Bargain World CQ (Rockhampton) Pty Ltd v AHC Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bargain World CQ (Rockhampton) Pty Ltd v AHC Limited [2023] QSC 201

PARTIES:

BARGAIN WORLD CQ (ROCKHAMPTON) PTY LTD

(Applicant)

v
AHC LIMITED

(Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 8320 of 2023

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

5 September 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

10 August 2023

JUDGE:

Sullivan J

ORDER:

1.   The respondent is obliged under the Lease to grant the applicant a lease of the Premises for a term of
5 years commencing on 19 July 2023, subject to the same covenants and conditions as are contained in the Lease (“Further Lease”).

2.   The respondent deliver up to the applicant executed copies of the documents necessary to register the Further Lease in the form which are attached to the draft order as Annexure “A”.

3.   The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

CATCHWORDS:

INTERPRETATION – GENERAL RULES OF CONSTRUCTION OF INSTRUMENTS – COMMERCIAL AND BUSINESS TRANSACTIONS – PARTICULAR TRANSACTIONS – LEASES – where the applicant seeks a declaration that it validly exercised the first of its options to renew contained in the original Lease – whether on the proper construction of a provision in the Lease the grant of the Lease was subject to an obligation on each of the named guarantors to execute an appropriate document – whether on the proper construction of a provision in the Lease the lessor had to require the relevant guarantors to execute an appropriate document prior to the commencement date of any renewed Lease

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 127

AFC Holdings Pty Ltd v Shiprock Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 985, cited
Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd (1973) 129 CLR 99, cited
Beaufort Developments (Nl) Ltd v GilbertAsh Nl Ltd [1999] 1 AC 266, cited
Dovuro Pty Ltd v Wilkins [2000] FCA 1902, cited
Dryden Construction Co Ltd v New Zealand Insurance Co Ltd [1959] NZLR 1336, cited
Electricity Generating Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd (2014) 251 CLR 640, considered
HP Mercantile Pty Ltd v Hartnett [2016] NSWCA 342, cited
LCA Marrickville Pty Ltd v Swiss Re International SE (2022) 290 FCR 435, considered
Mt Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104, considered
North v Marina [2003] NSWSC 64, cited
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355, cited
Re Sigma Finance Corp [2009] UKSC 2, cited
Re Strand Music Hall Co Ltd; Ex parte European and American Finance Co Ltd (1865) 35 Beav 153, cited
Tripple A Pty Ltd v WIN Television Qld Pty Ltd [2018] QCA 246, cited
Wilkie v Gordian Runoff Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 522, cited
XL Insurance Co SE v BNY Trust Company of Australia Limited [2019] NSWCA 215, considered

COUNSEL:

JP Hastie for the applicant
NJ Derrington for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Macpherson Kelley for the applicant
Hopgood Ganim for the respondent

Introduction

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bargain World CQ (Rockhampton) Pty Ltd v AHC Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bargain World CQ (Rockhampton) Pty Ltd v AHC Limited, the applicant sought a declaration that it validly exercised the first of its options to renew under the terms of an original lease. The dispute arose when the respondent argued that the applicant could not exercise the option unless both named guarantors signed an appropriate document. The matter was heard and determined by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the grant of the lease was subject to an obligation on each named guarantor to execute an appropriate document, and if so, whether the lessor had to require the relevant guarantors to execute such a document prior to the commencement of any renewed lease. The Tribunal was required to interpret the relevant provisions of the lease agreement, particularly clause 2.3, to determine the rights and obligations of the parties under the agreement.

The Tribunal found that the guarantee and indemnity was not separate from the lease as defined in the covenants and conditions, but rather formed part of the overall agreement. Clause 2.3 was intended to condition the circumstances where there may be an extension of the occupancy of the leased premises beyond a particular term. However, the Tribunal also found that the former director had unequivocally refused to execute any further guarantee document, and therefore the lessor was not required to produce and require the guarantors to sign an appropriate document.

The Tribunal made an order declaring that the applicant validly exercised the option to renew, and that the respondent was obliged to grant the applicant a lease for a term of 5 years commencing on 19 July 2023, subject to the same covenants and conditions as are contained in the lease. The respondent was also ordered to deliver up to the applicant executed copies of the documents necessary to register the renewed lease, and to pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondent is obliged under the Lease to grant the applicant a lease of the Premises for a term of

5 years commencing on 19 July 2023, subject to the same covenants and conditions as are contained in the Lease (“Further Lease”).

2. The respondent deliver up to the applicant executed copies of the documents necessary to register the Further Lease in the form which are attached to the draft order as Annexure “A”.

3. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

I will now turn to the relevant facts involved in this case.Facts The Original Lease was registered on 31 October 2018. It had an initial five year term with two five year options. Whilst dated 19 April 2018, the term of the Original Lease did not commence until 19 July 2018 and accordingly ended on 18 July 2023. At the time the Original Lease was executed, the applicant had two directors, a Mr Prajapati and a Mr Patel. Each of them were named as guarantors in the Reference Schedule which formed part of the larger Schedule to the Original Lease.[2][2]Each of them executed that Lease schedule by specific execution provisions which made plain that they were executing as guarantors and that they agreed to be bound by the terms of the Lease as a party to the Lease. During the initial term of the Original Lease, a dispute arose between the two directors. Mr Prajapati purchased Mr Patel’s shares in the applicant in late 2021. Mr Patel ceased to be a director of the applicant on or about 22 December 2021. At the time Mr Patel ceased his directorship, no release was sought or obtained in respect of Mr Patel’s obligations and liabilities as a guarantor under the Original Lease. Subsequent to that time, but still within the initial term of the Original Lease, Mr Patel started to demand that the respondent release him as a guarantor of the Original Lease. By 27 January 2022, solicitors for the respondent had written to the solicitors for Mr Patel informing him that he remained a guarantor under the Original Lease. On 12 April 2023, the applicant, by its then solicitors, gave notice under clause 2.1(b) of the Original Lease that the applicant exercised the option to take a further five year lease (“Option Notice”). There is no dispute that the Option Notice was properly given by the applicant. On 28 April 2023, solicitors for the respondent wrote to solicitors for the applicant about the exercise of the option, and inter alia, queries about the market rent review at option. As part of the statements in that letter, the following appeared: “…Lastly, we advise that any amendments to the Lease required to give effect to your client’s exercise of option will be required to be signed by your client as the Lessee, as well as by both current guarantors to the Lease, Rakeshkumar Patel and Rajubhai Navinchadra Prajapati.Please seek your client’s instructions and revert to our office as a matter of urgency so that all outstanding issues can be resolved.” On 13 May 2023, Mr Patel wrote to a representative of the respondent by email under the subject matter “Personal Guarantee withdrawn-CQ Bargain World”. It referred to his having previously informed the respondent on many occasions that he wanted to withdraw his personal guarantee in respect of the Original Lease but had not received any response or communication regarding the matter. He then stated:“I here by want to inform concerned authorities that I Will be no longer held liable for any damages caused by Leased of CQ Bargain world at Parkhurst town centre and withdraw my personnel (sic) guarantee from the Lease and held no longer liable for any damage caused by the breach / discontinued or renewals of its Lease agreements.As I have personally informed Rod and Victor about the change of ownership, No steps are taken to ensure that my personal guarantee on the Lease will gets removed.I here by request landlord of CQ Bargain World to take necessary measures to ensure that this change of ownership will get acknowledged and My personal guarantee from Lease will get removed and confirmation of the same will be issued.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, it was submitted that the respondents did not have to produce and then require the guarantors to sign an appropriate document because the former director had unequivocally refused to execute any further guarantee document. Consideration I will deal with each of the two identified issues in turn. First Issue: Proper Construction of the Condition in Clause 2.3 of the Lease The first issue to be determined is whether on the proper construction of clause 2.3, the grant of a further lease was subject to the existing guarantors executing an “appropriate document”, if required. The starting point for the consideration of this issue is the argument as to whether the guarantee and indemnity is independent and separate from the “Lease” as defined in the covenants and conditions. The short answer is that it is not separate. Clause 1.1 defines the term “Lease” to mean and include the document in the Form 7 and all schedules, appendices and annexures to that document. In that respect, unless the context otherwise requires, when the term “Lease” is used in the covenants and conditions, it is a reference to the entirety of those covenants and conditions, including clause 21 which deals with the guarantee and indemnity. The context does not otherwise require a different construction in clause 2.3. Having said this, it is appropriate to acknowledge that whilst the term “Lease” within the covenants and conditions refers to the totality of the Forms 7 and 20, it is plain that the vast majority of the covenants and conditions within the attached Schedule concern the lessor and the lessee in those particular capacities. There is a separate execution page, at page 53 of 54 of the Form 20. This execution page records consideration flowing from the guarantors to the lessor for the granting of the Lease at the guarantors’ request. In return, the guarantors agree to be bound by the terms of the Lease as a party to such Lease. The signature clauses for each of the named guarantors, being by way of execution in compliance with s 127 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for the corporate applicant and being executed as signed, sealed and delivered by the natural person guarantors, are consistent with the executions being intended to be by way of deed. The existence of express consideration does not preclude the existence of there being a deed. Whilst it is incorrect to say that the guarantee and indemnity do not form part of the “Lease”, it is accurate to say that most parts of clause 21 are only intended to have a legal operation as between the guarantors and lessor. As with an ordinary commercial contract between multiple parties, the one physical contractual document may have distinctive parts or clauses which are operative only in respect of a subset of the total number of parties to the overall contract. It is then appropriate to look at the structure of clause 2.3 in some detail. First, a clear purpose for the clause is to deal with the conditioning of the circumstances where there may be an extension of the occupancy of the leased premises beyond a particular term. This includes as a result of the exercise of an option to renew, pursuant to an agreement for a term in respect of a further lease equivalent to the term applicable to an option to renew, or in the circumstances of a holding over pursuant to clause 2.4.