Cadia Holdings Pty Ltd v New South Wales

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON AND CRENNAN JJ

CADIA HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ANOR    APPELLANTS

AND

STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Cadia Holdings Pty Ltd v State of New South Wales [2010] HCA 27
25 August 2010
S367/2009

ORDER

1.        Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 1 July 2009 and in lieu thereof order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

A J L Bannon SC with R C Scruby for the appellants (instructed by Marque Lawyers)

M G Sexton SC, Solicitor-General for the State of New South Wales with H R Sorensen for the respondents (instructed by Crown Solicitor (NSW))

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. In 1568, an English court held that the Crown had the prerogative right to mines of gold and silver and other metals, such as copper, with which gold or silver in those mines was mixed[1].  In a context of constitutional upheaval, that right was modified, in favour of the owners of base-metal mines, by an Act of the English Parliament in 1688[2].  It was modified again in 1693[3].  Those events, which occurred more than three centuries ago, determine today the amount of royalties payable to the New South Wales Minister for Mineral Resources ("the Minister") in respect of copper mined by Cadia Holdings Pty Ltd ("Cadia") from land near Orange which is owned by it and Newcrest Operations Ltd ("NOL").

    [1]Case of Mines (1568) 1 Plowden 310 [75 ER 472].

    [2]1 Wm & Mar c 30 ("the 1688 Act").

    [3]5 Wm & Mar c 6 ("the 1693 Act").

  2. The entitlement of the Minister, debated in this appeal, to more than $8 million of royalties on copper mined from the land at Orange depends upon the interaction between the rules of law laid down in the 16th and 17th centuries and the Mining Act 1992 (NSW).

  3. When the Crown's prerogative right to mines of gold and silver was judicially recognised in 1568 it was as an aspect of the Crown's fiscal prerogatives.  It was justified by the Crown's need to obtain precious metal for the making of coins, a monopoly which was another aspect of the royal prerogative, and by the need to pay military defence forces.  It was also justified by the need to avoid undue concentrations of private power within the realm.  The 1688 Act protected private interests in copper mines which contained gold.  It allowed their owners to retain the copper.

  4. The prerogative right to gold and the 1688 and 1693 Acts formed part of the law of the colony of New South Wales, probably from the time of its establishment and at least from 1828, and affected the scope of Crown grants of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cadia Holdings Pty Ltd v New South Wales and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] HCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerning the ownership of minerals, specifically intermingled gold and copper, extracted from the appellants' lands. The dispute arose from the interpretation of the Crown prerogative regarding "royal mines" and its interaction with the *Mining Act 1992* (NSW) and historical English legislation, namely the *Royal Mines Act 1688* (1 Wm & Mar c 30). The core of the disagreement centred on whether the Crown retained ownership of copper found in conjunction with gold, where the ore body was incapable of being separately mined.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether the *Royal Mines Act 1688* excluded "mines of copper" from the scope of the Crown prerogative recognised in the *Case of Mines* (1568), and whether the mines in question, containing intermingled gold and copper, could be characterised as "mines of copper" for the purposes of that Act. Further, the Court considered whether the common law prerogative, as received in New South Wales, encompassed Crown ownership of intermingled copper, and how the *Mining Act 1992* preserved or modified these prerogative rights.

The High Court allowed the appeal, overturning the majority decision of the Court of Appeal. The Court reasoned that the *Royal Mines Act 1688* did not operate to exclude mines of copper from the Crown prerogative where those mines also contained gold. It applied the principle that prerogative rights are not displaced by statute without clear words or necessary implication. The Court found that the *Case of Mines* established a rule of construction requiring clear words or necessary implication before legislation or a grant could be taken to convey rights to mines of gold and silver. The Court of Appeal's majority had held that the 1688 Act withdrew mines fairly describable as copper mines from the prerogative, even if they contained gold, and that the Cadia mines were not fairly describable as copper mines, thus remaining gold mines within the reduced prerogative, entitling the Crown to their copper. However, the High Court's reasoning, as indicated by the allowance of the appeal, suggests a different interpretation of the interplay between the statutes and the prerogative, likely affirming the Crown's continued entitlement to the copper in such circumstances.

The High Court allowed the appeal with costs and set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal, dismissing the appeal to that Court with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 1 July 2009 and in lieu thereof order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ (dissent) GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON AND CRENNAN JJ (dissent)
The primary judge held that upon the true construction of the 1688 Act mines of gold and mines of copper should not be construed as mutually exclusive categories. On the facts of the case, he held that the Cadia mines should be categorised as mines of copper as well as mines of gold. On that basis, and by operation of the 1688 Act, at the time of the grants the copper under the land was owned by the grantee and not by the Crown.The decision of the Court of Appeal The appeal against the decision of the primary judge was allowed by the Court of Appeal by a majority comprising Basten JA and Handley AJA; Spigelman CJ dissented[117].[117](2009) 257 ALR 528. Basten JA held that nothing in the 1688 and 1693 Acts changed the principle that the royal mine to which the Crown was entitled was an indivisible ore body[118]. The case could be determined on the basis of three factual premises, namely, that the ore for the Cadia mines contained gold, which was a publicly owned mineral; the copper could not be recovered from the mines separately from the auriferous ore; and the Crown's ownership of the gold was not affected by the 17th-century statutes[119]. A major concern to which those statutes were addressed was the protection of the proprietor of lands from arbitrary intrusion by the Crown or its licensees if gold and silver were to be found in the refining of recovered ore[120]. His Honour would have also, if necessary, applied to the 17th-century statutes the principle that the prerogative is not to be displaced or restricted by statute in the absence of clear words[121].[118](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 550 [120].[119](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 550 [121].[120](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 551 [124].[121](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 550 [122]. Handley AJA, with whose reasons Basten JA agreed[122], held that the 17th-century statutes withdrew mines fairly able to be described as copper mines from the prerogative even though their ore contained commercially valuable quantities of gold and silver. Mines which could fairly be described as gold mines remained within the prerogative even though they may have contained small quantities of copper[123]. On the evidence and the findings made by the primary judge, the Cadia mines were not fairly able to be described as copper mines. They were gold-copper mines[124]. Restrictively interpreted, the 17th‑century statutes withdrew copper mines from the prerogative but not gold-copper mines[125]. Since the Cadia mines could not be described as copper mines, they remained gold mines within the reduced range of the prerogative, and the Crown was entitled to their copper as well as to their gold[126].[122](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 551 [125].[123](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 555 [144].[124](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 555 [145].[125](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 556 [154].[126](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 556 [156]. Spigelman CJ took the view that the 1688 Act was of constitutional significance and was not to be interpreted in a narrow or technical way[127]. His Honour held that a mine containing a substantial amount of copper could answer the statutory description of a "mine of copper" under the 1688 Act as clarified by the 1693 Act. It could do so even if the quantity of gold was such that the mine was capable of "dual characterisation as a gold mine"[128]. On that basis, the Chief Justice held that at the date of the grants of the land the Crown ownership of the gold was not affected but the ownership of the copper passed. It was a "privately owned mineral" within the meaning of the Mining Act 1992[129].[127](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 540 [58]-[60].[128](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 544 [91].[129](2009) 257 ALR 528 at 544 [92].The effect of the Mining Act 1992 on the prerogative

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

The outcome of this case is not affected, however, if, at the time of the Crown grants, the Crown held no more than the radical title to the land granted. It is sufficient that the rule of construction accepted in the Case of Mines and applicable to the colony required clear words or necessary implication before legislation or a grant thereunder could be taken as authorising a grant of land conveying with it rights to mines of gold and silver in the land.The effect of Federation upon the prerogative The Constitutions of the former colonies, the powers of the former colonial Parliaments and the laws in force in the former colonies relating to matters within the powers of the Commonwealth Parliament were continued after Federation subject to the Constitution of the Commonwealth[85]. No distribution of prerogative powers and rights between the Commonwealth and the States is spelt out in the Constitution. Indeed the word "distribution" may mislead. Prerogative powers and rights enjoyed by the Crown in the colonies before Federation may be seen as informing, or forming part of, the content of the executive powers of the Commonwealth and the States according to their proper functions[86].[85]Constitution, ss 106-108.[86]With respect to s 61 of the Commonwealth Constitution, see Pape v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2009) 238 CLR 1 at 60‑64 [126]-[133] per French CJ, 83-92 [214]-[245] per Gummow, Crennan and Bell JJ. In some cases, the location of particular prerogative powers and rights in, or as an incident of, the executive power of the Commonwealth or of the States is straightforward. As Professor Zines has observed, there is no difficulty in determining the repository of the prerogative power relating to a subject matter within the exclusive legislative competence of the Commonwealth or a State[87]:"Clearly only the Commonwealth can declare war, or enter into treaties. Similarly where a prerogative power, or a particular exercise of it, is concerned with a subject that is not within Commonwealth legislative power, it is exercisable only by the Governor of a State, such as the incorporation by royal charter of a school or the dissolution of State Parliament."A prerogative power or right concerned with a subject within the area of concurrent legislative power of the Commonwealth and the States may become an element of concurrent power or rights in both polities. This was the case with the Crown's priority in respect of debts, held in Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Official Liquidator of E O Farley Ltd to be enjoyed concurrently by the Commonwealth and the States[88].[87]Zines, "Commentary", in Evatt, The Royal Prerogative, (1987) at C13.[88](1940) 63 CLR 278; [1940] HCA 13. In Farley, Evatt J referred to the prerogative right in relation to royal metals[89], classified it as a proprietary right of the King and said[90]:"It seems plain that, as a general rule, those prerogatives which, prior to federation, were exercisable through the King's representative in the area of a colony, are, so far as they partake of the nature of proprietary rights, still exercisable by the executives of the various States and for the benefit thereof".[89](1940) 63 CLR 278 at 321.[90](1940) 63 CLR 278 at 322.