Bay v Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bay v Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency [2024] QSC 315

PARTIES:

DR WILLIAM ANICHA BAY

(applicant)

v
AUSTRALIAN HEALTH PRACTITIONER REGULATION AGENCY

(first respondent)

THE MEDICAL BOARD OF AUSTRALIA

(second respondent)

STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(third respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 14178 of 2022

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

13 December 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

21 – 23 October 2024, supplementary written submissions filed 8 and 15 November 2024

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDERS:

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1. The decision of the second respondent under sections 156(1)(a) and (e) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) to take immediate action by suspending the applicant’s registration as a medical practitioner is set aside from 16 August 2022.

2. The decisions of the second respondent under section 160 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) to commence investigations of notifications 00502227, 00502429, 00503368, 00505504, and 00505600 are set aside from 16 August 2022.  

3. The decision of the second respondent under s 193B of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) to refer matters about the applicant as a registered health practitioner to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal is set aside from 13 December 2024.

4.   The first and second respondents’ application in the proceeding filed 10 February 2023 is dismissed.

5.   The first and second respondents are to pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

6.   The first and second respondents are to pay the third respondent’s costs of the proceeding.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT – DECISIONS TO WHICH JUDICIAL REVIEW LEGISLATION APPLIES – where the applicant (Dr Bay) was a registered general practitioner – where Dr Bay made various statements about COVID-19 vaccinations on Facebook and other social media platforms – where Dr Bay attended the Queensland office of the first respondent (AHPRA) to protest against AHPRA and the use of COVID-19 vaccines – where Dr Bay made various statements about COVID-19 vaccinations at a national conference attended by medical practitioners – where Dr Bay’s conduct was the subject of five complaints to the Queensland Health Ombudsman which were later referred to AHPRA for consideration – where, based on the complaints, the second respondent (the Board) decided to suspend the applicant’s registration as a general practitioner and to investigate the complaints (together, the decisions) pursuant to ss 156 and 160 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) (the National Law (Qld)) – where Dr Bay applied to the Court for a judicial review of the decisions – where, pursuant to s 193B of the National Law (Qld), the Board referred the matter to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) (the QCAT referral) – where AHPRA and the Board filed an application for the summary or final dismissal of the judicial review application – where the judicial review and dismissal applications were heard together – where, on the final day of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bay v Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 315
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bay v Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency involved Dr Bay, a registered general practitioner, who challenged decisions made by the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPRA) and the Medical Board of Australia (the Board) to suspend his registration and to investigate complaints about his conduct relating to COVID-19 vaccinations. The legal issues before the court were whether the suspension and investigation decisions were legally sound and whether the referral to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was proper. Additionally, Dr Bay challenged the constitutional validity of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) and the jurisdiction of QCAT.

The court found that the suspension decision was flawed because it was based on an irrelevant consideration and was affected by apprehended bias. The investigation decision was also set aside for similar reasons. The referral to QCAT was deemed invalid as it was contingent on the flawed decisions. The court held that the National Law (Qld) was not misleading or constitutionally invalid despite its short title. The law's extraterritorial application and its interaction with Commonwealth laws were also found to be valid. The jurisdictional challenge to QCAT was dismissed.

The orders of the court included setting aside the suspension decision, the investigation decisions, and the QCAT referral. The application by AHPRA and the Board for the dismissal of Dr Bay's judicial review application was dismissed. Costs were awarded to Dr Bay against AHPRA and the Board, and to the third respondent against AHPRA and the Board.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE ORDER OF THE COURT IS THAT:

1. The decision of the second respondent under sections 156(1)(a) and (e) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) to take immediate action by suspending the applicant’s registration as a medical practitioner is set aside from 16 August 2022.

2. The decisions of the second respondent under section 160 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) to commence investigations of notifications 00502227, 00502429, 00503368, 00505504, and 00505600 are set aside from 16 August 2022.

3. The decision of the second respondent under s 193B of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) to refer matters about the applicant as a registered health practitioner to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal is set aside from 13 December 2024.

4. The first and second respondents’ application in the proceeding filed 10 February 2023 is dismissed.

5. The first and second respondents are to pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

6. The first and second respondents are to pay the third respondent’s costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The suspension decision should be set aside on those two grounds. The outcome on the investigation decision There remains the question of whether the investigation decision should also be set aside, as well as the related decision to refer Dr Bay to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The Board and AHPRA made no concession about these decisions. The investigation decision, as Dr Bay described it, was really three decisions concerning five notifications (or complaints) about Dr Bay, which were referred to the Board. These were as follows: (a)on 21 June 2022, a “delegate of the Board” decided to investigate the first and second notifications.[4] The delegate made this decision two days before the Office of the Health Ombudsman (OHO) decided to refer the second notification to AHPRA for consideration by the Board. (b)on 20 July 2022, a “delegate of the Board” decided to investigate the third notification.[5] (c)on 16 August 2022, a “delegate of the Board” decided to investigate the fourth and fifth notifications. These complaints were made by the Queensland State Manager of AHPRA and Associate Professor Rait, respectively. [4]Both notifications were from the same complainant. [5]The Board has kept the identity of this complainant confidential. The Board did not disclose the name of the delegate who made any of these decisions. The decisions appear to be undocumented, save that the decisions to investigate the first, second and third notifications were noted by the Board committee, chaired by Professor Tonkin, at the meeting when it made the suspension decision. So they appear in the agenda paper and the record of that meeting’s decisions and actions. The decision (as made by a “delegate of the Board”) to investigate the fourth and fifth notifications were made on the same day as this meeting. I infer that all the decisions were confirmed by or made at the meeting chaired by Professor Tonkin at which the suspension decision was made. Each notification was about Dr Bay’s conduct at political meetings, in on-line political broadcasts, or at political protests or demonstrations. None concerned his clinical practice. None made any allegation that Dr Bay had or was providing any clinical services that failed to meet the applicable professional standards. None could be properly characterised as a “mandatory notification” under the National Law (Qld),[6] despite some being submitted and accepted by the Board as such. The Board considered the notifications on the assumption that Dr Bay had acted “in contravention of relevant legislation”, and failed to comply with “regulatory safeguards”, including the relevant Code of Conduct. Neither assumption survived scrutiny at the hearing. [6]See National Law (Qld) ss 5 (definition of “mandatory notification”), 140-141. The nature of the notifications, the timings of the investigation decision (or decisions), and the role played by Professor Tonkin and the AHPRA State Manager in relation to them, have led me to conclude that the investigation decision (or decisions) should also be set aside on the ground of having taken into account an irrelevant consideration (a contravention of legislation and a breach of a Code of Conduct that had not occurred) and the ground of apprehended bias.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The National Law (Qld) is not misleading or invalid because its short title includes the word “national” in its short title. Firstly, the inclusion of the word “national” merely describes a regulatory scheme that operates throughout Australia. It is not intended to imply that it is Commonwealth legislation. Similarly, nothing turns on the inclusion of “Australia” in the names “Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency” or “Medical Board of Australia”. Parliaments are empowered to name entities as they see fit. Secondly, Dr Bay’s submission that a statute is constitutionally invalid where its short title is misleading is misconceived. As authority for this proposition, he points to obiter of French CJ in Kuczborski v Queensland where his Honour remarks that the inclusion of the words “vicious lawless association” in the title of the Vicious Lawless Association Disestablishment Act 2013 (Qld) is as “at best meaningless and at worst misleads as to the scope and substance of the law”.[36] Nothing turns on the title of that statute in the High Court’s decision – his Honour was simply expressing an opinion about its name. There is otherwise no constitutional principle of invalidity that arises from statutes being given misleading names. Can the National Law (Qld) have lawful extraterritorial operation in relation to conduct that occurred in New South Wales? [36](2014) 254 CLR 51 at [14]. Where there is “even a remote and general connection between the subject-matter of the legislation and the State”, State legislation can apply extraterritorially. [37] By only applying “so far as possible” to things situated or acts, transactions or matters done outside Queensland,[38] the National Law (Qld) applies extraterritorially where it meets this test. Given the decision to set the suspension decision and the investigation decision aside, it is not necessary to consider its application to Dr Bay’s alleged conduct in New South Wales. Does the Regulation purport to amend or modify Commonwealth laws? And if so, are such amendments or modifications lawful?[37]Union Steamship Co of Australia Ltd v King (1988) 166 CLR 1 at 14.[38]See National Law (Qld) s 8. The National Law (Qld) does not purport to amend or modify Commonwealth laws. It applies particular Commonwealth legislation as laws of Queensland. The National Law Regulation makes amendments to the Commonwealth legislation only as it applies as a law of Queensland. The amendments are so it may apply sensibly in Queensland as a law of Queensland.[39] Although somewhat complex, this is a valid way of legislating. The Queensland Parliament, by the National Law (Qld), and the Governor in Council, by the National Law Regulation, do not purport to modify or amend Commonwealth legislation. An attempt to do so would be ineffective. Does the National Law (Qld) purport to establish AHPRA and the Board as Commonwealth agencies with lawful national jurisdiction? If so, is the National Law (Qld) invalid and/or does the Board lack jurisdiction to regulate Australian health practitioners?[39]For example, s 25 of the National Law Regulation provides that the Ombudsman Act 1976 (Cth) applies as if a reference to the “Federal Court” were a reference to the “Supreme Court”.