ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
Verscheure & Bradbury v Richards & Retmock (Residential Tenancies) [2009] ACAT 11
RT 90 of 2009
Catchwords: RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES – rental bond dispute – cost of repairs - fair wear and tear – final inspection
Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT)
ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT)
Yandle v Katsoulis [1999] ACTRTT 1
Young v Forsyth [2003] ACTRTT
Hlubucek v Sinodinos [2007] ACTRTT 12.Abela v Walker (1997)
Taylor v Webb [1937] 2 KB 283
Tribunal:Jennifer David, Senior Member
Date: 26 May 2009
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ) NO: RT 90 of 2009
RE: Catherine VERSCHEURE & Wayne BRADBURY
(Lessor)
AND:Kelly RICHARDS & Adam RETMOCK
(Tenants)
DECISION
Tribunal : Jennifer David, Senior Member
Date : 23rd April 2009
Decision :
That the Office of Rental Bonds is directed to release $860.00 to the tenants forthwith.
…………………………….
Jennifer David – Senior Member
26th May 2009
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY )
CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL ) RT 90 of 2009
CATHERINE VERSCHEURE AND WAYNE BRADBURY
(Lessors)
AND
KELLY RICHARDS AND ADAM RETMOCK
(Tenants)
REASONS FOR DECISION
BACKGROUND
This is a rental bond dispute over the claimed cost of replacing an area of approximately 10 square meters of wooden flooring the Lessors alleged was damaged during the tenancy by 5mm stiletto heels causing “hundreds of circular indentations”. The flooring consisted of thin wood laid on boards.
The residential tenancy commenced on 12 January 208 for a fixed term of 6 months and continued thereafter as a period tenancy from month to month. There were a number of “Additional Clauses” attached to the tenancy agreement that were unenforceable as they were not endorsed by the Tribunal under section 10 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (‘the Act’). The wooden flooring was not referred to in any of the Additional Clauses.
The Tenants vacated the property on 12 January 2009 with the final inspection being undertaken by the Lessors’ Property Manager on 13 January 2009. After the Final Inspection the Property Manager emailed the Tenants on the same day stating that she had found the property in “generally good clear condition but the owners do need to get back to me in regards to the following items:
- Small holes to the largest lounge room wall from where a hook has been removed
- Black scuff marks to centre of this same wall about head height
- Several kitchen floor times chipped
- Bedroom blinds dusty
- Window sills dirty throughout
- Dark marks towards the centre of the carpet in the back room
- Small holes to the wall with toilet roll holder from where hook removed in toilet
- Small black mark to this same wall in toilet
- Toilet seat cracked to edges and underside (from heat?)
- Inside of laundry cupboard needs cleaning
- The hook board attached to the back of the bathroom/laundry door has a couple of broken hooks.”
On 15 January 2009…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Verscheure & Bradbury v Richards & Retmock (Residential Tena... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] ACAT 11
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The ACAT examined whether the lessors had incurred the claimed cost of replacing the damaged flooring, and whether the damage was attributable to the tenants. The Tribunal considered the evidence that the lessors had not actually replaced the flooring, and that the damage might have predated the tenancy. Additionally, the Tribunal found that the alleged damage was consistent with normal use of the premises, including the wearing of high heels, and thus fell within the definition of fair wear and tear. The Tribunal also noted that the lessors had not noticed the damage during the final inspection, which was a critical point in determining whether the damage was attributable to the tenants. The ACAT held that the tenants were not liable to compensate the lessors for the cost of replacing the floorboards.
Consequently, the ACAT ordered the Office of Rental Bonds to release the disputed $860 to the tenants. The decision underscores the importance of the final inspection in determining the condition of the premises at the end of a tenancy, and reinforces the principle that damage resulting from normal wear and tear is not compensable under the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was heard by the Australian Capital Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) on 23 April 2009. The Tribunal examined the evidence provided by both parties and made a decision on the same day. On 29 April 2009, the Tenants requested a Statement of Reasons for the decision, which was provided on 26 May 2009. The Tribunal found in favour of the Tenants and ordered the release of the disputed amount of the bond to the Tenants.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Lessors are entitled to deduct from the bond the cost of replacing the damaged floorboards under section 31(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997.
2. Whether the Lessors' inspections after the final inspection were lawful and if they can raise additional items after the final inspection.
3. Whether the indentations in the floorboards could have been present prior to the tenancy commencing and if they fall under the definition of "fair wear and tear" under section 31(b) of the Act and clause 64(b) of the standard terms.
Held
1. The Lessors are not entitled to deduct from the bond the cost of replacing the damaged floorboards under section 31(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 as they have not incurred any such cost.
2. The Lessors' inspections after the final inspection were lawful; however, they cannot raise additional items after the final inspection if the items would have been visible at the time of the final inspection.
3. The indentations in the floorboards could have been present prior to the tenancy commencing and fall under the definition of "fair wear and tear" under section 31(b) of the Act and clause 64(b) of the standard terms.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Tribunal considered whether the Lessors were entitled to deduct from the bond the cost of replacing the damaged floorboards under section 31(a) of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997. The Tribunal found that the Lessors had not incurred any cost for the claimed replacement of the floorboards as no replacement had been undertaken prior to new tenants moving into the premises. The Tribunal emphasised the need for finality about the condition of the premises at the end of the tenancy, referencing cases such as Yandle v Katsoulis, Young v Forsyth, and Hlubucek v Sinodinos. The Tribunal also considered whether the Lessors' inspections after the final inspection were lawful and found that while the inspections were not unlawful, the Lessors could not raise additional items after the final inspection if the items would have been visible at the time of the final inspection. The Tribunal determined that the indentations in the floorboards would have been visible at the final inspection.
Regarding the definition of "fair wear and tear," the Tribunal held that the marks on the floorboards, even if caused during the tenancy, fall within the definition of "fair wear and tear" under section 31(b) of the Act and clause 64(b) of the standard terms. The Tribunal found that the wearing of high heels, including stiletto heels, is a normal use of residential premises and that the tenants were not required to take special care of the wooden floors as there was no endorsed clause to that effect in the tenancy agreement. The Tribunal distinguished the decision in Alexander and Persi v Rogan on this issue, deciding that the wearing of high heels does not constitute damage beyond fair wear and tear.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the wearing of high heels, including stiletto heels, is a normal use of residential premises and does not constitute damage beyond fair wear and tear unless there is an express clause in the tenancy agreement requiring special care of the premises or prohibiting the wearing of high heels.