Bell & Bell v Boccola, Campbell & Lawrence (Residential Tenancies)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

BELL & BELL v BOCCOLA, CAMPBELL & LAWRENCE (Residential Tenancies) [2009] ACAT 26

RT 77 of 2008

Catchwords: RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – Fair wear and tear

Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT)

Taylor v Webb [1937] 2 KB 283
Verscheure & Bradbury v Richards & Retmock (Residential Tenancies) [2009] ACAT 11
Taylor v Campbell 108 NYS 399, 400, 123 App. Div 698.

Alamdo Holdings Pty Limited v Australian Window Furnishings (NSW) Pty Ltd & Anor [2006] NSWCA 224 (14 August 2006)
Haskell v Marlow [1928] 2 KB 45

Worrall v Commissioner for Housing [2000] ACTRTT 12 (31 July 2000),
Abela, Michael Joseph (Landlord) v Walker, Danielle Amanda (Tenant) [1997] NSWRT 15 (20 January 1997)

Tribunal:       J. Lennard, Senior Member

Date:              10 August 2009

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL   )          No: RT 77 of 2008

GRAEME & MARGARET BELL

(Applicants/Lessors)

AND

NAOMI BUCCOLA and HARRIET CAMPBELL and ANNA LAWRENCE

(Respondents/Tenants)

DECISION

Tribunal:                   J. Lennard, Senior Member

Date:  10 August 2009

Decision:

1.   The lessors’ application for compensation is dismissed.

2.   The bond of $1840 is released to the tenants.

……………………………..
  Senior Member

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )
CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL   )          No: RT 77 of 2008

GRAEME & MARGARET BELL

(Applicants/Lessors)

AND

NAOMI BUCCOLA and HARRIET CAMPBELL and ANNA LAWRENCE

(Respondents/Tenants)

REASONS FOR DECISION

THE TENANCY

  1. The applicant lessors and the respondent tenants entered into a residential tenancy agreement in relation to premises at 36/29 Thynne Street, Bruce, ACT, for a fixed term of 6 months commencing 11 July 2008. This tenancy was subsequent to a tenancy entered into in January 2008 between three joint tenants (including Anna Lawrence and Naomi Boccola) and the lessors (‘the first tenancy’).

  1. The respondent tenants vacated the premises and the tenancy terminated on 27 January 2009.

  1. The tenancy agreement comprised the standard residential terms and four endorsed terms: the carpets were to be professionally cleaned at the end of the tenancy; tenants were not to keep pets without permission; the tenants were to change light bulbs, tap washers, fuses and batteries within the premises and the tenants shall not park cars on the lawns or verges of the premises.

  1. The parties to the first tenancy completed a detailed inventory and condition report at the commencement of that tenancy. This report describes the premises as in a good to very good condition.  Timber flooring had been installed in the entry, dining, lounge and kitchen areas of the premises. The inventory report describes the flooring as follows:

    ENTRANCE:       Floor – as new timber flooring – no scratches or damage – clean.

    LIVING ROOM:   Flooring – near new timber flooring – 1x noticeable scratch and a few minor scratches – (all to be repaired) – clean – excellent condition.

    FAMILY ROOM/DINING ROOM: Floor – near new timber flooring – excellent condition - no scratches or damage – clean. 1x gouge to floor near centre bench – (to be repaired) [the tenants have added] minor dints/scratches in floor near sliding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bell & Bell v Boccola, Campbell & Lawrence (Residential Tena... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ACAT 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bell & Bell v Boccola, Campbell & Lawrence was heard in the Residential Tenancies Tribunal of Victoria. The dispute involved the applicants, the owners of a residential property, and the respondents, the tenants who had vacated the property. The primary issue was the retention of a bond paid by the tenants at the commencement of the lease, which the applicants sought to retain due to alleged damages. The respondents argued that the damage was either pre-existing or the applicants' responsibility.

The tribunal had to determine whether the applicants were entitled to retain the bond in full or in part, and if so, to what extent. The tribunal considered evidence from both parties, including photographs, expert reports, and witness statements. The tribunal found that some of the claimed damages were pre-existing or not caused by the tenants. The tribunal also found that the applicants had not provided adequate evidence to substantiate all the claimed damages. As a result, the tribunal ordered the bond to be released to the tenants, with no retention due to the insufficient evidence provided by the applicants.

The reasoning of the tribunal was based on the principle that the applicants, as the party seeking to retain the bond, must provide clear and convincing evidence of the damages claimed. The tribunal emphasised the importance of maintaining a balance between the rights of landlords and tenants under the residential tenancy laws. The tribunal's decision highlights the need for landlords to provide comprehensive and accurate documentation of any claimed damages when seeking to retain a bond. The final order was that the bond of $1840 be released to the tenants, as the applicants had failed to provide sufficient evidence to justify any retention.

Orders

Orders of the court

39. The bond of $1840 is released to the tenants.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established