certificate, the first defendant registered the certificate in the District Court of New South Wales and thereafter obtained a garnishee order against the plaintiff.

(c)Consequent upon the garnishee order the sum of $196,415.79 was paid into the trust account of the first defendant’s solicitors.

(d)On 26 November 2021 Mossop J quashed the adjudicator’s determination (Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] ACTSC 296; 363 FLR 238).

(e)On 11…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 4... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ACTSC 275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Beno Excavations Pty Ltd t/as Benex Pipelines (the plaintiff) brought an application against Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd atf Harlech Family Trust (the first defendant) seeking an order that the first defendant pay to the plaintiff the sum of $196,428.79 by way of restitution, together with various associated orders. The application was opposed. The basis for the application was that on 17 March 2021 an adjudicator (the second defendant) made a determination under the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) (the SOP Act) directing the plaintiff to pay $598,812.17 to the first defendant. On 26 November 2021 Mossop J quashed the adjudicator’s determination and, on 11 August 2022, an appeal from the decision of Mossop J was dismissed. An application for special leave has been filed in the High Court but has yet to be determined. The respondent contended that the application was not entitled to succeed on three bases: (a) the application for restitution could only be based on the unjust enrichment of the plaintiff, but as the plaintiff owed more than the claimed amount to the first defendant, there had not been any unjust enrichment; (b) the monies claimed had been paid pursuant to a garnishee order made in the District Court of New South Wales; and (c) the claim for restitution was inconsistent with s 38 of the SOP Act, which expressed a legislative intention that there should be no restitution until the whole of the dispute between the parties had been completed. Elkaim J held that the respondent’s arguments were unavailing. The application was entitled to succeed and the orders sought would be granted.

The orders of the court were as follows: (i) The applicant has leave to rely on the application in proceeding filed on 4 January 2022. (ii) The respondent (the first defendant) is to pay the applicant (the plaintiff) the sum of $196,428.79 by way of restitution. (iii) The respondent is to pay the applicant $11,893 by way of interest on the sum stated in the previous order. (iv) The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of the application in proceedings filed on 4 January 2022.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 17 March 2021, an adjudicator made a determination under the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT) directing Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) to pay $598,812.17 to Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (the first defendant). After obtaining the necessary certificate, the first defendant registered the certificate in the District Court of New South Wales and thereafter obtained a garnishee order against the plaintiff. Consequently, the sum of $196,415.79 was paid into the trust account of the first defendant’s solicitors. On 26 November 2021, Mossop J quashed the adjudicator's determination, and on 11 August 2022, an appeal from the decision of Mossop J was dismissed. Consequently, the plaintiff filed an application on 4 January 2022, seeking an order that the first defendant pay the plaintiff $196,428.79 by way of restitution, together with interest and costs. The application was opposed by the first defendant on the basis that the application for restitution was based on the unjust enrichment of the plaintiff, the monies claimed had been paid pursuant to a garnishee order, and the claim for restitution was inconsistent with s 38 of the SOP Act.

The plaintiff submitted that it fit within the principles stated in Production Spray Painting & Panel Beating Pty Ltd v Newnham (No 2) (1992) 27 NSWLR 659, which established that the reversal of a judgment on appeal entitles the successful appellant to recover any moneys paid under the reversed judgment. The plaintiff argued that the whole of the dispute between the parties revolved around whether money was owed by the applicant to the respondent, and the result was that the respondent had certainly established a basis for the existence of a debt but had not proved that debt, either by consent or through court proceedings. The plaintiff further argued that the District Court proceedings had been completed, and there was no need for any involvement of the District Court; whatever happened in that court was no longer relevant. The plaintiff submitted that if the District Court’s order was set aside, it would have no effect on the return of the money. The garnishee order was made and its role had been completed. The plaintiff argued that the difficulty the first defendant had was that there were no final proceedings awaiting resolution, and it was possible that there may be future proceedings, but that was speculative and did not influence a restitution claim presently before the Court.

This matter came before Elkaim J in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory as an application for restitution filed by Beno Excavations Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) against Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (the first defendant). The application stems from a payment made pursuant to a garnishee order issued by the District Court of New South Wales, following an adjudicator's determination under the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT). The adjudicator's determination was subsequently quashed by Mossop J in Beno Excavations Pty Ltd v Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] ACTSC 296, a decision that was upheld on appeal in Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd [2022] ACTCA 42. The plaintiff seeks restitution of the sum paid under the garnishee order, arguing that the reversal of the adjudicator's determination entitles it to recover the moneys paid. The first defendant opposes the application on several grounds, including the contention that the plaintiff was not unjustly enriched and that the court lacks the power to set aside the garnishee order. The court considers these arguments and ultimately determines that the plaintiff is entitled to the restitution sought, along with interest and costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the reversal of the adjudicator's determination on appeal entitle the applicant to recover any monies paid under the reversed judgment?
2. Is the applicant unjustly enriched if it owed more than the claimed amount to the respondent at the time of payment?
3. Does the court have the power to set aside the garnishee order made in the District Court of New South Wales?
4. Is the claim for restitution inconsistent with section 38 of the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT)?
5. Can the court mould the relief to be granted to the claimants to preserve a sum as a fund to meet any judgment that the opponents may eventually obtain against the claimants in the foreshadowed proceedings for fraud and deceptive conduct etc.?

Held
1. The applicant has leave to rely on the application in proceeding filed on 4 January 2022. Result: Application for leave is granted.
2. The applicant is not precluded from recovering the monies paid under the reversed judgment as it is not established that it was unjustly enriched by the payment. Result: Claim for restitution is allowed.
3. The court does not have the power to set aside the garnishee order made in the District Court of New South Wales. Result: Garnishee order remains in effect, but restitution claim is allowed.
4. The claim for restitution is not inconsistent with section 38 of the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT). Result: Claim for restitution is allowed.
5. The court cannot mould the relief to be granted to the claimants to preserve a sum as a fund to meet any judgment that the opponents may eventually obtain against the claimants in the foreshadowed proceedings for fraud and deceptive conduct etc. Result: Moulding of relief is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the applicant's entitlement to recover the monies paid under the reversed judgment. The applicant argued that the reversal of the adjudicator's determination on appeal entitled it to recover the monies paid, relying on the principle that the reversal of a judgment on appeal entitles the successful appellant to recover any moneys paid under the reversed judgment. The court agreed with the applicant, finding that the entire consideration for the payment had failed and that a common money count lay, as the applicant had obtained payment based on a void adjudication determination which had been quashed. Therefore, the applicant was entitled to recover the monies paid under the reversed judgment.

The court then considered the respondent's argument that the applicant was not unjustly enriched because it owed more than the claimed amount to the respondent at the time of payment. The court found that the respondent had established a basis for the existence of a debt but had not proved that debt, either by consent or through court proceedings. The payment made under the garnishee order was not necessarily a payment made for good consideration, or by compulsion, in satisfaction of the debt owed by the applicant to the respondent. Therefore, the respondent's argument failed.

Next, the court addressed the respondent's argument that the court did not have the power to set aside the garnishee order made in the District Court of New South Wales. The court agreed with the respondent that it did not have the power to set aside the order or to interfere with the due process that had occurred in the District Court. However, the applicant argued that the District Court proceedings had been completed and that there was no need for any involvement of the District Court. The court agreed with the applicant, finding that the garnishee order had been made and its role had been completed. Therefore, the court did not need to set aside the order.

The court then considered the respondent's argument that the claim for restitution was inconsistent with section 38 of the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 2009 (ACT). The respondent submitted that the statutory intention behind section 38 was that the question of restitution of monies paid in respect of statutory payment claims was a matter for determination in any final proceedings to establish contractual rights. The court found that there were no final proceedings awaiting resolution, and that the only proceedings in this matter were constituted by the adjudication, which had now been set aside, and the decisions of the trial judge and the Court of Appeal respectively. The court found that it could not be influenced by any speculative future proceedings, and that the applicant was entitled to the orders that it sought.

Finally, the court considered the respondent's argument that the court should mould the relief to be granted to the claimants to preserve a sum as a fund to meet any judgment that the opponents may eventually obtain against the claimants in the foreshadowed proceedings for fraud and deceptive conduct etc. The court found that it was not entitled to take that course, as it would either convert the opponents into secured creditors of the claimants, or else would tie up the fund in some other way. On either basis the claimants would continue to be disadvantaged as a result of the orders of the Industrial Commission quashed by this Court, and they would not have been "restored to all things" which they had lost as a result of those orders. The claimants were entitled to an unconditional order for the repayment of the sum paid under the order of the trial judge and interest thereon.

In conclusion, the court found that the applicant was entitled to recover the monies paid under the reversed judgment, that it was not necessarily a payment made for good consideration, or by compulsion, in satisfaction of the debt owed by the applicant to the respondent, that the court did not have the power to set aside the garnishee order made in the District Court of New South Wales, that the claim for restitution was not inconsistent with section 38 of the SOP Act, and that the court was not entitled to mould the relief to be granted to the claimants to preserve a sum as a fund to meet any judgment that the opponents may eventually obtain against the claimants in the foreshadowed proceedings for fraud and deceptive conduct etc. The court made the following orders: (i) the applicant had leave to rely on the application in proceeding filed on 4 January 2022, (ii) the respondent was to pay the applicant the sum of $196,428.79 by way of restitution, (iii) the respondent was to pay the applicant $11,893 by way of interest on the sum stated in the previous order, and (iv) the respondent was to pay the applicant's costs of the application in proceedings filed on 4 January 2022.