Belmont Night Patrol Pty Ltd v Woolworths Ltd & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Belmont Night Patrol Pty. Ltd. v. Woolworths Ltd. & Anor. [2004]  NSWCA 235

FILE NUMBER(S):
40163/03

HEARING DATE(S):               6 July 2004

JUDGMENT DATE: 14/07/2004

PARTIES:
Belmont Night Patrol Pty. Limited - appellant
Woolworths Limited - 1st respondent
Sam Matoka - 2nd respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Hodgson JA Tobias JA McColl JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Compensation Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          CC55046/00

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Hughes CCJ

COUNSEL:
Mr. B. McManamey for appellant
Mr. P. Morris for 1st respondent
Mr. G. Schipp for 2nd respondent

SOLICITORS:
Hunt & Hunt, Newcastle for appellant
Moray & Agnew, Sydney for 1st respondent
Bale Boshev & Associates, Hamilton for 2nd respondent

CATCHWORDS:
APPEAL - Error of law - Deficiency of reasons - Finding of causation where medical evidence against causation - Finding open to specialist tribunal on the basis of lay evidence, but reasons required for making finding against medical evidence.

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
1. Appeal allowed. 2. Orders below set aside. 3. Matter remitted to the District Court for further consideration. 4. First respondent to pay the costs of the appellant and the second respondent of the appeal, and to have a Suitors Fund certificate if otherwise qualified.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40163/03
CC 55046/00

HODGSON JA
TOBIAS JA
McCOLL JA

Wednesday 14 July 2004

BELMONT NIGHT PATROL PTY. LTD.  V.  WOOLWORTHS LTD. & ANOR.

Judgment

  1. HODGSON JA:  On 12 February 2003, Hughes CCJ found that the second respondent (Mr. Matoka) was entitled to a continuing award of compensation on the basis of total incapacity, and the sum of $5,000.00 in respect of a further 5% permanent impairment to his back.  He ordered that the appellant (Belmont) pay the sum of $5,000.00 and that the amount of weekly compensation and medical expenses be borne equally by Belmont and the first respondent (Woolworths).  Belmont appeals by leave against the orders that it pay the sum of $5,000.00, and one half the weekly compensation and medical expenses:  it does not in the appeal challenge the findings concerning Mr. Matoka’s entitlement to compensation. 

    CIRCUMSTANCES

  2. Mr. Matoka was born in 1970.  He commenced employment with Woolworths in 1989 as a storeman, and continued in that employment until October 1999. 

  3. During his employment with Woolworths, Mr. Matoka suffered a number of injuries to his back and left leg.  In 1989, he suffered an injury to his lower back and left leg carrying a television set at work:  he complained of back pain but did not seek medical attention or take time off work.  In 1993 or 1994, he suffered another such injury, lifting a gymnasium set:  he consulted a doctor at Maitland Hospital and had two or three weeks off work.  In 1996, he suffered an injury to his back lifting a box of camping equipment:  he consulted Dr. Chun and had about four weeks off work.  On 4 September 1997, he suffered an injury to his back and leg, when his left…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Belmont Night Patrol Pty Ltd v Woolworths Ltd & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCA 235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between Belmont Night Patrol Pty Ltd (the appellant) and Woolworths Ltd (the first respondent) and another party (the second respondent) regarding compensation for a worker, Mr. Matoka. The primary judge had found that Mr. Matoka was totally incapacitated for work and had suffered a 5% permanent impairment of his back as a result of his employment with the appellant. The primary judge had also apportioned liability for weekly payments 50/50 between the appellant and the first respondent. The appellant appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal.

The legal issues before the Court of Appeal included whether the primary judge erred in law by finding a 5% permanent impairment of the back caused by the appellant's employment when the medical evidence attributed the impairment to injuries sustained with the first respondent. The court was also required to determine if the primary judge failed to provide adequate reasons for concluding that the appellant's employment caused the impairment, particularly in light of conflicting medical opinions. Furthermore, the appeal raised questions about the primary judge's apportionment of liability for weekly payments, specifically whether there was evidence to support attributing any incapacity to the appellant's employment, and whether the reasons provided for this apportionment were sufficient.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, finding that the primary judge had erred in law by making findings of causation and apportionment without providing adequate reasons, especially when those findings were contrary to the available medical evidence. While acknowledging that a specialist tribunal could make findings based on lay evidence, the court held that such findings, particularly when they departed from expert medical opinion, required clear and comprehensive reasons. The court noted that the primary judge had accepted Mr. Matoka as a truthful witness and found him to be totally incapacitated, but the reasoning for attributing this incapacity and the specific impairment to the appellant's employment, in the face of medical reports suggesting otherwise, was deficient.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal set aside the orders of the primary judge and remitted the matter to the District Court for further consideration. The appellant was awarded costs of the appeal against the first respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed. 2. Orders below set aside. 3. Matter remitted to the District Court for further consideration. 4. First respondent to pay the costs of the appellant and the second respondent of the appeal, and to have a Suitors Fund certificate if otherwise qualified.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, there is a report from Dr. Pacey, a rehabilitation specialist, dated 28 November 2002, based on a consultation of the same day. This report refers to the work between August and December of 2000, and Mr. Matoka’s statement that he was forced to work many more hours per week and was unable to continue with the work because of symptoms of pain. It recorded a statement by Mr. Matoka that his low back pain was becoming worse. Dr. Pacey’s assessment was that “Mr. Matoka continued to suffer with low back pain as a result of work-related incidents”. Her view was that he was currently unfit for work because of his pain experience.DECISION OF PRIMARY JUDGE The primary judge identified medical reports before him, referred briefly to the history of the matter, and continued: 4. He apparently was successful in his work trial and Belmont took him on as a full-time employee. This involved him driving around to various business premises, getting out of a car, checking that the doors were locked, that the place was secured or locked and then getting back in the car. He said it required him some thousands of clutching and de-clutching with his left leg in the manual car that he was driving. Mr McManamey finds this to be significant since there is no claim for a further permanent impairment of his left leg. 5. After some time working at about 40 hours a week Mr Matoka was asked to work 60 hours a week. This became too much for him physically and he just stopped working. It was put to me by Mr McManamey that if any aggravation of his previous injuries were caused by his work with Belmont Night Patrol it was temporary, that was his first basis; and secondly, if it was not temporary but permanent, it was only to a small degree, and I should have regard to the fact that there was not an increased claim for his left leg.6. This claim largely depends on what regard I have as to Mr. Matoka's credit. I found Mr Matoka to be a truthful person. He is, as he said, not very good at reading and writing. He has done manual work for most of his life. Clerical work is not the type of job that would be available to him. He said that after his work with Belmont Night Patrol he could not continue doing manual work and in fact Mr Edwards submits that he is for all relevant purposes totally disabled.7. Mr Edwards pointed to the range of jobs that Professor Ghabrial says that the applicant should avoid. Professor Ghabrial says in a report of August 2000 and then again in a report of 2 October 1992:He is not fit for activities involving heavy lifting, excessive bending and twisting as well as activities involving any running, climbing ladders, going up and down stairs excessively, walking on uneven ground, standing for lengthy periods or walking for long distances.8. In my opinion then and as I said, I accept Mr Matoka as a witness of truth.9. I find that he came after he left Woolworths from being a man who could work five hours a day, five days a week to a man who effectively is totally unable to work as a result of his work with the second respondent. Mr McManamey points out that his treating doctor says he should be available for some work. It is hard to find what kind of work that he could do that did not involve the activities that Professor Ghabrial says he can no longer do. The Court of Appeal, and I think it was a result of an earlier judgment where one of the judges, I think it might have been Judge Maroney, said that even a person in an iron lung has some capacity for work. That is not the test according to the Court of Appeal and nor should it be. It is a test of, taking all things into consideration, is it realistic this man could do any work?10. First, I was thinking that there was some job that he could do, maybe getting $100 a week, but I find it difficult in the market readily available to him for a man with the skills that he does have, for him to do any job, and I find that he is effectively totally disabled for work.11. Now turning to s.66 there is a claim for an increase in the award pursuant to the applicant’s back of 5 per cent. I find that that is a result of his work with the second respondent. As to the apportionment between the first and second respondents, as I mentioned earlier I believe that when he left the employ of Woolworths he was capable of earning, or working at least as a check-out operator for some five hours a day, four days a week, and afterwards I find him to be totally incapacitated for work and I find the apportionment of quantum for compensation of weekly payments to be 50/50 to both employers.GROUNDS OF APPEAL1.His Honour erred in law when he found that the Second Opponent suffered a 5% permanent impairment of the back as a result of his employment with the Appellant when there was no evidence before him that supported that conclusion.2.His Honour erred in law when he failed to give reasons that explained why he concluded that employment with the Appellant caused a 5% permanent impairment of the back when the medical opinion before him attributed the impairment to injuries suffered with the First Opponent.3.His Honour erred when he apportioned liability for weekly payments 50/50 to both employers when there was no evidence before him that attributed any of the workers incapacity to injury occurring in the employ of the Appellant.4.His Honour erred in law when he failed to give adequate reasons to explain how he apportioned liability for weekly payment 50/50 when the expert evidence before him attributed incapacity solely to injury with the First Opponent.5.His Honour erred in law when he failed to consider the worker's evidence that the cause of his continuing problems at this time were the injuries suffered with the First Opponent.6.His Honour erred in law when he failed to consider the worker's evidence that as at August 2001 his only complaint was that in the mornings he would wake up stiff and have some degree of back pain relieved by having a hot shower.7.His Honour erred in law when he failed to consider the worker's evidence that his back condition became worse after he left the employ of the Appellant.SUBMISSIONS

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established