Bank of NSW v The Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

\pplCent

himheruA

Cnouch V

Ŝ!bCo>p

- Bank of Communoner

OcciTia/y,

ftyLfciv

gJurfUW 165

Afro^naf

ommuaion,$avin/p Bank N<w South

Commimanv

tLl—

CLR 360

U 16AU>]9

of Australia WaUs

9i;59AUR tSSUor,

85

Commissiofier

f61 CLR 639

ALR61

W9

PkIM 71

y Minister 15

ALD191

AlJUli

Coot

Cons

/^anetd

State Bank of

fnduMtneaHair Studio NSWy CAx

hyUdyTVW

Saving Btmk

i'i''''()liTS OK CASKS lli-*

Enterprises of Australia

Ltd 18 FCR 1

Cons Gould V Cons.

(?7 ALR 535

Consu^r^uickenden

RefdtôAfia ALĴWl

v

S'W te‘ inor

Pootbail

Uapjtlrie v

Ap

/nrtiVu/rfWl) ÂMonPly <97

FCR

ffcHamzy

Foil

INSD IN

Cuy of Char-

v

Ca^OT

Conarae^

27FCRS49 ' f,T^

199«r72

Tricon

Constructions

^7

International

(NSmPty

Auk

t'S;-

L 293

Restaurants

ALR 217

LtduNeison

I (2001) 1)5

92 ALR 193

ITJ FCRTf

CR 78

IIKill COIjKOFAFSi

It n IJIA

Appi

FoU

Us Stanton;

Con* A-G App!

Bouskev

Foil

EtpaneUCTy State (iVA)yAustrun

VFoilFoil

Susie Bank of

Atypciaifd

AFCOu Concrete

NationalMinisterfor

_

Bank of New

New South

■ • 'Vnv

Bank c£ New

ConstJuctiaru

Pmnary Tobacco

Soutfi Wales Atrhnes_

.

5«/// “

Lid Sou th Wales

(SS^Ply

industries AInstitute

96

fl<«OWj <R>

FCR3T

141

UdvNelion

!Mjf̂250 1̂976)̂ IfALR

670

m.

17 IPR 39

[HKJIl COURT OF AUSTRALIA.]

^•JIC

H. <:. or A.

sr

;ank of newSOOTH WALESANl)^

1948.

I’laintifks

OTHERS

.

Melboi-rnk,

>I1/A|);

(\r)pl

rvua

ic/l V

AND

Feb. 9-12,

ytytUsstoner

rtwiol

' Kailwuys'llailH

10-20,23-27 :

THE COMMONWEAl/rii AND OTHEHS

Dkkknoa.vts.

March 1-5,

8-12, 15-19,

Tm

^ralia

22-25, 31 ;

April

1, 2;

UNK OF AUSTHAI.ASIA AND OTHERS.

Fl.mntiffs ; ‘

___:

ânonwi^

Sydney,

rnw Pty Ltd

AND

April

13

1.5,

ITOT

.4 'ig. 11.

MIE COMMONWEALTH AND OTHEHS

I)f;fe.\iiants.

•n* htffis V

utrtum-

I-iktham C'.J.,

alik Tntd-

Kioh, Slarkr,

: Bank of

nixon,

uraua.

McTlirnan anil

WilllaiiLH JJ.

STATE OF VICTORIA AND ANO'I'HEH

I’l-Aintiffs ;

Coo« North

eastern Dairy

AND

Coy Dairy

*nmary

InJktssty Au^

rtdujtnea .

134̂

'HE COMMONWEAi;ni AND OTHEHS .

59

Defendants.

Com

'M

tVt'Jiem

J^7i992)

jinittŝotyv

.79 FCR 201

.otnuuMi’

IT ATE OF son'll AUSTRALIA.\ND^

Com

Rlaintiffs

SOS

ANOTHER

.

^nSan, Re;

xpane

AND

^

/

^7

HECOMMONWEALTHAND OTHERS

J)eeendants.

^nv

29>

STATE OF WESTERN AUSTR.VLIA AND"l

|Ln,Rc

Ri.aintieks

pane

ANOTHER............................................/

THE COMMONWEALTHAND OTHERS

Defendants.

Apo) State

Oilman V

{SflPr

Dised

Aumosinea

SwiaeHand

Cons 7*0/̂.̂

App*

trtwertst

?3TAra

iHsuranee

318 pZ^

Taxanon wA

Australia Ltd v

^fXmany

|I996)«9f̂

Mowie Fisheries

Ci)̂ 140

P Mmerals

ALR 129

Refd to ConsCons

Foil

Foil

R V Land UseClenae

.P/y ^ .r w" V_

P V Dunne

1

Appl Newcrest

,Ltd V AmO'Haliornn

(2003) 31

Cons '

C olcman

Ebner.Re;

,

Mining (fV}0 Green

Banking

hmLR 178

v Davies

g000̂ll57g002] 2 QdR

EbnervOfficiaH

Limited V BH

Group 11999]

(1997) 95

Trustee in- ]

i vTsYl

P Minerals

ACrimR 238

Pl/l

Limited dc Cth

Bankruptcy

(1997)71 (1999)161 1(53:

i LGERA 38

AUR1346ALR 557

HIGH COURT[1948.

H. C. OF A. Constitutional Law—Powers of Coinnionwealth Parliament—Hanking—Acquisition

1948.                 of property—“ Just terms ”—Original jurisdiction of High…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bank of NSW v The Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1948] HCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a dispute between the Bank of New South Wales and the Commonwealth of Australia concerning the validity of the *Banking Act 1947* (Cth). The Bank challenged the constitutional validity of the Act, which sought to nationalise the private banking system in Australia.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the *Banking Act 1947* (Cth) was a valid exercise of the legislative power of the Commonwealth Parliament. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the Act, in its provisions for the compulsory acquisition of private banking businesses, fell within the scope of the powers granted to the Commonwealth under the *Constitution*.

The Court, by a majority, held that the *Banking Act 1947* (Cth) was invalid. The majority reasoned that the Act's provisions for the compulsory acquisition of private banking businesses went beyond the scope of the Commonwealth's legislative powers, particularly in relation to the implied prohibition against the acquisition of property by the Commonwealth for a purpose for which the Parliament has not power to make laws. The Court found that the Act's broad scope and the compulsory acquisition provisions were not supported by any specific head of power in the Constitution.

Consequently, the High Court made orders declaring the *Banking Act 1947* (Cth) to be invalid and of no effect.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established