Belacho v Nurses Board of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Miscellaneous Appeal: Civil)

BELACHO v NURSES BOARD OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2007] SASC 252

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kelly

6 July 2007

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - MEDICAL AND RELATED PROFESSIONS - OTHER FIELDS OF PRACTICE - NURSES

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW

Appeal against decision of Nurses Board to refuse appellant’s application for reinstatement as a registered nurse – the Board was not satisfied that the appellant was a fit and proper person to be registered under the Nurses Act 1999 (SA) – whether decision of Nurses Board to refuse appellant’s application for reinstatement was harsh, unreasonable and unjustified. Board delegated its powers to hear the reinstatement application to a committee – appeal on the ground that the Board which determined the application for reinstatement was not properly constituted. Decision of the Board was made in circumstances where one or more members of the Board had presided in earlier hearings at which appellant had appeared – whether decision of Nurses Board to refuse appellant’s application for reinstatement should be set aside for apprehended bias – consideration of what constitutes apprehended bias.

Held: Board complied with the appropriate procedures set out in the Act for the determination of the application for reinstatement – all matters considered by the Board were relevant in determining whether or not the appellant was a fit and proper person. Delegation of the Board’s functions to the committee was authorised by the Act – the constitution of the quorum was valid. Past decisions of the Board concerning the appellant were relevant considerations on the application – no indication in either the Board’s reasons or in the manner in which the proceedings were conducted to give rise to an apprehension of bias. Appeal dismissed.

Nurses Act 1999 (SA) ss 10, 13, 16, 26, 44, 46, 49, 52, referred to.
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond & Ors (1990) 170 CLR 321; Sobey v Commercial & Private Agents Board (1979) 22 SASR 70; Grljusich v Andrews (2003) WASCA 206 ; Gabrielsen v Nurses Board of South Australia [2006] SASC 1999; Craig v Medical Board of South Australia (2001) 79 SASR 545; Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia Legeng (2001) 205 CLR 507, applied.
Belacho v Nurses Board of South Australia [2002] SASC 69; Belacho v Tolstoshev [2002] SASC224, discussed.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"Fit and proper person"

BELACHO v NURSES BOARD OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2007] SASC 252

  1. Kelly J:     Ms Belacho (the appellant) appeals the decision of the Nurses Board of South Australia (“the Board”) which refused the appellant’s application for reinstatement to the Register of Nurses on 11 January 2007.

    Background

  2. Some aspects of the history of the appellant’s dealings with the Board are relevant to an understanding of the appellant’s grounds of appeal.

  3. The appellant first registered as a nurse on 13 January 1989.  She completed her training at the Royal Adelaide Hospital.

  4. In 1993 there was a complaint against…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Belacho v Nurses Board of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 252
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Belacho v Nurses Board of South Australia, the applicant, Belacho, sought reinstatement as a registered nurse following the cancellation of her registration by the Nurses Board of South Australia. The Board had refused the application on the basis that it was not satisfied Belacho was a fit and proper person to be registered under the Nurses Act 1999 (SA). The applicant challenged the decision on multiple grounds, including the Board's composition, the delegation of its powers, and the justification of the decision. The central legal issue revolved around whether the Board's refusal to reinstate Belacho was harsh, unreasonable, or otherwise unjustified, and if there was an apprehended bias in the decision-making process.

The court examined whether the Board had complied with the statutory requirements for the determination of reinstatement applications, including the relevance of past decisions concerning Belacho. It found that the Board had followed the appropriate procedures and that all matters considered by the Board were relevant to determining Belacho's fitness to be a registered nurse. The court also concluded that the delegation of the Board’s functions to a committee was authorised by the Act, and that the constitution of the quorum was valid. Additionally, the court determined that there was no indication of apprehended bias in the Board's reasons or the manner in which the proceedings were conducted.

Given these findings, the appeal was dismissed. The court held that the Board's decision was justified based on the evidence presented, and that there were no procedural irregularities or biases that would warrant setting aside the Board's decision. Consequently, the Board's refusal to reinstate Belacho as a registered nurse was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant directed most of her arguments to the third complaint that the decision of the Board was unjustified. For this reason I have dealt with that issue first.Was the Board’s decision justified? The application by the appellant for reinstatement was made under the provisions of s26 of the Act. That section provides:26—Reinstatement of person on register or roll(1) A person whose name has been removed from the register or roll—(a) at his or her request; or(b)on account of a failure to renew the registration or enrolment or to pay the practice fee,may apply to the Board at any time for the reinstatement of the person's name on the register or roll (as appropriate).(2)A person whose registration or enrolment has been suspended may apply to the Board for the reinstatement of the person's name on the register or roll (as appropriate) after the period of suspension has expired.(3)A person whose registration or enrolment has been cancelled for unprofessional conduct may not apply to the Board for reinstatement of the person's name on the register or roll before the expiration of 12 months after the cancellation.(4) An application for reinstatement must—(a) be made to the Board in the manner and form approved by the Board; and(b) be accompanied by the fee fixed by regulation.(5) The Board may require an applicant under this section—(a)to provide the Board with any information required by the Board for the purposes of determining the application;(b)to submit a medical report or other evidence acceptable to the Board to ensure that the applicant can practise effectively as a nurse;(c)to obtain additional qualifications or experience specified by the Board before the Board determines the application.(6)The Board should, subject to the operation of subsection (5), reinstate the name of a person who applies under this section if satisfied that the person—(a)has sufficient competence and capacity to practise in the field of nursing to the standards required by the Board for the purposes of this Act; and(b) is a fit and proper person to be registered or enrolled under this Act. The onus is upon the applicant under that section to satisfy the Board of the criteria for reinstatement articulated in s26(6). I am mindful of the fact that the appellant was unrepresented, both at the hearing before the Board and on the hearing of this appeal. For this reason I have considered the Board’s reasons as a whole and the whole of the evidence before the Board and before me in reaching a conclusion as to whether the evidence before the Board justified its decision to refuse the appellant’s application for reinstatement. The Board refused the appellant’s application for reinstatement on the ground that it was not satisfied that the appellant was a fit and proper person to be registered under the Act within the meaning of s26(6)(b). The evidence before the Board consisted of a number of documents tendered by the appellant. Material was tendered relating to contractual arrangements she entered into with a quadriplegic man, Mr X, apparently from July 2005 to July 2006; a letter was tendered from Nursebank Australia confirming that the appellant had worked on a casual basis as a registered nurse with that organisation between August 2003 and May 2005 and a number of court documents were tendered concerning a summons apparently issued by the appellant against Mr X. From the contents of that document it appears that the appellant was suing Mr X for breach of contract and defamation on the basis that he had dismissed her for alleged incompetence. In addition to this material there were extensive notes in the appellant’s own handwriting concerning her services to Mr X during the period of the contract. This material was supplemented by oral evidence from the appellant. The Board was also appraised of earlier decisions of the Board concerning the appellant’s registration and/or the restrictions on her right to practise.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established