Belacho v Tolstoshev No. Scciv-01-1353

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

BELACHO  v  TOLSTOSHEV
[2002] SASC 224

Full Court:  Duggan, Nyland and Gray JJ

  1. DUGGAN J.         The appellant, a registered nurse, has appealed against the decision of a single judge of this court dismissing her appeal against a finding by the Nurses Board of South Australia (the Board) that the appellant was guilty of unprofessional conduct.  The appellant was unrepresented before the single judge and at the hearing of  this appeal.

  2. The complaint laid before the Board by its Registrar alleged that the appellant had acted in an incompetent and unprofessional manner in relation to certain patients at Glenside Hospital while the appellant was working there as part of the clinical component of a course of study for a Graduate Diploma in Mental Health Nursing.  After finding that the allegations had been proved and that they amounted to unprofessional conduct, the Board reprimanded the appellant and imposed conditions upon her registration which restrict the appellant’s right to provide nursing care.  The appellant challenges the findings and orders of the Board.

  3. It is necessary to refer to some matters of background.  The appellant was first registered as a nurse on 13 January 1989 after completing her training at the Royal Adelaide Hospital.  A complaint of unprofessional conduct was laid against her in 1993 arising out of her employment at the Royal Adelaide Hospital.  However, the complaint was withdrawn when the appellant requested that her registration be cancelled so that she could apply immediately for reinstatement on the basis that certain conditions would attach to her registration.  This was achieved through agreement between the appellant and the Board.  The allegations in the complaint were not at any stage proved before the Board.

  4. In August 1998 the appellant again requested cancellation of her registration.  She had been unable to find employment as a registered nurse and she desired to undertake a re-entry programme at the School of Nursing as she had not practised for five years.

  5. The Board reinstated the appellant on the Nurses’ Register on 12 November 1999, after she had completed the re-entry programme, but imposed restrictions on her right to practise nursing.  The conditions were imposed pursuant to the Nurses Act 1999 (“the Act”) s 27.

  6. In January 2000 the appellant embarked upon a course of study for the Graduate Diploma in Mental Health Nursing and in March 2000 she commenced the clinical component of her course at Glenside Hospital.  Her placement was terminated after two days and the complaint alleging unprofessional conduct was laid before the Board on 14 September 2000.  The grounds of complaint were as follows:

    “1.At all material times the respondent was a registered nurse studying for her Graduate Diploma in Mental Health Nursing at the Flinders University (“her course”).

    2.On 12 November 1999 the Nurses Board granted the respondent’s application for reinstatement as a nurse, but pursuant to section 27 of the Act, ordered that the respondent was to work as a nurse under the direct supervision of another Registered Nurse who is more experienced in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Belacho v Tolstoshev No. Scciv-01-1353 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Belacho, a registered nurse, appealed against the decision of a single judge of the South Australian Supreme Court dismissing her appeal against a finding by the Nurses Board of South Australia that she was guilty of unprofessional conduct. The Board found that Belacho had acted in an incompetent and unprofessional manner in relation to certain patients at Glenside Hospital while working there as part of the clinical component of a course of study for a Graduate Diploma in Mental Health Nursing. The Board reprimanded Belacho and imposed conditions upon her registration which restrict her right to provide nursing care. The appeal was heard by Duggan, Nyland, and Gray JJ, who dismissed the appeal for the reasons provided by Duggan J. The court found that the Board followed the procedure set out in the Nurses Act 1999 for the hearing of complaints and that there was ample evidence to support the Board's findings and orders. The court also found that the Board was entitled to have regard to a psychiatric report prepared by Dr Baigent, a psychiatrist, as it was relevant to both the evaluation of the evidence of the Glenside Hospital staff concerning Belacho's behaviour and to the type of limitation which might be imposed upon her right to practise in the event of a finding of unprofessional conduct.

The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Nurses Board of South Australia stands. The conditions imposed on Belacho's registration, which restrict her right to provide nursing care, remain in place.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DUGGAN J NYLAND J GRAY J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DUGGAN J, NYLAND J, GRAY J